This story was originally published by WIRED and is reproduced here as part of the Climate Desk collaboration.
asserted
story → publish → collaboration
Michigan residents overwhelmingly passed a midterm ballot measure intended to restrict the ability of utilities and state contractors to influence politics.
asserted
residents → pass → politics
Now, the utilities are fighting back.
asserted
utilities → fight → ?
In a lawsuit filed on November 5, the two major utilities in Michigan, Consumers Energy and DTE, argue that the measure—dubbed Proposal 2—threatens their First and 14th Amendment rights.
asserted
measure → file → rights
The ballot measure, which passed with 81 percent of the vote, amends the state’s campaign finance laws to put restrictions on donations for both utilities and companies with more than $250,000 annually in state and local government contracts.
asserted
which → pass → contracts
The new language explicitly bans political donations from utilities, contractors, and high-level employees, lobbyists, and their immediate family members.
asserted
language → ban → utilities
The ballot measure also tightens the state’s regulations around disclosures for political ads, mailers, and other forms of communication.
asserted
measure → tighten → communication
Michigan was part of the blue tsunami election where energy prices and government corruption—and data centers—played a huge role in getting Democrats elected and getting ballot measures like this passed.
asserted
measures → play → this
The state is a major hub for data center development, with at least 26 projects planned across the state as of July.
asserted
projects → plan → July
The utilities have supported that development: the industry has lobbied in the past for tax breaks for data centers, and DTE has proposed building two new massive gas plants to handle potential data center load, at a cost of $6.4 billion, with consumers potentially on the hook.
asserted
consumers → support → hook
Michiganders have seen energy bills increase by 10 percent over the past 12 months, the fourth-largest increase in the US, according to Energy Bill Lab.
uncertain
bills → see → Lab
“Michigan really is ground zero right now for a utility accountability wave that is quite national,” says David Pomerantz, the director of the Energy & Policy Institute, a nonprofit utility watchdog.
asserted
Pomerantz → say → Institute
The ballot initiative, the utilities say in the lawsuit, was drawn up as “a means of excluding Plaintiffs from critical aspects of the political debate.”
asserted
utilities → say → debate
Consumers spokesperson Katie Carey writes in an email that the proposal “unfairly targets a Michigan business, its Michigan employees, and their family members from exercising their constitutionally protected rights to participate in the political process, while allowing out-of-state special interest groups and billionaires to continue flooding Michigan with political spending.
asserted
groups → write → spending
Michiganders should not lose their First Amendment rights because of where they work.”
asserted
they → lose → rights
DTE did not respond to WIRED’s request for comment.
asserted
DTE → respond → comment
Utilities are regulated by state-level bodies, either elected or appointed by the governor, which Pomerantz says means that there’s much more incentive to participate in pay-to-play schemes.
asserted
Pomerantz → regulate → schemes
Corruption scandals involving utilities have rocked neighboring states like Ohio and Illinois.
asserted
scandals → involve → Ohio
In the lawsuit, DTE and Consumers Energy say there is “no scandal, no exchange of official acts for money, no examples whatsoever.”
asserted
DTE → say → money
Daniel Weiner, the director of the Elections and Government program at the Brennan Center for Justice, says that the new language set up by the ballot proposal “moves Michigan toward being one of the states that more effectively regulates this kind of political giving, where there’s a particularly heightened risk of corruption.”
asserted
that → say → corruption
The lawsuit states that the new provisions “goes well beyond the laws of any other state.”
asserted
provisions → state → state
Weiner points out that it’s unusual, but not unprecedented, for states to restrict or prohibit political donations from the family members of people affiliated with government contractors.
asserted
states → point → contractors
New Jersey, Connecticut, and New Mexico have similar language in their laws.
asserted
Jersey → have → laws
However, these laws make no specific mention of utilities.
asserted
laws → make → utilities
(Other states, including Georgia and Alabama, do have restrictions on utilities making political donations.)
asserted
states → include → donations
“If you’re going to have an effective restriction on major state contractors pouring tons of money into campaigns, it cannot just be limited to the entity that holds the contract—that just creates an enormous loophole,” Weiner says, pointing to a recent ProPublica story about a government contractor who used a shell company to funnel donations to a super PAC affiliated with Senator Susan Collins of Maine.
asserted
who → go → Maine
A 2023 analysis from local outlet Bridge Michigan found organizations linked to the two utilities had given more than $2 million to state politicians via their PACs.
asserted
organizations → find → PACs
But the companies do much of their political spending via dark money distributed by affiliated outside groups, Pomerantz says.
asserted
Pomerantz → do → groups
Michigan Energy First, a 501(c)4 linked to DTE, has received more than $51 million in donations since 2014, according to the Energy & Policy Institute; DTE gave $8 million to Michigan Energy First from September 2025 through August 2026.
uncertain
DTE → link → August
(DTE has repeatedly denied any connections between the company and this group, despite the fact that it has been staffed by company executives.)
asserted
it → deny → executives
The Detroit News reported last year that Michigan Energy First had given $550,000 to a group associated with Gov. Gretchen Whitmer and $750,000 to state House Speaker Matt Hall in 2024, amid an influx of data center proposals in the state.
asserted
First → report → state
The donations also arrived right before the Public Utilities Commission approved a rate hike for customers.
asserted
Commission → arrive → customers
In total, Michigan Energy First had given $1.8 million to the Whitmer-affiliated group since its founding in 2020.
asserted
First → give → 2020
(DTE told the outlet that any insinuation that it expected preferential treatment for its contributions was “blatantly false.”)
asserted
it → tell → contributions
Michigan utilities spent a little over $200,000 in an attempt to defeat the measure.
asserted
utilities → spend → measure
“We are fully confident in the legality of Proposal 2 and look forward to seeing this out in court,” says Samuel Bagenstos, legal counsel for the groups behind the measure.
asserted
Bagenstos → look → measure
“The language of Proposal 2 was carefully crafted with constitutionality in mind, and we are well prepared for this expected legal challenge.
asserted
we → craft → challenge
We intend to vigorously defend the will of Michiganders who overwhelmingly approved this measure just one week ago.
asserted
who → intend → measure
Even if they had spent a massive amount of money to defeat the initiative, “they probably still would have lost, because they’re so unbelievably unpopular,” Pomerantz says.
asserted
Pomerantz → spend → initiative