U.S. boycotts U.N. human rights review for second year running
GENEVA, Switzerland —
asserted
U.S. → boycott → year
The United States has left an empty chair at a key United Nations human rights review for the second year running, becoming the only U.N. member state ever to do so.
asserted
States → leave → year
The review, known as the universal periodic review, is meant to be just that: universal.
asserted
review → know → review
Each state is reviewed every four to five years by fellow member states.
asserted
state → review → states
The aim is to ensure that every country, however powerful, undergoes a peer review of its human rights record.
asserted
country → ensure → record
As well as diplomats from countries under review, civil society groups are allowed to submit evidence too.
asserted
groups → allow → evidence
Several made the trip to Geneva, led by the American Civil Liberties Union.
asserted
Several → make → Union
Jamil Dakwar, the ACLU's human rights director, told journalists that the current U.S. administration was continuing to violate human rights "unabashed," citing the treatment of immigrants, student protesters and the LGBTQ community as examples.
asserted
administration → tell → examples
Dakwar said the U.N. must hold the U.S. accountable, warning that the Trump administration wanted to "dismantle human rights."
asserted
administration → say → rights
In a written response, the State Department pointed out that Washington had already formally withdrawn from the U.N. Human Rights Council, accusing it of "pushing anti-American rhetoric."
asserted
Washington → write → rhetoric
In fact, leaving the council, which has 47 elected members, does not mean the U.S. can easily get out of the review process, which is obligatory for all 193 U.N. member states.
asserted
which → leave → states
Human rights groups see Washington's stance as part of a pattern of disengagement and even active opposition to multilateral organizations, pointing to U.S. sanctions on the International Criminal Court and the decision to leave the World Health Organization.
asserted
groups → see → Organization
So what happens now?
asserted
what → happen → ?
The U.N. has few sanctions against a country that does not cooperate with the review process.
asserted
that → have → process
Israel skipped one review back in 2013 in protest at what it said was anti-Israel bias, but returned nine months later after the U.N. rescheduled.
asserted
U.N. → skip → protest
Until today's no-show by the U.S., no country has ever failed to turn up twice.
asserted
country → fail → U.S.
Rights groups would like the U.N. to hold the review anyway, and take evidence about alleged violations in the U.S.
asserted
U.N. → like → U.S.
Member states had already drawn up a list of questions for Washington's diplomats, including questions about the use of the death penalty and restrictions on abortion.
asserted
states → draw → abortion
But U.N. insiders fear that holding the review when there is no one to answer those questions could set a risky precedent.
uncertain
holding → fear → precedent
Even authoritarian regimes such as North Korea take part in the review process.
asserted
regimes → take → process
If the U.N. allows a review to go ahead without U.S. participation, it could encourage other member states to stay away, too, leaving rights groups to present their evidence, as one put it, "in a vacuum."
uncertain
one → allow → vacuum
For now, the U.N. has decided to postpone tricky deliberations about how to react until early next year.
asserted
U.N. → decide → year
In the meantime, a process regarded as a last resort for the victims of human rights violations is not available to U.S. citizens.
asserted
process → regard → citizens
It is, one rights activist said in Geneva, "a crisis of accountability."
asserted
activist → say → accountability