Photo via Fox News

Kirk family has powerful evidence — but Utah law could derail wrongful death case: experts

Read the original at Fox News ↗
Cite

Mallon, E. (2026, September 19). Kirk family has powerful evidence — but Utah law could derail wrongful death case: experts. Fox News. https://www.foxnews.com/politics/kirk-family-powerful-evidence-utah-law-could-derail-wrongful-death-case

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

Fox News · collected 2026-09-19 · by Elaine Mallon

Quick Summary

Attorneys for the Kirk family filed a notice of intent to sue Utah Valley University on September 9, one day before Charlie Kirk's assassination anniversary. They allege security failures such as inadequate police presence and ineffective safety measures during his visit in Orem. However, legal experts warn that Utah’s government immunity law shields entities from lawsuits involving reckless actions like assault or battery, making it difficult for the family to prevail in their wrongful death case. The challenge stems from UVU Police Chief Jeffrey Long's assurances of security despite known risks, which could be key evidence if the court deems UVU assumed a duty to protect Kirk.
Written by AI on 2026-09-19, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

The family of Charlie Kirk, a conservative activist killed by a rooftop shooter at Utah Valley University (UVU) on September 10, 2025, has taken legal action against the university and state officials. The filing claims that UVU and Utah officials failed to implement adequate security measures, such as drone surveillance of rooftops, despite being aware of potential threats. Attorneys argue these failures made Kirk vulnerable during his campus event. However, a Utah government immunity law may shield UVU from liability in wrongful death lawsuits unless specific exceptions apply.

Written for “Charlie Kirk Family Lawsuit Against Utah” on 2026-11-21, grounded in this article and the 6 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

6 outlets covered “Charlie Kirk Family Lawsuit Against Utah”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

Fox NewsThis outlet19 Sep

Attorneys for the Kirk family filed a notice of intent to sue Utah Valley University on September 9, one day before Charlie Kirk's assassination anniversary. They allege security failures such as inadequate police presence and ineffective safety measures during his visit in Orem. However, legal experts warn that Utah’s government immunity law shields entities from lawsuits involving reckless actions like assault or…

Kirk family has powerful evidence — but Utah law could derail wrongful death case: experts (this article)2 articles from Fox News on this story
Washington Examiner16 Sep

Charlie Kirk’s family has filed a notice of claim against the state of Utah and Utah Valley University (UVU) following his assassination at UVU in September 2025. The lawsuit alleges that inadequate security, despite promises to protect attendees from rooftops overlooking the event area, led to Kirk's death. Brett Parkinson, representing the family, argues that the failure to provide adequate security was a direct…

Charlie Kirk’s family one step closer to lawsuit against Utah and university where he was killed →
BBC16 Sep

Charlie Kirk's family has filed a legal notice against Utah Valley University and state officials, alleging "stunning failures" that led to Kirk’s assassination during a campus event. The notice claims inadequate security measures made Kirk an easy target when he was shot by a gunman on a roof while speaking at the university. The filing names UVU, local police, and other officials as parties who failed to protect…

Charlie Kirk's family alleges 'stunning failures' by Utah officials led to his assassination →
The Guardian16 Sep

Charlie Kirk's family filed a wrongful death notice against Utah Valley University (UVU) officials, alleging their negligence led to Kirk's fatal shooting during an outdoor debate on September 10, 2025. The incident occurred in Orem, Utah, where UVU failed to implement basic safety measures like drone surveillance and coordination with local law enforcement, leaving Kirk exposed to a sniper from over 400 feet away…

Charlie Kirk's family blame Utah university officials for his killing →
ABC News (AU)17 Sep

The family of Charlie Kirk, who was killed by a sniper at Utah Valley University during his debate tour, has filed a wrongful death notice against university officials and the state of Utah. They claim that inadequate security measures put him in danger, citing insufficient police presence, lack of rooftop surveillance, and no bag checks or metal detectors. The notice alleges negligence leading to Kirk being taken…

Charlie Kirk's family says officials failed to protect him before attack →
New York Post19 Sep

The Kirk family is facing significant legal challenges in their wrongful death lawsuit against Utah Valley University over Charlie Kirk’s assassination. They filed a notice of intent to sue on September 9, alleging security failures by the university. However, legal experts warn that Utah’s government immunity law makes it difficult for plaintiffs to win such cases, even if there was reckless behavior involved. The…

Kirk family’s powerful evidence faces legal twist that could upend wrongful death case, experts warn →

Where they agree and split

Framing

How the first headlines put it

Attributed to a source1
Stated as fact3
The headlines (4)

Charlie Kirk's family says officials failed to protect him before attack ABC News (Australia) · attributed to a source

Charlie Kirk’s family one step closer to lawsuit against Utah and university where he was killed Washington Examiner · stated as fact

Charlie Kirk's family alleges 'stunning failures' by Utah officials led to his assassination BBC · stated as fact

