Omar Soboh, a student at the University of Florida, was organizing a campus panel about Islamophobia when he found out one of the groups being represented had suddenly been blacklisted by the state.
asserted
one → organize → state
Under a new process, Florida had designated the Council on American-Islamic Relations (Cair), the nation’s largest Muslim civil rights group, a domestic terrorist organization.
asserted
Florida → designate → Relations
The university’s Arab Students’ Association decided to cancel the event, and Soboh, who is Palestinian American, was disheartened.
asserted
who → decide → event
“Our existence itself is political,” he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
In July, Governor Ron DeSantis approved legislation giving five state officials the power to designate groups as “domestic terrorist” organizations.
asserted
DeSantis → approve → organizations
Once the designation goes into effect, as it did on 5 November for Cair and its Florida chapter, it can trigger debilitating penalties for the group and its supporters under state law.
asserted
it → go → law
The threat of these punishments effectively forces designated groups to shut down, said Cair.
asserted
Cair → force → groups
In turn, the group has sued Florida officials, including DeSantis, in federal court with the help of the American Civil Liberties Union, alleging violations of free speech and due process.
asserted
group → sue → speech
Cair-Florida’s website homepage is now pitch black, except for a note stating that staff has suspended operations because of the “baseless and unconstitutional enforcement” of Florida’s law.
asserted
staff → state → law
“For the first time in over twenty years, Florida Muslims cannot call their community’s leading civil rights organization for help if they experience a hate crime at their mosque, illegal discrimination in the workplace, violent bullying in school, or any other acts of bigotry,” said Edward Ahmed Mitchell, national deputy director at Cair, in a press release.
asserted
Mitchell → call → release
The shutdown has already affected Muslims in the community, as Cair-Florida can no longer provide pro bono legal services for discrimination and immigration cases, leaving local attorneys scrambling to pick up the pieces.
asserted
Florida → affect → pieces
Civil rights advocates fear Cair’s targeting is only the beginning of Florida exploiting its power to cripple all kinds of lawful advocacy, especially the pro-Palestinian movement.
asserted
Florida → fear → advocacy
“It’s entirely unprecedented for state governments to attempt to shut down organizations by branding them as terror organizations,” said Shirin Sinnar, a law professor at Stanford University who co-authored an amicus brief for Cair in a related case.
asserted
who → ’ → case
“This sends a message to the Muslim American community, as a whole, that this organization, which has defended your civil rights, is no longer able to do that.”
asserted
which → send → that
The effects of the shutdown amid a rise in Islamophobia
Cair and its Florida chapter are the main civil rights organization for Muslims in the state, focusing on immigration, discrimination and free speech cases, know-your-rights workshops, voter mobilization and Islamophobia research.
asserted
Cair → focus → rights
Cair-Florida, which employed about 12 staff members and eight contractors, has fought for prisoners’ access to halal meals and pro-Palestinian students’ right to protest.
asserted
which → employ → meals
Cair’s national division took Muslim Americans’ grievances about federal “no-fly lists” to the supreme court – and won.
asserted
division → take → court
State officials have argued in legal filings, without clear evidence, that Cair and its Florida chapter have been operating as a front for Hamas and the Muslim Brotherhood, “all while masquerading as run-of-the-mill civil rights organizations”.
asserted
Cair → argue → organizations
Cair denies these claims and has never been charged with or convicted of any crime.
uncertain
Cair → deny → crime
Instead, Cair says, Florida is using the new law to “punish their perceived political enemies” and that the organization is being targeted for its religious missions and advocacy.
asserted
organization → say → missions
Aside from Cair, Florida also applied the domestic terrorist designation to the Muslim Brotherhood and “antifa” – a vague umbrella term for far-left-leaning and anarchist anti-fascist groups and individuals.
asserted
Florida → apply → groups
This aligns with the Trump administration labeling “antifa” and certain branches of “the Muslim Brotherhood” as terrorist groups, alongside its targeting of leftist and pro-Palestinian activists.
asserted
administration → align → activists
Tactically, Florida’s focus on Cair reflects an attempt to go after one of the most marginalized groups first, said Sinnar: “The whole point is to establish a precedent with the most disfavored of organizations – the one that few people in the state will rally to defend.”
asserted
people → reflect → state
Then, that power can be weaponized against other groups, she added.
asserted
she → weaponize → groups
Florida’s targeting of Cair comes amid rising Islamophobia in the US – and the pushback against it.
asserted
targeting → come → it
That includes a growing crackdown on pro-Palestinian activism, felt most sharply by students facing discipline and immigrants threatened with deportation.
asserted
That → include → deportation
Islamophobic attacks also colored Michigan Democrat Abdul El-Sayed’s run for Senate – with Trump referring to him as a “jihadi” and his Republican opponent falsely linking him with the Muslim Brotherhood.
asserted
opponent → color → Brotherhood
But El-Sayed’s victory, after leaning in to his Muslim identity and pro-Palestinian values, reflected that Muslims are building electoral power, regardless.
asserted
Muslims → lean → power
In January, El-Sayed will become the first Muslim US senator, joining a record-breaking seven newly elected Muslims in Congress.
asserted
Sayed → become → Congress
Civil rights advocates argue that electing progressive and Muslim lawmakers at the state level can help fight back against Republican-led legislatures and governors enforcing terrorism laws.
asserted
electing → argue → laws
This has already happened in Texas, which flipped blue on election night.
asserted
which → happen → night
Governor Greg Abbott, who issued a proclamation last year declaring Cair a terrorist organization, and attorney general Ken Paxton, who sued Cair in an attempt to shut down the organization, both lost their seats to Democrats.
asserted
who → issue → Democrats
Incoming Governor Gina Hinojosa said she will reverse Abbott’s designation in an interview with the Washington Post last week and Paxton recently dropped his lawsuit against Cair.
asserted
Paxton → say → Cair
The Muslim Legal Fund of America, which is representing Cair in its Texas lawsuit against Abbott’s designation, said that “it’s pretty clear this case is probably not going to go much further”.
asserted
case → represent → designation
However, it may be too late for an electoral solution in Florida, said Abdullah Sheikh, a community activist who tried to rally opposition to the state’s domestic terrorism program before the legislation hit the governor’s desk.
uncertain
legislation → say → desk
While he’s typically an optimist, he now worries: “The legislature has zero incentive to do anything at this point.”
asserted
legislature → ’ → point
A repeal would need to win over both chambers and the governor, all of which Republicans control.
asserted
Republicans → need → which
Florida serves as a “cautionary tale for other states”, he said, to squash these measures before they become law.
asserted
they → serve → measures
The chilling effect sets in
In a normal year, Cair-Florida would have scheduled meetings with elected officials right after the midterms, but that didn’t happen this year.
asserted
that → set → midterms
Before the designation even kicked in, Cair and its Florida chapter had already restricted activity in the state by pausing donor outreach, cancelling active recurring donations and suspending plans for its three annual “life-sustaining” fundraising galas.
asserted
Cair → kick → galas
…and 26 more, not listed.