New York City unveils a bold plan to move its jails off Rikers Island
New York City officials on Friday unveiled their plan to close the troubled jail complex on Rikers Island, the city's main pre-trial detention center, which has been plagued with reports of abuse and neglect for decades.
asserted
which → unveil → decades
"It is long past time to close what's been a moral stain on our city," Mayor Zohran Mamdani told NPR.
asserted
Mamdani → close → NPR
"We cannot simply accept the old approaches to public safety just because they've always been done that way."
asserted
they → accept → safety
Rikers, which sits on a former garbage dump in the East River, has long been infamous for its dismal conditions – including crumbling infrastructure.
asserted
which → sit → infrastructure
Inmates have accused guards of excessive force, sexual assault and high rates of violence in multiple lawsuits.
asserted
Inmates → accuse → lawsuits
Last year, a federal judge called the amount of violence at Rikers an "unconstitutional danger" for both the people held there and the staff.
asserted
judge → call → people
Since 2022, more than 50 people have died in the custody of the New York City Department of Correction.
asserted
people → die → Correction
Almost all had been held at Rikers.
asserted
all → hold → Rikers
People have been found unresponsive.
asserted
People → find → ?
They have died by suicide and been beaten to death.
asserted
They → die → death
Federal court records say Rikers is "significantly more violent" than comparable jails.
asserted
Rikers → say → jails
But now, city officials say they finally have momentum to close the jail for good, and the newly released plan details how they intend to do that.
asserted
they → say → that
The plan — which takes on both the conditions inside the jails and the size of the population behind bars — is ambitious.
asserted
which → take → bars
It seeks to transform how the city government thinks about crime prevention and safety overall, says Insha Rahman, president of the Vera Institute of Justice, a criminal justice reform nonprofit.
asserted
Rahman → seek → Justice
"If New York City can do this at scale, which it will, it is encouragement for places like LA, like Chicago, like Philadelphia, like Houston to do the same," Rahman says.
asserted
Rahman → do → same
A goal set by the city years ago
In 2019, the New York City Council approved a plan to close Rikers by 2027, and to build in its place four smaller jails in Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens and the Bronx.
asserted
Council → set → Brooklyn
The borough-based jails will be closer to the courts and to public transit, making it easier for families, lawyers and service providers to visit people inside the facilities.
asserted
families → base → facilities
Since 2019, not a lot of progress has been made toward closing Rikers.
asserted
lot → make → Rikers
City officials acknowledge they won't make the 2027 deadline.
asserted
they → acknowledge → deadline
But Mamdani says the city is in a new moment.
asserted
city → say → moment
"We're not the first administration to talk about this.
asserted
We → talk → this
We also know that the last administration had no interest in advancing this," Mamdani told NPR.
asserted
Mamdani → know → NPR
"And we are also confident that we can be the first administration to deliver on it."
asserted
we → deliver → it
Earlier this year, he appointed a "Close Rikers Czar" dedicated to closing the jail and reducing the jail population.
asserted
he → appoint → population
The mayor also appointed Stanley Richards as commissioner of the DOC, the first formerly incarcerated person to lead the department.
asserted
mayor → appoint → department
Mamdani says his administration has already taken concrete steps: The city revived plans for a housing initiative for New Yorkers released from jail with medical needs, for instance, and it opened a therapeutic housing unit at a public hospital in Manhattan.
'Human dignity at the center of incarceration'
asserted
it → say → incarceration
Last year, a federal judge stripped the city of its authority over Rikers.
asserted
judge → strip → Rikers
Operations are now controlled by a remediation manager, who released his own initial plan earlier this year for bringing the jail system into legal compliance, independent of the city's plan.
asserted
who → control → plan
Aspects of that plan took inspiration from carceral systems in Europe, a growing trend among correctional leaders across the U.S. The remediation manager, Nicholas Deml, traveled with Commissioner Richards to Germany earlier this year on a trip organized by the Vera Institute.
asserted
manager → take → Institute
There, they observed the country's prisons and jails, which are often regarded as an international model.
asserted
which → observe → model
"While German correctional systems are not directly transferable to New York, they reflect a fundamentally different orientation — one that places human dignity at the center of incarceration," Deml wrote in his plan.
asserted
Deml → reflect → plan
Last month, the Vera Institute took a second group of New Yorkers to Germany to see how jails can look when they're done right, including the Moabit jail in Berlin.
asserted
they → take → Berlin
Each member of that group had a part to play in reimagining New York City's criminal justice system: a prosecutor, a judge, a city councilmember, the chief who supervises officers at Rikers, among others.
asserted
who → have → others
At first glance, the group observed, Moabit looked like a lot of jails in the U.S., but key differences emerged on closer inspection.
asserted
differences → observe → inspection
The cells had windows to the outside.
asserted
cells → have → outside
In some of them, a door inside connected it to the adjacent cell.
asserted
door → connect → cell
"Some people are afraid of the first night here, and sometimes it really helps just to open the door to have someone to talk to," Katharina Spanaus, a staff member at Moabit, told the group.
asserted
Spanaus → help → group
"I'll never forget the cigarette vending machine," says Christopher Watler, who was recently appointed chair of the New York City Board of Correction, which oversees the city's jail system.
asserted
which → forget → system
What struck him wasn't really the cigarettes, but what the gesture communicates about treating people as human, Watler says.
asserted
Watler → strike → people
It also showed him how far New York City has to go.
asserted
City → show → him
…and 57 more, not listed.