Photo via Reason

Trump's Claims About Noncitizen Voting Are 'Not Credible,' a Federal Judge Says in a Scathing Decision

Read the original at Reason ↗
Cite

Sullum, J. (2026, October 29). Trump's Claims About Noncitizen Voting Are 'Not Credible,' a Federal Judge Says in a Scathing Decision. Reason. https://reason.com/2026/10/29/trumps-claims-about-noncitizen-voting-are-not-credible-a-federal-judge-says-in-a-scathing-decision/

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

Reason · collected 2026-10-29 · by Jacob Sullum

Quick Summary

U.S. District Judge David O. Carter dismissed a federal lawsuit brought by the Justice Department against California's Secretary of State Shirley Weber and Los Angeles County's top election official Dean Logan. The Justice Department sought to compel them to segregate ballots from individuals listed as "likely noncitizens" before verifying their citizenship status, based on an initial DHS estimate that suggested around 190,832 non-citizens might be registered to vote in California. However, after reviewing the methodology, this number was drastically reduced to about 20,000 and later found to contain no actual noncitizens. Judge Carter's decision criticized the federal government’s attempt to interfere with state election procedures, calling it unprecedented and a potential tool for election manipulation.
Written by AI on 2026-10-29, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

On October 26, 2026, federal appellate judges questioned the Justice Department's demand for California to set aside 20,000 mail ballots from people suspected of not being U.S. citizens. The panel expressed doubt about the timing and constitutionality of this request during a rare weekend hearing. Despite initial setbacks, on November 2, Chief U.S. District Judge James Boasberg ordered the Trump administration to stop demanding California officials set aside these ballots, delivering another setback to the DOJ's election oversight efforts. However, in an unusual legal twist, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals briefly lifted and then restored a block on the investigation into noncitizen voting in California hours before polls opened on November 3, setting up further legal battles.

Written for “Appeals Court Rejects DOJ Bid” on 2026-11-21, grounded in this article and the 42 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

18 outlets covered “Appeals Court Rejects DOJ Bid”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

ReasonThis outlet29 Oct

U.S. District Judge David O. Carter dismissed a federal lawsuit brought by the Justice Department against California's Secretary of State Shirley Weber and Los Angeles County's top election official Dean Logan. The Justice Department sought to compel them to segregate ballots from individuals listed as "likely noncitizens" before verifying their citizenship status, based on an initial DHS estimate that suggested…

Trump's Claims About Noncitizen Voting Are 'Not Credible,' a Federal Judge Says in a Scathing Decision (this article)
CBS News30 Oct

A 9th Circuit Court of Appeals panel rejected the Justice Department’s request to set aside disputed ballots in California, which the department alleged were sent to people who may not be U.S. citizens. The appeals court ruled that separating these ballots could have "catastrophic effects" on election integrity, with only one judge dissenting. This decision is part of a broader legal battle between federal and state…

Appeals court rejects DOJ bid to set aside disputed California ballots →5 articles from CBS News on this story
Al Jazeera30 Oct

An appeals court in the United States has again denied President Donald Trump’s request to invalidate nearly 20,000 ballots in California due to alleged non-citizen voting. The ruling came just days before the November 3 midterm elections and was issued by a panel including judges appointed by both Trump and his predecessor Joe Biden. While two judges supported the decision, one dissented. Critics argue that the…

US appeals court again rejects Trump bid to set aside California ballots →4 articles from Al Jazeera on this story
The Straits Times29 Oct

On October 28, US District Judge David Carter denied the Justice Department's request for a temporary restraining order to block California from counting votes received from individuals allegedly not citizens. This decision was part of an ongoing dispute over alleged non-citizen voters and reflects broader tensions between the federal government under President Trump and states like California regarding election…

US Justice Department loses initial bid to block votes from alleged non-citizens in California →4 articles from The Straits Times on this story
Washington Examiner3 Nov

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned a recent ruling that allowed the Trump administration to require election officials to separate ballots from suspected noncitizens and threaten them with criminal prosecution. The court’s decision came late Monday when a majority of active judges voted to rehear the case en banc, reversing an earlier three-judge panel's decision. This action reinstated restrictions…

