Photo via Reason

Andrew McCarthy on the Hegseth Impeachment

Read the original at Reason ↗
Cite

Somin, I. (2026, November 9). Andrew McCarthy on the Hegseth Impeachment. Reason. https://reason.com/volokh/2026/11/09/andy-mccarthy-on-the-hegseth-impeachment/

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

Reason · collected 2026-11-09 · by Ilya Somin

Quick Summary

Andrew McCarthy, a conservative legal commentator and former federal prosecutor, argues in the National Review that Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth should face impeachment for his role in the "drug boat" strikes and for abusing command authority by attempting to discipline Senator Kelly. McCarthy contends that Hegseth's actions were unconstitutional and indefensible, noting that drug trafficking does not justify military intervention or extrajudicial killings. He also agrees with the author on the charge of violating separation-of-powers principles in an effort to silence congressional criticism.
Written by AI on 2026-11-10, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

Pete Hegseth, the Defense Secretary, narrowly avoided impeachment by the House on November 13, 2026, after Democrats failed to secure a majority vote due to low attendance. The impeachment effort was spearheaded by Republican Representative Thomas Massie, who argued that Hegseth's handling of the war with Iran constituted "high crimes and misdemeanors." Despite Massie's push, many constituents in his district criticized the effort as politically motivated and lacking public support. President Donald Trump has maintained his support for Hegseth, stating that he is "doing a great job," even as Republicans suffered significant losses in the midterm elections. Democrats, who won control of the House and Senate, are now considering other avenues to investigate the war and potentially hold Hegseth accountable.

Written for “Hegseth Impeachment Fails” on 2026-11-21, grounded in this article and the 270 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

39 outlets covered “Hegseth Impeachment Fails”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

ReasonThis outlet9 Nov

Andrew McCarthy, a conservative legal commentator and former federal prosecutor, argues in the National Review that Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth should face impeachment for his role in the "drug boat" strikes and for abusing command authority by attempting to discipline Senator Kelly. McCarthy contends that Hegseth's actions were unconstitutional and indefensible, noting that drug trafficking does not justify…

Andrew McCarthy on the Hegseth Impeachment (this article)9 articles from Reason on this story
CBS News11 Nov

House Republicans prevented a bid to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, successfully blocking it during a recent vote. However, if eleven absent Democratic representatives had participated, the outcome could have been different. The article highlights the significance of these missing votes in altering the result of the impeachment proceedings.

11 House Democrats fail to attend vote on Pete Hegseth's impeachment →28 articles from CBS News on this story
Just the News12 Nov

Representative Melanie Stansbury explained on social media that she was one of 11 Democrats who missed a failed impeachment vote against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth due to rush-hour traffic and a police motorcade. The House of Representatives voted 211-204 on Tuesday to refer Kentucky GOP Rep. Thomas Massie's articles of impeachment to the House Judiciary Committee, a move that effectively stalls the attempt…

Democratic House lawmaker blames traffic for missing Hegseth impeachment vote: 'I am so sorry' →23 articles from Just the News on this story
Washington Examiner12 Nov

Democrats' celebration after winning midterms was short-lived as they faced two significant voting setbacks within days. On Tuesday, Republicans succeeded in advancing articles of impeachment against Secretary of War Pete Hegseth despite the Democrats' efforts. The following day, a bill that reduced veterans’ benefits for certain claims and increased them for others passed without Democratic opposition. These events…

Democrats’ midterm honeymoon over as they suffer quick-fire double voting blunder →21 articles from Washington Examiner on this story
The Independent12 Nov

Representative Jonathan Jackson of Illinois was one of 11 Democrats who missed the vote to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, leading to a 211-204 decision to refer eight articles of impeachment to the Judiciary Committee. Jackson was reportedly seen near the Capitol minutes before the vote, contradicting his earlier claim that traffic issues prevented his attendance. During an interview with TMZ, Jackson…

Democrat who missed Hegseth impeachment vote caught outside Capitol ‘with minutes to spare’ →18 articles from The Independent on this story
The Straits Times10 Nov

On November 10, the US House of Representatives voted 211 to 204 to refer impeachment charges against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to the Republican-led Judiciary Committee, effectively halting the impeachment process initiated by Representative Thomas Massie from Kentucky. Only Massie, a Republican, opposed this motion.

