The Scene
Lumentum CEO Michael Hurlston knows shareholders hate his deal.
asserted
shareholders → know → deal
“It’s been a rough go,” he told Semafor in a Thursday interview.
asserted
he → tell → interview
He has a message for them: Bear with us.
asserted
He → have → us
Lumentum was looking to buy a chip company for months.
asserted
Lumentum → look → months
“We felt like we needed semiconductor properties, so we were actually in the market,” Hurlston said.
asserted
Hurlston → feel → market
“Marvell got word we were on a shopping spree and they said, ‘Hey, you know, rather than do that, why not combine with us?’”
asserted
you → get → us
Lumentum and Marvell agreed to a $115 billion all-stock deal earlier this month that tacks Hurlston’s optical tech business — a key part of the data center buildout that allows high-powered GPUs to actually get their data onto users’ screens — to Marvell’s chips businesses.
asserted
GPUs → agree → businesses
On paper, the deal made all the sense in the world, Hurlston said.
asserted
Hurlston → make → world
“If you accept the premise that we needed to have a semiconductor asset, Marvell is the best semiconductor [maker] in this area,” Hurlston said.
asserted
Hurlston → accept → area
Investors howled.
asserted
Investors → howl → ?
Shares in both Marvell and Lumentum are down roughly 40% since the deal was announced on worries over how much runway the AI trade has left.
asserted
trade → announce → runway
Some Lumentum shareholders also say the company sold too soon.
asserted
company → say → ?
“The deal hasn’t worked as we expected, right?” Hurlston said.
asserted
Hurlston → work → ?
“The view from investors is, you took some of your upside off the table, and you’ve now hitched your wagon to a company whose upside is a little bit less known.”
asserted
upside → take → company
Hurlston says he expects shares to rebound once the companies can share more information with analysts, portfolio managers, and other shareholders through regulatory filings and other meetings.
asserted
companies → say → filings
And while there’s still a chance the deal falls apart — there is a material adverse change clause baked into the deal terms — “we’re going to have to see this thing through, unless shareholders vote no, or if we don’t get regulatory approval,” Hurlston said.
asserted
Hurlston → ’ → approval
“The set of circumstances under which we can exercise a MAC are very limited.”
asserted
we → exercise → MAC
There is a bit of portfolio-manager-on-portfolio-manager violence going on, Hurlston noted.
asserted
Hurlston → be → violence
Despite overlap in the two company’s shareholder bases — 80%, by Hurlston’s math — portfolio managers may hold Marvell but not Lumentum, or vice versa, triggering some forced selling.
uncertain
managers → hold → selling
“The name of the game in hyperscaling, from a supplier, is continuity of supply and time to market,” Hurlston said.
asserted
Hurlston → say → market
“What this system-sell enables is for us to deliver to our customers massive time to market,” he continued, because Marvell and Lumentum products can be shipped out to data centers as one finished product.
asserted
products → enable → product
The companies will also face regulatory review in both the US and in China, which is likely to draw more scrutiny following the Nvidia chip scandal.
asserted
which → face → scandal
Hurlston noted that both he and Marvell CEO Matt Murphy have gotten deals through China’s State Authority on Market Regulation, or SAMR, before, and that they already have a good sense of what to expect.
asserted
they → note → what
“They really want their supply to be there, and we’re a critical supplier” of transistors into the Chinese market.
asserted
we → want → market
Semafor has also reported that Marvell’s Murphy could be tapped to take the CEO position at Nvidia following Jensen Huang’s resignation.
uncertain
Murphy → report → resignation
Hurlston said he didn’t know whether Murphy was considering the role or whether he would take it, but said, “I think he can do the job.”
asserted
he → say → job
“The board is not going to want somebody who has any sort of besmirchment, and I think you want to have somebody who’s been a sitting CEO,” he said.
asserted
he → go → somebody
“There’s no argument that this guy’s done a terrific job [at Marvell].”
asserted
guy → ’ → Marvell