Appeals court wipes out Trump DOJ’s brief victory in California →4 articles from Washington Examiner on this story
Show 12 more outlets
Los Angeles Times29 Oct

Courts have twice rejected the Trump administration’s attempt to block the counting of approximately 20,000 ballots in California, alleging they may be from noncitizens. The Justice Department has appealed these rulings, intensifying a legal battle over election integrity between federal officials and state authorities days before midterms. Governor Gavin Newsom announced he would deploy lawyers to safeguard voting…

California, feds continue election war after courts rebuke challenge to 20,000 ballots →3 articles from Los Angeles Times on this story
ABC News (US)29 Oct

A federal judge in California denied the Justice Department’s request for an emergency order that would have required California to isolate approximately 20,000 ballots allegedly belonging to noncitizens. The Trump administration had argued these voters were “likely” ineligible, but Judge David Carter rejected this claim, emphasizing it was unprecedented for the federal government to interfere with a state's…

Judge rejects Trump admin request for order to segregate 20,000 Calif. ballots →3 articles from ABC News (US) on this story
Fox News3 Nov

A federal appeals court initially lifted a block on the Trump administration's investigation into alleged noncitizen voting in California but then reversed its decision hours later. The three-judge panel had temporarily allowed the Justice Department to proceed with requests to set aside ballots under threat of prosecution against state and local election officials who refused, citing it as a core executive…

9th Circuit block on California noncitizen voter probe lifted, then restored in legal boomerang →3 articles from Fox News on this story
The Independent30 Oct

A federal appeals court has rejected the Trump administration’s effort to stop counting approximately 20,000 ballots in California, citing concerns that such actions could jeopardize midterm elections and disenfranchise eligible voters. The decision, handed down on Friday with two days remaining until Election Day, marks the third consecutive loss for the administration in its attempt to block these ballots due to…

Trump’s bid to toss 20,000 California ballots could ‘jeopardize’ midterm elections, appeals court warns →2 articles from The Independent on this story
The Guardian29 Oct

Federal judge David Carter rejected a request from the Trump administration's Justice Department to isolate approximately 20,000 ballots in California from individuals claimed to be non-citizens. This ruling came two weeks after the Justice Department delivered a USB drive containing this list of names to election officials, who had only 48 hours to review it before facing legal action if they did not comply. Judge…

Judge rebuffs Trump DoJ’s bid to order California to set aside 20,000 ballots →2 articles from The Guardian on this story
NBC News30 Oct

A federal appeals court has again denied the Trump administration’s attempt to compel California to segregate over 20,000 ballots suspected of being cast by noncitizens. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court ruled that such action would cause significant disruption and lacks legal justification. Judge David Carter previously rejected a similar request from the Department of Justice, questioning its methodology and noting…

Appeals court again rejects DOJ’s bid to segregate over 20,000 alleged noncitizen ballots in California →2 articles from NBC News on this story
New York Post30 Oct

A federal appeals court has denied the Trump administration's attempt to block over 20,000 California ballots that were flagged by the Justice Department for suspected noncitizen voting. The ruling follows a previous rejection by US District Judge David O. Carter and comes days before Election Day. The decision supports California’s state laws for managing voter rolls, while the DOJ continues to argue that these…

Court rejects DOJ effort to block 20,000 California votes →2 articles from New York Post on this story
Time28 Oct

The Trump administration is increasing efforts to interfere with the midterms, raising concerns about unprecedented federal influence over election outcomes. These actions include legal challenges in Alaska and threats against California officials, along with suggestions of extreme measures like declaring martial law. Election officials across multiple states are bracing for potential disruptions on Election Day and…

How Trump Could Interfere With the Midterms on Election Day, and the Days After →
NPR29 Oct

A federal judge has denied the Justice Department’s request to halt processing ballots for 20,000 individuals deemed “likely” noncitizens in California’s midterm elections. The ruling came days before Election Day and cited concerns over disenfranchising eligible voters and disrupting state voting procedures. Judge David Carter rejected the DOJ's claim that setting aside these ballots was necessary, stating it would…

Judge denies the Justice Department's bid to stop processing California ballots →
The Hindu29 Oct

