Photo via The Sydney Morning Herald

Cats v Blues player ratings: From Geelong’s ‘Superman’, to those who had ‘horror’ nights for Carlton

Read the original at The Sydney Morning Herald ↗
Cite

Russell, D., & McClure, S. (2026, September 4). Cats v Blues player ratings: From Geelong’s ‘Superman’, to those who had ‘horror’ nights for Carlton. The Sydney Morning Herald. https://www.smh.com.au/sport/afl/cats-v-blues-player-ratings-the-players-who-had-terrible-horror-nights-as-the-fairytale-ends-for-carlton-20260904-p60ulm.html?ref=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_source=rss_feed

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

The Sydney Morning Herald · collected 2026-09-04 · by Danny Russell, Sam McClure

Quick Summary

The article rates the performance of each Carlton player from the elimination final against Geelong at the Melbourne Cricket Ground, where more than 96,000 fans watched the Cats win. Key ratings include Shaun Mannagh with an 8/10 and Max Holmes with a 3/10. The article highlights Jeremy Cameron's struggles to make an impact on the game, noting he "didn't get near the footy" in the first half and was "clearly not right". The ratings suggest that several Carlton players, including Jay Polkinghorne and Michael Edwards, had disappointing nights.
Written by AI on 2026-09-04, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

On September 3, 2026, the Hawthorn Hawks secured a stunning 32-point upset victory over the Fremantle Dockers in Perth to clinch an MCG preliminary final spot. Despite struggling early on and having key players like Josh Treacy enduring tough nights, the Hawks were methodical and decisive with their ball movement throughout the match. Coach Sam Mitchell's tactics proved effective as Hawthorn outplayed Fremantle in crucial aspects of the game, despite Dockers finishing atop the ladder during the regular season. This result marked a significant upset for the minor premier team and set up an exciting home prelim final at the MCG.

Written for “AFL Finals Update 2026” on 2026-11-21, grounded in this article and the 7 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

2 outlets covered “AFL Finals Update 2026”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

Sydney Morning HeraldThis outlet4 Sep

The article rates the performance of each Carlton player from the elimination final against Geelong at the Melbourne Cricket Ground, where more than 96,000 fans watched the Cats win. Key ratings include Shaun Mannagh with an 8/10 and Max Holmes with a 3/10. The article highlights Jeremy Cameron's struggles to make an impact on the game, noting he "didn't get near the footy" in the first half and was "clearly not…

Cats v Blues player ratings: From Geelong’s ‘Superman’, to those who had ‘horror’ nights for Carlton (this article)6 articles from Sydney Morning Herald on this story
ABC News (AU)4 Sep

The article reports on Geelong's win over Carlton in their AFL elimination final by 33 points at the MCG. Patrick Dangerfield led Geelong with five goals in his 378th game, while Geelong secured a solid victory despite an early challenge from Carlton. The loss ends Carlton's fairytale season after they won 12 games and drew one out of 16 matches under new coach Josh Fraser.

Clear and present Danger as Cats sweep aside Carlton →2 articles from ABC News (AU) on this story

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 3% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
The Sydney Morning Herald
Hedges 4 of 53 claims Outlet record 61/100
ABC News (AU)
Hedges 2 of 81 claims Outlet record 67/100
The Sydney Morning Herald
Hedges 1 of 28 claims Outlet record 61/100
The Sydney Morning Herald
Hedges 2 of 67 claims Outlet record 61/100
“Article A discusses a football match between Geelong and Carlton, while Article B mentions the Western Bulldogs' season after an injury to Sam Darcy, who is not mentioned in Article A”
The Sydney Morning Herald
Hedges 0 of 1 claims Outlet record 61/100
“Article A describes an AFL elimination final between Geelong and Carlton, while Article B lists teams for a different game, possibly the finals series but not specifically mentioning Geelong vs. Carlton.”

