Photo via Toronto Star

Lindsay Clancy returns to court in a bid to dismiss charges she killed her three young children

Read the original at Toronto Star ↗
Cite

Casey, M. (2026, November 2). Lindsay Clancy returns to court in a bid to dismiss charges she killed her three young children. Toronto Star. https://www.thestar.com/news/world/united-states/lindsay-clancy-returns-to-court-in-a-bid-to-dismiss-charges-she-killed-her-three-young-children/article_0ce9c219-a80e-51eb-8a0c-b69eb5f7c7a6.html

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

Toronto Star · collected 2026-11-02 · by Michael Casey

Quick Summary

Lindsay Clancy appeared in Plymouth, Massachusetts court on Monday to contest charges related to the deaths of her three children in 2023. Her defense team claims double jeopardy applies due to a mistrial following a hung jury in September. The hearing became contentious when Clancy's attorney accused a juror of misconduct during deliberations, prompting arguments over whether the judge adequately investigated the issue. Prosecutors maintain that further judicial inquiry would have improperly influenced the jury’s deliberative process.
Written by AI on 2026-11-02, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

Lindsay Clancy, accused of murdering her three young children, returned to a Massachusetts court on November 2 for a hearing that could determine whether she will face another trial after a hung jury in September. Prosecutors argue that a new trial is necessary and legal, while defense attorneys claim the lone holdout juror's behavior justifies dismissing the case due to potential misconduct. The court has scheduled another hearing for November 16 to further discuss the case's future, with prosecutors now stating their intention to retry Clancy despite the mistrial declaration.

Written for “Lindsay Clancy Likely Headed For New Trial” on 2026-11-21, grounded in this article and the 21 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

12 outlets covered “Lindsay Clancy Likely Headed For New Trial”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

Toronto StarThis outlet2 Nov

Lindsay Clancy appeared in Plymouth, Massachusetts court on Monday to contest charges related to the deaths of her three children in 2023. Her defense team claims double jeopardy applies due to a mistrial following a hung jury in September. The hearing became contentious when Clancy's attorney accused a juror of misconduct during deliberations, prompting arguments over whether the judge adequately investigated the…

Lindsay Clancy returns to court in a bid to dismiss charges she killed her three young children (this article)
NBC News2 Nov

Lindsay Clancy appeared in court on Monday to argue against a retrial based on double jeopardy after her first murder trial ended in mistrial. Her defense team seeks to dismiss charges by claiming their client cannot face prosecution twice for the same crime, while prosecutors insist they have the right to pursue justice for Clancy's three children who were killed in January 2023. The case has garnered national…

Lindsay Clancy returns to court as defense seeks to block retrial in murder case →4 articles from NBC News on this story
New York Post2 Nov

In a Massachusetts courtroom on Monday, Judge Sullivan reprimanded Lindsay Clancy's attorney Alex Reddington for publicly disclosing the identity of the holdout juror who caused a mistrial in Clancy’s case. The judge instructed Reddington to refer to the juror only as "Juror Doe." Prosecutors and Clancy’s legal team debated whether the entire case should be dismissed due to potential misconduct by Desronvil, the…

Lindsay Clancy judge slaps down her hotshot lawyer after he names holdout juror in court →2 articles from New York Post on this story
BBC2 Nov

Massachusetts prosecutors are indicating plans for a retrial of Lindsay Clancy on charges related to the murder of her three children in 2023. At a recent hearing, Judge William Sullivan scheduled another meeting for November 16th to rule on motions that could impact how the potential retrial proceeds. The initial trial ended in September with a hung jury due to disagreement among jurors, particularly regarding one…

Prosecutors hint at retrial for Lindsay Clancy on murder charges →2 articles from BBC on this story
The Independent2 Nov

Lindsay Clancy appeared in court on Monday to argue for the dismissal of charges related to the deaths of her three children due to double jeopardy, asserting that the mistrial could have been avoided without dismissing the jury. Prosecutors contend that investigating the lone holdout juror was unnecessary and would have improperly influenced the jury’s deliberations. The hearing also addressed a request by…

Lindsay Clancy returns to court in a bid to dismiss charges she killed her three young children →2 articles from The Independent on this story
Show 6 more outlets
Daily Mail29 Oct

Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz is urging a judge not to dismiss the murder charges against Lindsay Clancy, who admitted to killing her three young children in January 2023. Prosecutors argue that Clancy’s case does not meet double jeopardy criteria since it involves a mistrial rather than an acquittal or conviction. Despite this stance, the district attorney's office remains noncommittal about whether…

Lindsay Clancy murder charges should not be dismissed, says DA who still won't confirm whether he'll try killer mom a second time →
The Straits Times2 Nov

Lindsay Clancy appeared in Plymouth, Massachusetts court on November 2 for a hearing that could determine whether she faces a retrial for killing her three children in January 2023. Judge William Sullivan is set to decide if the case will proceed based on arguments from both sides; prosecutors want to retry Clancy on first-degree murder charges while her defense team claims double jeopardy protections should prevent…

Lindsay Clancy returns to Massachusetts court for hearing that could shape potential murder retrial →
The Guardian2 Nov

Lindsay Clancy appeared in court again on Monday to request dismissal of murder charges against her for killing her three children, following a mistrial due to a deadlocked jury in September 2023. Her lawyer argued that Judge William Sullivan should have further investigated juror misconduct based on notes indicating one juror was not adhering to the rules, which could have led to dismissing this juror and…

Lindsay Clancy back in court seeking to dismiss murder charges after mistrial →
Al Jazeera2 Nov

Lindsay Clancy appeared in court on Monday for a second time since September to attempt dropping the first-degree murder charges against her for killing her three children in Duxbury, Massachusetts, in 2023. Her lawyers argued that Judge William Sullivan should have further investigated after receiving two notes from the jury foreperson indicating issues with one juror's adherence to court rules during…

Lindsay Clancy in court to drop child murder charges after mistrial →
South China Morning Post2 Nov

Lindsay Clancy appeared in court for a second time on Monday to challenge charges that she murdered her three young children. The case has seen no verdict since September when a trial ended with a hung jury due to jurors' inability to reach an agreement. During the latest hearing, Clancy's defense team moved to dismiss charges based on double jeopardy and also sought an investigation into one juror’s conduct during…

Lindsay Clancy back in court in bid to dismiss charges she killed her 3 young children →
ABC News (AU)3 Nov

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer is urging a judge to either dismiss murder charges against her or set a new trial date after a mistrial was declared due to an 11-1 split in favor of acquittal. The defense argues the case should have been dismissed earlier on double jeopardy grounds, citing that removing the lone juror who favored conviction could have led to a unanimous decision without needing a mistrial. A hearing is…

Lindsay Clancy lawyer urges judge to dismiss case or put it back on trial →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

Reported by outlets on both sides of the middle

The focus at Monday's hearing in front of Judge William Sullivan is expected to be on a motion from the defense to dismiss the charges on double jeopardy grounds.

4 outlets
Show 1 more

The proceedings grew heated as defense attorney Kevin Reddington accused the lone holdout juror of using a cellphone to research terms related to the case and questioned whether he had been truthful during jury selection.

4 outlets

Framing

How the first headlines put it

Attributed to a source1
Stated as fact2
The headlines (3)

Lindsay Clancy murder charges should not be dismissed, says DA who still won't confirm whether he'll try killer mom a second time Daily Mail · attributed to a source

Lindsay Clancy jury notes on holdout juror revealed as prosecutors urge against bid to toss charges New York Post · stated as fact

Prosecutors ask judge to reject Lindsay Clancy defense’s motion to dismiss charges NBC News · stated as fact

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 22 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 7% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
The Independent
Hedges 3 of 23 claims Outlet record 59/100
South China Morning Post
Hedges 0 of 5 claims Outlet record 62/100
The Guardian
Hedges 3 of 23 claims Outlet record 64/100
BBC News
Hedges 8 of 43 claims Outlet record 65/100
NBC News
Hedges 3 of 33 claims Outlet record 77/100
Al Jazeera
Hedges 4 of 22 claims Outlet record 60/100
The Straits Times
Hedges 2 of 17 claims Outlet record 64/100
CBS News
Hedges 0 of 2 claims Outlet record 66/100
The Independent
Hedges 2 of 26 claims Outlet record 59/100

Story

Lindsay Clancy Likely Headed For New Trial
Crime & Law · 22 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
43
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
7%
3 of 43 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
64/100
Toronto Star's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
22
Crime & Law
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-11-02 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Toronto Star · 16434 article(s) · 31 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 31 correction(s)
2026-11-17
Correction
2026-10-26
Correction
2026-10-24
Correction
2026-10-07
Correction
2026-09-24
Correction

