Photo via Mother Jones

Did the Lindsay Clancy Trial Need to Happen?

Read the original at Mother Jones ↗
Cite

Oh, I. (2026, August 27). Did the Lindsay Clancy Trial Need to Happen? Mother Jones. https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2026/08/lindsay-clancy-trial-prosecution-motivations-postpartum/

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

Mother Jones · collected 2026-08-27 · by Inae Oh

Quick Summary

The article reports on the trial of Lindsay Clancy, who has been accused of killing her three young children in January 2023, with many arguing that the prosecution's decision to go to trial was unnecessary. According to forensic psychologist Leslie Dobson, prosecutors should have offered a plea agreement and civil commitment instead of pushing for a murder trial. The article notes that due to postpartum psychosis, which affects one to two out of every 1,000 women after giving birth, many are questioning the prosecution's decision. Clancy is likely to be committed to a psychiatric hospital for life regardless of the verdict.
Written by AI on 2026-08-27, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

As of September 2026, Lindsay Clancy's murder trial in Duxbury, Massachusetts ended in a mistrial after five weeks due to a hung jury. The case involves the deaths of Clancy’s three young children—5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson, and 8-month-old Callan—in January 2023. Clancy did not testify but admitted to killing her children while arguing she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time. The prosecution presented over 70 witnesses, including an FBI psychiatrist who testified that he does not believe Clancy heard a voice ordering her actions, suggesting she had control over her decisions.

The defense highlighted systemic failures in mental health support and rallied public sympathy by highlighting the challenges new mothers face when seeking help. However, one juror’s alleged misconduct prompted Clancy's attorney to ask Judge William Sullivan to investigate his phone use during deliberations and review a questionnaire he filled out prior to the trial. The judge is now considering whether Desronvil shared information or used his phone improperly during jury deliberation hours, which lasted seven days without reaching a verdict.

Written for “Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial” on 2026-11-20, grounded in this article and the 112 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

26 outlets covered “Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

Mother JonesThis outlet27 Aug

The article reports on the trial of Lindsay Clancy, who has been accused of killing her three young children in January 2023, with many arguing that the prosecution's decision to go to trial was unnecessary. According to forensic psychologist Leslie Dobson, prosecutors should have offered a plea agreement and civil commitment instead of pushing for a murder trial. The article notes that due to postpartum psychosis…

Did the Lindsay Clancy Trial Need to Happen? (this article)
CBS News22 Sep

Lindsay Clancy's defense lawyer wants the judge to interrogate a single dissenting juror and examine their phone records during her murder trial proceedings. The request follows from developments in the case that also include new insights from a previously undisclosed section of the 60 Minutes interview with Patrick Clancy.

Lindsay Clancy's attorney asks judge to question holdout juror, review his phone records →10 articles from CBS News on this story
NBC News18 Sep

The lone holdout juror in Lindsay Clancy's murder trial will not be giving interviews, according to his lawyer Edward Andrew Paltzik. The juror refused media requests after days of deliberations ended with a mistrial when the jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict on whether Clancy was guilty of murdering her three children. Clancy’s defense argued that she suffered from postpartum psychosis at the time of the…

Holdout Lindsay Clancy juror will not be giving interviews, his attorney says →10 articles from NBC News on this story
Daily Mail21 Sep

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer, Kevin Reddington, has requested that Judge William Sullivan investigate the mobile phone data of juror Michael P. Desronvil, who was the sole holdout against acquitting Clancy in her murder case of three children. The motion also asks the judge to question Desronvil about potential misuse of his phone or outside information during deliberations and the truthfulness of his jury selection…

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer asks judge to probe phone data of holdout juror who refused to acquit killer mother of murdering her three children →10 articles from Daily Mail on this story
The Guardian21 Sep

Lindsay Clancy’s defense lawyers have requested that the judge investigate juror Michael Desronvil for allegedly using a cellphone during jury deliberations and for discrepancies in his pre-trial questionnaire responses. This request comes after a mistrial was declared on September 4 due to the inability of jurors to reach a unanimous verdict, with eleven out of twelve jurors leaning towards acquittal based on…

Lindsay Clancy’s defense laywer asks judge to investigate lone juror →9 articles from The Guardian on this story
CBC21 Sep

