Three educators who were reported to the state for alleged misconduct were allowed to keep working — and to draw new complaints — until they were criminally charged.
asserted
they → report → complaints
One was reported for allegedly touching children inappropriately in 2019.
uncertain
One → report → 2019
California didn’t suspend his credentials until his 2024 arrest.
asserted
California → suspend → arrest
California’s educator licensing agency provides no guidelines to the volunteers who review teacher misconduct cases for determining when and how to mete out punishment.
asserted
who → provide → punishment
Five years before police arrested former elementary school counselor David Braff for allegedly sexually abusing students, complaints had already been sent to the state of California: that Braff had sat students on his lap, rubbed their legs and touched them near their vaginas.
uncertain
Braff → arrest → vaginas
But California’s educator licensing agency failed to conduct a thorough investigation after his school district reported Braff to the state in 2019.
asserted
district → fail → 2019
And the agency allowed Braff to continue working with children.
asserted
Braff → allow → children
It wasn’t until his 2024 arrest that the agency suspended his credentials.
asserted
agency → suspend → credentials
By then, he’d gotten jobs at three more Southern California schools.
asserted
he → get → schools
At one of them, prosecutors allege, another student complained the guidance counselor had touched him, too.
asserted
counselor → allege → him
The state Commission on Teacher Credentialing also delayed revoking the credentials of two other teachers who were later convicted of sexually abusing students.
asserted
who → delay → students
As with Braff, schools had reported those educators to the agency that determines who can work in California’s public schools.
asserted
who → report → schools
And as with Braff, the commission allowed those teachers to keep teaching — and draw new complaints — until after they were criminally charged, an investigation by KQED and ProPublica found.
asserted
investigation → allow → KQED
That includes a middle school math teacher who sent his student a video showing a boy’s genitals and an elementary teacher who touched students’ butts and vaginal areas and placed their hands on his crotch, according to court records.
uncertain
who → include → records
In each of the cases, state investigators did not interview some of the students who had alleged abuse, according to the students, parents and attorneys who spoke to KQED and ProPublica.
uncertain
who → interview → KQED
Several former agency staffers, including investigators, told the news outlets that, at times, the volunteer panel tasked with assessing teacher accusations overlooked evidence of wrongdoing.
asserted
panel → include → wrongdoing
That perspective from staff members was backed up by two former members of the panel and two people who served on the state commission that ultimately decides teacher discipline.
asserted
that → back → discipline
After police arrested Braff in 2024, a parent emailed Jeffrey Weinstein, superintendent at Santa Paula Unified School District, where Braff was first accused of sexually abusing students.
asserted
Braff → arrest → students
“Who dropped the ball and allowed this monster to still be around kids?” the parent wrote, according to public records obtained by the news outlets.
uncertain
parent → drop → outlets
(Weinstein was not working at Santa Paula at the time students accused Braff.)
asserted
students → work → Braff
In his emailed response, Weinstein blamed the state’s teacher licensing agency.
asserted
Weinstein → email → agency
He told the parent that the district had conducted its own investigation and reported the guidance counselor to the state as well as to police.
asserted
district → tell → police
He also said he had reviewed the district’s investigative file and “vehemently disagreed” with the agency’s decision not to revoke Braff’s credentials.
asserted
he → say → credentials
“We sent all the evidence we had gathered,” Weinstein said.
asserted
Weinstein → send → evidence
“The district did everything in its legal capacity it could.”
uncertain
it → do → capacity
Braff is soon to stand trial for sexually abusing 15 students, including 13 from Santa Paula.
asserted
Braff → stand → Paula
He has pleaded not guilty and did not respond to a request for comment sent through the Ventura County Sheriff’s Office’s electronic messaging system.
asserted
He → plead → system
His attorney declined to comment.
asserted
attorney → decline → ?
Braff had previously told Santa Paula Unified administrators that he did not touch students near their private parts or have them sit on his lap — and that he only gave students side hugs, high-fives, fist bumps and taps on the knee, according to the district’s 2019 report to the state.
uncertain
he → tell → state
“Mr. Braff described keeping an office environment where kids can move around; and he would not be closer than arm’s length,” the report said, summarizing the district’s interview with Braff.
asserted
report → describe → Braff
“It was not his intent to make them afraid but rather feel that there was someone in their corner; someone to talk to.”
asserted
them → make → corner
Anita Fitzhugh, a spokesperson for the Commission on Teacher Credentialing, said the state automatically revokes teachers’ credentials when they are convicted of sexual criminal offenses.
asserted
they → say → offenses
But she wrote in a statement that “unless the applicant or educator is convicted of a mandatory criminal offense, there are no written criteria that set the level of adverse action for educator discipline matters.”
asserted
that → write → matters
She did not answer questions about specific cases or details of the investigative process.
asserted
She → answer → process
Fitzhugh said the state does not provide any guidelines for those reviewing teacher misconduct cases about when discipline is warranted or the type of punishment that should be meted out.
asserted
that → say → punishment
And she said it was the commission’s role to balance “protecting students as well as the legal rights of educators who have been accused but not convicted.”
California’s system of disciplining educators dates to the 1970s, Fitzhugh said, and “a deep and comprehensive review of the educator discipline system, prioritizing student safety in the schools, is in order.”
“We expect the Commission to take this up in the near future,” she said.
asserted
she → say → future
In the summer of 2019, California’s Commission on Teacher Credentialing received a detailed report from the Santa Paula school district about Braff’s alleged misconduct at McKevett Elementary School.
asserted
Commission → receive → School
The state requires districts to report educators when they resign or are fired after allegations of misconduct.
asserted
they → require → misconduct
Braff, who had been a guidance counselor at the school for four years, had resigned in the midst of the district’s investigation into complaints by at least seven students that he had touched them inappropriately.
asserted
he → resign → them
The district told the state agency that it had contemplated but did not initiate any discipline against Braff before accepting his resignation.
asserted
it → tell → resignation
…and 139 more, not listed.