On October 28, 2026, a federal judge dismissed the U.S. Department of Justice's attempt to invalidate ballots from over 20,000 California voters potentially lacking citizenship status, calling it interference in the upcoming midterms. The decision supported California’s Democratic government and criticized the Trump administration for allegedly trying to cast doubt on electoral integrity ahead of November 3…

U.S. judge rejects Trump administration’s interference in California midterm vote →
Mother Jones29 Oct

A California district court dismissed a lawsuit filed by the Trump administration that sought to invalidate ballots from approximately 20,000 voters in California on grounds of potential non-citizenship, without providing concrete evidence. The decision was made based on concerns over federal interference with state election procedures and protecting voter rights. Judge David Carter’s ruling emphasized that such…

Court Denies White House Bid to Toss California Ballots →
Daily Mail1 Nov

The Justice Department under President Trump is refusing to comply with a court order to provide a list of California voters it seeks to remove from voter rolls, arguing that fulfilling this request would be unnecessary and burdensome. US District Judge James Boasberg plans to rule on Monday regarding the administration’s efforts to pressure states into investigating alleged noncitizen voting before midterms…

Trump DOJ thumbs its nose as nemesis judge in noncitizen voting war days before midterms →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

Reported by outlets on both sides of the middle

“This request violates longstanding constitutional principles mandating that states have control over their elections,” U.S. District Judge David Carter wrote.

4 outlets

Framing

How the first headlines put it

Stated as fact4
The headlines (4)

9th Circuit questions DOJ demand to set aside 20,000 California mail ballots Toronto Star · stated as fact

US appeals court sceptical of Trump’s lawsuit over California voter rolls Al Jazeera · stated as fact

Chabria: California votes. Trump's Justice Department panics Los Angeles Times · stated as fact

Trump-appointed judge questions president’s bid to block 20,000 California ballots The Independent · stated as fact

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 43 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans left and hedges 19% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
The Straits Times
Hedges 2 of 18 claims Outlet record 64/100
Fox News
Leans left Hedges 1 of 20 claims Outlet record 66/100
The Hindu
Leans right further right than this Hedges 3 of 22 claims Outlet record 78/100
“The articles describe different actions by the Trump administration related to voter eligibility in two separate states (Washington and California).”
The Guardian
Hedges 2 of 18 claims Outlet record 64/100
The Straits Times
Hedges 3 of 26 claims Outlet record 64/100
Al Jazeera
Leans left Hedges 2 of 19 claims Outlet record 60/100
The Straits Times
Leans right further right than this Hedges 3 of 11 claims Outlet record 64/100
“The articles describe different phases of an ongoing investigation: one is about a judge's decision on the credibility of claims, while the other discusses subpoenas issued as part of a criminal probe.”
NBC News
Hedges 2 of 24 claims Outlet record 77/100
“The articles describe different actions by the Trump administration regarding noncitizen voting in different states and at different times.”
ABC News (US)
Leans left Hedges 5 of 14 claims Outlet record 66/100
“Article A discusses a demand by the Trump administration for Washington state to set aside ballots it claims are from noncitizens, while Article B reports a federal judge's decision regarding Trump's claims about noncitizen voting in California. These articles describe different events occurring in distinct states.”
Fox News
Hedges 5 of 28 claims Outlet record 66/100
“Article A discusses federal officials identifying noncitizens registered to vote in Washington state, while Article B focuses on a federal judge's decision regarding Trump's claims about noncitizen voting and mentions estimates from the DHS and DOJ for California.”