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer is requesting the judge to investigate juror Michael Desronvil for allegedly using his cellphone during deliberations and lying on pre-trial questionnaires. The motion seeks to uncover any calls or texts made by Desronvil between specific hours of jury deliberation, as phone use in the courtroom is prohibited. This comes after a mistrial was declared due to the inability to reach a unanimous…

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer wants judge to investigate juror's conduct →9 articles from CBC on this story
Show 20 more outlets
Fox News21 Sep

Lindsay Clancy’s defense lawyer, Kevin Reddington, is demanding an investigation into Juror Doe who prevented a not guilty verdict in Clancy's murder trial involving her three children's deaths. Reddington has requested the court to preserve all juror records and conduct background checks on the holdout juror. He also seeks details on any contact between the prosecutor and Juror Doe, as well as phone records from…

Lindsay Clancy defense demands investigation into holdout juror who blocked not guilty verdict →9 articles from Fox News on this story
The Independent18 Sep

In the Lindsay Clancy trial for killing her three children, juror Michael P Desronvil was the only holdout who refused to accept the not guilty by reason of insanity plea. Despite being accused by fellow jurors of having reasonable doubt, Desronvil claims he consistently believed there was sufficient evidence proving Clancy's guilt. The jury deadlocked 11-1 after over 40 hours of deliberation, leading to a mistrial…

Holdout juror in Clancy trial didn't have 'any doubts' that she was responsible for killing her kids →8 articles from The Independent on this story
New York Post19 Sep

Michael P. Desronvil, the lone holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy trial who refused to agree with the other jurors' decision of not guilty by reason of insanity, is facing severe backlash including death threats and harassment from a group described as a "lunatic mob." His lawyer, Edward Paltzik, stated that Desronvil has received over $330,000 in donations through an online fundraiser aimed at covering security…

Holdout Lindsay Clancy juror Michael P. Desronvil’s lawyer claims client has faced death threats from ‘lunatic mob’ →8 articles from New York Post on this story
BBC22 Sep

Lindsay Clancy’s defense lawyer, Kevin Reddington, has requested a judge to investigate juror Michael Desronvil and examine his phone records during the deliberation period for the mistrial in Clancy’s murder case involving her three children. The lawyer alleges that Desronvil may have misled the court during jury selection and calls into question the validity of his questionnaire responses. Reddington also seeks…

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer asks judge to investigate juror and check his phone →7 articles from BBC on this story
Washington Examiner22 Sep

Lindsay Clancy’s defense attorney, Kevin Reddington, requested that Judge William Sullivan investigate juror Michael Desronvil over alleged cellphone use during the seven-day deliberations that led to a mistrial. The request includes checking if Desronvil made any calls or texts between 8 a.m. and 4:30 p.m. daily during deliberations, as using cellphones is strictly prohibited in Massachusetts courts. Reddington…

Lindsay Clancy defense attorney asks judge to investigate holdout juror over alleged cellphone use →7 articles from Washington Examiner on this story
ABC News (US)18 Sep

Michael P. Desronvil, the lone holdout juror from Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial, told ABC News that he did not have doubts about her guilt during seven days of deliberations. Despite attempts to explain his reasoning, he felt dismissed by other jurors who thought he had doubts based on the evidence presented. The case involved Clancy, who pleaded not guilty to three counts of murder for strangling her three young…

Lone holdout juror in Lindsay Clancy trial says he 'didn't have any doubts' →5 articles from ABC News (US) on this story
Reason18 Sep

Lindsay Clancy's murder trial in Massachusetts ended in a mistrial after a 11-1 deadlock, with Michael Desronvil being the sole vote for conviction. Following this, Desronvil faced scrutiny over his past legal issues including an assault charge and restraining orders. The article explores whether these details influenced his decision or if they were relevant to his jury service eligibility under Massachusetts law…

Lindsay Clancy's Holdout Juror Did What Jurors Are Supposed To Do →3 articles from Reason on this story
ABC News (AU)21 Sep

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer, Kevin Reddington, has requested that a judge investigate juror Michael Desronvil for alleged misconduct during a mistrial in Clancy’s murder case. The mistrial was declared after jurors could not reach a unanimous verdict regarding whether Clancy, accused of killing her three children, was suffering from postpartum psychosis or knew what she was doing. Reddington is asking the court to…

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer asks judge to investigate lone holdout juror →3 articles from ABC News (AU) on this story
The Free Press4 Sep

