Judge awards damages to both sides in lawsuit after neighbours' dispute over loose dogs 'spun out of control
asserted
dispute → award → control
'Robert Frost knew fences make good neighbours,' Justice Sheldon Lanchbery wrote in decision
A judge has awarded an eastern Manitoba couple sued by their neighbour $10,000 in damages, and their neighbour $1,000, after an "unfortunate series of events" unfolded over dogs allowed to run loose on an unfenced property.
asserted
series → know → property
The couple — a man and woman, named as the defendants in a lawsuit filed with Manitoba Court of King's Bench — purchased their "dream property" along the Winnipeg River, in the rural municipality of Alexander, in 2015, Justice Sheldon Lanchbery wrote in a Nov. 16 decision.
asserted
Lanchbery → name → decision
The property has a large forested area, with walking trails, that shielded them from their neighbours, and offered an escape from the "hustle and bustle of the real world," Lanchbery wrote.
asserted
Lanchbery → have → world
Around 2017, a woman — the plaintiff in the suit — purchased the adjacent property to the east, and decided it would be "a great location" to raise rescue dogs, the decision says.
asserted
decision → purchase → dogs
Though she lacked prior experience in handling rescues, she registered a business as a dog rescue — an idea that "originated during a course of employment on an Indigenous reserve," where dogs roamed freely, Lanchbery wrote.
asserted
Lanchbery → lack → reserve
She decided to also let the dogs she rescued roam on her new property.
asserted
she → decide → property
"The dogs in question are best described as feral," Lanchbery wrote, and their "aggressive tendencies" continued post-rescue.
asserted
tendencies → describe → -
Justice Sheldon Lanchbery decided against awarding legal costs to either party, saying in his decision they 'were painfully aware this was not their finest hour.'
asserted
this → decide → decision
Although the municipality had bylaws in place to restrict the number of dogs a landowner can have on their property, the woman "far exceeded that number," the judge wrote.
asserted
judge → have → number
"The evidence as to the precise number is inconsistent," but she had at least seven prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, Lanchbery wrote.
asserted
Lanchbery → have → pandemic
The couple said they "did not dare go walking" in the forested area of their property because of the dogs.
asserted
they → say → dogs
The man in the couple testified one of the woman's dogs bit his shin.
asserted
one → testify → shin
He also suffered a contusion on one of his hands after he punched the animal, Lanchbery wrote.
asserted
Lanchbery → suffer → animal
'A lot of talking, but not a lot of listening'
The woman had a dog kennel on her property, but the dogs were not always kept there and were not leashed when outside it
asserted
dogs → have → it
, the decision says.
asserted
decision → say → ?
The woman believed the dogs "should be able to roam," which included defecating on the couple's property.
asserted
which → believe → property
There were early attempts to resolve the conflict, which Lanchbery described as "a lot of talking, but not a lot of listening.
asserted
Lanchbery → be → listening
"
Accusations "flew back and forth," and "a first-year law student knows what follows next," wrote Lanchbery.
asserted
Lanchbery → flew → ?
Building a fence between their properties could have solved their problem.
uncertain
Building → build → problem
Security cameras were installed, and both parties started to photograph and film each other near the property line.
asserted
parties → instal → line
Land surveys were also ordered and boulders were placed near where the dog owner believed the property line was, but another survey done by the couple showed she was incorrect, the decision says.
asserted
decision → order → couple
The woman then approached the couple to ask if they would help pay for a fence to keep her dogs from entering their property.
asserted
they → approach → property
The couple refused, in part because they felt it was the woman's responsibility to control her dogs, Lanchbery wrote.
asserted
Lanchbery → refuse → dogs
He quoted American poet Robert Frost, who "knew fences make good neighbours."
"Building a fence between their properties could have solved their problem," wrote Lanchbery.
uncertain
Lanchbery → quote → problem
Both sides guilty of trespassing
Disputes continued between the parties.
asserted
Disputes → continue → parties
The woman purchased a "large, cumbersome" dock, and instead of putting it on her own property, she placed it on the couple's.
asserted
she → purchase → couple
"I find if the dock was to be placed in the Winnipeg River, the easiest unimpeded point of access to transport the dock into the Winnipeg River was on the east side of … [the dog owner's] property, not on the west side [closer to the neighbours]," wrote Lanchbery.
asserted
Lanchbery → find → ]
The couple put up "no trespassing" signs, " adding to … [the dog owner's] frustration," he wrote.
asserted
he → put → frustration
The woman later accused the couple of trespassing and filed her lawsuit, after the man threw broken boards from the dock into her dog kennel.
asserted
man → accuse → kennel
One of her dogs suffered an eye injury, but the judge said evidence suggested it likely wasn't from the boards.
uncertain
it → suffer → boards
The man admitted he had thrown the boards into the kennel, but denied the dog was present when he did so.
asserted
he → admit → kennel
There was no evidence the dog was in the kennel at the time, Lanchbery wrote.
asserted
Lanchbery → be → time
The judge concluded, however, that both parties were guilty of trespassing — the couple by throwing the deck boards into the kennel, and the woman by letting her dogs run loose.
asserted
dogs → conclude → kennel
He awarded the couple $10,000 in aggravated and general damages for the woman's failure to control her dogs, which was ongoing behaviour, compared to the couple's single instance of trespassing, he said.
asserted
he → award → trespassing
He also awarded the couple an extra $100 because the woman placed her dock on their property, and parked cars there too, which he said was "an inconvenience at best."
asserted
he → award → cars
Lanchbery awarded the dog owner $1,000, saying the man's conduct in throwing the boards was "especially egregious" given that he has previous military experience, including training other members in hand-to-hand combat.
asserted
he → award → combat
The couple's lawyer had argued that given that background, the man had actually "exercised great restraint in not injuring" the woman's dogs, but the judge rejected that argument.
asserted
judge → argue → argument
"Removing boards from [her] dock and propelling them into a run are an intentional act of intimidation," he wrote.
asserted
he → remove → intimidation
The judge decided awarding legal costs to either party was not justified, given their conduct throughout the dispute.
asserted
awarding → decide → dispute
…and 1 more, not listed.