A self-professed sadist in Florida has been found guilty of first-degree murder and kidnapping in last year’s killing of a suicidal British piano tutor who searched the dark web for someone to kill her.
asserted
who → profess → her
Dwain Hall, 53, was convicted on Friday of stabbing Sonia Exelby, 32, to death near Gainesville in October of last year – just days after she flew over from the UK, seeking a violent death.
asserted
she → convict → death
The pair had met in an online fetish chatroom.
asserted
pair → meet → chatroom
Hall was shackled and handcuffed almost immediately, and given two consecutive life sentences.
asserted
Hall → shackle → sentences
A jury of 12 – eight women and four men, several of whom cried as they looked at photos of the victim in a shallow grave – deliberated for about an hour before signaling to Judge Timothy McCourt that they had reached the unanimous verdict.
asserted
they → cry → verdict
Roadside mechanic Hall, wearing an oversized dress shirt and slacks, stoically stood by his attorneys as the verdict was read.
asserted
verdict → wear → attorneys
The sentencing brings an end to the sad saga of Exelby, who was just 32 years old when she flew from London to meet with Hall in October 2025.
asserted
she → bring → October
Hall told police during the investigation that the victim had promised him $4,000 to kill her during a two-year relationship conducted through online chat rooms in websites like motherless.com, a now-defunct platform that allowed anonymous users to post photos of women and children being tortured, raped and killed.
asserted
users → tell → women
In their decision, the jury signified that they believed the murder was premeditated.
asserted
murder → signify → decision
Sonia Exelby, 32, was found dead in a shallow grave in Florida in October last year - just days after the suicidal British woman flew from the UK to meet 54-year-old Dwain Hall, seeking a 'violent death' (Source: Facebook)
Dwain Hall, 53, was convicted on Friday of stabbing Sonia Exelby, 32, to death near Gainesville in October last year.
asserted
Hall → find → October
He is pictured above during his trial
Hall could’ve faced the death penalty, but prosecutors said they reached an agreement with British authorities that they would not seek the death penalty in exchange for the UK’s full cooperation.
Eight of Exelby’s relatives - including two sisters and her older brother, flew from Portsmouth in the UK and from Australia to attend the week-long trial - sobbed uncontrollably as they heard the words ‘guilty’ twice.
uncertain
they → picture → words
In an unusual move, the judge retired to his chambers after the verdict and returned almost immediately with a sentence.
asserted
judge → retire → sentence
The prosecution had rested on Thursday afternoon after a medical examiner confirmed Exelby died from four deep stab wounds.
asserted
Exelby → rest → wounds
The injuries, lined up on the left side of her abdomen, indicated that a large fixed-blade knife was plunged as far as seven inches into her body, severing arteries and damaging her stomach, spleen, diaphragm, pancreas and left kidney.
asserted
knife → line → stomach
Associate Medical Examiner Rachel Lange, who performed the autopsy, told the court the stabbing was likely not self-inflicted or the outcome of a suicide attempt.
asserted
stabbing → perform → attempt
Exelby’s body, nude except for a bra and sandals, was recovered in a shallow grave in a wooded area off the I-75, just south of Ocala, on October 17, 2025.
asserted
body → recover → October
‘The paths of the wounds were not what is typically seen in self-inflicted wounds,’ Lange told the jury of 12 local residents.
asserted
Lange → see → residents
‘She was in the early stages of decomposition, but I found some bruising on her left buttock, breasts, abdomen and back.’
asserted
I → find → buttock
Hall, a tow-truck operator from Ocala, Florida, is accused of stabbing Exelby to death after the pair met on a fetish website.
asserted
pair → accuse → website
Early indications from the police probe into her death suggest Exelby had paid Hall to take her life.
asserted
Exelby → suggest → life
He has pled not guilty (Source: Facebook)
Exelby, who had well-documented mental health issues, flew to Florida on October 10, 2025, and had a return flight booked for three days later.
asserted
flight → plead → October
Her family, as well as boyfriend Steve Hunt (pictured with her), reported her missing when she failed to board the return flight (Source: Facebook)
asserted
she → picture → flight
Hall, a father-of-two, allegedly sexually abused and tortured the vulnerable British woman before killing her in a remote Airbnb (above) where the pair were staying, according to prosecutors
Hall declined to take the stand during his trial.
uncertain
Hall → abuse → trial
He pleaded not guilty to one count of first-degree murder and one count of kidnapping after his October 2025 arrest on allegations that he'd groomed the suicidal Exelby, who suffered from depression and mental illness, for two years on violent fetish websites before she was killed.
asserted
she → plead → websites
Without Hall’s contribution to the trial, Junior Barrett, his defense attorney, presented no witness and cross-examined just two of the prosecution’s witnesses.
asserted
Barrett → present → witnesses
‘I can’t force him to testify,’ he said during a recess.
asserted
he → force → recess
Throughout the trial, the case’s gruesome nature appeared to shock the majority female members of the jury.
asserted
nature → appear → jury
Most jurors took copious notes and passed written questions for witnesses to the Judge Timothy McCourt.
asserted
jurors → take → McCourt
One juror was seen crying openly when prosecutors flashed photos of the discovery of Exelby’s body in a fetal position on its right side - less than a foot from the surface of the shallow grave.
asserted
prosecutors → see → grave
Exelby’s family members often left their seats in the gallery when photos of her body and video recorded in the moments before her death were shown on large TV monitors.
asserted
photos → leave → monitors
Hall, too, cried several times, but only in moments that involved him.
asserted
that → cry → him
While Exelby's intent was to travel to Florida, prosecutors presented evidence showing she had second thoughts when the plane started taking off - including a letter she emailed to herself from her cell phone onboard Flight VS 103
Police told the court they uncovered a trove of sickening images on Hall's phone after he was arrested for allegedly stabbing Exelby to death near Gainesville in October last year.
uncertain
he → travel → October
He has pleaded not guilty (Source: Facebook)
asserted
He → plead → ?
When the jury sat through the four-hours-and-40-minute video of his interview with Florida Department of Law Enforcement agents, the accused was spotted repeatedly taking off his eyeglasses and wiping his eyes with the palms of his hands.ment.
Hall became emotional when he heard himself on the video telling police he had failed Exelby, who paid him $4,000, because ‘she didn’t want to be found, she wanted to be gone, gone, gone.’
asserted
she → sit → 4,000
‘Compassion,’ he said on the video when asked about her death.
asserted
he → say → death
In that interview and any other exchange with investigators, Hall did not admit to killing Exelby but also didn’t explain what had happened to her.
asserted
what → admit → her
For three days, prosecutors presented one witness after the next who spoke of various elements linking Hall to Exelby’s killing.
asserted
who → present → killing
Through the Life 360 app on Hall's phone, investigators were able to show his phone was at the airport in Gainesville around the time of Exelby’s arrival; at the nearby Airbnb she rented; at a Walmart where Hall bought rope and a shovel; and at the grave site for more than an hour.
asserted
Hall → show → hour
One forensic scientist testified that a black Cold Steet knife that investigators said Hall sent to a friend in Ohio for safekeeping had been cleaned and oiled and showed no blood – until she unscrewed the handle and found Exelby’s blood on the screws.
asserted
she → testify → screws
Following his arrest, Hall told police he had met Exelby on a fetish website two years ago and that she had had told him how she wanted to be killed
asserted
she → follow → him
…and 12 more, not listed.