Photo via Reason

If Canada is 'Ripping Off' the U.S., Why Is It Falling Behind?

Read the original at Reason ↗
Cite

Tuccille, J. (2026, September 7). If Canada is 'Ripping Off' the U.S., Why Is It Falling Behind? Reason. https://reason.com/2026/09/07/if-canada-is-ripping-off-the-u-s-why-is-it-falling-behind/

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

Reason · collected 2026-09-07 · by J.D. Tuccille

Quick Summary

The Fraser Institute has published a study showing that despite Canada being accused of "ripping off" the US by President Donald Trump, Canadians are actually poorer than Americans and falling further behind. According to the study, the gap between inflation-adjusted GDP per person in the US and Canada more than doubled from CA$10,766 in 1999 to CA$23,757 in 2024. The study also notes that while Canadian workers have increased productivity by 26.7% since 1999, they still lag behind American productivity growth of 67.9%.
Written by AI on 2026-09-07, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

Donald Trump suggested renaming New Mexico to “New America” on Truth Social, sharing a map with the word “Mexico” crossed out and replaced with “America.” This came days after he signed executive orders changing Lake Ontario’s name to Lake America amid tensions with Canada. The state's governor, Michelle Lujan Grisham, dismissed the proposal, stating that New Mexico’s name has been established since before the United States existed. Democratic lawmakers criticized Trump for attempting to distract from issues such as rising gas prices and his war in Iran. Google Maps and Apple Maps have not reflected these changes officially, while some users report seeing them due to user edits.

Written for “Trump Renaming New Mexico” on 2026-11-21, grounded in this article and the 15 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

13 outlets covered “Trump Renaming New Mexico”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

ReasonThis outlet7 Sep

The Fraser Institute has published a study showing that despite Canada being accused of "ripping off" the US by President Donald Trump, Canadians are actually poorer than Americans and falling further behind. According to the study, the gap between inflation-adjusted GDP per person in the US and Canada more than doubled from CA$10,766 in 1999 to CA$23,757 in 2024. The study also notes that while Canadian workers…

If Canada is 'Ripping Off' the U.S., Why Is It Falling Behind? (this article)
National Post7 Sep

The article is an opinion piece by Ben Woodfinden, a conservative commentator, who argues that some Canadian conservatives are hypocritical in criticizing US President Donald Trump's renaming of Lake Ontario to "Lake America", as they themselves supported similar name changes in Canada for ideological reasons. According to Woodfinden, a small group of Canadian conservatives have developed an attitude of "oikophobia"…

Ben Woodfinden: ‘Blame Canada’ conservatives are no better than woke statue topplers →3 articles from National Post on this story
Toronto Star6 Sep

Donald Trump's feud with Canada over tariffs and a proposed name change for Lake Ontario has prompted celebrities such as Jelly Roll, Seth Meyers, and Joe Rogan to publicly criticize him. The US president signed an executive order renaming the lake "Lake America" in response to a public spat with Ontario Premier Doug Ford and suspended trade talks between the two countries. Joe Rogan questioned Trump's decision on…

Donald Trump's escalating feud with Canada has prompted Joe Rogan and George Clooney to fire back →2 articles from Toronto Star on this story
Times of India5 Sep

Robert Corradino, the Republican mayor of Oswego, New York, has publicly rejected a proposal to rename Lake Ontario "Lake America". The city's residents have a strong emotional connection to the lake, which is crucial to their economy and history. According to Corradino, the renaming would negatively impact tourism from Canada, with stores and museums dependent on it already seeing a decline. Oswego County…

This city in New York rejects 'Lake America' name, Republican mayor says Lake Ontario is in the DNA of the residents →
Washington Examiner6 Sep

US President Donald Trump has posted on Truth Social a suggestion to rename New Mexico "New America", with an "X" marked through the word "Mexico". This is not an official order, but rather a teaser from the president who has previously attempted to change the names of other geographical locations. Trump has been involved in similar renaming efforts before, including changing "Gulf of Mexico" to "Gulf of America"…

Trump teases idea of changing New Mexico to ‘New America’ →
The Independent6 Sep

President Donald Trump is reportedly considering renaming New Mexico "New America" as part of his ongoing efforts to rebrand American geography. This move follows previous changes he made to the Gulf of Mexico, Lake Ontario, and Alaska's Denali mountain, which was renamed Mount McKinley in an executive order signed in January 2025. The proposal has sparked backlash from some, including the group Republicans Against…

Trump can’t stop changing the name of things and now has US state as his target →
Show 7 more outlets
Fox News6 Sep

President Donald Trump suggested renaming New Mexico "New America" through a post on his Truth Social account, which was then reposted by the White House on its X account. The proposal does not appear to be a formal policy initiative and has been met with opposition from Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham, who stated that the state's name is not up for debate. This comes just days after Trump signed an executive order…