A psychiatrist and Yale lecturer, Dr. Sally Satel, weighs in on the Lindsay Clancy trial, which ended in a mistrial due to a hung jury after 21 days of testimony and 7 days of deliberation. The jury was unable to decide whether Clancy, who strangled her three young children in January 2023, is guilty of murder or not criminally responsible by reason of insanity. Dr. Satel, who believes Clancy's actions were driven…

I’m a Psychiatrist. Here’s What the Lindsay Clancy Jury Should Have Found. →2 articles from The Free Press on this story
Toronto Star21 Sep

Lindsay Clancy's legal team has requested that a judge investigate one particular juror who wanted to convict her of murdering her three children in Massachusetts. The attorneys are asking for an inquiry into whether this juror used his cellphone during deliberations, if he was truthful on pre-trial questionnaires, and if his testimony under judicial questioning was accurate.

Lindsay Clancy's attorney asks judge to investigate the lone juror who wanted to convict her →2 articles from Toronto Star on this story
Global News4 Sep

Judge William Sullivan plans to declare a mistrial in the case of Lindsay Clancy, who is accused of killing her three young children in 2023, after jurors stated for a third time they couldn't reach a unanimous verdict. This marks the seventh day of deliberations and comes after the judge rejected a request from Clancy's lawyer to question one juror individually about their understanding of reasonable doubt…

Judge says he’ll declare mistrial in Lindsay Clancy case after jury cannot reach a verdict →
The Straits Times4 Sep

A judge has declared a mistrial in the trial of Lindsay Clancy, who is accused of murdering her three young children, after the jury deadlocked. The trial has been ongoing for nearly six weeks and has raised questions about how postpartum mental health is treated in the US. According to testimony, Clancy had struggled with her mental health after giving birth to her third child and was prescribed multiple…

Judge says he must declare mistrial in Lindsay Clancy trial over killing her children →
Persuasion4 Sep

The Lindsay Clancy trial has ended in a mistrial due to a hung jury after 11 jurors voted for acquittal. Clancy, who killed her three children and attempted to kill herself in 2023, was charged with first-degree murder but the focus of the case shifted from guilt to whether she was responsible due to psychosis or deliberate intent. A single juror's dissent led to a mistrial, allowing the prosecution to retry the…

Don’t Celebrate Lindsay Clancy →
South China Morning Post4 Sep

Lindsay Clancy's murder trial has ended in a mistrial after jurors failed to reach a unanimous verdict. A judge declared the mistrial on the seventh day of deliberations, allowing prosecutors to retry Clancy for killing her three young children. The case drew intense public interest and attention to maternal mental health issues. Prosecutors must now decide whether to put Clancy on trial again or drop the charges.

Mistrial declared in Lindsay Clancy child killings case →
NPR4 Sep

Lindsay Clancy, 36, is facing charges for murdering her three young children in Duxbury, Massachusetts in 2023. After six days of deliberation, the jury became deadlocked with one juror dissenting from the other 11, and a mistrial was declared by Judge William Sullivan. The key issue in the case is whether Clancy's severe postpartum psychosis at the time of the murders should exempt her from criminal liability. The…

With jury deadlocked, judge declares a mistrial in Lindsay Clancy's murder case →
The Globe and Mail4 Sep

A judge has declared a mistrial in the murder trial of Lindsay Clancy, who is accused of strangling her three children to death in January 2023 at their home south of Boston. The jury deadlocked after nearly six weeks of deliberation and seven days of deciding whether Ms. Clancy was criminally responsible for the killings amid conflicting testimony about her post-pregnancy mental health. Prosecutors argue that Ms…

The Lindsay Clancy case has been declared a mistrial. Here’s what to know →
Al Jazeera5 Sep

A judge in the case of Lindsay Clancy, a US mother accused of murdering her three children, declared a mistrial after jurors were unable to come to a unanimous decision on a verdict. No specific numbers or details about the voting breakdown are provided. The trial's outcome leaves uncertainty over what will happen next in the case.

