OTTAWA - In June, Prime Minister Mark Carney told Canadians that the country’s emissions would be higher “in the next few years” than previously projected.
asserted
emissions → tell → years
Those projections already said Canada would miss its 2030 emissions target under the Paris climate accord.
asserted
Canada → say → accord
The government’s own projections — published in its emissions reductions progress report a year ago — showed a best-case scenario of a 28 per cent reduction in emissions from 2005 levels in 2030.
asserted
projections → publish → 2030
And that was before the Carney government introduced a suite of climate policy rollbacks over the past year, including a delay to the introduction of more stringent tailpipe emissions.
asserted
government → introduce → emissions
That measure was supposed to take the place of the now-scrapped electric vehicle sales mandate; it won’t come into effect now until at least 2029.
asserted
it → suppose → 2029
Canada’s commitment under the Paris agreement was to cut emissions by between 40 to 45 per cent of 2005 levels.
asserted
commitment → cut → levels
The government of Stephen Harper set a target of 30 per cent.
asserted
government → set → cent
This week, Environment Minister Julie Dabrusin insisted Canada is committed to its Paris commitments.
asserted
Canada → insist → commitments
That claim earned her some public criticism from two of her predecessors while she attended the United Nations climate conference in Turkey last week.
uncertain
she → earn → Turkey
Dabrusin wouldn’t answer when asked whether that commitment includes the 2030 target.
asserted
commitment → answer → target
In its public statements, the government has leaned on the target of achieving net-zero by 2050.
asserted
government → lean → 2050
All the studies suggest Canada won’t meet its target.
asserted
Canada → suggest → target
The government’s own projections say it will miss it.
asserted
it → say → it
The prime minister himself acknowledged emissions are on the rise.
asserted
emissions → acknowledge → rise
So why hasn’t the federal government said it is no longer committed to the 2030 target?
asserted
it → say → target
“I think they’re afraid to come out and say it because it’s putting in people’s faces that they’re making a choice to make wildfires worse, to make flooding worse, to actually leave a worse world for our children,” said Keith Stewart, senior energy strategist with Greenpeace Canada.
asserted
Stewart → think → Canada
“Julie Dabrusin seems like a very nice person.
asserted
Dabrusin → seem → person
But she’s going to go down in history as the worst environment minister in Canada’s history because it’s been on her watch that Canada has rolled back environment and climate policies in a way that not even Stephen Harper attempted.”
asserted
Harper → go → way
Asked whether Dabrusin has been put in the job to defend Carney’s policy choices, Stewart said nobody is under the impression that she is “calling the shots.”
asserted
she → ask → shots
“This is clearly coming from the prime minister.
asserted
This → come → minister
But she’s at that cabinet table and she’s standing behind those decisions.
asserted
she → ’ → decisions
And as someone who has said she’s committed to action on climate change, her other option is to resign in protest to make it clear that this is unacceptable,” Stewart said.
asserted
Stewart → say → protest
“If being at a cabinet table is more important to you than having the right decisions come out of the cabinet table, that’s a choice a politician can make.”
asserted
politician → have → table
In a statement, Dabrusin’s office said Canada is “committed to its Paris agreement of achieving net-zero by 2050.”
asserted
Canada → say → 2050
The statement did not address a direct question of whether Canada is still committed to its 2030 target.
asserted
Canada → address → target
“We cannot achieve our climate goals when we are divided,” wrote Amy Falkner, Dabrusin’s press secretary.
asserted
Falkner → achieve → goals
“Our focus is on results that unite Canadians: building major clean energy projects across the country, driving mass electrification, making significant investments in the low-carbon economy, and working in co-operation with provinces, territories and Indigenous Peoples.”
asserted
that → unite → provinces
Falkner added that Canada is still committed to reporting its progress under the Net-Zero Accountability Act as required in December 2027, and will report on its 2030 target next month to the United Nations Climate Change Secretariat — as required under the Paris Agreement.
asserted
Canada → add → Agreement
The act doesn’t set out any fines or penalties for Canada missing or abandoning its climate targets.
asserted
Canada → set → targets
At Thursday’s meeting of the House of Commons environment committee, B.C. Conservative MP Ellis Ross grilled Canada’s interim environment commissioner on what purpose the act even serves.
asserted
act → grill → purpose
“It seems like everybody agrees, except government, that they’re not going to meet their targets.
asserted
they → seem → targets
So when the government is clearly falling short of emissions targets, and in actuality intends to expand its emissions, what exactly does the Net-Zero Accountability Act do?” Ellis asked.
asserted
Ellis → fall → what
“We’ve been talking about (emissions) for the better part of 20 years.
asserted
We → talk → years
But in terms of the 2030 commitments and 2050 commitments, we’re not going to meet it.
asserted
we → go → it
So does the Net-Zero Accountability Act mean anything today?”
asserted
Act → mean → anything
Elsa Da Costa, the interim environment commissioner, replied that the act was an “important tool” for her office to hold the government to account.
asserted
office → reply → account
The Angus Reid Institute released an online poll of 1,770 Canadians in July which suggested climate was the top issue for 21 per cent of respondents.
uncertain
climate → release → respondents
The poll also suggested the Liberals’ track record on climate might be driving one in six Liberal voters to the NDP.
uncertain
record → suggest → NDP
The poll found climate was the top concern for half of NDP supporters.
asserted
climate → find → supporters
The Canadian Research Insights Council, an industry organization that promotes polling standards, says online surveys cannot be assigned a margin of error because they do not randomly sample the population
Aside from the political repercussions of publicly abandoning its commitment to the 2030 emission targets, Stewart said there are also legal implications.
asserted
Stewart → promote → targets
…and 11 more, not listed.