US House votes to derail impeachment of Defence Secretary Hegseth →15 articles from The Straits Times on this story
Show 33 more outlets
Fox News14 Nov

This reporting piece explores the divided reactions of northern Kentucky residents to Representative Thomas Massie's effort to impeach War Secretary Pete Hegseth over the Iran war. Local constituents offered conflicting views, with some praising Massie's independence and principles while others dismissed the move as "pure spite" and "petty" political payback. The piece highlights these internal district tensions…

Massie's push to impeach Hegseth splits constituents in his own backyard: 'Pure spite' →13 articles from Fox News on this story
Al Jazeera11 Nov

The U.S. House of Representatives voted 211-204 to refer impeachment articles against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth back to the Judiciary Committee, effectively halting any immediate impeachment proceedings. Democrats initiated this move but their absence of eleven representatives during the vote was decisive in allowing Republicans to pass the procedural measure. This outcome prevents a full House vote before the…

Did Democrats save Pete Hegseth from impeachment? →13 articles from Al Jazeera on this story
NBC News10 Nov

The Republican-led House voted on Tuesday to reject a motion for impeaching Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth over his handling of military actions in Iran, Yemen, Venezuela, and the Caribbean. The vote was 211-204 against sending the impeachment resolution to committee, effectively ending the effort initiated by Rep. Thomas Massie. Despite criticism from some Republicans, including Massie, who argued that Hegseth…

Republican-led House rejects Hegseth impeachment effort →13 articles from NBC News on this story
The Guardian13 Nov

This analysis argues that Democrats' procedural disorganization during the recent House session allowed Republicans to scuttle Representative Thomas Massie’s articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. The author contends that while the initial articles regarding war powers and civilian harm might have failed in a Senate vote due to a history of presidents ignoring Congress, the failure provides…

Democrats fumbled the Hegseth impeachment. That could be a blessing in disguise | Claire Finkelstein →12 articles from The Guardian on this story
The Daily Wire11 Nov

Far-left voters are upset after 11 Democratic lawmakers failed to attend a key procedural vote that could have led to the impeachment of War Secretary Pete Hegseth. The vote was narrowly defeated with a 211-204 tally, preventing the impeachment process from advancing. Democrats Hakeem Jeffries and Nancy Pelosi were among those absent, drawing criticism on social media for their absence just days after midterm…

Far-Left Voters Melt Down After Dems Fail To Impeach Hegseth →11 articles from The Daily Wire on this story
Daily Mail12 Nov

Jonathan Jackson, an Illinois Democrat, claimed he missed the impeachment vote against Pete Hegseth due to traffic issues but was seen filming near the Capitol steps just before the vote closed. Despite his initial excuse and later acknowledgment that it was a mistake, Jackson defended his stance on Hegseth's removal. The article highlights how eleven absent Democrats impacted the outcome of the 211-204 vote, which…

Democrat caught right outside Capitol during Hegseth impeachment vote… despite blaming traffic for absence →7 articles from Daily Mail on this story
The Intercept13 Nov

This opinion piece argues that House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries and Democratic leadership failed a major leadership test by allowing an impeachment resolution against Secretary of War Pete Hegseth to fail by a 211 to 204 margin. The author highlights that 11 Democrats missed the critical vote, with members citing reasons ranging from traffic and being out of town to attending super PAC events. The author…

The Hegseth Vote Was Jeffries's First Big Test. He Failed. →7 articles from The Intercept on this story
New York Post12 Nov

Rep. Melanie Stansbury (D-N.M.) expressed disappointment and near-tears in a video apology for missing an impeachment vote against War Secretary Pete Hegseth due to heavy traffic. She was among 11 Democrats who missed the 211-204 vote, where Republicans blocked an impeachment resolution. Stansbury argued her absence would not have changed the outcome given current political dynamics but admitted she should have made…

