Photo via The Guardian

Experts warn AI copyright changes could breach Australian constitution and spark huge compensation rights case

Read the original at The Guardian ↗
Cite

Butler, J. (2026, October 30). Experts warn AI copyright changes could breach Australian constitution and spark huge compensation rights case. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/law/2026/oct/31/experts-warn-ai-copyright-changes-could-breach-australian-constitution-and-spark-huge-compensation-rights-case

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

The Guardian · collected 2026-10-30 · by Josh Butler

Quick Summary

Coalition senators and the recording industry warn that changes to Australian copyright law could breach the country’s constitution by acquiring property on unjust terms, potentially exposing Australia to significant legal challenges from rights holders globally. The attorney general's department acknowledges concern over this issue, while constitutional expert Anne Twomey suggests it depends on how any legislation is drafted. Labor is considering reforms to accommodate AI companies’ requests for access to copyrighted material without stringent licensing agreements, but creative industries fear this could undermine their rights and compensation under existing law.
Written by AI on 2026-10-30, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).

AI analysis

Story summary

The Australian government is facing potential legal challenges and constitutional concerns as it considers changes to copyright law to accommodate AI companies. Coalition senators and representatives from the recording industry warn that allowing AI firms to scrape music, books, and journalism could breach the constitution and expose Australia to massive legal action and compensation claims globally. Anne Twomey, a leading Australian constitutional expert, acknowledged the potential issue depending on how legislation is drafted. Nationals Senator Ross Cadell expressed concern about liability for "just terms" compensation for every rights holder worldwide if such changes are made. The attorney general’s department has admitted it is aware of these issues amid intense lobbying from tech companies and rights holders ahead of a federal government announcement on AI regulations.

Written for “AI Copyright Concerns In Australia” on 2026-11-21, grounded in this article and the 0 other(s) covering the same event.

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans left and hedges 29% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
New York Post
Leans strongly right further right than this Hedges 4 of 21 claims Outlet record 66/100
“The articles discuss different legal and constitutional concerns in separate countries regarding AI scraping of copyrighted material, rather than the same specific court filing or incident.”
The Guardian
Leans left Hedges 3 of 42 claims Outlet record 64/100
“While both articles discuss opposition to proposed changes in AI copyright law, they describe different aspects of the issue: Article A focuses on constitutional concerns and potential legal ramifications, while Article B highlights local opposition within a specific electorate.”

Story

AI Copyright Concerns In Australia
Politics · 1 article(s) covering the same event.
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
34
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
29%
10 of 34 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
64/100
The Guardian's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
1
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-10-30 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

The Guardian · 3752 article(s) · 8 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 8 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Josh Butler
32 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
The music industry has declared it will not accept an AI carveout deal that leaves other creative sectors behind, rejecting a reported proposal to give musicians special treatment while allowing big tech to train on other copyrighted material – described by David Pocock as a “divide and conquer strategy”.
While the government maintains it will not undermine copyright law, the industry minister, Tim Ayres, said on Tuesday “the status quo is no good” for the creative sector, ahead of a package of AI legislation expected by early 2027.
As Labor considers copyright changes in an AI policy suite including datacentres, online safety, energy resources and economic benefits, the South Australian backbencher added weight to mooted constitutional challenges as to whether watering down copyright law would be an illegal acquisition of property.
Australian concerns In Australia, a former intelligence officer said they expected Australian security agencies would have sought briefings from overseas counterparts about Megaspeed or undertaken their own assessments of the local subsidiary this week.
A Microsoft spokesperson said the company “had no indication of a cyber-attack” and suggested the issue could be related to a configuration change to its servers that was causing some to become overloaded and taken offline.
Entry-level jobs will be the first to be automated due to AI, but it could mean fewer hours and higher wages for ordinary workers – or make jobs tougher with more burnout and workplace surveillance – the government has warned employers.
“The embassy of Finland in Canberra will be temporarily closed on Tuesday, 10 November 2026.
A key recommendation is for the attorney general’s department, the Australian federal police and home affairs to consider reforming the law to introduce “penalties for egregious regulatory non-compliance” and a “failure to prevent” offence which would criminalise developing an AI model that engaged in harmful conduct while failing “to take reasonable steps to prevent that harm”.
Australia weakening copyright protections to aid AI companies would be “ridiculous and dangerous”, the global peak body for the music recording industry has warned as it watches with concern how the Albanese government responds to big tech’s demands.
When will Australia see the benefits of the AI and datacentre boom?
Also by Josh Butler
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 32 articles by Josh Butler →

Topics

Australia Australian Coalition Guardian Australia Nationals

Subjects

Australia GPE · 3× Cadell PERSON · 3× Guardian Australia ORG · 3× Anne Twomey PERSON · 2× Australian NORP · 2× Twomey PERSON · 2× Coalition ORG · 1× Michaelia Cash PERSON · 1× Nationals ORG · 1× Ross Cadell PERSON · 1×

Narrative

Chris Maund, CEO of Mushroom Records, said current copyright law was working and that AI companies should use existing licensing arrangements, noting companies such as Spotify were already making AI-related deals. He also raised concern about international ramifications were Australia to change copyright law, saying it would not only apply to Australian artists and copyright owners.
framing: mixed · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-10-30
Altering copyright law to allow AI companies to scrape music, books and journalism could trigger a constitutional breach, Coalition senators and the recording industry have warned, as they raise new fears it could open Australia to massive legal action and compensation claims from rights holders worldwide.

