The late Howard Rubenstein was the best public relations executive I have ever known.
asserted
I → know → ?
His foundational advice to his corporate and political clients facing a crisis was captured on a small plaque in his office.
asserted
advice → face → office
It read: “If you always tell the truth, you don’t have to remember what you said.”
asserted
you → read → what
The first time I saw it, I laughed out loud and, with a smile, he nodded and said, yes, that’s what I’ve learned and what I believe.
asserted
I → see → what
Howard and his wisdom came to mind in recent days as I watched federal officials try to reassure the nation after the grounding of aircraft stranded tens of thousands of Americans at airports and disrupted the travel plans of millions.
asserted
grounding → come → millions
The problem for officials, especially on Friday when late afternoon delays started without warning and quickly cascaded, was that they didn’t know what was happening and why.
asserted
what → start → warning
Still, they had to appear in public to at least try to calm the contagious outrage and anxiety.
asserted
they → have → outrage
The only good news is that they didn’t hit the panic button and try to convey a sense of certainty they didn’t have.
asserted
they → hit → certainty
Instead, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and Homeland Security director Markwayne Mullin confessed they couldn’t say with full confidence what was happening nor could they predict when the crisis would end.
uncertain
crisis → confess → confidence
The truth was far from comforting, but they nonetheless did the right thing by admitting the limits of what they knew.
asserted
they → comfort → what
Had they exaggerated their knowledge to project a certainty they didn’t have, they would have made a bad situation worse and jeopardized their jobs and reputations.
asserted
situation → exaggerate → jobs
‘Zero evidence’
Duffy, who appeared a bit rattled Friday night, said the disaster likely was caused by the failure of “old hardware that went down” and affected air traffic controllers at regional hubs across the country.
asserted
that → appear → country
Mullin appeared calmer, but he also was restrained, especially in response to a media question about whether there had been a cyber attack.
asserted
he → appear → question
If he could have flatly denied it, he surely would have.
uncertain
he → deny → it
Instead, Mullin chose his words carefully by saying only that there was “zero evidence” of such an attack.
asserted
Mullin → choose → attack
Although their answers were frustrating given the scope of the problem, both men chose the right course by refusing to project false confidence.
asserted
men → give → confidence
In fact, their uncertainty demonstrated why the lure of pretending to have complete conviction in a crisis often proves irresistible to public officials.
asserted
lure → demonstrate → officials
Especially for the millions of Americans trapped in airport hell without explanations or promises about when they could get to their destinations, the truth could not have been very comforting.
uncertain
truth → trap → destinations
Ditto for the millions of others who had travel plans for the rest of the weekend and were left unsure about what to do next.
asserted
who → have → what
But the truth was important because the government did not know what had happened to the computerized network and officials were wise to say so.
asserted
officials → know → network
The situation remained dicey Saturday, with as many as 4,000 more flights delayed or canceled.
asserted
flights → remain → ?
In some cases, the aircraft were not in the right locations or flight crews had “timed out” during the delays.
asserted
crews → time → delays
The best news federal officials had on the second day was that they hoped that normal operations would be in place later Sunday.
asserted
operations → have → place
This time, Duffy appeared more calm and confident as he advanced possible causes, saying investigators were looking into whether a contractor’s error or faulty equipment had set off the cascade of disaster.
“What we’re working to determine was whether we had incompetence — meaning, was it user error or installation error,” he said.
asserted
he → appear → incompetence
Duffy added that the work of switching from old copper wires to fiber optic cable had caused a router to overload the system.
asserted
router → add → system
He confessed it remained unknown if the flaw was with the equipment itself or with a contractor doing the work, L3Harris.
asserted
flaw → confess → work
Again, that wasn’t the most hopeful statement, but he still was being extra careful not to go beyond what he could say with full confidence.
uncertain
he → go → confidence
FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford also stuck to a narrow script by echoing Mullin’s Friday cautionary statement about a cyber attack.
asserted
Bedford → stick → attack
Bedford said investigators still “don’t believe” any attack or foreign interference caused the incident.
asserted
attack → say → incident
And he said there was “zero evidence” that anything AI-related caused the meltdown, although he didn’t completely rule out the possibility.
asserted
he → say → possibility
The most troubling consistency of both the press conferences on Friday and Saturday was the officials’ eagerness to blame Congress for not budgeting enough money to speed the modernization of the FAA’s communication network.
asserted
consistency → blame → network
Duffy said the work should have been done years earlier, and renewed his appeal for Congress to appropriate a staggering $50 billion in new funding for emergency overhauls.
asserted
Congress → say → overhauls
Coming in the midst of the mysterious shutdown, the not-enough-money argument struck me as being predictable and off key.
asserted
argument → come → me
Especially when it comes from Duffy, the demand for another mountain of money is disappointing.
asserted
demand → come → money
He was elected to Congress in the 2010 Tea Party anti-tax wave, and was a reliable fiscal hawk until he resigned in 2019.
asserted
he → elect → 2019
Moreover, if you were stuck at an airport or were unsure about planning to fly in coming days and weeks, watching the person in charge demanding billions more of taxpayer dollars was hardly comforting or convincing.
asserted
person → stick → dollars
Even if Congress wrote the check tomorrow, the work would take years.
asserted
work → write → years
So the cavalry is not coming soon.
asserted
cavalry → come → ?
Such pleas always sound like everything would be fine if only America spent more.
asserted
America → sound → more
We just had a hard-fought national election that saw Democrats seize control of both the House and Senate, and I don’t recall a single accusation by a challenger that incumbents had not spent nearly enough money to upgrade airports or that Duffy was unfit.
asserted
Duffy → have → airports
…and 3 more, not listed.