Democratic House lawmaker gets emotional as she blames rush hour traffic for missing Hegseth impeachment vote →7 articles from New York Post on this story
ABC News (US)11 Nov

Several Democratic representatives missed a crucial procedural vote on Tuesday night to refer the impeachment of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to the Judiciary Committee. The absence of eleven Democrats led to the motion passing with a vote of 211-204, preventing further action on the impeachment resolution. Many lawmakers blamed traffic issues near the Capitol for their tardiness, although some were absent due to…

Several Democrats missed the crucial Hegseth impeachment vote. Many blamed traffic →6 articles from ABC News (US) on this story
The Hindu11 Nov

On November 10, 2026, Republicans in the U.S. House blocked a resolution to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth over his handling of the Iran war, voting 211 to 204 against advancing the measure. The effort was led by Republican Thomas Massie and opposed by President Donald Trump, who praised Hegseth's performance on social media. The vote came amidst ongoing anger at the Iran war and high fuel prices that…

U.S. Republicans derail bid to impeach Hegseth →6 articles from The Hindu on this story
NPR14 Nov

This analysis explores the implications of the House's failure to advance an impeachment effort against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, a move that stalled due to 11 absent Democrats. The piece highlights that only one Republican, Rep. Thomas Massie, voted in favor of the effort, while noting that a Democratic speaker could have potentially managed the floor differently to accommodate missing votes. The author…

Hegseth's failed impeachment was a warning to Democrats. Where will they go from here? →6 articles from NPR on this story
Times of India10 Nov

JD Vance, US Vice President, defended Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth against impeachment efforts by calling the proceedings "absurd" and arguing they stem from opposition to Hegseth's changes at the Pentagon rather than concerns about Iran. In an X post, Vance asserted that lawmakers were choosing impeachment as an easier alternative to passing legislation and suggested that recent moves involving shifts in military…

JD Vance calls impeachment push against Pete Hegseth ‘absurd’, says move is not about Iran war →5 articles from Times of India on this story
BBC11 Nov

The House of Representatives rejected a bid by Republican congressman Thomas Massie to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, with the resolution failing in a 211-204 vote. The effort accused Hegseth of waging unauthorized war on Iran and overseeing extrajudicial killings during drug interdiction operations. President Trump celebrated the defeat as a victory for his administration, while Massie viewed it as a…

US House blocks bid to impeach Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth, for now →5 articles from BBC on this story
Dawn11 Nov

On Tuesday, Republicans in the US House blocked a bid to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth by voting 211 to 204 against referring eight articles of impeachment to the Judiciary Committee. This move prevents an imminent full House vote on impeachment, with only Representative Thomas Massie and no other Republicans supporting the effort. Democrats who did not vote could have changed the outcome; however…

US House blocks bid to impeach Defence Secretary Hegseth →4 articles from Dawn on this story
CBC10 Nov

U.S. Secretary of War Pete Hegseth dismissed a recent House resolution calling for his impeachment as a "farce" initiated by disgruntled Kentucky Republican Thomas Massie, who is leaving Congress soon. Massie's articles of impeachment cite lack of congressional authorization for the war in Iran and other military actions, but Hegseth maintains that these are merely policy disagreements rather than impeachable…

Defiant Hegseth calls Republican's impeachment resolution a 'farce' →4 articles from CBC on this story
The Bulwark10 Nov

Susan Glasser criticizes Chris Hegseth, a spokesperson for the defense secretary, for claiming that efforts to impeach someone are driven by a single congressman. Glasser argues that numerous Republican congresspeople who lost their seats due to Trump and Hegseth’s policies regarding the war now have reasons to oppose them. She also mentions that Iran's perception of the U.S. election results weakens Trump’s…

Susan Glasser: A Vote of “No Confidence” in Hegseth →4 articles from The Bulwark on this story
South China Morning Post10 Nov

US Secretary of Defence Pete Hegseth held a press conference on Tuesday to dismiss an impeachment bill against him introduced by Republican congressman Thomas Massie as a "farce." Hegseth defended the military operations in Iran and air strikes targeting drug traffickers, stating they were lawful actions. He accused Massie of pursuing a personal vendetta against President Trump due to policy disagreements and called…

