Why experts fear Canada's not-for-profits are prime targets for hackers
Crime Stoppers data breach not an outlier, but an example of worldwide threat
asserted
breach → fear → threat
When Paul Nichol first heard about the Crime Stoppers data breach, one thought immediately crossed his mind: "Holy crap, this happens every day."
asserted
this → hear → mind
"It was a real wake-up call for me.
asserted
It → wake → me
It was like, 'Oh yeah … this could happen to us,'" he told CBC News.
uncertain
he → happen → News
Nichol, who is from rural Brussels, Ont., manages one of the 267 offices of Community Futures, a national non-profit network that loans money to and advises local entrepreneurs.
asserted
that → manage → entrepreneurs
"We do collect an enormous amount of data," like names, addresses and social insurance numbers, he said.
asserted
he → collect → names
His organization fends off three or four phishing attempts a week, easily — in his experience, they are "very, very common."
asserted
they → fend → experience
"There’s always that little dark cloud behind you saying, 'Is today the day we’re going to get hacked?'"
asserted
we → ’ → you
Cybersecurity experts interviewed by CBC News say the Crime Stoppers data breach, which exposed information linked to more than 1.5 million tips sent to Canadian chapters of the non-for-profit organization over 25 years, was not an outlier but rather one example of a worldwide threat.
asserted
which → interview → threat
While most Canadians don't think of data breaches when they donate to a non-profit, experts warn they can gather datasets just as massive and sensitive as any commercial bank.
asserted
they → think → bank
But unlike a major bank, they lack the resources to defend themselves against increasingly sophisticated cyber attacks — and when these groups are breached, they often stay silent to protect donor confidence and community trust.
asserted
they → lack → confidence
"Non-profits are targeted by everyone," said Stéphane Duguin, CEO of the Geneva-based Protect.ngo Foundation, in an interview with CBC News.
asserted
Duguin → target → News
'What you attack is their reputation'
asserted
attack → attack → What
Duguin said non-profit organizations are more at risk because in addition to common attacks like email phishing attempts, they can also fall victim to targeted, politically motivated hacks, due to the nature of their work.
asserted
they → say → work
That can look like cyber-attacks backed by wealthy states or state-backed criminal groups, meant to disrupt on-the-ground activities or destroy credibility.
asserted
That → look → credibility
Even larger organizations with more resources have not been spared, with major non-profits like Greenpeace and Amnesty International Canada having suffered targeted cyberattacks in recent years.
asserted
profits → spar → years
If anything, their prominent profile makes them more appealing to groups that want to silence them, says Duguin.
asserted
Duguin → make → them
"You attack them so that people are not going to trust them anymore....
asserted
people → attack → them
What you attack is their reputation.
asserted
attack → attack → What
"
And when hackers attack, NGOs often struggle to defend themselves because of their restrictive funding and lack of IT expertise.
asserted
NGOs → attack → expertise
Stéphane Dugui is the CEO of the Geneva-based Protect.ngo Foundation.
asserted
Dugui → base → Foundation
"When your funding mechanism becomes more and more project-based, it's extremely difficult as an organization to maintain a strategy when it comes to your digital resilience," said Duguin, whose organization helps non-profits prevent and recover from cyberattacks.
asserted
profits → become → cyberattacks
Most not-for-profits receive funding and grants for specific projects, limiting their ability to invest in a long-term cybersecurity strategy and to attract experienced IT professionals.
asserted
profits → receive → professionals
"They would not access the talent," said Duguin.
asserted
Duguin → access → talent
So they will not be competitive when it comes to salary and retention.
asserted
it → come → salary
"
The crisis even prompted dozens of global humanitarian leaders to sign an open letter in 2024 pleading for support.
asserted
crisis → prompt → support
"We lack the resources and expertise to undertake the state-of-the-art cybersecurity measures that our mission requires," reads the open letter.
asserted
letter → lack → that
Many non-profits also share the reluctance of private companies to publicly acknowledge cyber attacks.
asserted
profits → share → attacks
Protect.ngo estimates there have been more than 1,000 publicly recorded cyber attacks targeting non-profits around the world since November 2018 — at least 22 of which are Canada-based — but Duguin says the true total is likely higher.
"There's no gain for them to report anything," Duguin said.
asserted
Duguin → estimate → anything
"If they report, donors are going to cut them loose."
Voluntary cybersecurity certification largely ignored
One potential solution for non-profits is to complete the CyberSecure Canada federal certification program, said Ian Ashor, managing director at Complade, one of several accredited certification bodies.
asserted
Ashor → report → bodies
The certification, developed by Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada, is valid for two years, and requires organizations to implement over a dozen security measures, like multi-factor authentication and encrypting their data.
asserted
certification → develop → data
Ashor argues that failing to evaluate cybersecurity measures should be treated with the same severity as hiring an unaccredited accountant.
asserted
failing → argue → accountant
Ian Ashor is the managing director of Complade, one of several accredited certification bodies for the CyberSecure Canada program.
asserted
Ashor → manage → program
He says that in the U.K., cybersecurity certification is mandatory for vendors — including non-profits — that bid on certain government contracts involving personal information.
asserted
that → say → information
As a result, Ashor says, only 58 small or medium organizations currently hold an active CyberSecure Canada certification, including the 19 non-profits certified by Complade.
asserted
organizations → say → Complade
For context, the Canada Revenue Agency's website currently reports over 85,000 organizations registered as charities in Canada.
asserted
website → report → Canada
Neither the Canadian Crime Stoppers Association (CCSA) nor any of its local programs are CyberSecure-certified.
asserted
Association → certify → programs
He went through the process at the request of FedDev Ontario, the federal agency that funds his non-profit's Southern Ontario offices.
asserted
that → go → offices
It also came with one-time funding to hire an accreditation company.
asserted
It → come → company
We checked every app, every platform, from every supplier, vendor."
asserted
We → check → vendor
…and 14 more, not listed.