New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani's plan to gut the city’s tactical police unit is not what is seems, two former high-ranking NYPD officials tell Fox News Digital.
asserted
officials → gut → Digital
They argue the stunt is a political sleight of hand in which specialized officers responsible for handling violent protests will be rebranded under a different name despite the socialist mayor's promise to disband it completely.
asserted
officers → argue → it
"The problem is…day-to-day New Yorkers don't understand all this gas lighting," former NYPD Chief John Chell told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Chell → understand → Digital
"And they feel the angst of it.
asserted
they → feel → it
"But at the end of all that, this is nothing more than smoke and mirrors," he added.
asserted
he → add → smoke
The move to dissolve the Strategic Response Group (SRG) and replace it with a "first-of-its-kind" civilian dialogue team fulfills one of Mamdani's campaign promises — noted in the first sentence of his news release on the move.
asserted
move → dissolve → move
But Chell and retired NYPD inspector Paul Mauro are questioning whether it's all a facade to please the mayor's left-wing base and is a restructuring rather than a disbandment.
asserted
it → question → base
They say the unit will likely be rebuilt under a new name to continue dealing with mass protests, major crimes and counterterrorism.
asserted
unit → say → protests
"The con here is that the SRG is simply being rebranded into an unknown name right now," Chell said.
asserted
Chell → rebrande → name
"First of all, Mamdani did add…that there will be uniformed police standing by to take more forceful enforcement if necessary," Mauro said.
asserted
Mauro → add → enforcement
"So what really changed?
asserted
what → change → ?
Well, he changed the name of that unit and he inserted this civilian unit between those uniformed cops and the protesters."
asserted
he → change → cops
The newly proposed civilian-led Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division (CDDD) is meant to work as a buffer between protesters and the on-duty police that will remain present at large demonstrations.
asserted
that → propose → demonstrations
"Socialism and public safety do not go hand in hand," Chell insisted.
asserted
Chell → go → hand
Mamdani’s office did not respond to Fox News Digital’s request for comment on the criticism of his plan.
asserted
office → respond → plan
Both former NYPD officials warned that relying on civilians to mediate rowdy crowds could delay police intervention if a peaceful protest turns into a violent riot.
uncertain
protest → warn → riot
This, he said, could leave officers responding to an escalating situation rather than preventing it in the first place.
uncertain
he → say → place
"Once a cop, wherever they're assigned, becomes reactive versus proactive — public safety suffers," Chell said.
asserted
Chell → assign → ?
"And [when cops] become reactive, they tend to hold back and that can get them hurt, and it can get civilians hurt.
asserted
civilians → become → ?
"That is one of the risks inherent in this thing," Mauro added.
asserted
Mauro → add → thing
"That you deploy the civilians, they're trying to talk…and by the time the civilians turn around and say, ‘Police, we need help,’ it may be too late."
uncertain
it → deploy → help
SRG receives information from NYPD’s Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau to be kept aware of known or potentially dangerous demonstrations that will require specialized training to deescalate.
asserted
that → receive → training
The SRG unit is trained to handle crowds that have turned violent, beginning with verbal de-escalation.
asserted
that → train → escalation
The physical training teaches officers how to get a noncomplying individual and into police vans.
asserted
training → teach → vans
A common tactic used by the SRG is bicycle crowd management where officers can line up their bikes to build a barricade in crowds, using those formations for crowd control.
asserted
officers → use → control
"The purpose of the SRG was to make sure that you had highly trained officers who could diffuse, spin down, but then control if need be, protests that were getting out of hand," Mauro said.
uncertain
Mauro → make → hand
"That's why they were only deployed in about 6% of the instances."
asserted
they → deploy → instances
In a budget hearing earlier this year it was noted the SRG did not often deal with peaceful protests, and were mostly only deployed for protests that turned violent.
asserted
that → note → protests
In 2025, NYPD reportedly facilitated 4,255 protests and the SRG was available for roughly 6% of them.
uncertain
SRG → facilitate → them
Critics of the SRG, including the ACLU's New York affiliate, say the unit is inherently violent due to its counterterrorism specialization that they claim "suppress protesters" and disregards "focus on First Amendment protections."
uncertain
they → include → protections
The training manual, reviewed by Fox News Digital, distinguishes between "peaceful/compliant" crowds and those deemed "violent/non-compliant."
asserted
manual → review → crowds
It also identifies three categories of protesters: "everyday citizen," "professional" and "anarchist."
asserted
It → identify → protesters
The first identifier under the "everyday citizen" protester immediately acknowledges that they are honoring their First Amendment right to organize.
asserted
they → acknowledge → right
Despite the dismantling of the SRG, Mamdani's plan would still likely require police officers be present at larger demonstrations.
asserted
officers → require → demonstrations
The new civilian-led group, however, would be there to attempt to de-escalate the protesters if it should show signs of turning violent.
asserted
it → lead → signs
Mamdani has not yet said when the civilian-led team will be established or take the streets.
asserted
team → say → streets
He also announced the creation of the First Amendment Support Team (FAST), a 30-officer NYPD unit, that will help deescalate crowds while the CDDD is being developed.
asserted
CDDD → announce → crowds
Chell, who has announced he will be running for mayor of New York City in 2029 when Mamdani would likely be seeking a second term, said he doubts the new team will take form until at least 2028 – if ever.
asserted
team → announce → 2028
"What's scary about all this, the mentality of how the mayor and his staff and his socialist friends want to run this city," Chell said.
asserted
Chell → want → city
"If they get everything they want, we're gonna be a third world city and I don't know if we can ever get it back."
asserted
we → get → it