One of the biggest court battles over artificial intelligence (AI) is putting an age-old legal principle to the test – and raising important questions about the Trump administration's AI policy.
asserted
One → put → policy
Several news organizations, including The New York Times, are suing OpenAI and Microsoft for using millions of newspaper articles to train AI systems.
asserted
organizations → include → systems
The newspapers argue that the tech firms violated basic copyright protections.
asserted
firms → argue → protections
The tech firms contend that training their models on those articles qualifies as "fair use," a longstanding principle that allows copyrighted material to be used in certain ways without permission from or compensation to the copyright owner.
asserted
material → contend → owner
The Department of Justice (DOJ) has sided squarely with OpenAI's position – breaking with the administration's previously more balanced stance on the issue.
asserted
Department → side → issue
The DOJ filed a statement of interest embracing an extreme vision of fair use that would grant AI companies virtually unfettered access to copyrighted material for commercial training, without obtaining permission from or compensating the creators whose works fuel these systems.
asserted
works → file → systems
This expansive interpretation threatens to turn a narrow copyright exception into a blanket exemption for the world's most powerful and profitable industries.
asserted
interpretation → threaten → industries
The DOJ's reasoning is that requiring a copyright license for material used in AI training would impose high costs on AI developers.
asserted
requiring → require → developers
It claims those costs could make it harder for small companies to compete and hamper U.S. AI leadership and national security.
uncertain
companies → claim → leadership
Those concerns deserve consideration.
asserted
concerns → deserve → consideration
But the DOJ's aggressive arguments in the brief depart from more measured guidance elsewhere in the administration.
asserted
arguments → depart → administration
The White House's official AI framework acknowledges valid arguments on both sides of the copyright debate.
asserted
framework → acknowledge → debate
Likewise, the Carolina Principles for Emerging Technologies, adopted by G20 ministers at the Commerce Department's recent Innovation Ministerial, recognize that the intersection of AI and copyright poses "complex legal and policy questions."
asserted
intersection → adopt → questions
The principles note the "essential role" of copyright protections in supporting creators and call for respecting IP as a pillar of G20 AI policy.
asserted
principles → note → policy
The DOJ statement also overlooks how its stance could favor larger AI companies over smaller firms and startups.
uncertain
stance → overlook → firms
Several AI startups have argued that paying for the material they use provides more reliable access to training material, reduces legal uncertainty, and improves models.
asserted
they → argue → models
Other companies have emerged to aggregate copyrights and make licensing easier.
asserted
licensing → emerge → copyrights
It's particularly problematic for large AI companies to complain about paying for access to copyrighted materials.
asserted
companies → complain → materials
They are among the best positioned to pay for those materials, and doing so would help develop the kind of licensing markets they claim are lacking.
uncertain
they → position → markets
And even if national security were a legitimate justification, the government could not simply disregard property rights.
uncertain
government → disregard → rights
The Constitution and other laws require just compensation when private property is taken for public use, and intellectual property rights are still property rights.
asserted
rights → require → use
Letting AI firms appropriate creators' IP without permission or compensation would be akin to letting data center builders seize private land without paying fair value.
asserted
builders → let → value
If courts adopt the DOJ's position that fair use protects AI developers in virtually all circumstances, it would reduce incentives to create new works.
asserted
it → adopt → works
Copyrights encourage creative work by assuring writers, artists and other creators that their work can't be easily stolen or copied.
asserted
work → encourage → writers
Licensing those rights allows creators to earn a living and underpins over $1 trillion in U.S. economic activity.
asserted
creators → license → activity
Weaker copyrights could result in fewer human-created books, articles, research papers, films and songs.
uncertain
copyrights → result → books
Ironically, that could eventually leave AI systems with fewer and lower-quality materials to train on – a scenario that serves no one's interests.
uncertain
that → leave → interests
All of this is why the Trump administration would be wise to follow its own AI framework and let the court system evaluate AI copyright disputes case by case, rather than arguing for unfettered fair use exceptions.
asserted
system → follow → exceptions
The DOJ's reasoning is that requiring a copyright license for material used in AI training would impose high costs on AI developers.
asserted
requiring → require → developers
It claims those costs could make it harder for small companies to compete and hamper U.S. AI leadership and national security.
uncertain
companies → claim → leadership
Policymakers also have a role to play.
asserted
Policymakers → have → role
Introduced in February by California Democrat Sen. Adam Schiff and Utah Republican Sen. John Curtis, the CLEAR Act would require AI developers to publicly disclose the copyrighted works used in each new generative-AI model's training dataset.
asserted
Act → introduce → dataset
The proposal would not settle whether any particular training practice qualifies as fair use.
asserted
practice → settle → use
But it would give creators more information about whether their work helped train an AI system, enabling them to pursue appropriate compensation or other remedies when they believe their rights have been violated.
asserted
rights → give → compensation
That kind of targeted reform offers a useful model for copyright enforcement in the age of AI.
asserted
kind → target → AI
Rather than treating licensing as an obstacle to innovation, policymakers should foster a market where AI developers can efficiently license copyrighted material while respecting creators' rights.
asserted
developers → treat → rights
But America's creative industries still depend on strong copyright protections.
asserted
industries → depend → protections
Policymakers need to promote both.
asserted
Policymakers → need → both