Hegseth calls impeachment bid a ‘farce’ as he defends Iran war →3 articles from South China Morning Post on this story
Time10 Nov

On Tuesday, the Republican-controlled House voted 211-204 against impeaching Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth over unauthorized military actions in Iran, Venezuela, and Yemen. Rep. Thomas Massie of Kentucky had proposed the impeachment resolution, citing violations of constitutional law and misuse of office. Despite this rejection, Democrats plan to revisit the issue when they take control of Congress in January…

House Republicans Block Hegseth Impeachment, but Democrats Could Revive Effort in January →3 articles from Time on this story
The Blaze11 Nov

Republican Representative Thomas Massie of Kentucky attempted on Monday to impeach War Secretary Pete Hegseth with eight articles of impeachment, including accusations like waging unauthorized wars and committing extrajudicial killings. However, the effort failed on Tuesday when the House voted 211-204 against advancing the articles to a floor vote; eleven Democrats did not show up for the vote, which prevented the…

Massie’s effort to impeach Hegseth fails miserably, but Democrats vow to try again next year →3 articles from The Blaze on this story
Toronto Star11 Nov

House Republicans blocked an effort to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth over his conduct and handling of Iran-related matters, which some attribute to Republican losses in recent elections. Meanwhile, details emerged from President Joe Biden’s White House memoir about a farewell letter Trump wrote to Biden, praising him as someone who would be true to the American people. Rep. Jim Jordan was elected by…

The Latest: Efforts to impeach Pete Hegseth are blocked by House Republicans →3 articles from Toronto Star on this story
Evening Standard10 Nov

Pentagon chief Pete Hegseth criticized efforts to impeach him, arguing that NATO allies are now fulfilling their financial commitments after years of relying on U.S. support due to President Trump’s demands. He dismissed the impeachment bid as a political stunt aimed at damaging President Biden and U.S. military morale. The article focuses on Hegseth's defense against accusations related to his handling of military…

Nato allies ‘riding on American taxpayer’ for decades until Trump, says Hegseth →3 articles from Evening Standard on this story
Euronews11 Nov

On Tuesday, US Republicans blocked efforts by Democrats to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth over his involvement in military operations against Iran and other actions. The House vote was 211 to 204, preventing the impeachment resolution from advancing to the Judiciary Committee. Despite criticism of the war on Iran and high gas prices, Republican President Donald Trump expressed strong support for Hegseth…

US Republicans block efforts to impeach US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth over Iran war →3 articles from Euronews on this story
ABC News (AU)10 Nov

Pete Hegseth, US Defense Secretary, dismissed efforts by outgoing Republican congressman Thomas Massie to impeach him as a political stunt and farce. Massie's resolution accuses Hegseth of "high crimes and misdemeanours" related to military operations in Iran, Venezuela, and Yemen. Hegseth insisted his actions were lawful and ordered by the commander-in-chief, claiming this is the first time a cabinet secretary…

Pete Hegseth vows to fight 'farce' impeachment push →2 articles from ABC News (AU) on this story
Sydney Morning Herald10 Nov

US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth strongly denounced ongoing impeachment proceedings against him as politically motivated and legally baseless, comparing them to former President Trump's impeachment trials. The House of Representatives is set to vote on eight articles of impeachment brought by Republican congressman Thomas Massie of Kentucky, who alleges Hegseth broke laws regarding troop engagement in Iran and…

‘This is sabotage’: Hegseth fires back over impeachment as Vance comes to his aid →2 articles from Sydney Morning Herald on this story
Global News10 Nov

Pete Hegseth, the Defense Secretary, held a press conference to defend himself against impeachment proceedings initiated by Rep. Thomas Massie. The Kentucky Republican filed an impeachment resolution in the House targeting Hegseth for alleged "high crimes and misdemeanors," focusing primarily on his handling of the war against Iran but also touching on military operations in Yemen and Venezuela. Hegseth argues that…

Hegseth says ‘policy disagreements’ led to bipartisan impeachment push →2 articles from Global News on this story
The Dispatch12 Nov

The article briefly mentions several unrelated news points: Nvidia's board is planning to remove CEO Jensen Huang, Democrat Scott Colom has won a Senate race in Mississippi, and Indian officials are concerned about bananas that contain illegal drugs. These topics are presented without additional context or analysis.

