A nearly 12 per cent wage increase for City of Kelowna staff, approved just days before the Oct. 17 municipal election but announced publicly afterward, is raising questions about transparency in how city council communicates with taxpayers.
asserted
council → approve → taxpayers
The agreement was ratified on October 19, two days after the municipal election.
asserted
agreement → ratify → election
While the former council was kept apprised of the negotiations, residents were not given a public announcement before the vote.
asserted
residents → keep → vote
Many learned about the wage hike through local media reports.
asserted
Many → learn → reports
“Taxpayers shouldn’t be learning how much stuff costs from reporters.
asserted
stuff → learn → reporters
This kind of transparency should really be the bare minimum standard for cities,” said Gage Haubrich, a director with the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
asserted
Haubrich → say → Federation
Haubrich added the city should have let residents know in advance what was being considered and the financial implications.
asserted
what → add → advance
“At bare minimum it should be a news release,” he said.
asserted
he → say → minimum
Stuart Leatherdale, the city’s lead negotiator for the agreement and general manager of people and protective services, says the City had an understanding with CUPE at the beginning of negotiations not to involve the media.
asserted
City → say → media
That understanding remained in place through the bargaining process and ratification.
asserted
understanding → remain → process
Leatherdale acknowledged the public’s criticism over the lack of an announcement.
asserted
Leatherdale → acknowledge → announcement
“I think it’s a fair comment, and I’ll accept that from the general public,” Leatherdale said.
asserted
Leatherdale → think → public
Leatherdale explained that the city has issued news releases about labour agreements in the past, but those announcements were made jointly with the union.
asserted
announcements → explain → union
“Normally, when we have done that in the past, it’s by joint agreement.
asserted
it → do → agreement
We both put that statement out,” he said.
asserted
he → put → statement
“We just never did get to making that agreement this time around.”
asserted
We → get → agreement
The city instead issued a subsequent “For the Record” news release disputing information published in media reports and providing additional context about negotiations.
asserted
city → issue → negotiations
It is part of a growing collection of after-the-fact statements on the city’s website, including a recent release in which the city manager defended the municipality’s record on transparency.
asserted
manager → grow → transparency
Sean Holman, a journalism professor at the University of Victoria, says the city’s approach points to a broader communication problem.
asserted
approach → say → problem
It is the symptom of a bureaucratic public relations process that is afraid of sharing facts with the media and by extension with the public,” Holman said.
asserted
Holman → share → public
“Constant massaging of image actually does not serve government in the long run.
asserted
massaging → serve → run
It actually simply makes the government appear less trustworthy.”
asserted
government → make → ?
- Calgary man pleads guilty to threatening to kill Prime Minister Mark Carney and family
- 25 new prosecutors half to what is needed to make ‘meaningful change’ on Manitoba Crown workloads
- Stellantis meeting ‘challenging’ but ‘productive’, Premier Ford says
-
asserted
Ford → plead → workloads
N.S. school support workers’ union seeks renewed talks after members reject offer
asserted
members → seek → offer
When Global News requested interviews Friday about the broader issue of transparency and communication, neither the mayor, city manager, or anyone else from city hall was available to meet the daily news deadline for an on-camera interview.
asserted
mayor → request → interview
The issue comes as Kelowna’s re-elected mayor has vowed to improve communication with residents, but how that commitment will translate into changes at city hall remains to be seen.
asserted
translate → come → hall
“It’s an incredibly adversarial approach that the city is taking,” Holman said.
asserted
Holman → ’ → that
“What they should be doing is providing facts in a timely manner to journalists, so we can report on stories in a timely manner to the public who we serve, just like the city is supposed to serve.”
asserted
city → do → who