An Alabama appeals court has overturned part of a divorce settlement after finding that a lower court wrongly excluded a surgeon's medical-business investments from the couple's marital assets.
asserted
court → overturn → assets
The woman had worked and helped meet household expenses while her husband completed medical training.
asserted
husband → work → training
The case has now been sent back for a fresh assessment of the couple's property.
asserted
case → send → property
Sarah Gordon and Charles Gordon married in 2011, the year Charles completed medical school.
asserted
Charles → marry → school
He subsequently underwent an internship, a five-year orthopaedic surgery residency and a spine-surgery fellowship.
asserted
He → undergo → internship
During this period, Sarah worked as a nanny and took up other jobs to help pay household expenses.
asserted
Sarah → work → expenses
Charles completed his fellowship in 2018, after which the couple moved to Baldwin County.
asserted
couple → complete → County
He joined Baldwin Bone and Joint, an orthopaedic practice, and became a partner in 2020 or 2021 after borrowing money from First Horizon Bank.
asserted
He → join → Bank
Sarah, meanwhile, became a full-time homemaker and had no separate income.
asserted
Sarah → become → income
In its November 20, decision, the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals
ruled that the husband's business interests should have been considered marital property.
asserted
interests → rule → Appeals
It reversed the property division and directed the lower court to determine their value and reconsider the distribution.
asserted
It → reverse → distribution
However, it did not specify what share Sarah should receive.
asserted
Sarah → specify → share
Financial disputes during divorce
Sarah filed for divorce in February 2024.
asserted
Sarah → file → February
The trial court subsequently ordered the couple to maintain their existing financial arrangements and prohibited them from disposing of assets acquired during the marriage without permission.
asserted
court → order → permission
Sarah later accused Charles of restricting her access to bank accounts and credit cards.
asserted
Sarah → accuse → accounts
She also alleged that he had withdrawn around $183,000 from their joint checking account.
asserted
he → allege → account
Under a temporary agreement adopted by the court in October 2024, Charles was required to place the withdrawn money in an interest-bearing account, resume depositing his salary into the joint account and transfer another $20,000.
asserted
Charles → adopt → 20,000
He was also directed to restore Sarah's access to their financial accounts.
asserted
He → direct → accounts
Sarah subsequently alleged that Charles had issued three cheques totalling $19,400 after depositing the additional money.
asserted
Charles → allege → money
She also complained that he had again restricted her access to the joint account.
asserted
he → complain → account
Charles admitted during the trial that he had stopped depositing his salary into the account around May 2024 and again around February 2025.
uncertain
he → admit → February
He also acknowledged removing Sarah as an authorised credit-card user, saying her spending exceeded what he could afford.
uncertain
he → acknowledge → what
Court rejects request to postpone trial
In October 2025, Sarah sought $30,000 towards expert assistance and legal expenses, saying she needed professionals to examine her husband's assets.
asserted
professionals → reject → assets
The final hearing was scheduled for December 8, 2025.
asserted
hearing → schedule → December
Three days before the trial, she sought a postponement, saying she could not afford a forensic accountant and had recently discovered a bank account and credit card for which she had not received records.
uncertain
she → seek → records
The trial judge rejected the request, noting that the divorce case had been pending since February 2024.
asserted
case → reject → February
The appeals court upheld that decision.
asserted
court → uphold → decision
It said Sarah had raised the need for expert assistance in October but waited until shortly before the hearing to seek a postponement.
asserted
Sarah → say → postponement
Her lawyer had also failed to explain what an accountant might discover or how the findings would affect the case.
uncertain
findings → fail → case
Medical businesses should be included
The main issue in the appeal was Charles's ownership interests in Baldwin Bone and Joint, a surgery centre and other medical consulting businesses.
asserted
issue → include → Bone
During the trial, Sarah submitted an assessment estimating that Charles's 15.38% interest in Baldwin Bone and Joint Medical Center, LLC, was worth $219,491.
asserted
interest → submit → Bone
The calculation was based on a September 2025 balance sheet.
asserted
calculation → base → sheet
The lower court admitted the document but treated the business as Charles's separate estate.
asserted
court → admit → estate
It also declined to accept a tax document relating to the surgery centre as a valuation.
asserted
It → decline → valuation
Charles had invested $150,000 in that centre but maintained that its shares were "worth nothing" because the business was operating at a loss.
asserted
business → invest → loss
The appeals court found that the business interests had been acquired during the marriage.
asserted
interests → find → marriage
Charles completed his medical training seven years after the wedding and purchased his medical-practice partnership interest in 2020 or 2021.
asserted
Charles → complete → 2020
There was no evidence that he had acquired these interests before marriage or received them through gifts or inheritance.
asserted
he → be → gifts
Under the law, property accumulated during marriage can form part of the marital estate.
asserted
property → accumulate → estate
The appeals court said the lower court had no sufficient evidence to classify the businesses as Charles's separate property.
asserted
court → say → property
…and 14 more, not listed.