The Lord Speaker has sounded the alarm over plans to spend up to £40billion on a Star Trek-style overhaul of Parliament.
asserted
Speaker → sound → Parliament
Lord Forsyth of Drumlean has questioned the options being laid before MPs and peers as a crunch vote looms within weeks.
asserted
vote → question → weeks
In a letter to members, he warned that politicians were being asked to sign off billions of pounds of initial spending without knowing the 'scope, affordability and consequences'.
asserted
politicians → warn → scope
Lord Forsyth argued that the proposals need to be fundamentally rethought, stressing the 'exceptionally difficult choices over public expenditure' currently facing the country.
A 'costed options' report published by the authorities in February laid out two options for politicians to choose between.
asserted
politicians → argue → options
One would see MPs move out of Parliament entirely for eight to 10 years and peers for up to 15 years - which could hit taxpayers for £15.6billion.
uncertain
which → see → 15.6billion
Lord Forsyth of Drumlean has questioned the options being laid before MPs and peers as a crunch vote looms within weeks
The plans for Parliament could see a striking area created underneath Central Lobby
A glass-roofed visitor's entrance could be constructed next to the Houses, the report said
Another would involve MPs staying on the historic site, but peers relocated to a nearby building such as the QE2 conference centre - which would be fitted out with facilities such as catering outlets and a library.
uncertain
which → question → outlets
That would take 38 to 61 years to complete and cost up to £39.2billion, according to the report.
uncertain
That → take → report
A vote expected next month will see MPs and peers asked to agree to 'initial' works at the Houses of Parliament lasting seven years, at a cost of up to £3billion.
asserted
MPs → expect → 3billion
They would then decide in the mid-2030s which of the two recommended options to pursue.
asserted
They → decide → options
Senior MPs have voiced doubts that the decision would in reality happen by then, given Parliament's previous delays on the issue.
asserted
decision → voice → issue
Wrangling over what to do about the Westminster estate - which critics regard as a mouse-infested fire risk blighted by power cuts and heating failures - has been going on for decades.
asserted
critics → wrangle → decades
Striking designs for how the crumbling buildings at the heart of British democracy could look were published in the report.
uncertain
buildings → crumble → report
The depicted spacious underground atriums with glassy ceilings, and plush new courtyards for MPs to 'meet constituents'.
asserted
MPs → depict → constituents
Lord Forsyth, who was a Tory before being elected as Lord Speaker, said in his letter that there is 'no doubt that the Palace needs substantial restoration'.
But he queried whether the proposals, which predate his time in the chair, 'distinguished essential restoration from improvements that could be deferred or undertaken separately'.
uncertain
that → elect → improvements
Lord Forsyth pointed out that since the report there had been delays to the Northern Estate project that could in the 'worst case' add seven years to the full decant option timescale.
uncertain
that → point → timescale
He contrasted the plans with the overhaul of Buckingham Palace, which took 10 years and cost £400million.
asserted
which → contrast → 400million
Solely the cost of converting the QEII conference centre to house peers temporarily is estimated to be more than £400million.
asserted
cost → convert → peers
Lord Forsyth asked: 'Should we be prepared to reconsider the parliamentary calendar?
asserted
we → ask → calendar
Could more extensive use be made of recesses for major works?
uncertain
use → make → works
'Is a September sitting essential if a different arrangement would enable significant restoration work to be completed more quickly, efficiently and at less cost?
asserted
work → enable → cost
'Is it responsible to regard the parliamentary timetable as entirely inflexible when considering a programme of this magnitude?
'Are the costs of more than £400 million converting the QEII Conference Centre as accommodation for the Lords justified and are the arrangements practical?
asserted
arrangements → regard → Lords
'How would State Openings of Parliament and other important ceremonies be conducted?'
asserted
Openings → conduct → Parliament
Lord Forsyth went on: 'It would be wrong to suggest that essential work should be delayed.
asserted
work → go → ?
But there is an important distinction between proceeding with necessary safety and conservation work and committing billions of pounds to a programme whose scope, affordability and consequences have yet to be agreed.
asserted
scope → be → programme
The question before Parliament is not whether earlier decisions were justified when they were taken, but whether they remain the right decisions today.
asserted
they → justify → Parliament
At a time when the country faces exceptionally difficult choices over public expenditure, Parliament must be able to demonstrate that it has subjected expenditure on its own buildings to the most rigorous scrutiny.
asserted
it → face → scrutiny
I urge colleagues to read the Costed Proposals report and consider these issues carefully before the debate.
asserted
I → urge → debate
Wrangling over what to do about the Westminster estate - regarded by critics as a mouse-infested fire risk blighted by power cuts and heating failures - has been going on for decades
One option would see MPs move out of Parliament entirely for eight to 10 years and peers for up to 15 years - which could hit taxpayers for £15.6billion
'
uncertain
which → wrangle → 15.6billion
The Palace of Westminster is a national treasure which we have a duty to preserve.
asserted
we → have → duty
We also have a duty to ensure that the means chosen are necessary, affordable and properly accountable.'
asserted
means → have → duty
Kemi Badenoch has already launched a campaign for a 'fundamental rethink' of the restoration proposals.
asserted
Badenoch → launch → proposals
The Tory leader said taxpayers were being asked to bankroll turning the Palace of Westminster into a 'Net-Zero Dubai hotel'.
asserted
taxpayers → say → hotel
'This was meant to be essential works to keep a cherished, historic building safe and functioning.
asserted
This → mean → building
It has turned into a basket case white elephant project,' she said in February.
asserted
she → turn → February