Democrats debate best path forward
What Dems do with their big majorities in Congress will shape U.S. politics over next two years
Still giddy from their sweeping midterm victory over U.S. President Donald Trump's Republican Party, the Democrats now face a dilemma over what to do next.
asserted
Democrats → debate → what
Some Democratic factions are urging the party to use its new majorities in the House and Senate to investigate Trump, his family and his allies over allegations of corruption.
asserted
factions → urge → corruption
Others insist the Democrats must avoid being distracted by trying to score political points against the president and instead stay laser-focused on what voters signalled as their biggest concern: the cost of living.
asserted
voters → insist → living
The path Democrats choose could shape much of U.S. politics over the next two years and influence what happens in the post-Trump presidential election of 2028.
uncertain
what → choose → 2028
The choices the party faces over its future direction were on full display in Denver, Colo., where a new but well-funded political organization that aims to steer Democrats toward the centre sponsored a conference entitled What's Next.
asserted
What → face → conference
A long list of Democratic rising stars and power brokers took turns delivering their visions for the party, including the candidate who pulled off arguably the most monumental red-to-blue flip of election night, senator-elect James Talarico of Texas.
James Talarico, senator-elect of Texas, speaks during a conference about the future of the Democratic Party on Thursday in Denver, Colo.
asserted
Talarico → rise → Denver
"We must deliver immediate, bold relief during this affordability crisis.
asserted
We → deliver → crisis
We must unrig this economic system that only benefits the top one per cent," Talarico told the crowd.
asserted
Talarico → unrig → crowd
He went on to lay out another 10 must-dos, including universal healthcare, overhauling the immigration system and cutting red tape to build millions of new homes, each greeted by raucous applause.
asserted
each → go → applause
Talarico then offered a "we must" that stunned the crowd into near silence.
asserted
that → offer → silence
"The American people cannot wait two years for change.
asserted
people → wait → change
So we must work with President Trump," he said.
asserted
he → work → Trump
"We should make the final two years of his presidency the most productive of any presidency in American history, because this moment is so much bigger and so much more important than the red team or the blue team."
asserted
moment → make → team
Talarico's proposal acknowledges a fundamental reality the Democrats will face when they take control of Congress in January: Trump will still be president, with veto power and executive authority, giving him plenty of scope to thwart the party's agenda.
asserted
Trump → acknowledge → agenda
Yet there's plenty of skepticism that Trump will want to co-operate in any way, prompting some Democrats to argue for a more aggressive approach with the White House aimed at holding the administration accountable.
asserted
administration → be → House
Robert Garcia, the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee, is vowing "to take on corruption wherever we find it."
asserted
we → vow → it
He's one of several Democrats with key roles in powerful congressional committees already signalling they intend to investigate a range of the Trump administration's dealings and actions.
asserted
they → signal → dealings
Garcia argues it's not a binary choice for Democrats between investigating corruption and reducing the cost of living.
asserted
it → argue → living
"As families struggle with rising costs, the Trumps are cashing in on the presidency and stealing from the American taxpayer.
asserted
Trumps → struggle → taxpayer
Taking on their corruption is about making life more affordable," Garcia posted on X.
asserted
Garcia → take → X.
Robert Garcia, a Democrat from California, is the party's leading member of the House Oversight Committee.
asserted
Garcia → lead → Committee
He's pictured on the steps of the Capitol in Washington, D.C. on Nov. 10.
asserted
He → picture → Nov.
How Democrats navigate this terrain over the next two years matters deeply because it will play into voters' perceptions of the party and its presidential candidate heading into the 2028 election.
asserted
it → navigate → election
They're getting no shortage of advice about how best to approach it.
asserted
They → get → it
Two pieces published within days of each other in The Atlantic last week illustrate the ends of the spectrum.
asserted
pieces → publish → spectrum
'Investigate Trump like a mob boss'
"Democrats should cut a deal with Trump" says the headline of the first, by Villanova University law professor Chaim Saiman.
asserted
headline → investigate → Saiman
"Investigate Trump like a mob boss" says the headline of the second, by former federal prosecutor Randall Eliason.
asserted
headline → investigate → Eliason
The Democrat behind the most shocking win of the midterms, senator-elect Scott Colom of Mississippi, rejects the notion that the party faces an either-or scenario.
asserted
party → reject → scenario
"Did Mississippians elect you to work with the president or stand up to him?" CNN's Dana Bash asked Colom on the weekend.
asserted
Bash → elect → weekend
Colom responded by saying voters elected him to ensure Trump follows through on his commitments.
asserted
Trump → respond → commitments
Mississippi Democrat Scott Colom defeated Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith in the midterm election for U.S. Senate.
asserted
Colom → defeat → Senate
He is seen here speaking to reporters Jackson, Mississippi on Nov. 4.
asserted
He → see → Nov.
Trump "promised lower grocery prices on day one.
asserted
Trump → promise → day
Well, I want to work with him to actually accomplish that," Colom said.
asserted
Colom → want → that
"He promised no more endless wars.
asserted
He → promise → wars
Well, I want to work with him to accomplish that."
asserted
I → want → that
One thing Democrats won't control is how Trump reacts to their tactics.
asserted
Trump → control → tactics
If Congress puts a bill on his desk with populist measures to rein in the costs of things like health care and housing, will Trump welcome it or veto it?
asserted
Trump → put → it
If the Democrats' investigations start probing Trump or his family a little too closely for the president's comfort, will he go into full-on flamethrower mode, blocking everything that comes from Congress and ordering the Department of Justice to pursue his political enemies?
asserted
that → start → enemies
- Analysis
How the Democrats' midterm wave shows a path back to the presidency
Senior Democratic congressman says party 'going to put an end' to Trump's tariffs
Democratic leaders are aware that an attempt to impeach Trump would almost certainly fall short of the two-thirds majority needed in the Senate for a conviction.
They're also conscious of the risk that investigations that smack of political grandstanding and appear out of step with Americans' priorities could ultimately backfire with voters.
uncertain
that → show → voters
…and 3 more, not listed.