School cellphone bans are beginning to produce measurable academic gains, according to a new nationwide study that found students at schools with strict restrictions made the equivalent of an additional one to two weeks of learning over the course of a year.
uncertain
students → begin → year
The study, published Tuesday by Harvard University’s Center for Education Policy Research, examined test scores from approximately 3.3 million students between 3rd and 10th grade at 4,600 schools between 2021 and 2026.
asserted
study → publish → 2021
Researchers compared academic growth at schools that prohibited students from accessing their phones throughout the school day with growth at similar schools without strict bans.
asserted
that → compare → bans
Students at schools requiring phones to be locked away in pouches saw modest improvements in both math and reading.
asserted
Students → require → math
Researchers estimated the gains reversed roughly half of the annual learning losses experienced by students in the years leading up to the COVID-19 pandemic.
asserted
gains → estimate → pandemic
“The earlier studies on cellphone bans have been dismissed as implying small impacts, and in-school cellphone use has been ruled out as playing a big role in the decline,” Thomas Kane, a Harvard education professor and co-author of the study, told The New York Times.
asserted
Kane → dismiss → Times
“But we think that’s mistaken.”
asserted
that → think → ?
The findings arrive as states and school districts increasingly restrict students’ access to smartphones.
asserted
states → arrive → smartphones
Forty-six states have enacted school cellphone bans or restrictions, although the policies vary considerably.
asserted
policies → enact → bans
Some schools require students to lock their devices away for the entire day, while others allow phones to remain in backpacks or permit their use during lunch and between classes.
asserted
phones → require → classes
The study found the strongest academic improvements at schools with the strictest restrictions, particularly those requiring students to place their phones in locked pouches that cannot be opened until dismissal.
asserted
that → find → dismissal
Less restrictive policies also appeared to produce gains, although researchers expressed less confidence in those results.
asserted
researchers → appear → results
The findings offer support for policies that have gained momentum among educators and lawmakers concerned about the effects of smartphones on students’ academic performance.
asserted
that → offer → performance
But researchers cautioned that the improvements remain modest and that phone restrictions alone are unlikely to reverse the broader decline in American student achievement.
asserted
restrictions → caution → achievement
A separate nationwide study published earlier this year found that phone bans had close to zero overall effect on standardized test scores, although researchers identified some positive effects in high school math.
asserted
researchers → publish → math
The two studies used different approaches.
asserted
studies → use → approaches
The newer Harvard analysis tracked individual students’ test scores over time, while the earlier research examined average scores at schools adopting phone restrictions.
asserted
research → track → restrictions
The Harvard study also relied on a smaller subset of schools using the NWEA testing system.
asserted
study → rely → system
Brian Jacob, a University of Michigan professor who co-authored the earlier study, said the newer findings were broadly consistent with his team’s research, even though its positive results were not statistically significant overall.
asserted
results → co → research
He cautioned against placing too much weight on small academic gains, but said their cumulative effect could become meaningful if they persist over time.
uncertain
they → caution → time
The question of whether those improvements will continue remains unsettled.
asserted
improvements → continue → ?
The Harvard researchers found that gains did not appear to disappear after the first year of a ban, instead continuing through as many as three years of implementation.
asserted
gains → find → implementation
American student achievement began declining around 2013, years before the pandemic disrupted schools nationwide, according to NPR.
uncertain
pandemic → begin → NPR
Researchers have pointed to several potential explanations, including changes in school accountability policies, chronic absenteeism and the widespread adoption of smartphones.
asserted
Researchers → point → smartphones
Smartphone access among teenagers increased dramatically during that period.
asserted
access → increase → period
In 2011, fewer than one-quarter of teenagers had access to smartphones, according to the researchers.
uncertain
quarter → have → researchers
By 2018, approximately 95% did.
asserted
% → do → 2018
The study’s authors believe restricting access during school hours could help recover some of the learning lost during that period.
uncertain
restricting → believe → period
Kane argued that the approach is relatively inexpensive, estimating the cost of phone pouches at approximately $25 per student.
asserted
approach → argue → student
Still, researchers say schools cannot eliminate digital distractions simply by collecting students’ phones.
asserted
schools → say → phones
School-issued laptops and other devices can provide alternative ways to access social media and messaging platforms, while smartphone use outside school hours may also affect students’ sleep, mental health, and ability to concentrate on homework.
uncertain
use → issue → homework
The researchers also emphasized that test scores capture only part of the potential effects of phone restrictions.
asserted
scores → emphasize → restrictions
Teachers have reported that students without phones spend more time talking with classmates, playing, and participating in classroom discussions.
asserted
students → report → discussions
Whether those broader benefits translate into lasting improvements in student well-being and academic performance will require further research.
asserted
translate → translate → research