Who wrote this

Michael Casey
25 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
In a May 2026 interview with The Associated Press, Johnson said he didn’t hear or see the attack.
During a May 2026 interview with The Associated Press, he said he neither saw nor heard the event.
Texts in late 2020, after she was pregnant, showed they argued over what role, if any, Farwell would play in the child’s life.
Clancy’s defense team had asked Judge William Sullivan to end the case based on an unusual argument that a mistrial shouldn’t have been declared in September when jurors were unable to reach a unanimous verdict.
Defense attorney Daniel Marx criticized the decision to prosecute in a statement, saying, "The DOJ never should have brought this highly unusual ‘smuggling’ prosecution against Kseniia Petrova, a talented scientist at Harvard," and adding, "Ms. Petrova only sought to advance medical research into aging that could benefit everyone, and her handling of scientific samples — inert, non-living, non-toxic, frog embryos — never posed any danger to anyone."
They argued that the government only filed criminal charges after it looked like she would win her immigration case.
Judge William Sullivan repeatedly intervened as Reddington publicly identified the juror and raised allegations involving potentially confidential information.
They could choose to retry her on first-degree murder charges or pursue lesser charges, including second-degree murder or manslaughter, or drop the case entirely.
In southwestern Colorado, officials in Pagosa Springs, a town in the Rockies located near ski resorts and known for its hot springs, warned in a Facebook post of potentially “catastrophic flooding” as the San Juan River was forecast to crest at more than 19 feet (5.8 meters) around 11:00 p.m. Sunday.
An expert brought in by federal authorities, Dr. William Smock, concluded Birchmore was strangled with a duffel bag strap and that she struggled before dying.
Also by Michael Casey
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 25 articles by Michael Casey →

Topics

Mass. Massachusetts PLYMOUTH U.S.

Subjects

Sullivan ORG · 7× Clancy PERSON · 3× Weinberg PERSON · 3× Desronvil PERSON · 2× Kevin Reddington PERSON · 1× Lindsay Clancy PERSON · 1× Mass. GPE · 1× Massachusetts GPE · 1× PLYMOUTH GPE · 1× William Sullivan PERSON · 1×

Narrative

Prosecutors seek restrictions on public statements The other motion expected to be discussed was the Commonwealth’s request for a gag order that would bar attorneys and their supporters “from making extrajudicial statements to the media that would have a substantial likelihood of materially prejudicing the criminal proceeding.”
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-11-02
Judge William Sullivan repeatedly intervened as Reddington publicly identified the juror and raised allegations involving potentially confidential information.

Claims (43 extracted, 3 hedged)