After 'Lake America,' Trump suggests a new name for the state of New Mexico →
Daily Mail6 Sep

President Donald Trump posted a map of New Mexico on social media with the state's name crossed out and replaced with "America", prompting speculation about his intentions. The post came after he previously renamed Lake Ontario to "Lake America" and also proposed renaming the Gulf of Mexico to the "Gulf of America". A poll by Reuters/Ipsos found that only 14% of US citizens support such name changes. Trump's…

Trump appears to set sights on renaming entire STATE after Lake America rebrand →
The Straits Times7 Sep

US President Donald Trump suggested renaming New Mexico "New America" on social media, saying it would be "more prestigious and beautiful" for the state's residents. This proposal comes days after he signed an order to rename Lake Ontario as "Lake America", which was also met with rejection from Canada. Governor of New Mexico Michelle Lujan Grisham dismissed Trump's idea, stating that the name has been unchanged…

Trump suggests renaming New Mexico state ‘New America’ →
The Hindu7 Sep

US President Donald Trump suggested renaming New Mexico "New America", posting about it on social media and sharing an image of the state's name changed. The idea may have originated as an internet hoax, with some reports suggesting its authenticity is unclear. Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham dismissed the proposal, stating that the name "isn't up for debate" and has been a part of the state since before the US…

Trump suggests renaming New Mexico state 'New America' →
The Guardian8 Sep

A group of New Mexico Democrats are pushing back against President Trump's suggestion that the state should be renamed "New America". Martin Heinrich, the state's senior senator, led the response on social media, saying he would always refer to the state by its actual name. His colleagues Ben Ray Luján and Melanie Stansbury also echoed his sentiment, calling out Trump as a "scoundrel" and reaffirming their pride in…

Democrats hit back at Trump after president floats changing name of New Mexico to ‘New America’ - US politics live →
Euronews8 Sep

US President Donald Trump suggested renaming the state of New Mexico to "New America", tweeting that it would be more prestigious and beautiful for its people. According to the White House, this idea was posted on social media with an image showing the word "Mexico" crossed out from the state's name and replaced with "America". State governor Michelle Lujan Grisham dismissed Trump's proposal, stating that the…

What's in a name? Trump suggests renaming New Mexico state 'New America' →
Time8 Sep

President Donald Trump has shared maps of New Mexico with the label "New America," following similar renaming attempts last weekend, including dubbing the Strait of Hormuz as "Trump Strait" and Lake Ontario as "Lake America." The move has prompted backlash from Democratic lawmakers in New Mexico, who argue that the state's name is not up for debate. This is the latest example of Trump's habit of renaming…

Trump Shares Map Renaming New Mexico as 'New America,' Days After 'Trump Strait' and 'Lake America' Uproar →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

AI · cited, from two or more outlets

  • The renaming of Lake Ontario as 'Lake America' was signed by President Trump following a trade dispute with Canada.45

Disputed

Picked by our model, which is sometimes wrong

  • Some conservatives oppose the name change of Lake Ontario but support other initiatives by the current administration, while others strongly disagree with both.16

Framing

How the first headlines put it

  • The Times of India frames Mayor Corradino's stance as a personal and local issue for Oswego residents, while The Guardian presents it in the context of broader political opposition to Trump.17
  • The Washington Examiner highlights Trump's suggestion to rename New Mexico as 'New America', emphasizing his name-changing spree, whereas Euronews focuses on the immediate reaction and dismissal by state officials.23
Attributed to a source1
Stated as fact2
The headlines (3)

This city in New York rejects 'Lake America' name, Republican mayor says Lake Ontario is in the DNA of the residents Times of India · attributed to a source

J.D. Tuccille: Trump shouldn’t have the authority to rename Lake Ontario National Post · stated as fact

'It's childish': Americans in Canada react to Trump's renaming of Lake Ontario Toronto Star · stated as fact

