There is no such thing as a free lunch, except on the Big Build where the Victorian taxpayer picked up the bill.
asserted
taxpayer → be → bill
This week, the royal commission probing corruption and criminality in Victoria's construction sector tallied up some of the receipts.
asserted
commission → probe → receipts
It aired evidence of a $20,000 souvlaki scam lunch, $12,000 in donations to the CFMEU and $17,000 worth of fake invoices.
asserted
It → air → invoices
Then there were pay cheques for bikies and union officials worth hundreds of thousands of dollars for work that was never done or explained.
asserted
that → be → work
And already, the commission has referred two witnesses to police — understood to be Bandidos Bikie Joel Leavitt and BK Labour Hire boss Bernard Kearney — over allegations they failed to answer questions during their evidence.
asserted
they → refer → evidence
If prosecuted and proven guilty, they face two years' imprisonment or a fine of $50,000.
asserted
they → prosecute → 50,000
'I cannot recall' heard over 300 times
Commissioner Chris Kourakis AC repeatedly warned both witnesses in the face of their apparent amnesia in the witness box that answering questions by claiming to have no memory of events could constitute an offence.
uncertain
answering → recall → offence
"Just because words come out of your mouth after a question doesn't mean that you've answered it," Mr Kourakis emphasised to Mr Kearney.
asserted
Kourakis → come → Kearney
During intense grilling from the commission, Rebels-turn-Bandidos bikie Mr Leavitt said he could not remember what happened for most of 2021 and 2022, uttering a variation of "I cannot recall" more than 300 times.
uncertain
I → say → times
"Have you seen a medical practitioner about your lack of recollection of two years of your life?" the Commissioner asked, "You've not received any diagnosis of cognitive decline or recollection decline?"
asserted
You → see → decline
"No," Leavitt replied.
asserted
Leavitt → reply → ?
The bikie blamed PTSD from having been shot, his ADHD and past drug use for his memory failure, as well as being "slightly hungover" on his second day of evidence.
asserted
bikie → blame → evidence
The commission heard the CFMEU had muscled the bikie onto Big Build sites, as the union's nominated health and safety representative, via his employment by the union's preferred labour hire firm BK Labour.
asserted
CFMEU → hear → firm
The commission heard once Mr Leavitt started getting work on jobs, the bikie dined out on the contractors' dime — with the state ultimately picking up most of the bill.
asserted
state → hear → bill
On one occasion, evidence showed thaat he along with a fellow CFMEU nominated health and safety (HSR) rep cashed in on a workers souvlaki lunch, having inflated the bill from $9,000 to $20,000 and pocketed the change.
asserted
he → show → change
"The workers would get a few souvlakia, the CFMEU members would get a few souvlakia, and maybe some other things, and their two HSR reps were going to pocket $5,000 each and it looks like you were one of the HSR reps," Commissioner Kourakis said.
asserted
Kourakis → get → reps
"Can I take it you're not surprised that you might have engaged in that conduct?"
uncertain
you → take → conduct
Mr Leavitt replied: "I'll accept that I'm not surprised that I could of (sic)."
uncertain
I → reply → ?
The commission also aired evidence Mr Leavitt claimed wages for shifts while he was either at the gym or at home and had boasted about costing a Big Build project half a million dollars by causing delays.
asserted
he → air → delays
Cocaine helped bikie 'zone in' on paperwork
asserted
bikie → help → paperwork
Under questioning, Mr Leavitt said there "was a possibility" he could have controlled who worked on construction sites on behalf of the CFMEU, and had arranged jobs for his fellow bikies and their partners.
uncertain
who → say → bikies
The bikie also invoiced the CFMEU's preferred labour hire firm BK Labour $165,000 as a consultant but couldn't recall the detail of that work, except that it involved "tips on safety".
asserted
it → invoice → safety
In response, the commissioner asked him if he was good at detailed paperwork, to which the bikie suggested only after "a big line" of cocaine which allows him to "zone in".
BK Labour's boss Mr Kearney later conceded he had paid the bikie but he hadn't done any work, telling the inquiry he "just decided to pay it and move on".
Mr Carr wrapped up a day-and-a-half of questioning of Mr Leavitt with two propositions.
uncertain
Carr → ask → propositions
"One conclusion that might be reached is that you were nothing more than a bikie heavy who the CFMEU wanted on building sites so you could intimidate people into doing what the union wanted," he said.
uncertain
he → reach → what
"I wouldn't say that's a conclusion I would reach, but — is that your conclusion?"
asserted
that → say → ?
Mr Leavitt responded.
asserted
Leavitt → respond → ?
Mr Carr offered a second option.
asserted
Carr → offer → option
You took full advantage of the power of the CFMEU to pilfer money, to get your bikie mates jobs, to unlawfully benefit the union, all at the expense of the state; do you say that's a fair conclusion to reach on the basis of what I've put to you over the last day and a half?"
asserted
I → take → day
Mr Carr said.
asserted
Carr → say → ?
Mr Leavitt replied: "Again, counsellor, I wouldn't say that that would be my conclusion."
asserted
that → reply → ?
In its first two weeks the royal commission focused on the 2022 Gap Road level crossing removal, hearing it was one of the few remaining projects that the CFMEU had gained control of through an enterprise agreement and installing its own health and safety reps.
asserted
CFMEU → focus → reps
The inquiry probed why BK Labour Hire began winning lucrative contracts on the state's multibillion dollar Big Build projects, including at Gap Road.
asserted
Hire → probe → Road
Witnesses have testified that the CFMEU had insisted the project's contractors John Holland engage the labour hire firm after the union stopped work for two days during a critical time on the project.
asserted
union → testify → project
In a meeting at the CFMEU's headquarters in Melbourne's CBD, contractors capitulated to the union's demands to engage BK Labour and use the union's nominated health and safety reps, in order to end the stoppage and resume works.
asserted
contractors → capitulate → works
Despite being a labour hire firm, BK Labour didn't provide the actual labour, the workers "switched shirts" having been forced to resign from Zoom recruitment and work for BK Labour, and sign up to the CFMEU for up to $1,200 a year in fees.
asserted
workers → provide → fees
The labour hire firm billed contractors for two non-working CFMEU nominated health and safety reps for about $2,000 a day on the job, according to a tendered invoice.
uncertain
firm → bill → invoice
'Elaborate forgery' used for fake invoices
Investigating the business's finances, the inquiry heard the firm supplied fake invoices to the labour hire authority when the regulator asked the business to explain why it had paid former CFMEU boss Joe Myles $127,000 and had withdrawn $77,000 in cash.
asserted
it → use → cash
The invoices totalling $17,000 were faked to suggest the firm had sponsored junior football clubs and a bowling club in Melbourne, by way of explaining the cash withdrawals, the commission heard.
asserted
commission → total → withdrawals
The firm never provided an explanation to the industry regulator about why it'd paid the union boss.
asserted
it → provide → boss
At Thursday's hearing when Mr Carr asked Mr Kearney if someone had done some "elaborate forgery to come up with the fake invoices" the witness told the hearing: "it happened, yes".
asserted
it → ask → hearing
…and 14 more, not listed.