Photo via The Sydney Morning Herald

Jail or hospital should not be the only choice for treating mental health

Read the original at The Sydney Morning Herald ↗
Cite

View, T. H. (2026, September 27). Jail or hospital should not be the only choice for treating mental health. The Sydney Morning Herald. https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/jail-or-hospital-should-not-be-the-only-choice-for-treating-mental-health-20260928-p610th.html?ref=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_source=rss_feed

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

The Sydney Morning Herald · collected 2026-09-27 · by The Herald's View

Quick Summary

Sydney magistrates are increasingly sending mentally ill individuals to hospitals instead of jail due to overcrowded conditions and lack of appropriate care in the criminal justice system, according to a report by Kate Aubusson in The Herald. Data shows that dismissals from lower courts based on mental illness or disorder rose from 435 to 561 between 2021 and 2025. St Vincent’s Hospital recently had to handle 17 such individuals, causing severe strain on its emergency department. This highlights the failure of current community-based mental health support as originally envisioned by the Richmond report in 1983, leading to an overburdened hospital system and inadequate alternatives for those with mental illness.
Written by AI on 2026-09-27, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).

AI analysis

Story summary

A clinical director at St Vincent’s Hospital in Sydney asked Downing Centre Local Court to stop sending accused individuals with mental health issues to their emergency department, which is already overwhelmed. On Monday, there were 17 patients deemed mentally unwell by magistrates waiting for psychiatric assessment or admission; 15 were awaiting admission to full mental health units and two had been in the ED for 10 days each. Under Section 19b of the Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Provisions Act, magistrates can send potentially mentally ill individuals to public hospitals for detention and assessment, a practice that has led to significant strain on emergency departments like St Vincent’s. Dr Pramudie Gunaratne, chief executive of the Australian Society of Psychiatrists, commented that this situation highlights broader issues with community-based mental health services not functioning adequately.

Written for “Mental Health Treatment” on 2026-11-21, grounded in this article and the 1 other(s) covering the same event.

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans strongly left and hedges 14% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
The Sydney Morning Herald
Hedges 4 of 22 claims Outlet record 61/100
The Sydney Morning Herald
Hedges 2 of 44 claims Outlet record 61/100
“The articles discuss different issues related to healthcare facilities but describe distinct incidents in separate locations.”

Story

Mental Health Treatment
Health · 2 article(s) covering the same event. See how they differ ↑
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
21
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
14%
3 of 21 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans strongly left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
61/100
The Sydney Morning Herald's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
2
Health
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-09-27 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

The Sydney Morning Herald · 7770 article(s) · 16 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 16 correction(s)

Who wrote this

The Herald's View
39 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
The government also panicked the agriculture, tourism and hospitality sectors into warning that the cuts would significantly reduce the supply of seasonal workers and leave them struggling to fill jobs this coming summer.
The industry warned the Minns government on October 22 but Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong rejected the concerns, saying the laws would benefit buyers and agencies.
In September, the industrial property giant Goodman Group backed away from building an $800 million, 24/7 data centre at Lane Cove amid resident protests and concerns by utility providers Sydney Water and Ausgrid that it would strain existing infrastructure and increase electrocution and fire risks.
2026-11-12 · assertive framing · The pushback on data centres is democracy at work
Smith was banned also from the captaincy for at least two years, while Warner was told he would never lead Australia.
Three years ago, Anchorage Capital Partners bought the department store chain for less than $100 million but still could not make a go of it.
2026-11-06 · assertive framing · The demise of David Jones leaves an empty feeling
Trump may have fumed that he was not on the ballot before grudgingly conceding his ill-conceived war in Iran was a factor in the Republican defeat in both the House and the Senate, but only someone in deep denial of reality could see the result as anything other than a repudiation of his administration, if not the man himself.
Despite the recent downturn in property prices, many would-be home buyers still find themselves priced out of the market.
“Kids who don’t receive love at home will come to school to receive it … creating an environment in which kids feel supported and accepted will then support them to do better academically and to thrive here,” she said.
2026-11-03 · assertive framing · Changing the way teachers see the world
After wrecking the joint for two years, he has run out of puff and is poised to suffer a defeat that will be a new “shot heard round the world”. Polls strongly suggest that Trump’s cowed Republicans are about to lose control of not just the House but perhaps even the Senate, to the Democrats, in Tuesday’s midterm elections.
2026-11-02 · assertive framing · Judgment day comes for Trump and the abuse of power
The Reserve Bank of Australia is expected to lift official interest rates to an 18-year-high on Tuesday.
Also by The Herald's View
The pushback on data centres is democracy at work
2026-11-12 · The Sydney Morning Herald
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 39 articles by The Herald's View →