Story

Appeals Court Rejects DOJ Bid
Politics · 43 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
59
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
19%
11 of 59 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
67/100
Reason's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
43
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-10-29 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Reason · 1464 article(s) · 4 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 4 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Jacob Sullum
45 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
Contrary to the implication of that label, the initiative affected many people who had no criminal convictions that would justify revoking their visas.
Trump also averred that his projects do not involve much money, although the ballroom alone is expected to cost around $600 million, half of which will be covered by taxpayers.
Last week, the city of Delray Beach, Florida, announced that it will not organize or sponsor next year's St. Patrick's Day parade, citing a state law that takes effect on January 1.
That means SSJC members cannot even legally transport their guns to the vicinity of the synagogue on those occasions, since they would pass within 300 feet of parks, schools, and other houses of worship while walking there.
In a 60 Minutes interview that aired on Sunday night, President Donald Trump conceded that his mass deportation campaign may have contributed to the Republican rout in last week's midterm elections because "a lot of people think it's too tough."
2026-11-11 · assertive framing · Trump Debates Mass Deportation With Himself
They say Hegseth is flouting the law, undermining basic principles of justice, and perverting the mission of the U.S. military by treating civilians as combatants who can be killed at will, from a distance and in cold blood, without any semblance of due process.
Attorney General Todd Blanche nevertheless seemed to reinforce Trump's threat during an interview on CNN's State of the Union yesterday, saying members of the House Oversight Committee, which will be chaired by Rep. Robert Garcia (D–Calif.) in the next congressional session, should "be very worried."
President Donald Trump today announced that Stephen Miller will replace Susie Wiles as White House chief of staff.
Like many other police officers in New Mexico, Paul Jessen Jr., a Bernalillo County sheriff's deputy, was willing to accept bribes from Albuquerque defense attorney Thomas J. Clear III in exchange for compromising DWI cases against Clear's clients.
These results might be dismissed as anomalous, the product of anger at the party of an unpopular president whose war, tariff, and deportation policies, combined with his constant self-aggrandizement and presidential profiteering, alienated Americans who otherwise might have voted for Republicans.
Also by Jacob Sullum
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 45 articles by Jacob Sullum →

Topics

California DHS Nevada The Justice Department U.S.

Subjects

DHS ORG · 7× California GPE · 5× Logan PERSON · 4× Nevada GPE · 4× Weber PERSON · 4× Mullin PERSON · 3× The Justice Department ORG · 3× Carter PERSON · 2× Trump PERSON · 2× U.S. GPE · 2×

Narrative

"Defendants do not 'interfere' with the United States' ability to enforce Section 611 by administering an ongoing election in accordance with established State and Federal law, rather than assuming new obligations pursuant to a federal criminal law they are not responsible for enforcing," Carter writes.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-10-29
In a July 16 letter to California Secretary of State Shirley Weber, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) said a "preliminary review" suggested there "may be as many as 190,832 non-citizens registered to vote" in her state.

Claims (59 extracted, 11 hedged)

