United States President Donald Trump knocked repeatedly at Pyongyang’s door this week for a meeting with Kim Jong Un, but the North Korean leader was out at a ski resort, a sacred mountain and then a naval university.
asserted
leader → knock → resort
Trump finally left Asia late on Thursday after a landmark trilateral with China and Russia’s presidents, but without a meeting with Kim.
asserted
Trump → leave → Kim
AFP looks at what the missed encounter means:
asserted
encounter → look → what
Roles reversed
asserted
Roles → reverse → ?
Trump met Kim three times during his first White House term.
asserted
Trump → meet → term
Their previous summits, including in Hanoi in 2019, aimed to curb Pyongyang’s nuclear programme but failed to produce a deal.
asserted
summits → include → deal
Kim left Hanoi empty-handed after the talks collapsed, making a 60-hour train journey home.
asserted
talks → leave → journey
Since Trump’s return to the White House, the US leader has repeatedly floated a new meeting with Kim.
asserted
leader → float → Kim
Trump reached out to Pyongyang ahead of his Asia tour last year, even describing North Korea as “sort of a nuclear power”, but received no response.
asserted
Trump → reach → response
In March, South Korea’s then-prime minister Kim Min-seok said that Trump thought a meeting with Kim would be “good”.
asserted
meeting → say → Kim
Trump raised the prospect of another meeting as he travelled to Asia this week for several summits, but Kim remained silent.
asserted
Kim → raise → summits
The US leader later suggested that he was too busy to fit it in.
uncertain
he → suggest → it
“The relationship is there, but we didn’t meet,” Trump said on Thursday, according to NBC News reporter Gabe Gutierrez, who said he spoke with the president as they were flying back to Washington from Asia.
uncertain
they → meet → Asia
“There was too many meetings,” Trump said, according to Gutierrez.
uncertain
Trump → be → Gutierrez
“It wouldn’t have worked out.”
asserted
It → work → ?
Trump added: “We’ll have that meeting at some point.”
asserted
We → add → point
Was he overbooked?
asserted
he → overbooke → ?
Although Trump said this week that Kim “would like to” meet, experts voiced doubts over the claim.
uncertain
experts → say → claim
“I am sceptical that any concrete behind-the-scenes contacts took place” between Pyongyang and Washington, Lim Eul-chul, a professor at Kyungnam University’s Institute for Far Eastern Studies, told AFP.
asserted
chul → take → AFP
After the Hanoi summit collapsed, Kim likely “concluded that while he and Trump might understand each other personally, the US itself is fundamentally untrustworthy, regardless of whether a Republican or Democratic administration is in power”, Lim added.
uncertain
Lim → collapse → power
Given Trump’s penchant for impromptu diplomacy, Washington may not have pursued formal channels to arrange a summit with Pyongyang, analysts said.
uncertain
analysts → give → Pyongyang
“A proper summit would require at least an exchange of special envoys and working-level negotiations,” Koh Yu-hwan, a professor emeritus at Dongguk University, told AFP.
asserted
hwan → require → AFP
“Kim probably had no reason to be used for a photo opportunity aimed at boosting Trump’s political achievements without such preparations.”
asserted
Kim → have → preparations
What might move Pyongyang?
uncertain
What → move → Pyongyang
Experts say Pyongyang is highly unlikely to respond to Trump’s overtures unless Washington takes concrete steps towards recognising it as a nuclear-armed state.
asserted
Washington → say → state
But the US government has so far stuck to its position demanding that Pyongyang give up its nuclear weapons.
asserted
Pyongyang → stick → weapons
Just weeks before Trump’s arrival in Asia, Washington, Seoul and Tokyo reaffirmed their commitment to North Korea’s “complete denuclearisation”.
asserted
Washington → reaffirm → denuclearisation
“Trump may have personally shown goodwill towards Kim, but I don’t think Kim feels that the United States, at its government level, has created a credible environment for resuming dialogue,” expert Lim told AFP.
uncertain
Lim → show → AFP
Rather than responding to Trump directly, North Korean state media depicted Kim visiting a ski resort and sacred Mount Paektu earlier this week, followed by a naval university on Wednesday, where he stressed maritime defence.
asserted
he → respond → defence
Experts said Kim may have calculated that publicly tending to provincial matters while ignoring Trump would be a better response than remaining silent and staying in Pyongyang.
uncertain
tending → say → Pyongyang
After all, Pyongyang’s closer ties with Beijing and Moscow give it less incentive to engage Washington.
asserted
ties → give → Washington
“Pyongyang is also receiving economic and military support from Russia in return for its involvement in the Ukraine war, while expanding economic cooperation with China,” expert Koh said.
asserted
Koh → receive → China
“Despite international sanctions, it continues to generate funds through activities including hacking and cryptocurrency theft.”
asserted
it → continue → hacking
The absence of an explicit no from Pyongyang also left open the door to a future meeting, said Yang Moo-jin, former president of the University of North Korean Studies.
asserted
jin → leave → Studies
“It seems like Trump is still eager to meet with Kim, and Pyongyang seems to be undecided — so the possibility cannot be ruled out,” he told AFP.
asserted
he → seem → AFP