Claims (34 extracted, 10 hedged)

Altering copyright law to allow AI companies to scrape music, books and journalism could trigger a constitutional breach, Coalition senators and the recording industry have warned, as they raise new fears it could open Australia to massive legal action and compensation claims from rights holders worldwide. uncertain
it → alter → holders
The attorney general’s department admitted it was “extremely alive” to the issue, and Australia’s leading constitutional expert, Anne Twomey, agreed there was “potentially” a concern – depending how legislation was drafted – that granting AI companies permission to scrape copyrighted material from the internet could amount to an acquisition of property by the government. uncertain
granting → admit → government
In a simmering debate centred on the same legal point as the movie The Castle, the question of acquiring property “on just terms” is emerging as a key concern amid furious lobbying from tech companies and rights holders ahead of a looming federal government announcement on AI. “We could be liable for ‘just terms’ compensation for acquiring that property for every rights holder on Earth,” Ross Cadell, a Nationals senator, told Guardian Australia. uncertain
Cadell → simmer → Australia
Michaelia Cash, the shadow attorney general, said the government should not “sell out Australian creators and rights holders in the rush to entice AI investment”. asserted
government → say → investment
Labor is mulling copyright changes in a suite of reforms around AI, including datacentres, online safety, workforce, energy and the economy. asserted
Labor → mull → datacentres
While the prime minister, Anthony Albanese, has promised “the strongest possible protection”, warning it would be “theft” if creatives weren’t paid for their work, creative industries are alarmed that AI companies have requested a weakening of copyright law to train on Australian material. asserted
companies → promise → material
Some AI companies have rejected making licensing agreements under existing copyright law, saying it was too difficult. asserted
it → reject → law
Anthropic suggested an “opt-out” model which would allow it to scrape content unless a rightholder deployed digital protections signaling an objection. uncertain
rightholder → suggest → objection
A fresh concern being aired by sceptics and creatives is that any weakening of copyright to benefit AI could represent a breach of section 51 of the constitution, which allows the commonwealth to make laws about “the acquisition of property on just terms”. “If they go ahead with an opt-out model, it does raise a real question of whether the government is acquiring the intellectual property rights of others,” said Cadell, a member of the federal parliamentary committee on AI. uncertain
Cadell → air → AI
“How we support property rights is core to this.” asserted
support → support → this
A spokesperson for the attorney general, Michelle Rowland, said the government was “committed to supporting” creatives and pledged that “any future copyright changes deliver meaningful control and fair compensation”. asserted
changes → say → control
Anne Twomey, professor emerita of law at the University of Sydney, said the issue was exceedingly complex and noted no legislative proposal had been aired. asserted
proposal → say → Sydney
She said numerous cases had come before the high court relating to copyright and acquisition of property, including about video games, cigarette plain packaging and cassette tapes, with varying outcomes. asserted
cases → say → outcomes
Twomey expected the federal government would be hyperaware of such concerns, but said granting a new right to AI companies to use copyrighted material and diminishing the rights of copyright holders could “potentially” trigger constitutional issues. uncertain
granting → expect → issues
“The high court has recognised a number of exceptions to section 51 … asserted
court → recognise → section
One would want to be quite confident before enacting the legislation about whether or not section 51 would apply,” Twomey told Guardian Australia. asserted
Twomey → want → Australia
She said any change allowing Australia to host AI companies training on international data could potentially create grounds for global rights holders to take legal action here. uncertain
holders → say → action
Cadell told Guardian Australia he worried about such a development opening the federal government to liability for “the biggest compensation rights case in history”. asserted
development → tell → history
Cadell raised his concerns about the constitution in a committee hearing with the attorney general’s department on Friday, in which officials said they were conscious of those issues. asserted
they → raise → issues
Officials did not directly answer when Cadell asked about international implications and liability for compensation to foreign rights holders. asserted
Cadell → answer → holders
Annabelle Herd, the CEO of the Australian Recording Industry Association, claimed any proposal to allow AI companies to scrape data was “clearly an acquisition of property”. asserted
companies → claim → property
“It’s hard to imagine what kind of compensation would make up for the fact that they’re basically taking our right … and trading it away to the AI companies to then monetise themselves, and that appears to be a clear path to a constitutional challenge.” asserted
that → ’ → challenge
Chris Maund, CEO of Mushroom Records, said current copyright law was working and that AI companies should use existing licensing arrangements, noting companies such as Spotify were already making AI-related deals. He also raised concern about international ramifications were Australia to change copyright law, saying it would not only apply to Australian artists and copyright owners. asserted
it → say → artists
“The AI company could do their training here in Australia and circumvent the copyright laws that apply outside of Australia, and that’s why the international creative industries are watching this very closely,” he said. uncertain
he → do → this
Maund said international rights holder groups had been urging Labor not to weaken copyright law. asserted
groups → say → law
Guardian Australia has provided submissions to the Joint Select Committee as a member of Australia’s wider rights holder community. asserted
Australia → provide → community
They’ve set up Creative Music Australia, which companies like us and our artists have done very well out of, but it feels like they’re out of step with artists and copyright owners on this point,” he said. asserted
he → set → point
Cash said the Coalition welcomed the benefits of AI and wanted investment, but also raised the constitutional concern. asserted
Coalition → say → concern
“That is the prime minister’s own test, and the government should be held to it,” she said of compensation to rights holders. asserted
she → hold → holders
“The constitutional question of property rights and their acquisition on just terms is also a live issue we will be examining depending on what the government puts forward.” asserted
government → examine → what
Cadell said while AI had benefits, he worried about its risks. asserted
he → say → risks
“There’s lots of talk about what the benefits may be and what may happen. uncertain
what → ’ → talk
But if we take these rights away, we know what will happen,” Cadell said. asserted
Cadell → take → rights
“I don’t want to hurt people for a ‘may’.” uncertain
I → want → may
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support