Hegseth Dodges Impeachment—for Now →2 articles from The Dispatch on this story
Daily Caller11 Nov

The House of Representatives voted to block efforts to impeach War Secretary Pete Hegseth, with eight articles of impeachment proposed by Representative Thomas Massie. These articles accused Hegseth of various abuses of power related to military actions in Iran and the Caribbean, including violations of the War Powers Resolution. The article argues that this failure to hold Hegseth accountable will be seen as a…

STATE OF WEDNESDAY: The Case For Impeaching Pete Hegseth →2 articles from Daily Caller on this story
Semafor6 Nov

After the midterm elections, there are calls for changes at the White House due to poor electoral performance. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth faces the most pressure, with Republican lawmakers urging his dismissal over issues related to the Iran war and rising fuel prices. An outgoing Republican lawmaker plans to initiate impeachment proceedings against Hegseth next week in the House of Representatives, although it…

Midterms spark calls for White House shakeups →
Zeteo10 Nov

A former Pentagon official argues that Pete Hegseth, currently serving as secretary of defense, should be impeached and removed from office due to recent threatening behavior towards political opponents. The author claims that Hegseth’s actions demonstrate violent extremism and psychological instability, echoing previous warnings about the dismantling of protective measures within the military under his leadership…

I Worked at the Pentagon. Congress Must Impeach and Remove Pete Hegseth Now →
Toronto Sun10 Nov

U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth held a combative news conference at the Pentagon to defend his position amid calls for his impeachment following Republican losses in midterm elections partly due to public disapproval of the ongoing Iran war. With more than 50,000 service members deployed there, Hegseth defended U.S. military actions as necessary and argued that impeachment proceedings are politically motivated…

Hegseth defends his record, Iran war as impeachment vote looms →
Mother Jones10 Nov

Pete Hegseth, a former Fox News host now accused of war crimes and constitutional violations, held a defiant press conference at the Pentagon on Tuesday where he dismissed impeachment efforts as sabotage. Representative Thomas Massie of Kentucky has introduced eight articles of impeachment against Hegseth, accusing him of extrajudicial killings and violations of the Constitution that led to civilian deaths in Iran…

Hegseth Lashes Out at Impeachment Push, Accuses Critics of “Sabotage” →
Los Angeles Times10 Nov

Rep. Thomas Massie has proposed an impeachment resolution against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth over his handling of military actions including the war in Iran, Yemen, Venezuela, and drug boat strikes. Hegseth strongly condemned these efforts as a "political spectacle" and criticized them for targeting him based on policy disagreements rather than misconduct. A House vote on the proposal is expected by midweek…

Hegseth condemns impeachment effort against him, as House members push for vote →
The Free Press11 Nov

Rep. Thomas Massie introduced articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth on Monday, an action that gained support from most Democrats in the House but faced strong opposition from President Trump and his team. The House voted 211–204 to refer the impeachment bill to the Judiciary Committee on Tuesday evening, effectively halting it, with eleven Democrats absent or abstaining from voting. Despite…

Did the Impeachment Threat Just Save Pete Hegseth? →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

AI · cited, from two or more outlets

  • The House narrowly rejected the impeachment resolution.35
Quoted from the coverage (4)

If the House votes to impeach Mr Hegseth by a simple majority, it would next go to the Senate for a trial, where a two-thirds vote is needed for a conviction and removal from office.

9 outlets

House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries said he was a “hard yes” on impeaching Hegseth.

8 outlets

Hegseth also announced that he would hold a rare news conference from the Pentagon on Tuesday — his first in more than 180 days — on the impeachment threat.

8 outlets

Republicans remain in the majority in both chambers, until the new Congress convenes in January and the Democrats take control.