Story

AFL Finals Update 2026
Sports · 8 article(s) covering the same event. See how they differ ↑
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
71
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
3%
2 of 71 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
61/100
The Sydney Morning Herald's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
8
Sports
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-09-04 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

The Sydney Morning Herald · 7770 article(s) · 16 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 16 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Danny Russell
37 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
On Tuesday, he will ride the same horse in the Melbourne Cup.
“I’ve been involved in horses in one form or another for 50 years, and this is the best horse I’ve ever been involved in, by a considerable margin,” retired school teacher Greg May told this masthead.
The Joseph O’Brien stayer has set European racing alight in the past six months by adopting daring catch-me-if-you can tactics and was expected to turn Tuesday’s 3200m race at Flemington into a gruelling test of stamina that would suit the Europeans.
When three-year-old gelding Doubt Time lines up behind the gates for Saturday’s Coolmore Stud Stakes, stablehand Montanna Gawith-Hutson is confident the horse will be relaxed and ready to race.
A 5am start will be trialled after the spring carnival.
The winner of one, he says, will become a household name.
This guide will be updated when the field is set with comments from Melbourne Cup-winning jockey Michelle Payne assessing each runner’s chances.
As trainer Andrea Leek, who operates stables in Nar Nar Goon North, celebrated becoming the first woman in 32 years to win Australia’s weight-for-age championship with West Australian star Cosmic Crusader, the dual Brownlow winner and his Carlton crew were left to wonder what might have been.
One of the country’s finest trainers will set foot on the vast green lawns at Flemington on Saturday with a serious Cox Plate chance and mixed emotions.
That would take Waller’s total victories in the race to seven and McDonald to five.
Also by Danny Russell
Point Of Law wins the $10.2 million Melbourne Cup
2026-11-03 · The Sydney Morning Herald
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 37 articles by Danny Russell →
Sam McClure
13 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
Carlton’s Lachie Cowan will be banned for two matches next season but teammate Will Hayward will escape AFL punishment after the pair were hospitalised after a house party on Sunday.
The Blues will release a statement on Sunday after reports circulated in the morning that players had required emergency medical care and that recreational drugs had allegedly been involved.
The Kangaroos, when contacted by this masthead, declined to comment on how it would handle the trade in light of the police investigation.
North, where Nick’s father John won two premierships back in the 1990s, are better positioned than the Suns both in draft capital and salary cap space, but the Suns, should they continue their pursuit, will likely have pick seven from the compensation of losing star forward Ben King to Hawthorn, plus the money saved from King’s exit.
Nick Blakey will meet with Geelong as soon as Thursday as he explores a potential move to the Cats amid the rancorous fallout from the Pullman Hotel scandal.
2026-10-07 · assertive framing · Nick Blakey to meet with Cats in trade bombshell
They can spend another trade period arguing over precisely what a 31-year-old Merrett is worth, extracting every last drop from Hawthorn and telling the football world they will not be pushed around.
Jaymie Graham will coach North Melbourne in 2027, after winning the race to fill the role vacated by Alastair Clarkson.
Two industry sources who spoke on the condition of anonymity confirmed to this masthead that Buckley had informed those involved in the process that he will not pursue the vacant position, ruling himself out of a return to senior coaching at Arden Street. Buckley was due to formally present to the coaching panel on Saturday, but told the club late last week that he would be removing himself from the process.
2026-10-04 · assertive framing · Buckley pulls out of North Melbourne coach race
Halfway through the last quarter I would have voted for Dayne Zorko, but Will Ashcroft’s last five minutes were really something and I reckon he’s stiff not to have matched Dusty for three Norms.
The champions of the 1990s and 2000s whose opinions still carry enormous weight in Australian football were not his childhood heroes. “He wouldn’t have grown up watching any of these people, or even knowing who they were,” Nolan said.
Also by Sam McClure
Two Carlton players hospitalised after separate incidents
2026-10-11 · The Sydney Morning Herald
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 13 articles by Sam McClure →

Topics

Blues Carlton Cats Geelong

Subjects

Geelong GPE · 5× Cats ORG · 4× Blues ORG · 3× Carlton GPE · 3× Mannagh PERSON · 2× Sam Walsh PERSON · 2× Danny Russell PERSON · 1× Jacob Weitering PERSON · 1× Jay Polkinghorne PERSON · 1× Sam McClure PERSON · 1×

Narrative

Follow behind-the-scenes intel from AFL finals - Inside Hawks win: The full story behind Will Day’s tears - Player ratings: How Hawks and Dockers fared - Prankster of Princes Park: Why Carlton can’t get enough of Harry Dean - Teams and tips:
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-09-04
4/10 (3) Bailey Smith: Struggled to shake off a Cooper Lord tag early and would have been annoyed that his opponent kicked two goals.