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 16 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans strongly right and hedges 7% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
National Post
Leans strongly left further left than this Hedges 6 of 71 claims Outlet record 60/100
Toronto Star
Leans left further left than this Hedges 1 of 49 claims Outlet record 64/100
CBC News
Hedges 23 of 48 claims Outlet record 72/100
“The articles discuss different phases and aspects of the ongoing trade dispute between Canada and the U.S., rather than a single specific incident.”
National Post
Leans right further left than this Hedges 2 of 5 claims Outlet record 60/100
“The articles discuss different topics related to Canada-US trade disputes, but do not report on the same specific incident”
TIME
Leans left further left than this Hedges 5 of 45 claims Outlet record 60/100
“Although both articles refer to the collapse of trade negotiations between the U.S. and Canada, they mention different details (Article A refers to 'last-minute changes', while Article B mentions a press release about tariffs) and imply that some time has passed since the incident”
ABC News (AU)
Hedges 3 of 36 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Article A discusses trade tensions between US and Canada without mentioning any specific incident, while Article B refers to a specific event (the collapse of trade negotiations) that didn't occur in the timeline suggested by Article A”
Retaliation Different event
Reason
Hedges 3 of 43 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Article A mentions a claim made in an August 25 press release about the collapse of trade negotiations, while Article B describes new retaliatory tariffs starting on September 8, indicating different events”
Los Angeles Times
Hedges 3 of 45 claims Outlet record 95/100
“Article A mentions the collapse of trade negotiations and the renaming of Lake Ontario as Lake America, which is not mentioned in Article B”
Toronto Star
Leans strongly right Hedges 7 of 59 claims Outlet record 64/100
“The articles discuss similar themes regarding U.S.-Canada trade relations but describe different aspects and perspectives on the issue.”
National Post
Leans left further left than this Hedges 3 of 34 claims Outlet record 60/100
“Article A discusses the impact of tariffs on Canada and a potential new tax, while Article B is about a broader trade dispute and President Trump's claims about Canada”

Story

Trump Renaming New Mexico
Politics · 16 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
43
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
7%
3 of 43 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans strongly right
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
67/100
Reason's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
16
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-09-07 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Reason · 1464 article(s) · 4 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 4 correction(s)

Who wrote this

J.D. Tuccille
21 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
The net effect could be that air traffic controllers are forced to continue to rely on severely outdated systems that are prone to failure leading to more system outages, ground stops, flight delays, or worse—safety incidents.
2026-11-18 · assertive framing · Get Government Out of Air Traffic Control
This was an election in which Republicans were rejected, and Democrats were selected by default as the maybe-less-bad option.
It's a scheme that seems considerate to those who run up debt but would instead deny riskier borrowers access to legitimate credit, and it could drive many people to lenders—some underground—who charge more.
The midterm elections may have been primarily a rejection of corruption and ineptitude among GOP officials, but they also empowered Democrats to enact an agenda in many places wildly at odds with what prevailed before.
It's easy to see how Stevens could conclude that a grifter is less odious than El-Sayed's inclinations.
The cost of carrying that extra debt will be added to the roughly $6 billion the state pays each year to service bonds issued in the past.
Whatever the excuse, we're told identification requirements will make us more secure, but a recent breach of Denmark's national ID system suggests that such an apparatus is just easy hacker bait.
That's the question behind a growing movement against property taxes, which is winning support across the country and may see its next big test in the form of a proposed constitutional amendment on the Florida ballot that would significantly trim taxes on owner-occupied homes.
2026-10-21 · assertive framing · Grassroots Revolt Targets Unpopular Property Taxes
Of specific interest in this case, the state adopted a law in 2021 that, among other things, says "the governing board of a community college or a district school board" may adopt policies banning guns on school grounds, even for those "licensed to carry a concealed handgun."
While it may be a while before the opportunity arises to roll back state intervention in the economy, given the drift of both major parties away from faith in the marketplace, the Cato Institute has launched a project to get the process started.
Also by J.D. Tuccille
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 21 articles by J.D. Tuccille →

Topics

Americans Canada Canadian Canadians the United States

Subjects

Canada GPE · 20× the United States GPE · 6× Canadian NORP · 5× Fraser PERSON · 5× Americans NORP · 4× Canadians NORP · 4× American NORP · 3× U.S. GPE · 3× Donald Trump PERSON · 1× the White House ORG · 1×

Narrative

As international communications strategist James Stranko noted last week in a Wall Street Journal column, Canada has defined itself since its founding as the "un-America" and "almost all of Canada's major moments of national unity were born out of rejection of, or protection from, American power." The Canadian Century That Wasn't
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-09-07
The real question in the years to come is who will be more damaged by the escalating trade war between the U.S. and Canada.
2026-09-07 · Reason
If Canada is 'Ripping Off' the U.S., Why Is It Falling Behind? · assertive framing

Claims (43 extracted, 3 hedged)

