Thursday morning, an ebullient Mayor Zohran Mamdani convened a City Hall Blue Room ceremony to ban Central Park’s horse carriages.
asserted
Mayor → convene → carriages
Signing this bill was the biggest political misstep of his near year in office.
asserted
Signing → sign → office
It made him what he has spent his career trying not to look like, just another grubby, grasping local pol.
asserted
he → make → career
Banning horse carriages was not part of Mamdani’s agenda, and for good reason.
asserted
Banning → ban → reason
But for two decades, a tiny if dedicated crew of animal-rights fanatics has pushed the issue.
asserted
crew → push → issue
They’ve lobbied New York’s most feckless pols, the people who will satisfy any narrow interest to get elected.
asserted
who → lobby → interest
You could see them standing behind Mamdani Thursday.
uncertain
them → see → Mamdani
The array of second-string jesters and hangers-on included former Mayor Bill de Blasio.
asserted
array → include → Blasio
De B, lacking fixed ideas of his own besides pre-kindergarten, agreed in his 2013 campaign to ban the carriages.
asserted
B → lack → carriages
It was just a coincidence that the main advocate behind the ban, real-estate magnate Steve Nislick, had spent big attacking de Blasio’s primary opponent, former City Council Speaker Christine Quinn.
asserted
advocate → spend → opponent
Also standing behind Mamdani was current Speaker Julie Menin.
Advertisement
asserted
Menin → stand → Mamdani
In passing this bill, Menin has serenely sold out more than 200 horse-driver jobs and 50 stable-hand jobs.
asserted
Menin → pass → jobs
No elected official wants to be attacked the way Quinn was attacked.
asserted
Quinn → elect → ?
And there was Nislick, visibly pleased with what his money had bought.
asserted
money → be → what
In pushing for a ban on public-safety grounds, Smith has seized on the death of Romanch Mahajan, the 18-year-old killed in a horse-carriage mishap in June.
asserted
Smith → push → June
Mahajan’s death was the only such incident in more than a century, and it has become the casus belli.
asserted
it → become → century
But the horse carrying Mahajan may have bolted because of stray electric voltage in the park.
uncertain
horse → carry → park
And the Transport Workers Union, which represents the horse-carriage workers, charges — with some documentary evidence — that the conservancy’s maintenance failures caused the voltage.
asserted
failures → represent → voltage
Strange: The conservancy has focused on banning horses, when it didn’t ban trees after a baby was killed by a branch, it didn’t ban its own vehicles after a crash killed an owl, and it hasn’t called for banning bikes despite multiple deaths.
asserted
it → focus → deaths
Menin’s council delivered the mayor a veto-proof majority, but he didn’t have to convene a ceremony to sign.
asserted
he → deliver → ceremony
He could have done nothing, and the ban would have become law.
uncertain
ban → do → nothing
The mayor may have figured that since this ban is going to happen anyway, he might as well get some free points from these special interests.
uncertain
he → figure → interests
But he may have tarnished himself.
uncertain
he → tarnish → himself
The law he just signed puts responsibility on him to find jobs for the horse-carriage workers.
asserted
he → sign → workers
He also must figure out how to compensate the owners of 68 horse-carriage medallions for the city’s instant extinguishment of these investments’ value.
asserted
He → figure → value
The mayor has tried to assuage workers’ concerns, saying that the city will offer stipends for education or training.
But it’s insulting to say that horse-carriage workers are uneducated or unskilled.
asserted
workers → try → education
Many have degrees.
asserted
Many → have → degrees
They chose this career, which isn’t disappearing because of evil free-market forces but by city decree.
asserted
which → choose → decree
One clue that Mamdani has no ideas here: He floated allowing the horse-carriage workers to drive electric cars in the park.
asserted
workers → float → park
Horse-carriage workers and medallion owners are now suing on constitutional grounds.
asserted
workers → sue → grounds
Killing the value of horse-carriage medallions by fiat is an unconstitutional taking of private property without compensation.
asserted
Killing → kill → compensation
Advertisement
And the ban interferes with private contracts.
asserted
ban → interfere → contracts
Many medallion owners owe debt backed by these investments, and owners of horse stables also have mortgages.
asserted
owners → owe → mortgages
Mamdani must expend political capital to “fix” these issues.
asserted
Mamdani → expend → issues
He’ll have to justify spending tens of millions to compensate medallion owners.
asserted
He → have → owners
Advertisement
In associating himself with the likes of de Blasio and Menin, he’s hurting his own unique political value: he ran on broad, once-in-a-generation appeal, not on sleazy Gotham politics as usual.
asserted
he → associate → politics
In signing, he also evoked the image of another unpopular figure.
asserted
he → sign → figure
Mamdani, wielding his glittering pens just after exulting about how “progress is good,” didn’t look like the young, idealistic Democratic Socialist mayor.
asserted
progress → wield → mayor
He looked like an increasingly cynical tech CEO, inelegantly and obliviously aging out of phase when everyone likes him.
asserted
everyone → look → him
He was so in his bubble that he didn’t realize that even the most socially inept CEO doesn‘t sign mass-layoff slips a week before Thanksgiving.
asserted
CEO → realize → Thanksgiving
…and 1 more, not listed.