When the U.S. Army blows up nearly five tons of unstable lead azide in southeastern Iowa on Friday, blanketing communities in lead-containing particles up to 100 miles away, it has a simple solution for concerned Iowans: Just rinse it off.
asserted
it → blow → it
“The good thing is, if people have concerns about it being on their property, all they have to do is hose that off, and it’s gone,” Army spokesperson Justine Barati told Radio Iowa earlier this week.
asserted
Barati → have → Iowa
This won’t be sufficient to mitigate the harm of the toxic plume the Army plans to release, environmental health experts based in Iowa told The Intercept.
asserted
experts → mitigate → Intercept
And, while the Army’s publicly released dispersion modeling shows that airborne lead particles could travel northeast from the detonation site near Burlington, Iowa, as far as Maquoketa, the experts found the Army’s modeling incomplete.
uncertain
modeling → release → Maquoketa
Because the Army’s plume modeling is a prediction based on anticipated weather conditions, changes in wind speed or direction could carry lead-containing particles into neighboring Illinois, even if the published projection does not show that path.
uncertain
projection → base → path
“They put out this plume model, which is basically a colored blob, so to speak, on a map,” said Patrick O’Shaughnessy, a professor of occupational and environmental health at the University of Iowa.
asserted
O’Shaughnessy → put → Iowa
“What they didn’t show was the projected or estimated concentration of settled dust within that plume.
asserted
show → show → plume
That settled dust will come from lead azide, a highly sensitive explosive commonly used in detonators.
asserted
dust → settle → detonators
The Army has been storing the material at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in a water-and-ethanol solution intended to keep it stable, but dangerous crystals formed during storage, according to an Army environmental assessment The Intercept found using the military’s Digital Visual Information Distribution System.
uncertain
Intercept → store → System
Army officials determined that the resulting instability made the material too hazardous to move or transport, leaving an in-place detonation as their best option for disposal.
asserted
material → determine → disposal
Now, the Army is warning residents and workers within the areas identified on its projected airborne exposure map to remain indoors, close windows and doors, and adjust air conditioning systems to prevent outside air from entering their homes “until the plume passes.”
asserted
plume → warn → homes
Children and pregnant individuals are among those specifically warned to avoid outdoor exposure.
asserted
Children → warn → exposure
O’Shaughnessy said the airborne plume could dissipate within hours, potentially ending the immediate inhalation hazard by Friday evening.
uncertain
plume → say → evening
But residents may not know how long they need to take precautions.
uncertain
they → know → precautions
“Should I stay indoors all weekend?
asserted
I → stay → ?
You know, the public doesn’t know, and no fault of theirs,” he said.
asserted
he → know → theirs
The Army environmental assessment shows that military officials considered several alternatives to Friday’s detonation, including chemically neutralizing the explosives or transporting them to an existing demolition facility, both of which were rejected as too dangerous.
asserted
both → show → which
The Army also warned that leaving the explosives in storage could leave them to blow up by accident — and indefinitely disrupt the installation’s ability to make new ammunition.
uncertain
leaving → warn → ammunition
The assessment does not establish how long the explosives had been stored, whether their deterioration was detected before March, or whether earlier intervention could have prevented them from becoming too dangerous to handle.
uncertain
intervention → establish → them
The Environmental Protection Agency, which issued an emergency permit authorizing the detonation, said the risk of an accidental explosion presented an “imminent and substantial threat to human health and the environment.”
asserted
risk → issue → health
“The Army, which has unparalleled expertise in matters concerning explosives safety, concluded that this material cannot safely be handled or moved and therefore, cannot be treated by any method other than in-place detonation,” an EPA spokesperson told The Intercept.
asserted
spokesperson → have → Intercept
The permit requires the Army to notify potentially affected communities, conduct environmental sampling before and after the detonation, clean up contaminated areas, and report its findings to the EPA.
asserted
permit → require → EPA
At the University of Iowa, which is 60 miles away and not in the predicted pathway, researchers hadn’t gotten details about how that monitoring would be conducted, O’Shaughnessy said.
asserted
O’Shaughnessy → predict → details
“We don’t know where it’s going to be conducted.
asserted
it → know → ?
We don’t know what instrumentation they’re going to use or how they’re going to report the information,” he said.
asserted
he → know → information
Researchers there are preparing to assess the consequences independently, including by measuring potential lead contamination and conducting their own plume modeling.
asserted
Researchers → prepare → modeling
The Army’s environmental assessment also acknowledges that contaminants from the detonation could enter waterways through stormwater runoff or seep into groundwater.
uncertain
contaminants → acknowledge → groundwater
It’s clear, said Peter S. Thorne, professor emeritus of occupational and environmental health at the University of Iowa, that washing away lead dust would not eliminate the contamination.
asserted
washing → ’ → contamination
“Hosing lead dust off of cars and other surfaces will indeed move it to the soil or into surface water,” he told The Intercept.
asserted
he → hose → Intercept
“This could lead to human and animal exposure beyond inhalation of the generated lead dust plume.”
uncertain
This → lead → plume
Asked what scientific evidence supported the advice to hose lead dust off residential property, the Army did not provide any studies or technical analysis.
asserted
Army → ask → studies
Instead, it said the EPA had provided cleanup guidelines as a condition of the emergency permit.
asserted
EPA → say → permit
In an environmental handout prepared for an Oct. 15 community open house, the Army acknowledged that the detonation could damage nearby homes and contaminate surrounding property.
uncertain
detonation → prepare → property
The military said it would conduct environmental sampling on private property with homeowners’ permission and clean up lead contamination exceeding regulatory thresholds.
asserted
it → say → thresholds
It also acknowledged that cleanup operations could temporarily disrupt agricultural leases.
uncertain
operations → acknowledge → leases
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has found that no safe blood lead level in children has been identified.
asserted
level → find → children
Even low levels of exposure can harm children’s brain development and ability to learn.
asserted
levels → harm → development
Asked what concentrations of airborne lead it expected in surrounding communities, the Army did not provide specific projections.
asserted
Army → ask → projections
Instead, it pointed to naturally occurring lead in soil and contamination associated with leaded gasoline, lead-based paint, and hazardous waste sites.
asserted
it → point → gasoline
Asked about plans to monitor potential long-term health effects, Barati, the Army spokesperson, said only: “We do not anticipate long-term health impacts.”
asserted
We → ask → impacts
…and 15 more, not listed.