Charlie Kirk's family blame Utah university officials for his killing The Guardian · stated as fact

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 7 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 26% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
New York Post
Hedges 10 of 40 claims Outlet record 66/100
Washington Examiner
Hedges 8 of 18 claims Outlet record 67/100
The Guardian
Leans strongly left Hedges 4 of 27 claims Outlet record 64/100
BBC News
Hedges 2 of 15 claims Outlet record 65/100
“While both articles discuss Charlie Kirk's assassination, Article A focuses on the family's accusations of security failures by Utah Valley University and state officials, while Article B discusses legal challenges to a wrongful death lawsuit based on those same failures. They are reporting on related but distinct aspects of the event.”
ABC News (AU)
Leans left Hedges 3 of 28 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Article A describes the family blaming officials after Charlie Kirk's death, while Article B focuses on potential legal challenges to a wrongful death lawsuit notice filed by the family. They describe different stages of the same situation but not the same specific event.”

Story

Charlie Kirk Family Lawsuit Against Utah
Politics · 7 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
39
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
26%
10 of 39 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
withheld
no quote in the article backed the model's score
Publisher signals
66/100
Fox News's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
7
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-09-19 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Fox News · 8349 article(s) · 16 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 16 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Elaine Mallon
56 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
I'm just simply saying that this is yet another step at a time where we could have paused and done this a right way.
Democrats are set to take control of Congress with eight lawmakers backed by the Democratic Socialists of America.
Holguín warned Democrats that keeping Latino voters’ support will depend on delivering results.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio will deliver his first major speech apart from his diplomatic duties Friday following the GOP’s blowout midterm losses, with some attendees at the Federalist Society's National Lawyers Convention eager to hear how he will chart a path forward as the 2028 presidential race draws closer.
And I hope that this new governor — and I think she will — work with us."
I don't know why they would have pushed him to be the candidate there.
"I would absolutely agree that noncitizen voting bans are overwhelmingly popular," Jason Snead, executive director of Honest Elections Project, told Fox News Digital.
May we never have to see the likes of you in this state again."
Democrat Johnny Garcia is projected to win Texas' newly redrawn 35th Congressional District on Tuesday, overcoming a Republican-favored map designed to flip the seat after redistricting pushed Democratic Rep. Greg Casar into another district.
The Fox News Decision Desk projects that Democrat Josh Turek will win Iowa's open U.S. Senate seat, flipping a Republican-held seat as the GOP fights to retain control of the chamber.
Also by Elaine Mallon
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 56 articles by Elaine Mallon →

Topics

Fox News Digital UVU University of Utah Utah Utah Valley University

Subjects

Kirk PERSON · 9× Utah GPE · 5× Fox News Digital ORG · 4× Brown PERSON · 3× Rahmani PERSON · 3× Utah Valley University ORG · 3× UVU ORG · 2× Charlie Kirk's PERSON · 1× Charlie Kirk’s PERSON · 1× Kirks PERSON · 1×

Narrative

" Brown pointed to the case of Mika Scott, a 19-year-old Utah Valley University student who sued Utah County and the Utah County Sheriff's Office after Shawn Leonard, a prisoner with a violent criminal record who had escaped from a work-release program, raped her in 2010.
framing: mixed · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-09-19
A Utah government immunity law could upend the Kirk family’s efforts to bring a wrongful death lawsuit against Utah Valley University over alleged security failures surrounding Charlie Kirk’s assassination.

Claims (39 extracted, 10 hedged)