6 outlets

Disputed

Picked by our model, which is sometimes wrong

  • Hegseth claims the impeachment effort is a policy dispute, while Massie argues it involves high crimes and misdemeanors.65

Framing

How the first headlines put it

  • The Evening Standard focuses on the impeachment charges against Hegseth, while Just the News highlights Trump's support for Hegseth.14
  • Euronews emphasizes the introduction of impeachment articles, while Fox News frames the issue as a policy dispute.26
Attributed to a source3
Stated as fact7
The headlines (10)

Trump asking advisers if Hegseth should go, sources say CBS News · attributed to a source

Trump says Hegseth doing ‘a very good job’ as questions swirl about Defense Secretary’s future The Straits Times · attributed to a source

Trump says Hegseth doing 'a very good job' as questions swirl about defence secretary's future Dawn · attributed to a source

Hegseth becomes target No. 1 for Trump’s midterm failure as questions swirl on his future The Independent · stated as fact

Impeach Pete Hegseth for the Disastrous Iran War Reason · stated as fact

Hegseth's future draws ominous predictions from insiders after GOP losses, but Trump isn't budging yet Fox News · stated as fact

Is Pete Hegseth’s job safe with Iran war taking the blame for blue wave? Washington Examiner · stated as fact

Trump dismisses prospect of replacing Hegseth amid Iran war fallout ABC News · stated as fact

Is Pete Hegseth on his way out? Trump weighs Pentagon leadership after GOP setback Times of India · stated as fact

Pete Hegseth may take fall for Republicans’ midterm losses, despite Trump support The Guardian · stated as fact

Words to watch (5)

Desperate Hegseth Lashes Out Amid Impeachment Efforts | Command Post The Bulwark

Hegseth rips impeachment push from outgoing Republican as 'farce,' 'stunt' Fox News

Embattled Pentagon chief slams impeachment effort as 'farce' Dawn

Massie touts Hegseth impeachment as lawmakers return to Capitol Hill Just the News

Hegseth defends record as Pengaton chief, slams 'sham' push for his impeachment CBC

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 271 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans strongly left and hedges 5% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
The Guardian
Leans right further right than this Hedges 1 of 3 claims Outlet record 64/100
NPR
Leans left further right than this Hedges 1 of 13 claims Outlet record 60/100
CBS News
Hedges 0 of 2 claims Outlet record 66/100
South China Morning Post
Hedges 0 of 5 claims Outlet record 62/100
“Article A reports on Hegseth's reaction to Democrats' impeachment push after an election victory, while Article B discusses a Republican congressman filing impeachment charges, which is a different but related development.”
Reason
Leans strongly left Hedges 1 of 47 claims Outlet record 67/100
Just The News
Leans strongly right further right than this Hedges 0 of 7 claims Outlet record 59/100
Just The News
Leans strongly right further right than this Hedges 0 of 7 claims Outlet record 59/100
The Independent
Leans left further right than this Hedges 5 of 33 claims Outlet record 59/100
ABC News (AU)
Leans right further right than this Hedges 3 of 16 claims Outlet record 67/100
The Sydney Morning Herald
Leans left further right than this Hedges 1 of 10 claims Outlet record 61/100

