When a judge took the rare step of granting Duan Julien bail on a murder charge, she declared:
“It could well be the case that at the end of the trial, Mr. Julien will be determined to have merely been present when a crime was committed by someone else.”
uncertain
crime → take → someone
It took a jury about six hours to agree.
asserted
It → take → hours
Late last month — more than three years after Julien’s arrest — the 28-year-old man stood in a virtually empty courtroom with a few family members and just one reporter present.
asserted
man → stand → members
Defence lawyers Monte MacGregor and Amanda Warth were visibly shaking.
asserted
MacGregor → shake → ?
The jury foreperson stood and declared Julien not guilty in the shooting death of his former friend, 24-year-old Munawar Warsama.
asserted
Julien → stand → friend
MacGregor let out a loud “Yes!”
asserted
MacGregor → let → ?
And then he and Warth left court with their client — a free man.
asserted
he → leave → client
What they took with them out of that courtroom was a question: How did the case of a “completely innocent” man get to this point in the first place?
asserted
man → take → place
It’s not unusual for a Toronto murder trial to begin and end without outside attention.
asserted
trial → ’ → attention
And acquittals do happen.
asserted
acquittals → happen → ?
Instead, the prosecution came down to one action by the accused, captured in a few frames of grainy video: an attempted kick.
asserted
prosecution → come → video
Preamble to a shooting
It was April 14, 2023, and Julien was out near Bloor Street West and Ossington Avenue with two close friends — Deniell McKenzie Clark and Matthew Phillips-Downey — and Daniel Lara-Orellana, a friend of Phillips-Downey’s who Julien described as an acquaintance.
asserted
Julien → describe → acquaintance
They were looking to buy some marijuana before they went their separate ways.
asserted
they → look → ways
Approaching a dispensary, Julien was beckoned across the street by someone on a scooter he soon recognized to be his former friend, Munawar Warsama.
asserted
he → approach → scooter
They had known each other for years, but the friendship had “fizzled out” during the pandemic.
asserted
friendship → know → pandemic
Julien testified he had learned Warsama had been spreading a rumour that he’d fled the scene after a friend of theirs got stabbed during a robbery while the three of them were downtown ringing in the new year in 2019.
asserted
three → testify → 2019
In response to the rumours, Julien said he had told people the truth — it was Warsama who had fled, while Julien himself had also been stabbed.
asserted
Julien → say → truth
That night outside the dispensary, Julien said, Warsama tried to confront him.
asserted
Warsama → say → him
“I was calling him a bitch, and he was calling me a bitch,” Julien testified.
asserted
Julien → call → me
But he insisted this dispute was “not important at all” to him, and that he kept telling Warsama to leave him alone.
asserted
he → insist → him
In one of several surveillance footage clips showing Julien walking away from Warsama, he appears frustrated before entering the dispensary with the three others, while Warsama waits outside.
asserted
Warsama → show → others
Inside, the group can be seen laughing and fist-bumping employees.
asserted
group → see → employees
Crown attorney Anna Tenhouse contended at trial that this footage showed Julien was readying himself for a fight.
asserted
Julien → contend → fight
Pointing to one frame, she suggested to him in cross-examination: “You kept raising your shirt in aggression.”
uncertain
You → point → aggression
Julien replied: “I was hot.”
asserted
I → reply → ?
When the four emerge, they walk in the opposite direction of Warsama, but he follows them on his scooter.
asserted
he → emerge → scooter
Julien testified Warsama followed him to his car and suggested they take it to a nearby alley.
uncertain
they → testify → alley
“At this point, I feel like if this is the only way to get you to leave me alone, let’s go fight,” Julien told the jury.
asserted
Julien → feel → jury
Surveillance footage shows Warsama and Julien — about six-foot-two and five-eight respectively — heading into the dark alleyway, followed by the other three.
asserted
Warsama → show → three
Julien set down his belongings: a phone, hat, car keys and a ring.
asserted
Julien → set → belongings
“He’s bigger than me,” Julien testified.
asserted
Julien → ’ → me
“It was a fight I was going to lose.”
asserted
I → go → ?
The murder of Munawar Warsama
The entire fight is not captured on camera.
asserted
fight → capture → camera
Julien testified he was unable to land a blow before Warsama left the alley — leaving Julien to think the fight was over — only to return with a weapon.
asserted
fight → testify → weapon
It was described in court as a garden lamp retrieved from the lawn of a nearby home.
asserted
It → describe → home
There was no dispute that the light component fell off at some point in the next few moments, leaving only a black stake.
asserted
component → be → stake
The centrepiece of the Crown’s evidence was an eight-second cellphone video of what happened next, filmed by a woman visiting from France between the blinds of a window overlooking the alley.
asserted
what → happen → alley
The video was repeatedly played in court, frame by frame.
asserted
video → play → frame
Warsama’s family stepped out to avoid having to watch it over and over again.
asserted
family → step → it
In it, Warsama charges past Julien and heads directly for Lara-Orellana, who shoots him.
asserted
who → charge → him
…and 122 more, not listed.