The Electoral College “makes no sense,” says aspiring Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg, and as a relic of “some very arcane, parochial politics in the 1770s,” it should be abolished.
asserted
it → make → 1770s
Now, if Buttigieg wants the United States, the most stably democratic nation in history, to use the electoral process favored by Algeria, the Dominican Republic and Turkey, that’s certainly his prerogative.
asserted
that → want → Algeria
But everyone understands why left-wingers want direct popular presidential elections, and it has everything to do with grabbing power.
asserted
it → understand → power
Advertisement
Rather than making the case for a constitutional amendment, Democrats hatched the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, in which participating states circumvent the law and award all electoral votes to the presidential ticket that wins the nonexistent “popular vote” rather than the one that wins the state’s electors.
asserted
that → make → electors
Democrats have already gotten 17 states with 222 electoral votes to join this endeavor.
asserted
states → get → endeavor
They need 270.
asserted
They → need → 270
After expanding control of state legislatures and governorships in the midterm elections, they probably have enough.
asserted
they → expand → enough
It’s scandalous, it must be said, that smaller states such as Vermont, Colorado, New Mexico and so on, willingly cede their sovereignty to Los Angeles, Chicago and New York City.
asserted
states → ’ → Angeles
But more than that, the NPVIC is also a constitutional crisis waiting to happen.
asserted
NPVIC → wait → that
The rules for electing the president aren’t opaque.
asserted
rules → elect → president
Indeed, the founders explicitly rejected a popular vote.
asserted
founders → reject → vote
They debated numerous other processes, mechanisms and ideas, and landed on a compromise.
asserted
They → debate → compromise
States have leeway in how they run their own elections, but by creating a de facto direct democracy, the compact threatens not only to compel state electors to cast votes against candidates their voters have chosen; it also denies the rest of the country the ability to run a presidential election as prescribed by law.
asserted
it → have → law
Advertisement
Also, the fact that states have leeway in how they run their own elections means the entire country is at the mercy of decisions made by California, which could decide to allow illegal immigrants, or 12-year-olds, to vote.
uncertain
immigrants → run → California
We keep hearing how the “split” between the imaginary “popular vote” and very real Electoral College is a “problem” that needs correcting rather than a device that works exactly as intended.
asserted
that → hear → vote
On the most basic level, the Electoral College compels presidential candidates to appeal and govern nationally rather than represent a handful of states — or rather, a handful of cities.
asserted
College → compel → cities
Now that presidents rule the country by fiat, that fact is more important than ever.
asserted
fact → rule → fiat
Forty states have smaller populations than Los Angeles County.
asserted
states → have → County
Yet Democrats believe Los Angeles County should have a bigger say in electing the president than nine of the least populated states in the country combined.
asserted
County → believe → country
Why would any president concern themselves with the problems of vast swaths of the country when those voters are irrelevant?
asserted
voters → concern → country
When Buttigieg says “parochial politics,” he means federalism.
asserted
he → say → federalism
The leftists who want to pack the Supreme Court, weaken the Senate, get rid of the legislative filibuster and make the presidential election a direct popular vote don’t believe in a “United States” but in a centralized national government.
asserted
election → want → government
But a diffused democracy is the only way to keep a sprawling, geographically, ethnically, culturally, religiously diverse nation free and self-governing.
asserted
nation → keep → ?
If people in Mississippi wanted to live under the ideas that got Zohran Mamdani elected, they would move to New York.
asserted
they → want → York
Yet, it’s become so common for pundits and reporters to declare a candidate won the “popular vote” that we tend to forget that it isn’t a reflection of any electoral reality.
asserted
it → become → reality
The popular vote represents the gross score of a game that hasn’t been played.
asserted
that → represent → game
Advertisement
Presidential tickets focus on 51 separate elections.
asserted
tickets → focus → elections
If presidential tickets concentrated on untapped reserves of voters in only major urban areas, the candidates’ agendas would shift to the left, and the “popular vote” may look very different.
uncertain
vote → concentrate → left
Then again, we all know Democratic governors would never adhere to any pact if they believed a Republican would capture the “popular vote” but lose the Electoral College.
asserted
Republican → know → College
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact exists to steal an election from a GOP candidate should the need arise.
asserted
need → exist → candidate
If we faced that reality, any constitutionally mindful Supreme Court would immediately overturn the compact.
asserted
Court → face → compact
Very few free countries have systems with direct national votes for their leaders.
asserted
countries → have → leaders
After all, how long can a constitutional republic exist if states can enter into pacts for the purpose of ignoring the parts of the Constitution they don’t like?
Advertisement
Not long, I suspect.
asserted
I → exist → Constitution