Claims (71 extracted, 2 hedged)

The fairytale had to end at some stage for the Blues, and it happened at the MCG in front of more than 96,000 fans as the finals-hardened Cats flexed their muscles right when they needed to most. asserted
they → have → muscles
Danny Russell (Geelong) and Sam McClure (Carlton) rate every Carlton player’s performance from the blockbuster elimination final. asserted
Russell → rate → final
The latest to suffer the curse of the big forward during this finals series, he found it hard to break free and was monstered by Jacob Weitering in several marking contests but did manage a goal. asserted
it → suffer → goal
4/10 (3) Bailey Smith: Struggled to shake off a Cooper Lord tag early and would have been annoyed that his opponent kicked two goals. asserted
opponent → struggle → goals
But he is impossible to keep down and got busy in the third. asserted
he → keep → third
He was able to become a spectator as the game wore on and the Cats shifted the match into their forward 50. asserted
Cats → become → forward
He didn’t get near the footy. asserted
He → get → footy
He started at half-back before moving to the wing, but struggled to have any meaningful impact. asserted
He → start → impact
He’s clearly not right. asserted
He → ’ → ?
3/10 (7) Shaun Mannagh: He has yanked himself out of the “opportunist/goal sneak” pigeonhole to become a damaging midfielder. asserted
He → yank → pigeonhole
Close to the Cats’ best as he rotated through the square and found stacks of the ball. asserted
he → rotate → ball
8/10 (9) Max Holmes: Is it poor taste to say the operation was a success but the patient died? asserted
patient → say → ?
He ran the game out and, after a long lay-off, will be better for the run, but he could not find the footy and had little impact. uncertain
he → run → impact
His biggest moment was being crunched by Blake Acres in a third-quarter marking contest. asserted
moment → crunch → contest
It was a relief to see him get up. asserted
him → see → ?
Other than that, he was probably shaded by Marc Pittonet in the ruck. asserted
he → shade → ruck
He probably wished they had another week off when the Blues came out firing in the first quarter, but was able to put the bus in cruise control thereafter. asserted
Blues → wish → control
None of the big Blues got off the chain. asserted
None → get → chain
6/10 (17) Lawson Humphries: Created one of the pivotal moments of the match when he spoiled a Carlton kick-in at full speed at the start of the third term. asserted
he → create → term
It set up a Mannagh goal, and sparked the Geelong avalanche. asserted
It → set → avalanche
5/10 (21) Oliver Wiltshire: He kicked three behinds. asserted
He → kick → behinds
While others shaded him on the stats sheet – he had 22 disposals – he was vital to the Cats’ turnaround. asserted
he → shade → turnaround
He took two marks deep in the forward pocket in the first and third terms, but could not convert either. uncertain
He → take → terms
He looked bamboozled, or even slow, when Sam Walsh and Jagga Smith were creating havoc in the opening term. asserted
Walsh → look → term
But the never-say-die fan favourite combined with Mannagh to help swing the game back on Geelong’s terms. asserted
favourite → say → terms
More reliable than a box of matches, he was one of the chief fire starters for Geelong in the second term, streaming through half-forward. asserted
he → stream → forward
He kicked two. asserted
He → kick → two
It’s funny how the game works. asserted
game → ’ → ?
He was odds-on favourite to be worst on ground in the first half, a poor showing that included a butchered shot on goal. asserted
that → include → goal
But he lifted to kick two after the long break. asserted
he → lift → break
He will be popping up in Jagga Smith’s nightmares for the next six months. asserted
He → pop → months
He was shaded by Sam Walsh in the first term before switching to the dangerous Smith and rendering him helpless. asserted
He → shade → him
He had a touch of the Clark Kents early, fumbling some marking contests, but found the Superman cape and became unstoppable. asserted
He → have → cape
And if that wasn’t enough, he booted five. asserted
he → boot → five
He needs to sit down and watch Dangerfield’s game to understand the difference between promising and delivering. asserted
He → need → promising
Another of the Cats’ unsung heroes, he provides reliable cover deep in defence that allows Tom Stewart to strut his stuff. asserted
Stewart → provide → stuff
He often picked up Harry McKay as he pushed up the ground. asserted
he → pick → ground
With another solid night in defence, he had 16 disposals and took four marks. asserted
he → have → marks
He was instrumental in keeping the small Carlton forwards quiet. asserted
He → keep → forwards
If you measure his performance on Cripps’ output (24 disposals) asserted
you → measure → output
…and 31 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support