Global climate talks that should have concluded on Friday remain deadlocked, with negotiators expected to resume discussions on Sunday in Antalya, Turkey, amid questions about the strategy of Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen in leading the summit.
asserted
negotiators → conclude → summit
Nations remain at loggerheads over a series of key issues.
asserted
Nations → remain → issues
Small island nations that are vulnerable to climate change, including in the Pacific, insist that any final agreement, known as a cover text, include specific reference to reducing fossil fuel emissions.
asserted
agreement → include → emissions
But that position has been objected to by oil-producing nations led by Saudi Arabia, and supported by Russia and some developing nations.
asserted
position → object → Russia
Some nations in the same bloc have objected to a proposed agreement championed by Bowen to have the world commit to making 35 per cent of its energy use electric by 2035.
asserted
cent → object → 2035
“Things worth doing, in my experience, don’t come easy,” Bowen said during a press conference at the COP on Saturday.
asserted
Bowen → do → Saturday
“And I’ll tell you what’s worth doing is electrification.
asserted
’s → tell → you
Electrification is the key to transitioning away from fossil fuels.”
asserted
Electrification → transition → fuels
Led by France and Panama, representatives from nations including Belgium, Côte d’Ivoire, Finland, Greece, Guatemala, Spain, Sweden and Vanuatu are demanding more ambitious climate action.
asserted
representatives → lead → action
“We cannot [tell] the world we are now getting to 1.5 [degrees of warming] and then do business as if nothing was happening,” said France’s minister for ecological transition, Monique Barbut.
asserted
minister → tell → transition
There is also disagreement over climate finance, and European Union Climate Commissioner Wopke Hoekstra called demands for increased pledges for finance from developing nations hit by climate disasters “dead in the water” before the talks even began.
asserted
talks → be → water
Finance has long between a contentions issue at climate talks, with developed nations wanting to maintain focus on reducing emissions, and developing nations demanding financial assistance to help them insulate their economies from the impact of warming that they did not cause.
asserted
they → have → that
The dispute is becoming more complex as the talks continue, with donor nations arguing that some countries that were considered poor when the first climate agreements were made have since become more wealthy and should no longer be receiving support.
asserted
agreements → become → support
While UN scientific assessments say that any effort to stabilise the climate will need to include removing carbon pollution from the atmosphere when the technology to do so at scale becomes available later in the century, many say that including reference to it now will simply be used as justification not to pursue emission reductions.
asserted
including → say → reductions
If the standoff cannot be resolved, UN rules allow for the talks to be suspended until next year.
asserted
talks → resolve → year
That outcome would be a blow to Bowen, who created the role of president of negotiations at the talks when Australia failed to secure the hosting rights in a standoff with Turkey.
asserted
Australia → create → Turkey
Though it is not unusual for COP negotiations, which demand consensus agreement between the almost 200 signatories of the Paris Accord, to extend beyond deadline, they have only ever once
asserted
they → demand → deadline
been suspended without an outcome, when Kyoto Protocol talks collapsed in 2000.
asserted
talks → suspend → 2000
By Friday evening in Antalya, frustrated activists had begun to blame Bowen and his Turkish counterpart, Turkish Environment Minister Murat Kurum, for the failure of the COP to command support for ambitious climate action.
asserted
activists → begin → action
“The COP presidents want to tell us this has been a great COP,” said Mohamed Adow, head of the climate group Power Shift Africa at a press conference convened by the Climate Action Network.
asserted
Adow → want → Network
“Well, I can tell you without any doubt that this has been the worst COP ever.”
asserted
this → tell → doubt
Others have questioned Bowen’s strategy of allowing nations to insert many ambitious claims in an early draft of the cover decision, and of even insisting that the talks include such a decision in the first place.
uncertain
talks → question → place
Leading climate analyst Bill Hare, the director of Climate Analytics – a global non-profit climate science and policy institute – said Bowen made the right call, particularly given the UN’s scientific report published before the COP which said the world was set to miss its 1.5-degree target.
asserted
world → lead → target
“The urgency of the crisis is visible to everyone, and if the COP didn’t do anything visible about the urgency in a political sense, there would be bigger questions about there was any point [in the process] at all,” Hare said.
asserted
Hare → do → process
“I think Bowen is right and correct and courageous to say we need to have a cover decision because it anchors things and provides a focal point for making some decent political signals.
asserted
it → think → signals
Get to the heart of what’s happening with climate change and the environment.
asserted
what → get → change