Not much can rouse Holyrood’s seat-warmers to something approaching interest but the NHS Grampian scandal is doing so.
asserted
scandal → rouse → something
MSPs across all parties are raising the issue, which dominated FMQs.
asserted
which → raise → FMQs
A few hours after the publication of a shock report revealing 19 avoidable deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI), Labour’s Michael Marra was leading the charge.
asserted
Marra → reveal → charge
Paramount for him was the case of Dr Habib, an ARI clinician who had ‘put his career on the line’ bringing the scandal to light.
asserted
who → put → light
With practised solemnity, the First Minister shared his ‘deepest concern’ but maintained ‘the standard of care is paramount in the NHS’.
asserted
standard → practise → NHS
If this is what paramount care looks like, may patients never experience neglect.
uncertain
patients → look → neglect
NHS Grampian had to ‘undertake very significant improvement’.
asserted
Grampian → have → improvement
Not killing quite so many of its patients would be a good start.
asserted
killing → kill → patients
The conspiracy of silence extended far beyond a hospital or health board.
asserted
conspiracy → extend → hospital
Dr Mohammed Habib said he made repeated warnings about ‘dozens’ of avoidable deaths to bosses
Dr Mohammed Habib works as a surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary
Mr Marra documented how the whistleblowing doctor had written directly to Swinney – three times – imploring his intervention, but to no effect.
Mr Marra found this unfathomable.
asserted
this → say → effect
The death rate at the ARI was six times what it ought to have been but at no point did Swinney alert the public.
asserted
Swinney → alert → public
‘Families were not told.
asserted
Families → tell → ?
The public was not told.
asserted
public → tell → ?
But the First Minister was told,’ Mr Marra lamented, before coming to the pivotal question: ‘Who decided to bury evidence?’
asserted
Who → tell → evidence
Of course the First Minister was never going to fess up names.
asserted
Minister → go → names
If candour evaded him then, it was hardly about to seize him now, and so we were treated to his familiar performance as a man terribly concerned at this news and, you may rest assured, committed to getting to the bottom of it.
uncertain
you → evade → it
Except he’s not just a man, he’s the First Minister.
asserted
he → ’ → ?
It’s his gaff.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
He calls the shots.
asserted
He → call → shots
In theory, he’s meant to take responsibility when things go wrong.
asserted
things → mean → responsibility
But he wants to contain the scandal to a poorly run health board, and for very good reason: what lies at the bottom of all this is him and his government.
asserted
lies → want → this
The SNP’s two-decade-long mismanagement of the NHS comes with consequences, 19 of them at the Aberdeen Royal Infirmary alone.
asserted
mismanagement → come → Infirmary
While Swinney pleaded for everyone to recognise there had been leadership changes at the board, Marra urged something a little more robust.
asserted
Marra → plead → something
‘The permanent secretary must commission an immediate review into who knew what and when,’ the Labour leader intoned, adding that the Lord Advocate should also consider criminal investigations.
asserted
Advocate → commission → investigations
Russell Findlay ploughed a similar furrow to Mr Marra, albeit his manner was more personal.
asserted
manner → plough → Marra
‘If John Swinney required surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary tomorrow, would he have any concerns?’
asserted
he → require → concerns
First Minister John Swinney maintained ‘the standard of care is paramount in the NHS’
asserted
standard → maintain → NHS
Russell Findlay attacked the SNP over the revelations
Swinney claimed he wouldn’t because clinical professionals deserved our confidence.
asserted
professionals → attack → confidence
That’s easy to say when you have a job title that guarantees you first-class treatment from every public service you come into contact with.
asserted
you → ’ → contact
Mr Findlay got to the heart of the matter: ‘This rotten culture has been imposed by this rotten SNP government.’
asserted
culture → get → government
Malcolm Offord turned his attention instead to homelessness and joblessness among young Scots.
asserted
Offord → turn → Scots
After the SNP pledge of ‘no one left behind’ in the labour market, the number of youngsters out of work had doubled to 55,000.
asserted
number → leave → 55,000
If the Scottish Government simply did nothing it would do less damage.
asserted
it → do → damage
Mr Offord queried what, with youths under such pressure to secure work, Swinney made of Andy Burnham’s plans to allow 100,000 young European ‘outsiders’ to come and work in Britain under a new EU deal.
asserted
outsiders → query → deal
The First Minister got on his high horse about Reform’s ‘divisive rhetoric’.
asserted
Minister → get → rhetoric
There is an effort at Holyrood to portray as intolerable bigotry any attempt by Reform to raise issues the establishment parties would rather not confront.
asserted
parties → be → issues
The parliament is their little echo chamber and they won’t have Reform spoiling it by bringing in dissonant voices.
asserted
Reform → have → voices
It’s bad enough that they must beg the voters for their right to sit in this place without also having to listen to their squalid, hateful opinions come out of the mouths of Reform MSPs.
asserted
opinions → ’ → MSPs
Refusing to listen, let alone act, when told things they would rather not hear was a theme at FMQs.
asserted
they → refuse → FMQs