Story

Hegseth Impeachment Fails
Politics · 271 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
43
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
5%
2 of 43 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans strongly left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
67/100
Reason's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
271
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-11-10 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Reason · 1464 article(s) · 4 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 4 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Ilya Somin
39 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
As I explained previously, Republican candidate Dan J. Sullivan can potentially be confused with Dan S. Sullivan (the incumbent GOP senator), and some voters might have accidentally chosen Dan J. even though they intended to back Dan S. Today, as reported by prominent election law scholar Rick Hasen, DOJ filed a brief in the US Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit seeking to dismiss the case.
Among other things, it would allow the federal government to suspend the writ of habeas corpus (and thereby detain people - including US citizens - without due process) at any time.
Just months ago, the Supreme Court in Learning Resources applied those fundamental principles to hold that the President may not use a general grant of authority to "regulate … importation" to impose tariffs, because the power to "regulate" is not the power to tax and Congress did not clearly delegate its taxing power.
A few of my own experiences with Posner and his work may shed some small additional light on the man and his achievements.
2026-11-12 · assertive framing · Judge Richard Posner, RIP
The Republicans may be able to effectively bottle up the impeachment in committee for the rest of the current Congress (which ends on January 3, 2027).
2026-11-11 · mixed framing · The Hegseth Impeachment is Far From Over
Even if they don't pass in the narrowly Republican-controlled lame duck Congress, they will almost certainly do so in the incoming Democratic one.
2026-11-09 · assertive framing · Andrew McCarthy on the Hegseth Impeachment
That makes it very likely it will happen.
2026-11-08 · assertive framing · Impeach Pete Hegseth
In each case, he illegally tried to transform relatively narrow delegations to the executive into a blank check to impose tariffs at will.
I address a variety of counterarguments, including claims that voting for a lesser evil makes you morally complicit in that candidate's wrongdoing, arguments that it's better to cast a "protest vote" for a candidate that has no chance of winning, arguments based on the very low probability that your vote will be decisive, and more.
If Section 338 is still valid and does grant the kind of nearly unlimited authority Trump claims, that would violate the constitutional "nondelegation" doctrine, which restricts delegation of legislative power to the executive…
Also by Ilya Somin
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 39 articles by Ilya Somin →

Topics

Congress Defense GOP Republican the House of Representatives

Subjects

Hegseth PERSON · 9× McCarthy PERSON · 5× Trump PERSON · 3× Congress ORG · 1× Defense ORG · 1× GOP ORG · 1× Pete Hegseth PERSON · 1× Republican NORP · 1× Thomas Massie PERSON · 1× the House of Representatives ORG · 1×

Narrative

The president's designation of Venezuelan criminal gangs as foreign terrorist organizations, besides being legally dubious (drug dealing is not "terrorist activity" as defined in federal law), does not authorize the use of force (it instead makes material support to the organization a crime and helps the government cut off funding sources).
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-11-10
Even if they don't pass in the narrowly Republican-controlled lame duck Congress, they will almost certainly do so in the incoming Democratic one.
2026-11-10 · Reason
Andrew McCarthy on the Hegseth Impeachment · assertive framing

Claims (43 extracted, 2 hedged)

