Advocates fear it could be severed in fight over federal bill
Meta says Bill C-22 could force it to 'consider' withdrawing encrypted services
When Raymond Gukiina came to Canada in 2022 as a refugee, he used WhatsApp to stay in touch with his family back home in Uganda.
uncertain
he → fear → Uganda
But Gukiina also turned to the popular messaging app to help other refugees and asylum seekers who were struggling to find safe places to live amid a housing crisis in Toronto.
asserted
who → turn → Toronto
"We opened up a WhatsApp group that had mostly refugees that were sent out of the shelters or living on the streets ... to share information" about shelter beds and other services, the 26-year-old said.
asserted
old → open → beds
Gukiina, now executive director of the National Network for Immigrants and Refugees-Canada, a non-profit that grew out of the WhatsApp group, said the platform remains key for newcomers to get support in their new communities and maintain ties to loved ones abroad.
asserted
newcomers → grow → ones
But a recent Senate committee hearing has fuelled concerns that a lawful access bill being advanced by the federal government could affect messaging services such as WhatsApp and cut vulnerable people off from the platform they rely on.
uncertain
they → fuel → platform
Raymond Gukiina says WhatsApp is a key tool for refugees and other newcomers to Canada.
asserted
WhatsApp → say → Canada
That's because major tech companies have said they may be forced to suspend services that offer end-to-end encryption if the controversial legislation, known as Bill C-22, which would give law enforcement more access to private communications and data, comes into force.
uncertain
which → say → force
"Shutting it down [would be] really a tragedy," Gukiina said of WhatsApp.
asserted
Gukiina → shut → WhatsApp
Alina Murad, director of federal government relations at The Refugee Centre, a non-profit group in Montreal, also described WhatsApp as "a very, very crucial tool" in the refugee resettlement and integration processes.
asserted
Murad → describe → processes
"It's a lifeline in many ways," she said.
asserted
she → say → ways
"So if you take away this tool that, for the most part, everyone in the world is familiar with and knows how to use with ease, it leaves people vulnerable — extremely vulnerable."
asserted
it → take → people
The legislation
Bill C-22, which is being studied in the Senate, would require technology companies to adapt their systems to be able to provide private communications to Canadian law enforcement and the CSIS spy agency during investigations.
asserted
which → study → investigations
Companies would also be forced to retain users' metadata for six months.
asserted
Companies → force → months
The government has said the measures will help create "a modernized legal framework that helps ensure that CSIS can investigate threats to the security of Canada and law enforcement agencies can effectively detect, deter and respond to crime.
asserted
CSIS → say → crime
But at a Senate committee hearing on Monday, representatives for Meta, which owns WhatsApp, and Signal, another encrypted messaging service, said Bill C-22 would hamper their ability to offer end-to-end encryption in Canada.
asserted
C-22 → own → Canada
Rachel Curran, Meta's head of public policy for Canada, said the company "would need to consider" withdrawing affected services — effectively, WhatsApp — if the legislation passes.
asserted
legislation → say → WhatsApp
"In a similar situation, when Apple was served with a technical assistance order that it could not comply with without weakening or breaking encryption in the U.K., it chose to withdraw those affected services from the market," she said.
uncertain
she → serve → market
"And I think we would need to consider the same option."
asserted
we → think → option
Udbhav Tiwari, vice-president of strategy and global affairs at Signal, also told the Senate committee on Monday that the firm would be forced to either "engineer a vulnerability" into its platform or refuse to comply with the law.
asserted
firm → tell → law
"And at that point in time, we will have no choice but not to serve Canadian users."
asserted
we → have → users
David Taylor, a spokesperson for Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree, told CBC News in an email Friday that the legislation does "not permit or require companies to introduce systemic vulnerabilities or so-called 'back doors.'
asserted
legislation → tell → vulnerabilities
"
Amendments adopted in the House of Commons also clarify that "service providers cannot be required to break encryption or introduce systemic vulnerabilities, that ministerial authorities cannot be used in place of judicial warrants and that any data-related requirements are strictly limited to metadata, with reduced retention periods and clear legal thresholds," Taylor said.
asserted
Taylor → adopt → periods
"The proposals on encryption in C-22 are similar to those in Australia, where WhatsApp continues to operate.
asserted
WhatsApp → continue → Australia
Nevertheless, the legislation has fuelled fears that WhatsApp service could be affected.
uncertain
service → fuel → fears
WhatsApp says more than three billion people around the world use its platform.
asserted
people → say → platform
While usage varies by country, a 2023 survey by the U.S.-based Pew Research Center found that it had "broad reach" in middle-income countries in particular.
asserted
it → vary → countries
Ashika Niraula, a senior research associate at Toronto Metropolitan University's Global Migration Institute, studies how highly skilled migrants and international students use digital platforms before and after they get to Canada.
asserted
they → study → Canada
WhatsApp says more than three billion people around the world use the messaging platform.
asserted
people → say → platform
She said WhatsApp groups — where more than 1,000 people can exchange messages in a single digital space — have emerged as a key place for newcomers to get information about life in Canada.
asserted
newcomers → say → Canada
That ranges from how to rent an apartment, open a bank account or find affordable groceries to navigating the Canadian immigration process.
asserted
That → range → process
The group chats help newcomers feel less isolated while creating a place to speak openly with people who share their cultural backgrounds or languages and have gone through similar experiences, Niraula said.
asserted
Niraula → help → experiences
"It can help [make] settling into a new country feel less overwhelming.
asserted
settling → help → country
"
Encryption offers 'level of safety'
asserted
Encryption → offer → safety
At the same time, WhatsApp remains an easy and cost-effective way for newcomers to stay in touch with relatives in their home countries, said Lauren Lallemand, co-executive director of the Canadian Council for Refugees.
asserted
Lallemand → remain → Refugees
"Not being able to get back in touch with your family members who you've been separated from" can have very real effects, including on peoples' mental health, she said.
asserted
she → get → health
"If it's no longer possible to use WhatsApp in Canada but it continues to be available across most other countries ... there's a sense of people in Canada being left behind."
asserted
people → use → Canada
Lallemand also said the fact that WhatsApp is encrypted "provides some level of safety" for people who fled persecution in their home countries — and losing that encryption could put them at risk.
uncertain
losing → say → risk
"People who are journalists, human rights defenders, refugees in Canada — they often already face repression transnationally, like surveillance threats and intimidation by foreign governments," she said.
asserted
she → face → governments
"So it is doubly dangerous to be introducing laws that could further target communities that are already very vulnerable."
uncertain
that → introduce → communities