A Utah government immunity law could upend the Kirk family’s efforts to bring a wrongful death lawsuit against Utah Valley University over alleged security failures surrounding Charlie Kirk’s assassination. uncertain
law → upend → assassination
Attorneys for Kirk’s family filed a notice of intent to sue on Sept. 9, one day before the anniversary of his death. asserted
Attorneys → file → death
The filing alleges a series of security failures by the university, including declining additional police officers, failing to adequately address concerns from Kirk's security team and not having an adequate security plan in place for his visit. asserted
filing → allege → visit
But legal experts say the Kirks face an uphill legal battle because Utah law grants government entities — including their officers and employees — broad immunity from lawsuits arising from a lengthy list of circumstances, including the performance or failure to perform discretionary functions and claims involving assault, battery, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution and civil rights violations. uncertain
law → say → assault
"Unfortunately, Charlie Kirk's family is going to have a very difficult time prevailing in a wrongful death case in Utah," Tenielle Brown, a University of Utah law professor, told Fox News Digital. asserted
Brown → go → Digital
"And that's because Utah's government immunity statute is phrased in such a way that says even if the state and UVU were reckless, they retain immunity in cases that arise out of a battery, and that would include gunshot wounds. asserted
that → phrase → wounds
Kirk, 31, co-founded Turning Point USA in 2012 and grew the conservative youth organization into a major force on high school and college campuses nationwide. asserted
- → co → campuses
He was shot and killed while speaking at Utah Valley University in Orem on Sept. 10, 2025. asserted
He → shoot → Sept.
Neama Rahmani, president of West Coast Trial Lawyers, told Fox News Digital that wrongful death claims against the government are already difficult for plaintiffs to win because government entities generally enjoy broad immunity from lawsuits stemming from assaults or batteries committed by third parties. uncertain
entities → tell → parties
"I've handled lack of security cases, including lack of security cases against the government," Rahmani told Fox News Digital. asserted
Rahmani → handle → Digital
"They are tough because you are trying to hold the police or city, county or state responsible for someone else's criminal actions. asserted
police → try → actions
But Rahmani suggested the Kirk family's strongest evidence could be a message from UVU Police Chief Jeffrey Long acknowledging concerns about rooftop access to the Sorenson Center, a building located "pretty close" to where Kirk was scheduled to speak. uncertain
Kirk → suggest → Center
The Sorenson Center sits directly west of the Losee Center, where prosecutors say Tyler Robinson fired the shot that killed Kirk. asserted
that → sit → Kirk
In response to the security concerns, Long messaged Kirk's team, "I got you covered." asserted
you → message → team
"That means they're gonna argue that they assume the responsibility to make sure Charlie Kirk was safe, and they failed to do so," Rahmani said of the Kirk family. asserted
Rahmani → mean → family
"In cases where you have the government taking on a duty, that tends to be better than simply arguing that the government has a duty to protect everyone because we know that murders happen all the time, and you can't sue the government just because someone is killed. asserted
someone → have → government
But Brown said Utah law can shield government officials from lawsuits even when they fail to perform their job functions. asserted
they → say → functions
"There have been a number of cases where the plaintiffs and the family of the victims have sued for either wrongful death or battery," Brown told Fox News Digital. asserted
Brown → sue → Digital
"And in some cases, the government did behave recklessly, and they could show carelessness and recklessness and the plaintiffs were not able to prevail because it arose out of a battery. uncertain
it → behave → battery
Most states don't have that broad of a statute. asserted
states → have → statute
" Brown pointed to the case of Mika Scott, a 19-year-old Utah Valley University student who sued Utah County and the Utah County Sheriff's Office after Shawn Leonard, a prisoner with a violent criminal record who had escaped from a work-release program, raped her in 2010. asserted
who → point → 2010
"They were supposed to screen inmates to make sure that they weren't violent," Brown told Fox News Digital. asserted
Brown → suppose → Digital
"And then when they went out in the community on the job sites, they were supposed to make sure that they were policing the boundaries so that these inmates couldn't escape and in a really terrible situation. asserted
inmates → go → situation
" "And she could have shown carelessness and maybe even recklessness, but because of the government immunity statute and because this claim arose out of a battery, she was not able to prevail against the state," Brown continued. uncertain
Brown → show → state
The Utah Supreme Court addressed the statute's language in its 2005 decision in Wagner v. Utah, which held that civil battery does not require an intent to cause physical or psychological injury. asserted
battery → address → injury
"The court said, it may not be prudent for the state to continue to retain immunity here," Brown told Fox News Digital. " uncertain
Brown → say → Digital
And they're kind of signaling to the legislature that the legislature should probably change the statute to allow for suits in cases like Charlie Kirk's." asserted
legislature → signal → Kirk
"But the state has not revised the statute and so it still says very clearly that you can't sue the state if the claim arises out of a battery," Brown continued. uncertain
Brown → revise → battery
Brown said state workers who are not elected cannot be held accountable at the ballot box for failing to do their jobs. asserted
who → say → jobs
"The president of UVU, the campus police, those people are not elected, and so if you were to say sovereign immunity is all about letting people decide whether they're state actors or careless at the ballot box, then you vote them out of office asserted
you → elect → office
," Brown said. asserted
Brown → say → ?
"That doesn't work," Brown continued. asserted
Brown → work → ?
"That argument doesn't for the UVU president because nobody can vote them of office, nobody is having any political check on the campus police." asserted
nobody → do → police
Astrid Tuminez, who served as the school's president at the time of Kirk's assassination, stepped down from her position in May 2026 after eight years. uncertain
who → serve → years
She and Long are named in the filing by Kirk's family. asserted
She → name → family
"We are aware of the notice of claim," a Utah Valley University spokesperson said in a statement to Fox News Digital. uncertain
spokesperson → say → Digital
"UVU addresses legal matters consistent with our established processes. asserted
UVU → address → processes
Our focus remains on supporting our campus community." Kirk leaves behind his wife Erika Kirk and their two small children. asserted
Kirk → remain → wife
Fox News Digital reached out to the Kirk family's lawyers for comment. asserted
Digital → reach → comment
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support