Judge declares mistrial in Lindsay Clancy children’s murder case →
National Post5 Sep

The CBC News published an article on September 1 discussing Lindsay Clancy, a Massachusetts mother accused of strangling her three children, and how the case would be treated differently if it had occurred in Canada. According to University of British Columbia law professor Isabel Grant, cited by the CBC, the main issue with Canada's infanticide law is that it does not apply to older children, such as Clancy's 5-…

Pete Baklinski: CBC platforms prof who says Clancy killings make case for looser infanticide law →
The Hindu6 Sep

Lindsay Clancy, 36, is on trial for killing her three young children after pleading not guilty by reason of insanity due to postpartum psychosis. A jury was unable to reach a unanimous verdict, with 11 jurors voting to acquit and one opposing them, resulting in a mistrial declared by Judge William Sullivan. This is the second setback in Clancy's case, following her apparent suicide attempt after the murders that…

Lindsay Clancy trial ends in mistrial over deaths of three children →
Times of India18 Sep

Juror Michael P Desronvil in Lindsay Clancy's murder trial has declared he had no doubts that she deliberately killed her three children, despite a mistrial being declared on September 4. The jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict after nearly 40 hours of deliberations; eleven jurors supported finding Clancy not criminally responsible while Desronvil remained the sole holdout. He stated that physical evidence and…

‘No doubts’: Lone holdout juror says Lindsay Clancy deliberately killed her 3 kids →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

AI · cited, from two or more outlets

  • The mistrial was declared due to jurors being unable to reach a unanimous verdict after seven days of deliberation.125
  • One juror held out against the rest, leading to the deadlock and mistrial.253
Quoted from the coverage (4)

"Based on all the physical evidence, key witnesses, and what the prosecution presents, I thought it was enough proof that she knew exactly what she was doing and planned," the statement read.

9 outlets

A lawyer for Lindsay Clancy is asking a judge to investigate the conduct of the lone juror who wanted to convict the mother from Massachusetts of murder in the deaths of her three young children.

9 outlets

Clancy can be found guilty of first-degree murder, second-degree murder, or manslaughter.

8 outlets

The case gripped the public for the past five weeks, sparking debates about maternal mental health, launching online conspiracy theories and creating dramatic moments both inside the court and out throughout the livestreamed trial.

8 outlets

Disputed

Picked by our model, which is sometimes wrong

  • Clancy's defense attorney claims one juror was biased and unwilling to follow instructions on reasonable doubt, while the holdout juror maintains there was enough evidence to find Clancy guilty.16

Framing

How the first headlines put it

  • The Guardian focuses on the immediate declaration of mistrial and jury deadlock, whereas The Hindu emphasizes the high-profile nature of the case involving a mother accused of killing her children.15
  • ABC News highlights juror statements about the deliberation process leading to the mistrial, while CBS News focuses on the perspective of the holdout juror who believed in Clancy's criminal responsibility.78
Attributed to a source1
Stated as fact3
The headlines (4)

Final witness in Lindsay Clancy trial says he doesn’t believe she heard a voice during killings The Guardian · attributed to a source

Five weeks, 80 witnesses and one agonizing question as Lindsay Clancy trial nears verdict The Independent · stated as fact

Did the Lindsay Clancy Trial Need to Happen? Mother Jones · stated as fact

Lindsay Clancy trial testimony ends, closing arguments set for Thursday CBS News · stated as fact

Words to watch (1)

Lindsay Clancy verdict 'disaster': Legal expert exposes a stunning twist in retrial battle and the 'un-American' admission hidden in jury's note Daily Mail

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 113 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans left and hedges 13% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
The Independent
Hedges 1 of 27 claims Outlet record 59/100
CBS News
Hedges 2 of 52 claims Outlet record 67/100
The Guardian
Hedges 2 of 27 claims Outlet record 64/100
CBC News
Leans left Hedges 7 of 47 claims Outlet record 60/100
The Free Press
Leans left Hedges 0 of 8 claims Outlet record 96/100
BBC News
Hedges 3 of 27 claims Outlet record 65/100

