The war of words between immigration critic Michele Rempel Garner and Immigration Minister Lena Metlege Diab this week in the House of Commons has set off social media users.
asserted
war → set → users
Earlier this month, Canada’s immigration levels plan was published in the federal budget, after which Garner slammed the plan, writing on social media that “Mark Carney just announced the highest level of permanent immigration in Canadian history, and tried to hide it.
asserted
Carney → publish → it
This is on top of hundreds of thousands of new temporary immigrants that Mark Carney also approved.”
asserted
Carney → approve → that
Garner’s criticism continued during question period on Wednesday, when the MP for Calgary Nose Hill pointed out that bringing in “close to a million new people next year” would overrun Canada’s already overwhelmed housing and health-care systems.
asserted
bringing → continue → systems
Diab posts her response online
asserted
Diab → post → response
Diab pushed back, and shared video of her response to Garner on X.
“The facts are the majority of the people that will be coming into permanent residency next year are already living here, paying taxes, working, helping our children in their daycares, feeding people in their homes, helping in hospital beds,” Diab said in the clip.
asserted
Diab → push → clip
“They’re already here on temporary status,” she continued, before directing questions to Garner.
asserted
she → ’re → Garner
“Which ones would she like to get rid of?
asserted
she → like → ones
Can she please tell us?”
asserted
she → tell → us
Diab continued in another post: “Conservatives are wrong about the basic facts.
asserted
Conservatives → continue → facts
Yesterday, I called them out.”
asserted
I → call → them
She added: “With our new immigration plan, we’re keeping arrivals at stable, sustainable levels while helping provinces retain the skilled workers who are already here contributing to Canada.”
asserted
who → add → Canada
Let the ratioing begin
However, Diab’s words didn’t go down very well, at least on X, where the comment section was filled with people calling the minister “incompetent” and “out of touch,” agreeing with Garner, and wishing there was an “unlike” button for them to punch.
asserted
them → let → Garner
What part of TEMPORARY don’t you understand???,” one person asked.
asserted
person → understand → TEMPORARY
One user wrote, “Get rid of all of them.
asserted
user → write → them
You are not listening,” before pointing out recent national polling numbers that “85.8% of Canadians do not want immigration levels to increase.”
asserted
levels → listen → Canadians
Another questioned her definition of “skilled workers,” noting, “They are Amazon drivers, employees of Walmart and fast food restaurants.
asserted
They → question → Walmart
All the jobs that previously went to students and seniors are taken by them.”
asserted
that → go → them
One user noted that “lifelong Canadians are going years without access to a family doctor.
asserted
Canadians → note → doctor
They should not lose their doctors to TFWs or to your immigration scheme to keep our GDP afloat.”
asserted
They → lose → GDP
They added: “Stop ignoring the real facts Lena.
asserted
They → add → facts
Canadians are fed up.”
asserted
Canadians → feed → ?
One user appeared to genuinely ask: “How is it SUSTAINABLE to bring in 650,000 people per year when the government has built 2000 homes in the past 2 years and home builders build on average 230,000 a year?”
asserted
builders → appear → 230,000
Another agreed, commenting, “You are bringing in 600K+ immigrants and 300K+ temporary residents but only increased employment by 17K net and built only 20K houses.
asserted
You → agree → houses
How does that make sense?
asserted
that → make → sense
One person suggested: “If we sent the 650k people packing that would represent a 20% reduction on the backlog of 3.5M houses.
uncertain
that → suggest → houses
And it wouldn’t require any new infrastructure at all.
asserted
it → require → infrastructure
The demand for labour would spike and people here would make more money helping offset inflationary government spending.”
asserted
people → spike → spending
Another wrote: “You’re wrecking the culture and you’re wrecking our cost of living and ability to own our homes.
asserted
you → write → homes
We know what’s going on and we’re not as gullible as your ‘elbows up’ base.”
asserted
we → know → base
Meanwhile, Garner appeared to grab some popcorn, sit back and enjoy the show.
asserted
Garner → appear → show
“I’m just here for the ratio,” she wrote.
asserted
she → ’m → ratio