Judge denies Alex Murdaugh's bid to dismiss murder charges
Murdaugh's attorneys alleged that the chief investigator lied to the grand jury.
asserted
investigator → deny → jury
A South Carolina judge denied Alex Murdaugh's motion to dismiss his indictments on charges alleging he murdered his wife and son.
asserted
he → deny → wife
Murdaugh sought to throw out the case as he faces a retrial, after the South Carolina Supreme Court overturned his 2023 murder convictions due to jury interference.
asserted
Court → seek → interference
His wife, Margaret "Maggie" Murdaugh, 52, and younger son, Paul Murdaugh, 22, were found dead from multiple gunshot wounds at the family's hunting estate in 2021.
asserted
wife → find → 2021
Judge Debra McCaslin issued her decision on Friday, clearing the way for the retrial set for next year.
asserted
McCaslin → issue → year
During a hearing last week on their motion before the judge, the defense alleged that Murdaugh's indictments were based on false testimony to the Colleton County grand jury by the chief investigator, former State Law Enforcement Division agent David Owen.
asserted
indictments → allege → investigator
While there is no transcript of the Colleton County grand jury session, defense attorney Jim Griffin referred to Owen's own statements as well as testimony at the original trial to claim the investigator knowingly misled the grand jury regarding certain evidence.
uncertain
investigator → be → evidence
Griffin claimed Owen told the grand jury that there was blood spatter on Murdaugh's shirt on the night of the murder when there was none.
asserted
Owen → claim → murder
He also claimed that Owen inaccurately stated that guns found on the property had the same load as the ammunition used to kill Paul.
asserted
guns → claim → Paul
While testifying during the trial, Owen confirmed that he told the grand jury that an expert found multiple particles of blood spatter on Murdaugh's shirt, and that he hadn't seen a report that found no human blood on the shirt until after Murdaugh had been indicted.
asserted
Murdaugh → testify → shirt
Owen also testified during the trial that he inaccurately told the grand jury that other firearms at the Murdaugh property were loaded in a similar fashion to the shotgun used to kill Paul.
asserted
firearms → testify → Paul
He said he wasn't trying to trick grand jurors.
asserted
he → say → jurors
Prosecutor Creighton Waters discounted the defense's arguments during last week's hearing, saying that at the time of the grand jury testimony, the claims about the splatter on the shirt were believed to be true.
uncertain
claims → discount → shirt
Waters also presented evidence that he said discounted Griffin's assertion that there was no other weapon at the house that had the same shot-load as the one used to kill Paul.
asserted
that → present → Paul
Additionally, Waters argued there was much more compelling evidence that would have been presented to the grand jury that would have been considered.
asserted
that → argue → jury
As an example, he brought up a video found on Paul's cell phone that he said had audio of Paul, Maggie and Alex Murdaugh together just moments before the killings.
asserted
he → bring → killings
Preparations have been underway for Murdaugh to stand trial for the murder of his wife and son again next year.
asserted
Murdaugh → stand → wife
His retrial has been set for April 5, 2027, in Sumter County, after McCaslin granted a change of venue.
asserted
McCaslin → set → venue
Prosecutors said they were prepared to seek another set of grand jury indictments as soon as next month, should the defense succeed in dismissing the original indictments.
asserted
defense → say → indictments
During last week's hearing, McCaslin asked the prosecution if they could be ready to resubmit to the grand jury during their Dec. 10 session in time to go ahead with the April 5, 2027, trial, should they succeed in getting a new indictment.
uncertain
they → ask → indictment
Waters said he'd be ready.
asserted
he → say → ?
The South Carolina Supreme Court overturned Murdaugh’s 2023 murder convictions and life sentences earlier this year -- citing "shocking jury interference" by the court clerk in the Colleton County trial.
asserted
Court → overturn → trial
Murdaugh remains in prison after pleading guilty to separate financial crimes.
asserted
Murdaugh → remain → crimes
He was sentenced to 27 years on state charges and 40 years on federal charges for the financial crimes.
asserted
He → sentence → crimes
The disgraced attorney admitted to stealing from his clients, though he has denied killing his wife and son.
asserted
he → admit → wife