The federal government’s new national security strategy, released last month, recognizes economic security as a national priority and identifies energy and critical minerals as strategic capabilities.
asserted
strategy → release → capabilities
While that is a welcome evolution, it fails to articulate a coherent theory for how to leverage those resources.
asserted
it → fail → resources
Canada has rarely thought strategically about its enormous natural resource endowment, but when it has, it’s been as a source of wealth.
asserted
it → think → wealth
It is time we started thinking about it as a source of power.
asserted
we → start → power
The concept of economic security is having a moment, as the capacity to meet material needs and withstand supply shocks at the national level becomes ever more important.
asserted
capacity → have → level
Some schools of thought have defined economic security as having two sides: strategic autonomy, which seeks to limit dependence on potentially coercive partners through diversification and resilient supply chains; and strategic indispensability, which seeks to develop goods or services that other nations cannot easily replace, making it harder for them to coerce or decouple from you.
asserted
them → define → you
Strategic autonomy is defensive in nature, and endeavours to limit vulnerabilities.
asserted
autonomy → endeavour → vulnerabilities
The national security strategy invokes the concept numerous times, and it’s no surprise why: Canada is in a moment where its greatest policy imperative is to respond to the changing nature of its relationship with the United States.
asserted
imperative → invoke → States
Our prosperity and our security rely to an uncomfortable extent on the graces of our southern neighbour, and it is in our interests to bolster our sovereign capabilities and foster other alliances.
asserted
it → rely → alliances
Prime Minister Mark Carney speaks after LNG Canada said it will go ahead with the Phase 2 expansion project at its LNG terminal in Kitimat, B.C., during an announcement in Vancouver, on Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2026.
asserted
it → speak → Tuesday
Where the national security strategy falls short is in articulating the means to increase our strategic indispensability.
asserted
falls → fall → indispensability
This is an offensive posture: making yourself so valuable that partners have an interest in protecting and cooperating with you.
asserted
partners → make → you
The products most likely to make global trading partners indispensable right now are semiconductors and chips, rare earth permanent magnets, energy, and some critical minerals.
asserted
partners → make → ?
For Canada, it is obvious where our strengths lie; indeed, it has been revealed.
asserted
it → lie → Canada
In the trade war with the United States, the products they had the most difficulty replacing domestically or from other trading partners were oil, potash, uranium, nickel, and aluminum, as well as natural gas in some regional markets.
asserted
they → have → markets
It has been remarked that the only countries that retaliated against American tariffs were Canada and China.
asserted
that → remark → tariffs
That is the short list of countries that are the most indispensable to the American economy and have leverage to exercise.
asserted
that → have → leverage
Export even more
Thinking proactively, how can Canada use its energy and minerals to make itself indispensable to more allies?
asserted
itself → think → allies
The obvious answer is to export more oil, LNG, uranium, potash, and minerals to trading partners in Asia and Europe.
asserted
answer → export → Asia
The commodity shocks arising from the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine and the 2026 disruption of the Strait of Hormuz make this both possible and imperative.
asserted
this → arise → Hormuz
The recent federal policy support for growing LNG exports, expanding West Coast oil pipeline access, and bolstering East Coast offshore oil production are tangible examples.
asserted
support → grow → production
The series of underlying regulatory and tax reforms to improve the competitiveness of Canada’s mining and oil and gas sectors can also be seen through this light.
asserted
series → underlie → light
Crude oil tankers SFL Sabine, left, and Tarbet Spirit are seen docked at the Trans Mountain Westridge Marine Terminal, where crude oil from the expanded Trans Mountain Pipeline is loaded onto tankers, in Burnaby, B.C., Monday, June 10, 2024.
asserted
oil → see → Burnaby
There have been further investments in critical minerals production that make sense only from a strategic, rather than economic lens.
asserted
that → make → lens
It has become well understood that China has developed monopolies in a variety of critical minerals that has given it strategic indispensability in the international system.
asserted
that → become → system
In an attempt to reduce their dependence, most Western nations have put out lists of minerals in which they plan to intervene to secure supply.
asserted
they → reduce → supply
NATO put out its own list in December 2024, and Canada has catalysed around it, in particular through its G7 Critical Minerals Resilience and Production Alliance.
asserted
Canada → put → Alliance
We have made significant investments in germanium, gallium, antimony, graphite, scandium, as well as lithium, rare earths, cobalt, and aluminum, with the most important probably being the major investment in July in Teck’s Trail Operations in British Columbia, one of the world’s largest fully integrated polymetallic smelting and refining complexes.
asserted
important → make → complexes
These represent costs, not sources of revenue, but they are worth it to make ourselves more important to our allies.
asserted
ourselves → represent → allies
Wealth, power, and the importance of predictability
Leveraging Canada’s energy and resource endowment for geopolitical purposes is increasingly viable in an era of AI competition.
asserted
Leveraging → leverage → competition
Because AI is now a strategic necessity, the raw materials needed for electrification, including natural gas, uranium, copper, and aluminum, are becoming more important.
asserted
materials → need → gas
But Canada has another opportunity: to generate more electricity domestically, where we have an enormous cost advantage for inputs relative to our Asian and European peers, and export compute.
asserted
we → have → peers
Canada could become strategically indispensable by providing GPU processing time, AI model training, inference, scientific computing, and cloud services to its allies.
uncertain
Canada → become → allies
View reader comments (0)
Canada’s natural resources are indeed a source of power, and should be cultivated as such.
asserted
resources → view → power
But that doesn’t mean the wealth they generate is secondary.
asserted
they → mean → ?
As Canada is pushed into spending more on defence in this fraught geopolitical era, the most significant source of additional income will come from growing its energy and resource exports.
asserted
source → push → exports
Within this framework, expanding energy and minerals production and growing global market share are ends in themselves, and essential to making Canada, and its allies, more prosperous and secure.
asserted
Canada → expand → themselves
The opposite is true: restricting Canadian resource development has negative political and economic repercussions that are difficult to tolerate.
asserted
that → restrict → repercussions
That is why telling the German Chancellor in August 2022 that there was no business case for Canadian LNG when that important ally was trying desperately to minimize reliance on Russian natural gas was so painful to many of us.
asserted
ally → tell → us
Many nations seek to become indispensable in order to exploit that dependence coercively.
asserted
nations → seek → dependence
…and 10 more, not listed.