In a July 16 letter to California Secretary of State Shirley Weber, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) said a "preliminary review" suggested there "may be as many as 190,832 non-citizens registered to vote" in her state. uncertain
review → say → state
Weber was skeptical—for good reason, it turned out. asserted
it → turn → reason
Three months later, the Trump administration reduced that estimate by nearly 90 percent, saying about 20,000 "likely noncitizens" had received California vote-by-mail ballots. asserted
noncitizens → reduce → ballots
The Justice Department gave Weber and Dean Logan, Los Angeles County's top election official, 48 hours to determine whether any of the people on the government's list were in fact citizens. asserted
any → give → fact
Otherwise, it said, Weber and Logan should segregate those ballots and refrain from processing them until citizenship could be verified. uncertain
citizenship → say → them
After Weber and Logan declined to comply with the Justice Department's demands, it asked a federal judge for a temporary restraining order (TRO) requiring them to do so—a request that he rejected in a scathing opinion on Wednesday. asserted
he → decline → Wednesday
"Never before in American history has the federal government, on the eve of an election, sought to coerce a state and local government to abandon their own Constitutional elections procedures and bend to the will of the Executive Branch asserted
government → seek → Branch
," writes U.S. District Judge David O. Carter, a Bill Clinton appointee. asserted
Carter → write → ?
"This request violates longstanding constitutional principles mandating that states have control over their elections. asserted
states → violate → elections
If Plaintiff's last-minute request for relief were granted, either party could create chaos for their own political purposes to disrupt the election process. uncertain
party → grant → process
Over 20,000 registered Californians would potentially lose the right that generations of Americans have fought to preserve." asserted
generations → register → Americans
The Justice Department delivered its list of "likely noncitizens" to Logan three weeks before Election Day. asserted
Department → deliver → Day
At that point, Los Angeles County already had sent ballots to 5.9 million voters and processed 331,000 of them. asserted
County → send → them
Logan said he was "legally prohibited" from doing what the Justice Department wanted because it had failed to explain the methodology used to compile the list, raising the possibility that citizens would be denied their voting rights. asserted
citizens → say → rights
On July 17, DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin averred that "as many as" 15,903 noncitizens were registered to vote in Nevada. asserted
noncitizens → aver → Nevada
The following month, when the DHS submitted a list of allegedly illegal voters to Nevada election officials, the number had fallen to 185—99 percent lower than Mullin's original figure. uncertain
number → submit → figure
It turned out that every one of those 185 voters was a U.S. citizen. asserted
one → turn → voters
"DHS has identified over 250,000 potential non-citizens illegally registered to vote" in California, New Jersey, Nevada, and Pennsylvania, Mullin said in July. asserted
Mullin → identify → July
He was echoing President Donald Trump, who for years has grossly exaggerated the extent of illegal voting by noncitizens, often in service of his own vanity. asserted
who → echo → vanity
Trump has repeatedly claimed, for example, that he would have won the popular vote in 2016 but for "the millions of people who voted illegally," and in January 2024 he warned that noncitizen voters "could very well affect the next election." uncertain
voters → claim → election
In a speech the night before Mullin's announcement, Trump asserted that the DHS had "identified approximately 278,000 non-citizens who are registered to vote in federal elections. asserted
who → assert → elections
Judging from Nevada's experience, the actual number may be closer to zero. uncertain
number → judge → zero
It is hard to say, because the methods used by the DHS remain hazy. asserted
methods → say → DHS
In the California case, Carter says, the DHS "purchased a voter file that appeared to reflect 'the actual voter rolls in California, that as of August 2025, may be used for the 2026 federal election.'" uncertain
that → say → election
It "then 'enhance[d]' the voter data through a 'reliable third-party data analytics'" and used records maintained by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) to find "an internal USCIS immigration number" that "may" correspond to each registered voter. uncertain
that → enhance[d → voter
"The matches are scored," Carter notes, "because 'the resulting data may be incomplete, outdated, or mismatched.' uncertain
data → score → ?
" The DHS "then compared the potential identity matches to Department of State and Social Security Administration data to screen out U.S. citizens," Carter adds. asserted
Carter → compare → citizens
"In the next step, a confidence level was assigned (where a high score supported a 'strong identity link') asserted
score → assign → link
a manual review was conducted for each match to 'determine which registered voters'" were "likely to be aliens." asserted
voters → conduct → match
Then came "a 'quality review' to identify issues such as 'duplicate entries' and 'incomplete records,'" followed by "an 'enrichment process' that utilized 'additional unique identifiers' to 'improv[e]' the matching process. asserted
that → come → process
The government did not initially specify the source of the "reliable third-party data analytics." asserted
government → specify → analytics
But it later revealed that "the third-party platform it relied on was Lexis Nexis," Carter notes. asserted
Carter → reveal → ?
"It remains unknown how Lexis Nexis performed its analysis, such as how it 'linked names to Social Security numbers not available on the California public voter file.' asserted
Nexis → remain → file
Plaintiff likewise did not explain what its 'enrichment process' entailed or how it occurred. asserted
it → explain → what
Plaintiff also provided 'no error rates' or 'validation against a reliable benchmark' that would enable a determination of the accuracy of its findings. asserted
that → provide → findings
Omissions of this critical information prevent an evaluation of Plaintiff's procedure, including how Plaintiff reduced its initial claim of nearly 200,000 alleged noncitizens to 20,000 individuals. uncertain
Plaintiff → prevent → individuals
" Potential sources of error include conflating people with similar or identical names and outdated records that do not reflect recent naturalization. asserted
that → include → naturalization
Because it is unclear how the DHS tried to address such problems, it is not surprising that Weber and Logan did not want to rely on the Trump administration's list, especially given its pattern of dramatically reducing the putative number of illegally registered voters. uncertain
Weber → try → voters
"It is well-documented that matching voter registration records with data from other administrative databases 'presents numerous challenges,'" Carter writes. asserted
Carter → document → challenges
And given the potential for error, he says, "Plaintiff's allegations are not credible." asserted
allegations → give → error
…and 19 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support