Yesterday, I wrote about why Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth deserves to be impeached and convicted for his role in in starting an unconstitutional war and perpetrating over 200 cases of outright murder with the "drug boat" strikes. asserted
Hegseth → write → strikes
Today GOP Rep. Thomas Massie filed impeachment charges in the House of Representatives. asserted
Massie → file → Representatives
Even if they don't pass in the narrowly Republican-controlled lame duck Congress, they will almost certainly do so in the incoming Democratic one. asserted
they → pass → one
Meanwhile prominent conservative legal commentator, national security law expert and former federal prosecutor Andrew McCarthy has published an excellent overview of the charges in the National Review. asserted
McCarthy → publish → Review
McCarthy is far to my right, and far more sympathetic to the War on Drugs (I myself believe it should be abolished). asserted
it → believe → Drugs
Thus, it's notable that he and I agree that Hegseth should be convicted for his role in the drug boat strikes, which McCarthy characterizes as "indefensible": asserted
McCarthy → agree → which
I do not believe there is any viable justification for the extrajudicial killings by military force of operators of suspected drug boats. asserted
I → believe → boats
Our law addresses it through trial and imprisonment, not the use of military force…. asserted
law → address → force
The administration has not proved that the boats were ferrying narcotics, much less that the drugs were headed to the United States. asserted
drugs → prove → States
The president's designation of Venezuelan criminal gangs as foreign terrorist organizations, besides being legally dubious (drug dealing is not "terrorist activity" as defined in federal law), does not authorize the use of force (it instead makes material support to the organization a crime and helps the government cut off funding sources). asserted
government → define → sources
While the unauthorized killings in the Caribbean and eastern Pacific have not drawn the level of public ire that the Iran war has, they are indefensible, and Hegseth has been their loudest, crudest champion. asserted
Hegseth → draw → that
As noted in my earlier post, this view is similar to that of John Yoo, well-known former Bush Administration official and leading conservative advocate of sweeping executive power over national security and foreign affairs. asserted
view → note → security
McCarthy also argues Hegseth should be convicted on at least one other charge: asserted
Hegseth → argue → charge
Similarly, I do not believe there is any defending Hegseth on the charge that he has abused command authority and violated constitutional separation-of-powers principles in trying to discipline and censure Senator Kelly, a retired Navy captain (who remains subject to the Uniform Code of Military Justice). asserted
who → believe → Justice
Hegseth's actions, undoubtedly endorsed by the president, constituted unlawful command influence. asserted
actions → endorse → influence
More importantly, they abused executive power in an effort to muffle congressional criticism. asserted
they → abuse → criticism
The haughty Hegseth was playing a dangerous game here; if it has now come back to bite him, he has himself to blame. asserted
he → play → himself
But I agree with McCarthy here. asserted
I → agree → McCarthy
McCarthy also appears to recognize that the Iran War is illegal, but suggests that Hegseth does not deserve impeachment on this score, because he was just obeying Trump's orders and implementing his policy. uncertain
he → appear → policy
He also notes (correctly) that previous presidents have gotten away with similar initiations of war without congressional authorization. asserted
presidents → note → authorization
I disagree for reasons summarized in my previous post: asserted
I → disagree → post
The former was following the latter's illegal orders (though he likely also helped influence Trump to give those orders in the first place). asserted
he → follow → place
But sanctioning officials for obeying illegal orders is still important. asserted
sanctioning → sanction → orders
I would add that Hegseth wasn't just some low-level flunky merely obeying orders. asserted
Hegseth → add → orders
He has had a major influence on policy, and was one of the key architects of both the Iran War and the boat strikes. asserted
He → have → War
He bears far greater responsibility than, e.g., servicemembers at the bottom of the chain of command. asserted
He → bear → command
As also noted in my earlier post, it is indeed true that previous presidents, such as Barack Obama, have gotten away with starting illegal wars. asserted
presidents → note → wars
Obama deserved to be impeached, as well. asserted
Obama → deserve → ?
But that makes it all the more imperative to start enforcing this part of the Constitution more effectively. asserted
it → make → Constitution
Moreover, the Iran War is much larger and has had far worse effects than any other illegal war of the last several decades. asserted
War → have → decades
I will not say much about McCarthy's analysis of the other charges, except briefly on that focused on the removal of Venezuelan dictator Nicolas Maduro. asserted
I → say → Maduro
McCarthy laments that Trump left the brutal socialist regime in power (minus Maduro), but suggests that the intervention might have been legally justified by the precedent of the 1989 US military action that removed and captured Panamanian strongman Manuel Noriega. uncertain
that → lament → Noriega
I differ for reasons I outlined here: asserted
I → differ → reasons
Defenders of the legality of Trump's actions cite the 1989 invasion of Panama, which was undertaken in large part for the purpose of apprehending Panamian dictator Manuel Noriega; like Maduro, Noriega was charged with smuggling illegal drugs into the US. asserted
Noriega → cite → US
But the 1989 Panama precedent does not actually justify Trump's actions. asserted
precedent → justify → actions
On December 15, 1989 (five days before the US invasion), Noriega foolishly announced that Panama and the US were in a "state of war," thereby creating conflict between the two countries that did not exist in the Venezuela case. asserted
that → announce → case
In addition, Panamanian forces had killed or wounded two US military personnel in the Panama Canal area, and detained other American citizens. asserted
forces → kill → citizens
Unlike Noriega in 1989, the Venezuelan regime did not declare war on the US or otherwise initiate a military conflict. asserted
regime → declare → conflict
Thus, congressional authorization is needed to make any US military intervention constitutional. asserted
intervention → need → ?
That said, I think the Maduro intervention charge is much weaker than the Iran War and boat strike charges. asserted
charge → say → War
…and 3 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support