Topics

Downing Centre Local Court Herald NSW St Vincent’s Hospital Sydney

Subjects

NSW GPE · 5× St Vincent’s Hospital ORG · 2× Cumberland Hospital ORG · 1× Downing Centre Local Court ORG · 1× Herald ORG · 1× Kate Aubusson PERSON · 1× Mental Health ORG · 1× Richmond GPE · 1× Sydney GPE · 1× the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research ORG · 1×

Narrative

Desperately in need of care rather than further hardship, too many homeless, disturbed and sometimes dangerous people are being swept up by the criminal justice system – and in Sydney, magistrates are being forced to pass the buck to the hospital system.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-09-27
Under Section 19b of the Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Provisions Act, magistrates can send people who may be mentally ill or impaired to public hospitals, where they are detained and undergo psychiatric assessment.
2026-09-27 · The Sydney Morning Herald
Jail or hospital should not be the only choice for treating mental health · assertive framing

Claims (21 extracted, 3 hedged)

Desperately in need of care rather than further hardship, too many homeless, disturbed and sometimes dangerous people are being swept up by the criminal justice system – and in Sydney, magistrates are being forced to pass the buck to the hospital system. asserted
magistrates → sweep → system
It has become so bad recently that a clinical director at St Vincent’s Hospital has even asked a bail court to stop sending people accused of crimes to the hospital’s overwhelmed emergency department. asserted
director → become → department
The Herald’s health editor, Kate Aubusson, reports exclusively that Downing Centre Local Court was informed on Monday that the hospital ED was choked with 17 people deemed by magistrates to be mentally ill or disordered. asserted
ED → report → magistrates
They included 15 patients awaiting admission to full mental health units and two patients who had already spent 10 days in the ED. asserted
who → include → ED
Under Section 19b of the Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Provisions Act, magistrates can send people who may be mentally ill or impaired to public hospitals, where they are detained and undergo psychiatric assessment. uncertain
they → send → assessment
Data from the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research show the number of people dismissed by NSW lower courts due to being mentally ill or disordered rose from 435 to 561 between 2021 and 2025. asserted
number → show → 2021
The law became a focal point for security and resourcing concerns in NSW’s mental health system in February, after two men under the orders at Cumberland Hospital allegedly killed three people in separate incidents weeks apart. uncertain
men → become → incidents
This is not how it was meant to be when, in 1983, the Richmond report recommended closing NSW’s large mental health institutions. asserted
report → mean → institutions
The mentally ill were to live in small communities or with their families and, crucially, were to be well-supported by psychiatric and other services. asserted
ill → live → services
However, the appropriate community network did not materialise. asserted
network → materialise → ?
The mentally ill were liberated from psychiatric institutions to an uncertain fate. asserted
ill → liberate → fate
In NSW, only the very ill are allowed to stay in psychiatric beds in public health facilities. asserted
ill → allow → facilities
Otherwise, psychiatric patients are medicated and quickly discharged. asserted
patients → medicate → ?
Some are cared for by overburdened families and friends or find refuge in hostels. asserted
Some → care → hostels
And they often lead to jail. asserted
they → lead → jail
Meanwhile, the mental health system has continued to buckle. asserted
system → continue → ?
One-third of the state’s public psychiatry positions were vacant last year when more than 200 NSW public psychiatrists tendered their resignations in January protesting working conditions and low pay. asserted
psychiatrists → tender → conditions
Mental Health Minister Rose Jackson said the Minns government acknowledged pressures on emergency departments and the mental health system, adding the mental health budget had been increased by more than 20 per cent. asserted
budget → say → cent
“Much of this funding has gone to improving community-based mental health care, which has been identified as the area of greatest need,” Jackson told our reporter. asserted
Jackson → go → reporter
The St Vincent’s Hospital ED crisis is further evidence our mental health system is neither working nor fit for purpose. asserted
system → work → purpose
The government could prioritise investment in long-term residential clinical and rehabilitation services rather than allow the health and judicial systems to pick up the pieces of bad policy. uncertain
systems → prioritise → policy
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support