As a retired solicitor, I applied my litigation experience to carefully read Cam Bancroft’s account of Sandpapergate, published in the Herald yesterday (“Alone, betrayed: time to tell the truth”, November 20).
asserted
I → apply → truth
I then sought to recall Pat Cummins’ words at his press conference on Friday 13.
asserted
I → seek → Friday
Many commentators have stated the two versions can’t stand together, but in my opinion, that’s not the case.
asserted
that → state → opinion
In his version, Cam speaks of players and coaches walking in and out of the change rooms while the sandpaper strategy was being discussed and of various persons offering their views.
asserted
persons → speak → views
But nowhere does Cam state specifically who said what, other than to make it clear that Dave Warner was a strong advocate of using sandpaper, while Steve Smith and Kate Hutchison wanted nothing to do with such a strategy.
asserted
Smith → state → strategy
Nowhere does Cam specify what was the actual participation of any of the bowlers in those discussions.
asserted
participation → specify → discussions
It’s therefore possible that some players agreed that heavy work on the ball was required, and it’s also possible that some players did not know that sandpaper was to be used.
asserted
sandpaper → ’ → ball
Cam also states that he asked the bowlers whether his work was effective in causing the ball to swing, but he does not say that he specifically asked whether his sandpapering work was being effective.
asserted
work → state → bowlers
For his part, at his press conference, Pat was very specific in stating that he did not know that sandpaper was being used or that sandpapering had been agreed as a master plan.
asserted
sandpapering → state → plan
That statement, while possibly suspicious in its carefully chosen specificity, can stand together with Cam’s version.
uncertain
statement → choose → version
Danny Sankey, North Willoughby
Mitchell Starc said he stood by a joint statement released in 2021 with fellow bowlers Cummins, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon denying they had “any knowledge that sandpaper had been taken onto the field in Cape Town to tamper with the ball” (” ‘Angry, betrayed and alone’: Who knew what in the Sandpapergate saga”, smh.com.au, November 20).
asserted
Who → say → smh.com.au
Fair enough – but that’s not the same as saying that they had no knowledge about sandpaper possibly being used to tamper with the ball.
uncertain
they → ’ → ball
I fully support Pat Cummins, until such time as Cricket Australia conducts a forensic investigation and interviews the entire travelling party to South Africa (“Backs against the wall”, November 20).
asserted
Australia → support → wall
The term “everybody knew” has been used too broadly.
asserted
everybody → know → ?
The Australian captain should be offered more support in the short term, the forum will not succeed in uncovering those who knew, those who genuinely did not know, and those who were aware but preferred to stay silent.
asserted
who → offer → those
Kate Hutchison’s words are telling in the sorry Sandpapergate saga (“Team staffer who spoke up against use of sandpaper”, November 20).
asserted
who → speak → sandpaper
“That being part of the team did not mean having to accept everything the team was doing.”
asserted
team → mean → everything
Vicky Marquis, North Sydney
Culprit needs to be fingered
In my teaching past, I witnessed a principal interviewing three students who were caught truanting from school.
asserted
who → need → school
The principal’s main interest was to determine which student made the first suggestion to leave the school premises.
asserted
student → determine → premises
In a similar vein, I feel it is important to put the Sandpapergate to rest by finding the culprit who first suggested using the sandpaper, and secondly determining who was sent out to procure said sandpaper.
uncertain
who → feel → sandpaper
We surely can’t consider the whole team to be condemned for the actions of a few.
asserted
team → consider → few
Eric Sekula, Turramurra
The cricket sandpaper saga rolls on.
asserted
saga → roll → ?
I was recently looking at the famous 1905 photograph by George Beldam of Victor Trumper jumping out to drive.
asserted
Trumper → look → Beldam
He has a small cap perched on his head, he does not seem to be wearing batting gloves and has flimsy pads.
asserted
he → have → pads
His bat looks like a matchstick.
asserted
bat → look → matchstick
Things have improved for the batsman, but for the bowler not much has changed.
asserted
much → improve → bowler
He (she) just has the ball.
asserted
He → have → ball
Is it therefore a surprise if the bowler tries to level the playing field?
asserted
bowler → try → field
Alan Templeman, Wyoming
I’m going to forgive the Herald for the awful bon mots in the last paragraph of today’s editorial: “Cricket Australia must pad up” and then that their “reputation will be reduced to ashes” (“No winners as scandal shocks cricket lovers”, November 20).
asserted
scandal → go → lovers
I forgive because I have a cricket-related bon mot of my own: the “cheating scandal” has been getting some Deep Extra Cover.
asserted
scandal → forgive → Cover
Tim Egan, Mosman
Just supposing that the little square of sandpaper was suddenly uncovered, how much would it be worth on the market?
asserted
it → suppose → market
In the 2005 Ashes series, English players used Murray Mints to doctor the ball to achieve reverse swing.
asserted
players → use → swing
The result: England won the series and numerous OBEs and MBEs were awarded to the coaches and players.
asserted
OBEs → win → coaches
Sunscreen and trouser zippers have also played a role in English cricket.
asserted
zippers → play → cricket
Meanwhile, in Australia, a small piece of sandpaper was used on a past South African tour and eight years later we’re beating ourselves up about it, and if the commentators are to be believed, the fallout threatens the future of Australian cricket.
asserted
fallout → use → cricket
I think a deep breath and some perspective are in order.
asserted
breath → think → order
Matthew Holle, Erskineville
The only way to eliminate this existential threat of Sandpapergate to the future of world cricket is to make the use of sandpaper mandatory.
asserted
use → eliminate → sandpaper
Neil Maclean, Bowral
Truth and ethics aside, how can vigorously employed cricketers drop a small sandpaper piece into their undies and expect it to stay put ’til needed?
asserted
it → employ → undies
Rosemary O’Brien, Ashfield
My wife complained bitterly this morning saying: “Why is the Herald so full of this rubbish about cricket?
asserted
Herald → complain → cricket
Who really cares?”
asserted
Who → care → ?
…and 61 more, not listed.