Ministers have been accused of “gambling with the safety of mothers and babies” after admitting they do not know how much repairing decrepit maternity units would cost.
asserted
repairing → accuse → units
NHS chiefs said last year that shoddy infrastructure meant 43% of maternity and neonatal units in England did not meet basic safety standards.
asserted
% → say → standards
Infrastructure problems hampered the delivery of clinical care thousands of times every year, NHS England said.
asserted
England → hamper → times
The Care Quality Commission (CQC) watchdog has also voiced concern that lack of space, ageing facilities and shortage of operating theatres presents “serious safety risks” for mothers and babies.
asserted
lack → voice → mothers
The latest warning over risks to women’s safety has been made by the Liberal Democrats amid growing concern that leaks, broken equipment and cramped treatment areas are disrupting the delivery of maternity care.
However, Karin Smyth, the NHS minister at the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC), admitted in responses to recent parliamentary questions that it could not put a figure on how much it would cost to upgrade maternity and neonatal units that NHS England believed either needed significant repair or replacement soon or were running “a serious risk of imminent breakdown”.
uncertain
England → make → breakdown
Smyth made the admission in response to questions tabled by Helen Morgan, the Liberal Democrats’ health spokesperson.
asserted
Smyth → make → Morgan
“NHS England has spelt out in black and white just how serious this is, with dozens of maternity units falling apart and some at serious risk of imminent breakdown,” said Morgan.
asserted
Morgan → spell → breakdown
“It is appalling that, despite those warnings, the government still has no idea how much it would cost to make every maternity unit fit for purpose.
asserted
unit → have → purpose
Ministers are gambling with the safety of mothers, babies and NHS staff caring for them.”
asserted
Ministers → gamble → them
The maternity unit at Musgrove Park hospital in Taunton, Somerset, is “old and not designed to deliver 21st-century care”, Baroness Valerie Amos’s review of childbirth services concluded in the summer.
asserted
review → design → summer
She found “leaking roofs, poor temperature control with rooms often too hot or too cold”.
asserted
She → find → rooms
The unit’s antenatal ward is in such a state of disrepair that it is being propped up by metal poles.
asserted
it → prop → poles
Musgrove Park bosses acknowledged in September that its maternity unit is “old, outdated and cramped” after CQC inspectors found that water had leaked into clinical areas and mould had formed on the walls and ceilings of the postnatal ward, although they rated the care staff provided as good.
asserted
they → acknowledge → care
Last week, Jules Wilkinson described how he had to hold up a light that had come loose from the ceiling for an hour while his wife was giving birth to their daughter Cora in the maternity unit at Stepping Hill hospital in Stockport, Greater Manchester.
asserted
wife → describe → Stockport
The light narrowly missed a midwife as it came off the ceiling.
asserted
it → miss → ceiling
So much of the 121-year-old hospital is falling apart that “it’s almost in a death spiral”, Wilkinson added.
asserted
Wilkinson → fall → spiral
Stepping Hill, which regularly suffers leaks, needs £400m to ensure it is safe for patients and staff, its chief executive, Karen James, believes.
asserted
executive → suffer → patients
“There is a clear link between the condition of service infrastructure, the experience of service users and staff, and safety,” NHS England’s review of the infrastructure of maternity and neonatal units, published in September 2025, concluded.
asserted
review → be → September
“In the last three years there have been 14,519 formally reported instances in the maternity and neonatal estate where clinical services have been interrupted or service delivery has been impacted as a direct result of poor physical conditions.
asserted
delivery → report → conditions
”
Problems such as power outages and faulty nurse call systems put “additional pressure on already stretched staff … and can lead directly to procedures delays, such as planned caesarean sections”, it added.
asserted
it → put → sections
In 2024, the CQC warned in a report that “too many maternity units are currently not fit for purpose, lacking space, facilities and, in a small number of cases, the appropriate levels of potentially life-saving equipment.
asserted
units → warn → equipment
We are concerned about the serious safety risks this presents for women and babies.”
asserted
this → concern → women
St Helier hospital in Sutton, south London, is being forced to relocate its maternity services because of urgently needed repairs.
asserted
hospital → force → repairs
The “significant [repair] work” planned cannot be done “while maintaining a good birth, gynaecology and fertility experience and safe environment for babies and families in the building”, said Mat Shaw, the chief executive of the NHS trust that runs St Helier.
asserted
that → plan → Helier
In last month’s budget, ministers cut £1bn from on the NHS’s capital budget over the next four years, to help boost defence spending.
asserted
ministers → cut → spending
The cut is despite the fact that the cost of eradicating the NHS’s massive backlog of maintenance has risen to £17.3bn, according to the most recent official figures.
uncertain
cost → eradicate → figures
Ciarán Devane, the chief executive of the NHS Alliance, said: “A lot of maternity units are located in outdated, decaying buildings, making it much harder to ensure safe, high-quality care.
asserted
it → say → care
This comes on top of wider challenges including staffing, the size and location of some units and the increasing complexity of care.”
asserted
This → come → care
The DHSC blamed the Conservatives’ failure to properly maintain the physical fabric of the NHS during their time in office for the poor state of so many childbirth units.
asserted
DHSC → blame → units
“This government inherited struggling maternity services in buildings left to crumble,” a spokesperson said.
asserted
spokesperson → inherit → buildings
“That is why we’ve invested £271m since April 2025 into schemes related to critical safety risks in the maternity and neonatal estate and recently announced more than £1.5bn to improve NHS buildings and facilities.
asserted
we → invest → buildings
“We know there is a long way to go, but we have backed the NHS with a record capital budget for health, rising to £15bn in 2029-30.
asserted
we → know → 2029
Our 10-year capital plan will also put investment on a long-term footing and rebuild the health service for mothers, babies and all the other patients who rely on it.”
asserted
who → put → it