A two-hour hearing in Spain’s high court Friday on the US extradition request of wealthy leftwing activist and philanthropist James “Fergie” Chambers turned out to be a study in contrasts.
asserted
hearing → turn → contrasts
Chambers’s defense took most of the session to query the US citizen and detail irregularities in the Trump administration’s extradition request – several of which the Guardian has reported on – as well as the figures of Spanish law that would lead the three-judge panel to deny the request; while the prosecutor sped through his case, head down, asking Chambers no questions at all.
asserted
prosecutor → take → questions
Notably, neither the judges or the prosecutor asked Chambers to address the insinuation in the extradition request that the wealthy activist had supported Hamas.
asserted
activist → ask → Hamas
Chambers’s case is the first known instance of the US seeking to extradite a citizen over alleged support for Hamas, an accusation apparently tied to an international money laundering charge and donations to organizations helping Palestinians in Gaza.
asserted
US → know → Gaza
But the defense’s queries did allow him to speak for the first time since his 10 July arrest in Ibiza about events at the center of the case: 2023 protests against Israeli weapons manufacturer Elbit in Massachusets and New Hampshire and 2024 transfers of $7.2m to Tunisia, where he lived at the time.
asserted
he → allow → time
The latter was buttressed with testimony from a financial expert.
asserted
latter → buttress → expert
On the whole, Chambers painted a picture different from the depiction contained in the extradition request, that of a violent backer of Hamas on the run from the US.
asserted
Chambers → paint → US
At one point, he noted that his family’s next door neighbor in Tunis was the US ambassador.
asserted
neighbor → note → Tunis
The court will decide next week on extraditing Chambers.
asserted
court → decide → Chambers
If the decision is affirmative, Spain’s council of ministers can reverse the court’s decision.
asserted
council → reverse → decision
This means Chambers’s extradition may be among the last decisions made under Pedro Sánchez, the socialist prime minister, before national elections on 29 November.
uncertain
extradition → mean → November
Friday’s hearing began with Chambers’s defense asking about his wealth.
asserted
defense → begin → wealth
A self-described communist and anti-imperialist, Chambers sold stock back to his family’s business, Atlanta-based Cox Enterprises, worth about $250m in mid-2023.
asserted
Chambers → describe → mid-2023
Then he started a foundation, he told the court.
asserted
he → start → court
He and the foundation’s three-member board decide on funding and ensure that no projects seeking support are under US sanctions, Chambers said.
asserted
Chambers → decide → sanctions
The foundation has funded an estimated 100 progressive and humanitarian projects in 20 countries, according to his partner, activist and actor Stella Schnabel – including, Chambers said Friday, organizations in Gaza working on issues such as “medical treatment for children, transportation out of dangerous areas and clean water and food”.
uncertain
Chambers → fund → areas
Two of the request’s three charges – riot and conspiracy to riot – are related to the late-2023 protests against Elbit.
asserted
Two → riot → Elbit
Chambers detailed his participation in the protests: locking himself to a door, marching in the street and – in New Hampshire – standing in the road, speaking to the media and paying bail for four protesters who were eventually found guilty of misdemeanor charges and served 30 days in jail.
asserted
who → detail → jail
As for the $7.2m, the defense and a financial expert serving as a witness laid out how ten bank transfers from the US to Tunisia mostly went to sponsor the football club Club Africain – described by Chambers as “one of the largest football clubs in Africa” – and a sporting business Chambers launched while living in Tunisia.
asserted
Chambers → serve → Tunisia
“Is there any indication that the money went to support terrorist activities?” asked defense attorney Aitor Martínez.
asserted
Martínez → go → activities
“None,” said financial expert Albert Deulofeu Schilt.
asserted
Schilt → say → ?
Then, in about 15 minutes of rapid-fire monotone, prosecutor Juan Hernández Villalba laid out a wholly different picture of Chambers as backing “an organized structure … aimed at repeatedly committing illegal acts … together with funds destined for terrorist organizations”.
asserted
Villalba → lay → organizations
He accused the defense of laying out the facts of the case “in a fragmented way … when what’s most relevant is an evaluation of the whole picture”.
asserted
’s → accuse → picture
“The extradition petition isn’t based on ideology or political statements, but on actions [Chambers] organized, financed and carried out, causing material damage,” Hernández Villalba asserted.
asserted
Villalba → base → damage
The actions against Elbit “were presented as a simple protest”, he said.
asserted
he → present → protest
“Nevertheless, the actions described by the US were planned for days … with objectively violent content.”
asserted
actions → describe → content
Given all this, the prosecutor said, “there are more than enough indications to consider … that [Chambers’s] funding was aimed at terrorism”.
asserted
funding → give → terrorism
Among the 100-plus people in varying time zones following Friday’s hearing on the court’s YouTube channel was Irish film-maker and journalist Sinéad O’Shea, whose documentary on Chambers called All About the Money makes its New York premiere this weekend.
asserted
documentary → vary → premiere
It covers the time period cited by the FBI affidavit underpinning the US request.
asserted
It → cover → request
O’Shea said that extradition case “builds a false narrative which begins with the protest in New Hampshire – a piece of vandalism at worst and for which people ended up serving 30 days.
asserted
people → say → days
I saw myself the football club in which he invested in Tunisia and his donations to Palestinian and other charities are a matter of public record.
asserted
donations → see → record
It is impossible not to see this as a politically motivated case.”
asserted
It → see → case
Chambers’s views have been extensively profiled in US media.
asserted
views → profile → media
A week after the 7 October 2023 Hamas attacks on Israel, he posted on X about Israel’s response: “Stop calling it ‘collective punishment’/There’s nothing to be ‘punished’ for/No faction of the Palestinian resistance, Hamas or other, has done *anything* wrong/It’s simply genocide/Like it has been.”
asserted
it → post → anything
Dressed in dark jeans, a grey-blue shirt, a black jacket, with a close-cropped haircut and mustache, Chambers got the last word during the hearing.
asserted
Chambers → dress → hearing
“To this day I cannot understand why I have been in prison since July for what amounts to speaking emotionally and committing minor offenses of public disturbance,” he said.
asserted
he → understand → disturbance
“I’ve never had any contact with any terrorist organization.
asserted
I → have → organization
I’ve certainly never financed any terrorist organization … and for this my family has been torn apart.
asserted
family → finance → this
I missed my grandmother’s funeral last week.
asserted
I → miss → funeral
My five-year-old son asks where I am every day.
asserted
I → ask → ?
…and 3 more, not listed.