Lindsay Clancy returned to court Monday in a bid to dismiss the charges that she murdered her three young children. asserted
she → return → children
The hearing Monday was the second time the Massachusetts mother has been in court since her trial ended with a deadlocked jury in September after jurors were unable to agree on a verdict. asserted
jurors → end → verdict
Its focus was a motion from the defense to dismiss the charges on double jeopardy grounds. asserted
focus → dismiss → grounds
The proceedings grew heated as defense attorney Kevin Reddington accused the lone holdout juror of using a cellphone to research terms related to the case and questioned whether he had been truthful during jury selection. asserted
he → grow → selection
Judge William Sullivan repeatedly intervened as Reddington publicly identified the juror and raised allegations involving potentially confidential information. asserted
Reddington → intervene → information
Clancy has never disputed killing her three young children in 2023, but her lawyer has argued she had postpartum psychosis and was unable to control her behavior. asserted
she → dispute → behavior
Prosecutors have acknowledged that the 36-year-old Clancy had mental health problems but said she acted deliberately and understood her actions were wrong. asserted
actions → acknowledge → problems
EDITOR’S NOTE: This story includes discussion of suicide. asserted
story → include → suicide
If you or someone you know needs help, the national suicide and crisis lifeline in the U.S. is available by calling or texting 988. asserted
lifeline → know → 988
Defense challenges judge’s handling of deadlocked jury asserted
Defense → challenge → jury
At Monday’s hearing, defense attorney Martin G. Weinberg argued that Sullivan should have investigated further after the jury foreperson sent two notes indicating that a juror was not following the rules. asserted
juror → argue → rules
Further questioning could have revealed grounds to remove the lone holdout juror, Michael Desronvil, and continue deliberations — potentially avoiding the mistrial, he said. uncertain
he → reveal → mistrial
After receiving the notes, Sullivan spoke with each juror, reminded them of their duties and explained what constitutes reasonable doubt. asserted
what → receive → doubt
He asked whether they could apply the law to the case, and all said yes. uncertain
all → ask → case
But Weinberg argued that Sullivan had not gone far enough. asserted
Sullivan → argue → ?
A juror who said he could follow the law could have been lying, Weinberg said, and the situation warranted questioning the foreperson separately to learn more about what was happening during deliberations. uncertain
what → say → deliberations
“That’s what the foreperson was asking the court to do,” Weinberg said. “I can see that this is not easy,” he told the judge at one point. asserted
he → ’ → point
“You don’t have to keep saying that — I have thick skin,” Sullivan replied. asserted
Sullivan → have → skin
Prosecutor Jennifer Sprague argued that Sullivan had struck the right balance in his handling of the jury. asserted
Sullivan → argue → jury
Pressing the foreperson further would have required delving into the substance of the jury’s deliberations, potentially inserting the court’s “interpretation of what is correct” into the process. asserted
what → press → process
“You were the one who looked them in the eyes and asked them the questions and was in the best position to judge their credibility,” she told Sullivan. asserted
she → look → Sullivan
“And you credited their answers.” asserted
you → credit → answers
Sprague argued that there was no indication the holdout juror’s disagreement stemmed from personal bias or an inability to deliberate, rather than a different assessment of the evidence. asserted
disagreement → argue → evidence
“It is clear from the record that this juror did not refuse to deliberate,” she said. asserted
she → refuse → record
“He refused to agree.” asserted
He → refuse → ?
Prosecutors defend decision to declare mistrial Since the trial ended, Desronvil said he was certain of Clancy’s guilt but that no one would listen to him. asserted
one → defend → him
Prosecutors argue that double jeopardy “does not bar the Commonwealth from seeking justice on behalf of the three victims.” asserted
jeopardy → argue → victims
They argue it was unnecessary to investigate Desronvil, whom they don’t name but describe as the dissenting juror, because the foreperson’s complaint did not allege “any personal issue, bias, or extraneous matter attributable to the dissenting juror.” asserted
complaint → argue → juror
Singling that juror out, they argued, for an investigation “surely would have led to judicial coercion” and the “impermissible intrusion into the substance of the jury’s private deliberations.” asserted
they → single → deliberations
Sullivan did not immediately rule on the motion to dismiss, saying he would take it under advisement and issue a decision as soon as possible. asserted
he → rule → decision
When Reddington began criticizing Desronvil’s conduct during the trial in court, Sullivan sharply interrupted, admonishing the defense attorney for repeatedly identifying him by name. asserted
Sullivan → begin → name
The two raised their voices and spoke over each other as Reddington pushed back. asserted
Reddington → raise → other
Reddington said that the name was already “all over the internet,” but eventually stopped using it. asserted
name → say → it
Reddington also alleged that the juror had used a cellphone to research terms related to the case and that he wasn’t truthful about his criminal history during jury selection — something that, if true, would be “a fatal infection of the independence, the honesty and the integrity of this juror.” asserted
that → allege → juror
Reddington insisted the information prosecutors considered confidential was relevant to his challenge. asserted
prosecutors → insist → challenge
“Why don’t we all dial this back a little bit,” Sullivan said, calling the attorneys to a sidebar after prosecutors objected to Reddington’s comments. asserted
prosecutors → dial → comments
Prosecutors seek restrictions on public statements The other motion expected to be discussed was the Commonwealth’s request for a gag order that would bar attorneys and their supporters “from making extrajudicial statements to the media that would have a substantial likelihood of materially prejudicing the criminal proceeding.” asserted
that → seek → proceeding
Attorney Kevin Reddington has given a series of interviews since the mistrial and held walking news conferences almost every day during the proceedings. asserted
Reddington → give → proceedings
Prosecutors, in contrast, never talked to reporters. asserted
Prosecutors → talk → reporters
In response, Clancy’s lawyers said this motion would amount to prior restraint since it is barring speech before it occurs. asserted
it → say → speech
…and 3 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support