A record three-quarters of a billion pounds was spent keeping Britain’s lights on last month with Scottish wind farms paid to turn off.
asserted
farms → spend → lights
The UK’s balancing bill hit a record £744.6million in October – a cost ultimately picked up by households and businesses through their electricity bills.
asserted
bill → hit → bills
Almost two-thirds of the total, £470million, came from Scottish grid constraints which arise when Scotland’s wind farms generate more electricity than transmission lines can carry elsewhere in Britain.
asserted
lines → come → Britain
The bottlenecks can leave consumers paying twice, once to switch off wind farms and again to fire up alternative generators elsewhere in the country.
asserted
bottlenecks → leave → country
The figures come as ministers face renewed pressure to back domestic energy projects including the Rosebank oil field west of Shetland.
asserted
ministers → come → Shetland
Scottish Tory energy spokesman Liam Kerr said: ‘Scottish consumers are being left to foot a staggering bill because renewable energy is being expanded without the grid infrastructure to get that power where it is needed.
asserted
it → say → power
‘The SNP has repeatedly talked up the importance of generating renewable energy but is totally clueless when it comes to the bigger picture of actually getting it around the country.
asserted
it → talk → country
‘It is entirely reasonable to ask why households should be paying hundreds of millions of pounds to compensate for a failure to properly plan Scotland’s energy system.’
asserted
households → ask → system
Households and businesses are footing the bill for Scottish wind farms being paid to turn off
The latest figures from the National Energy System Operator show Scottish constraint costs accounted for almost 63 per cent of the UK’s total balancing bill in October, despite Scotland consuming less than a tenth of Britain’s electricity.
asserted
Scotland → foot → electricity
The October total shattered the previous record of £564.9million, set only a month earlier, while Scotland’s constraint costs also surged from £342.4million in September to almost £470million in October.
asserted
costs → shatter → October
The Nuclear Industry Association (NIA) said the cost of dealing with bottlenecks on Scotland’s electricity grid could reach £2.23billion this year – almost nine times the total five years ago.
uncertain
cost → say → 2.23billion
It estimates these costs could account for around £32 on the average household electricity bill across Britain this year compared with £3.60 in 2021.
uncertain
costs → estimate → 2021
On particularly windy days, Scotland can produce more electricity than it needs locally or can send to other parts of Britain.
asserted
it → produce → Britain
When the network cannot carry the electricity, wind farms can be paid to switch off their turbines, while other power stations, including gas-fired plants, can be paid to generate electricity closer to where it is needed.
asserted
it → carry → electricity
These costs are shared by households and businesses across Britain through their electricity bills.
asserted
costs → share → bills
NIA chief executive Tom Greatrex said: ‘For the second consecutive month, Scotland has broken records for monthly grid balancing costs, driving up energy bills for British households and businesses who already face some of the highest charges in Europe.
asserted
who → say → Europe
‘Because our grid lacks the transmission capacity to move power from where it’s generated to where it’s needed, billpayers are effectively paying twice: once to switch off Scottish wind farms during bottlenecks, and again for expensive backup power when the wind drops.
asserted
wind → lack → power
‘Maintaining the dependable, homegrown nuclear baseload in Scotland’s energy mix is the most reliable and cost-effective way to stabilise our grid, keep bills down and bring jobs and investment to Scotland.’
asserted
Maintaining → maintain → Scotland
Angela Hepworth, chief executive of industry body Scottish Renewables, said: ‘Keeping electricity affordable is a shared priority for industry and government.
asserted
Keeping → say → industry
‘Rising constraint costs underline the urgency of upgrading a grid that has not kept pace with Scotland’s renewable energy growth.
asserted
that → rise → growth
‘The onshore and offshore wind secured in the latest auction round was substantially cheaper than building and operating new gas power stations.
asserted
wind → secure → stations
‘Yet limited grid capacity forces Scottish wind farms to turn down while more expensive gas generation elsewhere turns up, adding to costs and leaving consumers exposed to global price shocks.’
asserted
generation → force → shocks
A Scottish Government spokesman said: ‘We recognise the impact constraint costs have on consumers and businesses, with the key levers for addressing these costs sitting with the UK Government.
asserted
levers → say → Government
‘The UK Government must take action to tackle rising constraint costs and accelerate investment in the grid infrastructure needed to enable Scotland’s abundant renewable energy to efficiently reach homes and businesses across the country.’
asserted
energy → take → country
The National Grid said it does not own the electricity transmission network in Scotland, which is operated by SSEN Transmission and SP Transmission.
asserted
which → say → Transmission
The UK Government has previously acknowledged that decades of under-investment in Britain’s electricity network have left consumers exposed to higher energy costs.
asserted
decades → acknowledge → costs
In April, it warned that the cost of dealing with grid bottlenecks across Britain could reach £7billion in 2030-31 without further action, adding the country ‘cannot afford delay’ in upgrading and expanding the electricity network.
uncertain
country → warn → network
Earlier this month, the UK Government outlined measures in its Energy Independence Bill aimed at speeding up delivery of new electricity infrastructure.
asserted
Government → outline → infrastructure
It estimates that accelerating key grid projects and avoiding further delays could reduce constraint costs by around £4billion in 2030, equivalent to a saving of £40 to £50 for the average household with gas and electricity.
uncertain
accelerating → estimate → gas
Scottish Tory energy spokesman Liam Kerr said the SNP is 'totally clueless' when it comes to distributing renewable energy around the country
A spokesman for the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero said: ‘Breaking the link with fossil fuels, upgrading our network and transitioning to clean power is the only way to bring down bills for good.
asserted
Breaking → say → bills
‘We’re giving families struggling with energy bills some breathing space this winter.
asserted
We → give → space
‘We’re providing funding for the Scottish Government to replicate the £100 energy payment, on top of slashing VAT on electricity bills.
asserted
Government → provide → bills
‘Those most in need will also get an extra £150 through the Warm Home Discount.’
asserted
Those → get → Discount
Dr John Constable of the Renewable Energy Foundation, the UK charity that first drew attention to constraint payments, said: 'These figures are not a sign that the lights are about to go out.
asserted
lights → draw → payments
They are a sign of an electricity system that is being kept secure at an extraordinary and rising cost, almost all of it resulting from grid bottlenecks: paying wind farms in Scotland to switch off and gas stations in England to switch on, all because generation was connected long before the network to carry it was built.
asserted
network → keep → it
'That was a bizarre policy choice, and consumers across Great Britain are now paying for the mistake.'
asserted
consumers → pay → mistake
He added: 'In my opinion, constraints are a commercial risk that developers should bear, and they should not be compensated by bill payers.'
asserted
they → add → payers
An SSEN Transmission spokesman said: 'These figures underline the urgent need to invest in the country’s electricity transmission network to unlock more homegrown renewable electricity, reduce costly constraints, and deliver a more secure and affordable energy system.
asserted
figures → say → system
We have a planned investment programme of £29billion in the north of Scotland transmission network, and as the recent National Audit Office report showed, the price to the consumer of not investing is greater than the cost of getting on with the job and delivering benefits for the communities we serve.'
asserted
we → have → communities