The era of the province’s hand-picked ”strong chairs” is here, setting the stage for potential power struggles and accusations of bias in decisions that could impact cities and towns around Toronto.
uncertain
that → pick → Toronto
Earlier this week, Municipal Affairs Minister Rob Flack appointed eight regional council chairs, including the surprise choice of two sitting mayors, who will now have the power to override the majority of their councils.
asserted
who → appoint → councils
The move, which in some cases replaces a directly elected chair, has been criticized for circumventing local democracy, creating the perception that regional council will simply do the bidding of the province.
“It is completely uncharted territory,” said Lindsay Jones, executive director of the Association of Municipalities of Ontario.
asserted
Jones → replace → Ontario
While the province began appointing chairs in some regions, including Peel, in 2022, this will be the first term where chairs will have the equivalent of strong-mayor powers.
asserted
chairs → begin → powers
“In theory these powers were given to be able to advance priorities like housing.
asserted
powers → give → housing
In practice there is no kind of restriction and that is not how the powers have been used
asserted
powers → be → restriction
,” said Jones of how the strong-mayor powers have been used at the municipal level.
asserted
powers → say → level
The strong-mayor powers the Ford government gave to 216 Ontario mayors are quietly reshaping local democracy.
asserted
government → give → democracy
But are they getting more homes built?
asserted
homes → get → ?
The strong-mayor powers the Ford government gave to 216 Ontario mayors are quietly reshaping local democracy.
asserted
government → give → democracy
But are they getting more homes built?
asserted
homes → get → ?
A recent Star investigation into the strong-mayor powers the Ford government bestowed on Ontario municipalities found that of more than 4,200 strong-mayor decisions since the law’s inception in 2022, only 81 were directly related to housing — about two per cent.
asserted
81 → bestow → housing
Mayors more often used them to hire and fire senior municipal staff, for pet projects including a giant flagpole and a pickleball court, and in some cases to halt council efforts to approve new housing.
asserted
Mayors → use → housing
Having Vaughan Mayor Steven Del Duca and Pickering Mayor Kevin Ashe assume the chair roles for York and Durham regions respectively has raised further concerns about the capacity of a mayor to wear two sometimes conflicting hats, and perform two full-time jobs.
asserted
Duca → have → jobs
With regional councils responsible for the infrastructure planning that paves the way for new housing developments, as well as regional transit, police budgets, social housing and services and more, there may be plenty of showdowns to come.
uncertain
that → pave → showdowns
The Pickering housing fight
One example of a brewing fight might be over a massive proposed housing development in rural northeast Pickering that could be home to 72,000 people, but which has faced criticism for prioritizing costly sprawl over density, and posing possible flood risks in neighbouring Ajax.
uncertain
which → propose → Ajax
“The problem with it is that there is no infrastructure anywhere in the ground there and that taxpayers are going to have to foot the bill,” said Abdullah Mir, co-chair of advocacy group Stop Sprawl Durham, who unsuccessfully ran for Pickering council in the recent municipal election.
asserted
who → be → election
He considers the strong-chair powers to be anti-democratic and open to abuse, even if the currently appointed chair has the best intentions.
asserted
chair → consider → intentions
“Our society doesn’t work on the ‘just trust me, bro’ principle,” said Mir.
asserted
Mir → work → principle
With Pickering’s Ashe holding strong-chair powers — he has pledged to only use them “sparingly” as required for procedural reasons — Mir worries that it will be more difficult to raise objections.
“It feels like the deck just got stacked against us.”
asserted
deck → hold → us
Environmental Defence lawyer Phil Pothen said this development is an example of the kind of housing the province wants to see, but which is far more expensive and time-consuming to build than encouraging infill in existing neighbourhoods.
asserted
which → say → neighbourhoods
Regional governments are going to find their municipal members pitted against each other, he said, as they have to choose between funding the basic infrastructure for greenfield housing development, like the Pickering example — or building more housing through mid-rises and multiplexes where there are already roads, sewers, sidewalks and other necessary services.
asserted
they → go → rises
“We can’t do both,” he said.
asserted
he → do → both
Pothen is also worried about conflicts arising from Ontario consolidating conservation authorities from 36 to nine.
asserted
Ontario → worry → nine
The new regional conservation authorities will have board members appointed by regional councils and single-tier municipalities like Toronto and Hamilton.
asserted
authorities → have → Toronto
In theory, he said, this gives the provincially appointed “strong chairs” more influence over bodies that consider the impact of development plans on watersheds — such as potential flooding in Ajax from the new housing plan in Pickering.
asserted
that → say → Pickering
Going forward, Ontario residents “should see decisions of regional governments and decisions of local governments with strong-mayor powers — except where the mayor has promised not to use the powers … really as decisions imposed by the province,” said Pothen.
asserted
Pothen → go → province
Markham’s mayor doubts York’s new chair
asserted
mayor → doubt → chair
Although they expressed their dislike of the appointment process and the minority rule powers of the regional chairs, several mayors told the Star they think Del Duca and Ashe will do a good job.
asserted
Duca → express → job
The province has also defended its decision.
asserted
province → defend → decision
“Each chair was vetted through a Ministry-led process and screened for any potential conflicts of interest that could arise from their appointment.
uncertain
that → vet → appointment
“We have full confidence in all eight chairs’ ability to advance our shared priorities, including respecting taxpayers, investing in critical infrastructure, getting homes built, and protecting Ontario jobs,” said Flack’s spokesperson Michael Minzak.
asserted
spokesperson → have → jobs
Markham Mayor Frank Scarpitti has a different view.
asserted
Scarpitti → have → view
Del Duca — York region’s new chair — “is no friend of the city of Markham,” he said.
asserted
he → say → Markham
Ford appointing an ally and mayor to chair the council overseeing nine York municipalities, and giving him a “mandate letter” similar to those given cabinet ministers, creates a “conflict of interest,” Scarpitti said.
asserted
Scarpitti → appoint → interest
He added he is especially focused on rapid transit development and will not stand for Markham’s interests being put behind those of the city of Vaughan or the Ford government.
asserted
interests → add → Vaughan
“The premier said the president of the United States could kiss a certain part of his anatomy (over tariffs), but he forgot to say that the president would have to push Steven Del Duca out of the way,” Scarpitti said, noting the close working relationship of the former provincial opponents.
Del Duca did not respond to a request for comment but issued a press release Thursday touting widespread support he has received for his appointment.
“I am very grateful to the mayors and regional councillors who have both publicly and privately congratulated me,” he said.
uncertain
he → say → me
Tito-Dante Marimpietri, the newly elected mayor of Oshawa, said he respects Ashe, but is also prepared to fight at the region to ensure his city gets the funding for police infrastructure and homelessness supports he says it deserves.
asserted
it → elect → infrastructure
Durham Region’s council, which represents eight municipalities, is facing some tough decisions over a $1.1-billion police capital budget plan that includes a new headquarters and two new police stations, as well as a 10-year housing and homelessness plan — while also trying to minimize a tax hike for residents in an affordability crisis.
asserted
that → represent → crisis
“We expect a Durham Regional Police headquarters with a training centre, and a police station for North Oshawa,” said Marimpietri, as one example of what he will be pushing for at the region.
asserted
he → expect → region
…and 11 more, not listed.