The federal budget tabled Nov. 5 contains no new money to protect Canada’s Jewish communities, even as the cost of securing synagogues, schools, and community centres has skyrocketed.
asserted
cost → table → synagogues
Toronto’s Beth Tzedec Congregation has roughly doubled its security spending since Oct. 7, 2023, to about $400,000 a year, The Hub previously reported in March, while Beth Sholom’s has jumped about fivefold.
asserted
Sholom → double → March
UJA Federation of Greater Toronto spent $24.2 million on security and fighting antisemitism in its 2025 fiscal year—a fifth of its budget—up from $18.4 million the year before.
asserted
Federation → spend → million
The 500-plus-page budget never mentions antisemitism or the Canada Community Security Program (CCSP), the federal fund that helps at-risk groups pay for cameras, reinforced doors, and guards.
asserted
groups → mention → cameras
As The CJN reported, it adds nothing beyond the five-year, $75-million top-up announced in the spring economic update.
asserted
it → report → update
It does commit $64 million over four years to the federal centre for preventing radicalization to violence.
asserted
It → commit → violence
A threat authorities call real
The threat is not hypothetical.
asserted
threat → call → threat
Jews, about 1 percent of Canadians, were targeted in 788 police-reported hate crimes in 2025—roughly one in six nationally, according to Statistics Canada.
uncertain
Jews → target → Canada
Three Toronto-area synagogues were hit by gunfire in March.
asserted
synagogues → hit → March
Federal threat assessments obtained by Global News warned in April that Iranian intelligence may be using local criminal networks against Jewish targets in Canada, and reported in June that authorities had disrupted four Islamic State-inspired plots against Jewish targets since 2023.
uncertain
authorities → obtain → 2023
Intelligence officials have repeatedly called an attack on the community a “realistic possibility.”
asserted
officials → call → community
In September, it nearly happened.
asserted
it → happen → September
On Sept. 20, as congregants gathered for Yom Kippur at Sons of Jacob Synagogue in Belleville, Ont., a 29-year-old gunman opened fire on Const. Jeff Smith, who was posted outside.
asserted
who → gather → Smith
Police said the shooter, who died, carried multiple guns, ammunition, and gasoline, and called it a thwarted mass killing.
asserted
who → say → it
Smith was critically wounded.
asserted
Smith → wound → ?
Three days before the budget, members of the small congregation went to Parliament Hill asking for help paying for bulletproof glass, a safe room, and guards they say they cannot afford alone.
asserted
they → go → glass
The budget offered nothing new.
asserted
budget → offer → nothing
Small communities, same costs
Government officials and intelligence agencies have said plainly that the danger to Jewish Canadians is serious.
asserted
danger → say → Canadians
Yet many institutions, particularly outside Toronto, Montreal, and other big cities, remain exposed.
asserted
institutions → remain → Toronto
“For a lot of small communities, the 70-30 split is a bit of a challenge,” David Cooper, vice-president of government relations at the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA), the advocacy arm of Jewish Federations of Canada-UIA, told The Hub in a phone interview.
asserted
Cooper → tell → interview
Under the CCSP, Ottawa covers 70 percent of approved costs, and the community pays the rest.
asserted
community → cover → rest
CIJA estimates Jewish communities across the country now spend more than $40 million a year on security.
asserted
communities → estimate → security
“This is a real thing for Belleville,” Cooper said.
asserted
Cooper → say → Belleville
“They had a security assessment done last summer, and they put off certain things because they’re a very small synagogue.
asserted
they → have → things
It’s literally between putting on the heat and putting in some of the security measures like security film, better doors, alarm systems, and so forth.”
asserted
It → ’ → film
“For big synagogues in big cities, it’s more easily paid for,” he said.
asserted
he → pay → cities
“But there’s no discount because you’re only protecting 36 people in a synagogue.”
asserted
you → ’ → synagogue
CIJA is pressing for a sliding scale so smaller institutions pay a lower share.
asserted
institutions → press → share
The program’s fine print allows Ottawa to cover 100 percent in extreme cases, but Cooper, who met with the minister and his deputy in September, said that option is “not well socialized,” either among program officers or potential applicants.
asserted
option → allow → officers
What Ottawa has done—and hasn’t
The Carney government has moved.
asserted
government → do → What
In March, after the Toronto-area shootings, Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree earmarked $10 million for Jewish community security, including operations centres that monitor cameras and alarms across institutions.
asserted
that → earmark → institutions
The $75 million followed.
asserted
million → follow → ?
Ottawa has also raised the maximum federal contribution per project to $5 million, from $1.5 million, and community security agencies can apply on behalf of the institutions they serve and decide where the money goes.
asserted
money → raise → institutions
Cooper told The Hub Ottawa also lifted a 90-day annual cap on funded security guards.
asserted
Ottawa → tell → guards
“They’ve almost subcontracted to the Jewish community security institutions to decide what is best for the community, and that’s a positive evolution,” Cooper said.
asserted
Cooper → subcontract → community
We’ve been fighting for it.”
asserted
We → fight → it
“The government after Belleville wanted to pony up extra money to pay 100 percent of all the costs that are now being implemented in the synagogue, but the community jumped in much quicker,” he said, calling Anandasangaree “one of the better ministers” he has dealt with.
asserted
he → want → ministers
Still, gaps remain.
asserted
gaps → remain → ?
“Right now, the government doesn’t give operational funding,” Cooper said.
asserted
Cooper → give → funding
Public Safety Canada’s published price caps are also out of date, he said.
asserted
he → publish → date
…and 21 more, not listed.