A London mosque has been given an official warning by the Charity Commission over 'inflammatory' and 'divisive' sermons.
asserted
mosque → give → sermons
The Lewisham Islamic Centre in south-east London was investigated following complaints about sermons delivered there, with the regulator concluding there was 'misconduct and/or mismanagement' by bosses.
asserted
regulator → investigate → bosses
It follows a sermon in October 2023, in the immediate aftermath of the Hamas attack on Israel, delivered by Head Imam Shakeel Begg.
asserted
It → follow → Begg
Mr Begg, a prominent UK Muslim who unsuccessfully launched a libel case against the BBC for calling him an extremist, claimed the West and Israel were 'smearing' Muslims by saying 'innocent children' were killed during the attack.
asserted
children → launch → attack
'We know that's a lie,' he told worshippers.
asserted
he → know → worshippers
He also discussed the 'suffering at the hands of the oppressors and the Zionists' and went on to label celebrities including Justin Bieber and Kylie Jenner 'sick' – thought to be linked to their support for Israel after the attack.
asserted
He → discuss → attack
A second event in August 2024 saw Imam Ashraf Dabous discuss the Southport riots, saying of the rioters 'their manipulators are Zionists, and they are supporters of the state of Israel' and referencing a 'Zionist agenda'.
asserted
they → see → agenda
The violence broke out following misinformation online about the identity of the Southport killer, whose knife attack led to the deaths of Bebe King, six, Elsie Dot Stancombe, seven, and Alice Dasilva Aguiar, nine.
asserted
attack → break → King
The Lewisham Islamic Centre in south-east London was investigated following complaints about sermons delivered there, with the regulator concluding there was 'misconduct and/or mismanagement' by bosses
It follows a sermon in October 2023, in the immediate aftermath of the Hamas attack on Israel, delivered by Head Imam Shakeel Begg
The Charity Commission said its finding of misconduct or mismanagement also took into account other events held at the centre, and was 'connected, but not limited to' two sermons which were the subject of complaints.
asserted
which → investigate → complaints
It found the charity also failed to carry out or record adequate risk assessment and due diligence 'in relation to an external speaker', saying this 'put the Charity’s resources including its reputation at unnecessary risk'.
asserted
this → find → risk
It added the centre also failed to implement adequate policies and procedures to mitigate the risks associated with speakers.
asserted
centre → add → speakers
The warning will remain visible on the Charity Commission's website for a year, and the regulator warns that failure to remedy the failings could lead to further action.
uncertain
failure → remain → action
In a response, Lewisham Islamic Centre said it 'rejects' the findings and called the warning 'overzealous,' adding that 'regulatory expectations' on Muslim charities are 'unnecessarily burdensome'.
asserted
expectations → say → charities
It added it is seeking legal advice.
asserted
it → add → advice
Mr Begg has been associated with the centre for at least 27 years.
asserted
Begg → associate → years
In 2016, he sued the BBC for dubbing him an extremist – but Lord Justice Haddon-Cave dismissed this, saying that Mr Begg had promoted religious violence 'by telling Muslims that violence in support of Islam would constitute a man's greatest deed'.
asserted
violence → sue → deed
A separate sermon by Imam Ashraf Dabous saw him blame 'Zionists' for the Southport riots
He previously said his statements were interpreted in a different way to how he intended them, he condemns extremism and does not want to encourage violence.
asserted
he → see → violence
Schoolchildren have regularly visited the mosque in recent years, and Mr Begg has been pictured speaking with them.
asserted
Begg → visit → them
It has been widely reported that Lee Rigby's killers worshipped at the mosque in the months before their Woolwich attack.
asserted
killers → report → attack
In a statement, Lewisham Islamic Centre said: 'Lewisham Islamic Centre is deeply concerned by the Charity Commission's attempted regulatory action against the Centre and its trustees.
'
asserted
Centre → say → Centre
The matters raised by the Commission represent a troubling attempt to scrutinise, restrict and penalise legitimate religious worship, the expression of solidarity with the Palestinian people, and the activities of a Muslim charitable institution.'
asserted
matters → raise → institution
It said that the sermon in October 2023 took place on a date when 'more than 3,500 Palestinians had been 'murdered.'
asserted
Palestinians → say → date
It added: 'The Centre does not accept that a regulator should be placed in the position of prescribing the permissible content of Islamic sermons or scrutinising established forms of Muslim prayer according to its own interpretation of religious language and expression.'
uncertain
regulator → add → language
The statement ended: 'While issuing a public warning is not mandatory and, in our view, overzealous, the Commission has nevertheless failed to provide adequate reasons for considering it necessary to publish an official warning, or for concluding that doing so was in the charity's best interests or served the public interest.
'
asserted
doing → end → interest
The Centre is continuing to seek legal advice on the most appropriate course of action.
asserted
Centre → continue → action
Should legal action be pursued, we would urge others to come forward and join a united challenge to an overbearing Commission in defence of religious freedom.'
asserted
we → pursue → freedom