Story

Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial
Crime & Law · 113 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
98
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
13%
13 of 98 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
60/100
Mother Jones's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
113
Crime & Law
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-08-27 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Mother Jones · 595 article(s) · 1 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 1 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Inae Oh
17 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
After spending the last several years licking Donald Trump’s boots with full-throated zeal, Elon Musk is apparently banking on a collective amnesia so stupifying that the public will believe him when he claims that he is “not MAGA.”
In Washington, DC, FBI Director Kash Patel failed to show up to a congressional hearing on global threats, effectively declining an invitation to calm nerves as fears that the outages may be related only mount.
2026-11-18 · assertive framing · The Guys Manning Our Outage Apocalypse Do Not Seem Okay
“It was abundantly clear that without my intervention, the possibility to bring humanitarian aid into the city and to evacuate the elderly would be impossible,” she said in a statement, referring to the Russian-occupied Ukrainian city where war-ravaged residents have subsisted on weed plants due to chronic food shortages.
2026-11-17 · assertive framing · It’s Now or Never for Melania
“That would be an honor,” Elon Musk wrote on Wednesday, responding to an online influencer’s plea for the trillionaire to hire Huang as news of the second affair emerged.
2026-11-12 · mixed framing · Jensen Huang Is Out. The Misogyny Is Forever.
“I am pleased to announce that Mr. Stephen Miller, the current Deputy Chief of Staff of the Trump Administration, and one of my most trusted advisors, will become the Chief of Staff starting Monday, November 9, 2026,” Trump wrote on Truth Social.
After years of lagging sales and multiple high-profile recalls, Elon Musk announced on Friday that Tesla will start closing out production of the Cybertruck in 2027.
2026-11-06 · assertive framing · The Cybertruck Is Dead
After years of lagging sales and multiple high-profile recalls, Elon Musk announced on Friday that Tesla will start closing out production of the Cybertruck in 2027.
2026-11-06 · assertive framing · The Cybertruck Is Dead
“I wasn’t on the Ballot and if I was, we would have won IN A LANDSLIDE!” Trump wrote.
2026-11-04 · assertive framing · Trump’s Midterms Nightmare
“Pretty disappointed that @ProfEmilyOster would choose to lend her credibility to prediction markets (which are, in practice, sportsbooks with a side of wagering on elections and oil futures), particularly when one considers the harm they are bringing to kids and parents,” Elliot Haspel, a senior fellow at the think tank Capita, wrote on social media.
2026-10-29 · assertive framing · The New Faces of Optimized Motherhood
From one angle, the comments could seem critical of Victoria’s Secret.
Also by Inae Oh
It’s Now or Never for Melania
2026-11-17 · Mother Jones
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 17 articles by Inae Oh →

Topics

Facebook Massachusetts Plymouth Yale Law School the Mental Health Justice Clinic

Subjects

Clancy PERSON · 8× Lindsay Clancy PERSON · 3× Facebook ORG · 1× Katie Miller PERSON · 1× Leslie Dobson PERSON · 1× Massachusetts GPE · 1× Patrick PERSON · 1× Patrick Clancy’s PERSON · 1× Plymouth GPE · 1× William Sullivan PERSON · 1×

Narrative

But this expectation that someone in crisis is going to have the wherewithal to go on an online portal to find out the right information, as opposed to trying to make information immediately available to them in any particular moment, or having follow-ups of people who are calling her, is another illustration of how we see how we have a system that’s really based on individual responsibility and an assumption that treatment is easy and that it always works.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-08-27
The scenes unfolding in Judge William Sullivan’s courtroom in Plymouth, Massachusetts, have been excruciating.
2026-08-27 · Mother Jones
Did the Lindsay Clancy Trial Need to Happen? · assertive framing

Claims (98 extracted, 13 hedged)

