Ralph Waldo Emerson once said, “an institution is the lengthened shadow of one man.”
asserted
institution → say → man
In NVIDIA’s case, the shadow of its CEO and co-founder, Jensen Huang, is a haunting one.
asserted
shadow → haunt → CEO
Many within Silicon Valley see Huang as a visionary genius, whose vision as the “Godfather of AI” has improved billions of lives around the world and contributed greatly to American prosperity and innovation.
asserted
vision → see → prosperity
When attending our Yale CEO forums, he has been revered by CEOs across sectors and around the world for his bold, entrepreneurial vision and his revolutionary technological triumphs.
asserted
he → attend → vision
But with Huang reportedly ensnared in an affair with a Chinese executive rumored to be a suspected Chinese intelligence asset and allegedly involved in laundering NVIDIA chips into China around bans, a growing chorus of voices across finance, tech, and government circles are whispering the once-unthinkable: that Huang may have lost the legitimacy to lead.
uncertain
Huang → ensnare → legitimacy
And indeed, we believe the NVIDIA board is finally doing the right thing: moving to oust Huang.
asserted
board → believe → Huang
That follows a tortured sequence of events.
asserted
That → follow → events
On Nov. 8, NVIDIA’s board of directors announced it had launched an independent investigation into reports that Huang has been the target of a foreign intelligence effort.
asserted
Huang → announce → effort
“While the Board has no reason to believe that either national security or NVIDIA secrets were compromised, the Board's inquiry will examine all available information,” wrote the leaders in a statement.
asserted
leaders → have → statement
“Jensen fully supports the review and has committed to cooperating with it.
asserted
Jensen → support → it
The Board has confidence in Jensen and his leadership team.”
Then, on Nov. 11, The New York Times reported that Huang allegedly had a relationship with an executive who reports to him.
uncertain
who → have → him
The saga culminated in The Wall Street Journal reporting that the NVIDIA board is preparing to oust Huang.
asserted
board → culminate → Huang
Critics point out that Huang has shown remarkably poor judgment, putting NVIDIA and U.S. national security at risk.
asserted
Huang → point → risk
Others argue he has lost the confidence of key customers with his recklessness.
asserted
he → argue → recklessness
Ideally, boards working with visionary founders can help ground the leader in reality while also supporting creative, calculated risk-taking.
asserted
boards → work → taking
A lot of visionary founders have grown tremendously in this model.
asserted
lot → grow → model
In fact, when managed the right way, these founders have the ability to drive their organizations to become more, not less, nimble.
asserted
founders → manage → organizations
That is why our research reveals that long-tenured CEOs often outperform.
asserted
CEOs → reveal → ?
Corporate boards must be able to speak truth to power, as good governance is neither blind loyalty nor an always-adversarial mentality—and have the courage to support or reprimand a CEO under scrutiny.
asserted
governance → speak → scrutiny
And most importantly, and overlooked, boards must be on the lookout for grandiose and reckless conduct, and curtail those instincts when appropriate.
asserted
boards → overlook → instincts
Now, the question is what comes next for NVIDIA with Huang seemingly out?
asserted
Huang → come → NVIDIA
NVIDIA's board had three choices when it comes to Huang’s future: remove him, force him to take a leave of absence, or let him off the hook with a reprimand amounting to a slap on the wrist.
asserted
it → have → wrist
And it did the right thing by moving to oust Huang.
asserted
it → do → Huang
Of note, NVIDIA does not have dual-class shares, and Huang only owns a single-digit percentage of the company’s shares, so the board controlled his fate, not Huang himself.
asserted
board → have → fate
Boards rarely remove a chief executive solely for being unfaithful to a spouse, but they do sometimes remove executives when the board subsequently loses trust in them.
asserted
board → remove → them
We would argue Jensen’s is a different kind of case.
asserted
Jensen → argue → case
Likewise, there are some examples of CEOs who were forced to take a leave of absence, either by their boards or for personal reasons, and then subsequently returned to the job successfully.
asserted
who → be → job
Some notable examples include Steve Jobs of Apple, who took a six-month medical leave to focus on his health in 2009, and then returned to run Apple alongside Tim Cook; Tony Fernandes of AirAsia, who gave up his role for two months amid allegations that were later disproven by an independent review which cleared him of all wrongdoing; as well as Kraft Foods CEO Roger Deromedi, who returned as CEO of Kraft after a medical leave.
asserted
who → include → leave
Sometimes, boards choose to reprimand founders, allowing them to stay on as CEO with barely any changes.
asserted
them → choose → changes
Perhaps the most famous example is Elon Musk of Tesla in 2018, over his false tweets that Tesla would be taken private for $420 a share.
asserted
Tesla → take → 420
The SEC settlement made Musk give up the chairmanship for three years while he stayed on as CEO.
asserted
he → make → CEO
Both he and Tesla each paid $20 million, and Tesla added two independent directors.
asserted
Tesla → pay → directors
The board likely weighed all three but came around to the right decision: Huang would be hard to replace, but the time was right to make a move and to replace Huang amidst escalating scandal and controversy.
asserted
time → weigh → scandal
As top GOP voices such as Senator Kevin Cramer called for Huang’s resignation as NVIDIA CEO, it is apparent that NVIDIA had no public succession plan.
asserted
NVIDIA → call → plan
Huang has boasted of having some 60 direct reports, a hub-and-spokes model which is common to many founders but which is unprecedented in its sheer scale.
asserted
which → boast → scale
Few founders can balance the global travel and responsibilities Huang has and still maintain even a fraction of that many direct reports.
asserted
Huang → balance → reports
Unfortunately for the NVIDIA board, they are unable to draft someone with requisite CEO experience off the board on an interim basis that would buy them time, unlike some other emergency succession parallels.
asserted
that → draft → parallels
For example, Lew Platt, an honorable former CEO of Hewlett-Packard, stepped in off the board when CEO Phil Condit left Boeing amidst a series of scandals; and similarly, when John Akers imploded at IBM, the company brought in Jim Burke of Johnson & Johnson fame as Chair of the search committee for a new CEO, ultimately landing Lou Gerstner.
asserted
company → step → Gerstner
One top internal candidate at NVIDIA would be Colette Kress, the veteran CFO who is widely known and admired across Silicon Valley and Wall Street circles.
asserted
who → know → circles
It seems clear that there is nobody outside of Huang and Ian Buck who knows the company as well as Kress and who already has relationships with key stakeholders inside and outside the company; but Kress is not a technologist by background.
asserted
Kress → seem → background
…and 23 more, not listed.