Over the course of nearly a month, Lindsay Clancy has stood trial for the January 2023 killings of her three young children, a catastrophic tragedy that has riveted the country. asserted
that → stand → country
The scenes unfolding in Judge William Sullivan’s courtroom in Plymouth, Massachusetts, have been excruciating. asserted
scenes → unfold → Plymouth
“I can’t do this,” Clancy sobbed at one point, as testimony about the fatal injuries she inflicted on her children was delivered. asserted
she → do → children
Patrick, Clancy’s former husband, who has publicly forgiven her, took the stand amid viral conspiracy theories suggesting that he was the one who really killed their children. asserted
who → forgive → children
Then there were the family members, including Clancy’s mother and sister, who testified to Clancy’s declining mental health in the months before she killed her children, forcing them to relive the pain of a loved one struggling to get the help she begged for. asserted
she → be → help
Meanwhile, outside the courtroom, hundreds of people, mostly women, have turned up to support Clancy. asserted
hundreds → turn → Clancy
Many argue they could have easily been in her place because of the systemic failures around maternal health. uncertain
they → argue → health
Indeed, postpartum psychosis affects roughly one to two out of every 1,000 women after giving birth. asserted
psychosis → affect → birth
One must wonder if prosecutors ever regret the decision to go to trial. asserted
prosecutors → wonder → trial
“It’s a witch hunt for fame,” forensic psychologist Leslie Dobson told a criminal justice podcast in early August, arguing that prosecutors should have offered a plea agreement and civil commitment rather than push a murder trial. asserted
prosecutors → ’ → trial
“If the prosecutors think they’re winning by winning, they’re horrible people.” asserted
they → think → ?
The rage resonates across social media, where threads pondering the same themes are rampant, and the prosecution’s strategies, including invoking “mortal sin” in questioning Patrick Clancy’s mother, have been roundly condemned. asserted
threads → resonate → mother
“This prosecution is a malicious circus with no benefit,” one observer wrote on Facebook. asserted
observer → write → Facebook
To be sure, Clancy has her detractors. asserted
Clancy → have → detractors
There are those, including prominent right-wing commentators, who call her a “monster” who methodically killed her children and should be punished. asserted
who → be → children
Others, like Katie Miller, go further: “Lindsay Clancy deserves to die for murdering her three children.” asserted
Clancy → go → children
Such exhortations for severe punishment tend to elide two certainties: No one, neither Clancy nor her defense team, disputes that she killed her children. asserted
she → tend → children
Even if she wins, she will be committed, likely for life, to a psychiatric hospital. asserted
she → win → hospital
Which forces an uncomfortable question: Should this ever have gone to trial? asserted
this → force → trial
I spoke with Marisol Orihuela, a clinical professor at Yale Law School and director of the Mental Health Justice Clinic, about the avenues the prosecution could have pursued—and the inherent challenges of evaluating mental health within the American criminal justice system. uncertain
prosecution → speak → system
Let’s start by defining what it means to evaluate competency to stand trial. asserted
it → start → trial
That’s a great question, because the two can often get confused. asserted
two → ’ → ?
Anyone criminally charged in the United States has a due process right to be competent during certain critical moments in criminal proceedings. asserted
Anyone → charge → proceedings
That includes pleading guilty or standing trial. asserted
That → include → trial
When someone does not have a rational understanding of the proceedings or cannot rationally assist in their defense, then they do not have the competency to stand trial, and the prosecution cannot proceed. asserted
prosecution → have → trial
That is different from what we call the insanity defense, or a defense where someone is not criminally responsible for the actions that occurred based on a mental health condition. asserted
that → call → condition
That has more to do with someone’s ability to appreciate right from wrong at the time of the offense. asserted
That → have → offense
My understanding of what the commonwealth is arguing is that Lindsay Clancy wanted to and tried to specifically kill the children and had the intent to kill the children and knew what she was doing. asserted
she → argue → what
It’s really about criminal responsibility, which also matters for what happens after the trial. asserted
what → ’ → trial
In jurisdictions around the country, when someone is acquitted based on a mental health condition, what follows is commitment based on that status. asserted
follows → acquit → status
In the Clancy trial, what incentivizes prosecutors to deliver such a harsh sentence? asserted
what → incentivize → sentence
If we give every benefit of the doubt to the commonwealth in this case, we would have to think that they really believe that she is criminally responsible, that she understood right from wrong. asserted
she → give → wrong
And the way that we give meaning to that is to provide a very lengthy sentence. asserted
we → give → sentence
We call these justifications for sentencing and how to respond to crimes through sentencing. asserted
We → call → sentencing
Another justification is what we call deterrence: an effort to prevent this person from doing it again or to send a message to the rest of the community so nobody else does it. asserted
nobody → call → it
Prosecutors might think that they need to deliver a hefty sentence to send that message. uncertain
they → think → message
But here in this case, Clancy is not going to be free, no matter what happens. asserted
what → go → case
And I think there’s a really good debate about what role deterrence has here. asserted
deterrence → think → role
That you did something really wrong, so we’re going to give meaning to that wrongness by imposing a lengthy sentence—and I think that might be one of the motivators for this prosecution. uncertain
that → do → prosecution
I haven’t watched the whole trial, but the parts I have watched and some of the questions, specifically how they’re phrased by the prosecution, suggest a level of blame-worthiness on Lindsay Clancy, especially for having concerns about taking medication. asserted
they → watch → medication
…and 58 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support