President Donald Trump's latest temper tantrum over Canada, including the renaming of Lake Ontario as Lake America after the collapse of trade negotiations, is premised on the claim that "Canada has been ripping off the United States for decades." uncertain
Canada → include → decades
At least, that's what the White House insisted in an August 25 press release about the tariff dispute. asserted
House → insist → dispute
But, if that's true, why are Canadians poorer than Americans and falling further behind? asserted
Canadians → fall → Americans
You are reading The Rattler from J.D. Tuccille and Reason. asserted
You → read → Tuccille
Americans Grow Wealthier More Quickly Than Canadians A new study from Canada's Fraser Institute points out that while our northern neighbors started the century with high hopes for their economic prospects, the years since have shown them lagging Americans. asserted
them → grow → Americans
If Canadians are taking advantage of us, they're doing a remarkably poor job of it. asserted
they → take → it
"In 1999, inflation-adjusted gross domestic product (GDP) per person in the US was CA$10,766 higher than in Canada. asserted
product → adjust → Canada
By 2024, that gap had more than doubled to CA$23,757," write study authors Grady Munro, Jake Fuss, and Joel Emes. asserted
Munro → double → CA$23,757
"Similarly, in 2010, inflation-adjusted median employment income in the US was CA$6,126 higher than in Canada. asserted
income → adjust → Canada
By 2024, that gap had increased to CA$8,663. asserted
gap → increase → CA$8,663
The Fraser study notes that since 1999, government-sector employment has been growing faster than private-sector employment in Canada. asserted
employment → note → Canada
And while Canadian workers have increased their productivity by 26.7 percent since 1999, they've still lost ground as Americans increased productivity by 67.9 percent. asserted
Americans → increase → percent
Canada's relatively slow growth in prosperity as compared to the United States is, no doubt, frustrating for our northern neighbors. asserted
growth → compare → neighbors
As international communications strategist James Stranko noted last week in a Wall Street Journal column, Canada has defined itself since its founding as the "un-America" and "almost all of Canada's major moments of national unity were born out of rejection of, or protection from, American power." The Canadian Century That Wasn't asserted
That → note → rejection
The Fraser authors underline this point, quoting Sir Wilfrid Laurier, Canada's seventh prime minister, who said in 1904, "the nineteenth century has been the century of the United States development….The twentieth century shall be the century of Canada and Canadian development." asserted
century → underline → Canada
When the 20th century turned out fine, but not brilliantly so, for the northern country, hopes for a Canadian breakthrough were transferred to the 21st century. asserted
hopes → turn → century
Again, Canada has done all right, but not especially well by comparison to the southern giant that Canadians measure their own achievements against. asserted
Canadians → do → achievements
"Policymakers have thus far squandered the Canadian Century," adds the Fraser study. asserted
study → squander → Century
"In particular, Canada began to truly squander this opportunity post-2014. asserted
Canada → begin → opportunity
Prior to 2014, Canada largely kept pace with, or in some cases exceeded the US, across multiple measures." asserted
Canada → keep → measures
World Bank figures demonstrate the problem. asserted
figures → demonstrate → problem
The gap largely disappeared a decade later—only to widen again within a few years. asserted
gap → disappear → years
The Fraser study draws its data from different sources, but they show a similar lag in Canada's relative economic performance. " asserted
they → draw → performance
From 1999 to 2024, GDP per person in Canada grew by 23.8%, while the United States experienced a 41.5% increase over the period. asserted
States → grow → period
Put differently, GDP per person in the United States has grown 1.7 times faster than in Canada since 1999," write Munro, Fuss, and Emes. asserted
Munro → Put → 1999
Or, to put it another way, Canadian per capita GDP was 81.7 percent of the figure for the U.S. in 1999 and 71.5 percent of American per capita GDP in 2024. asserted
GDP → put → 2024
Looking at another measure, as of 2010, the Fraser study observes, "median income in Canada was $32,580 compared to $38,706 in the United States, leaving an income gap of $6,126 between the two countries" in a comparison using Canadian dollars. asserted
income → look → dollars
While that gap narrowed over the next few years, "by 2024, median employment income had risen to $37,361 in Canada and $46,024 in the United States, leaving an income gap of $8,663." asserted
income → narrow → 8,663
Canada has been growing more prosperous over the years, but it's losing ground when compared to the increasing wealth of the United States. asserted
it → grow → States
Hobbled by a Growing Government A significant part of the problem is that government employment has been growing faster north of the border than private sector employment. asserted
employment → hobble → employment
In 1999, private sector jobs represented 85.8 percent of employment in the U.S. and 81.2 percent in Canada. asserted
jobs → represent → Canada
As of 2024, private-sector employment had slightly risen to 86.5 percent of all jobs in the U.S. but fallen to 78.5 percent of Canadian jobs. asserted
employment → rise → jobs
That means the private sector must shoulder a growing burden to fund the expanding government: "New government-sector jobs impose a corresponding cost through the tax system, which limits the extent to which government-sector employment growth contributes to overall economic growth." asserted
growth → mean → growth
Also, labor productivity has declined for Canadian government workers while increasing in the private sector. asserted
productivity → decline → sector
To an even greater extent than in America, Canada's private sector is hobbled by an unproductive and expensive government. asserted
sector → hobble → government
"Despite some early hopes prior to 2014, Canada has made virtually no economic progress relative to its southern neighbour and has instead fallen further behind where it stood at the turn of the century," the Fraser authors conclude. asserted
authors → make → century
It's difficult to see where Canada has been "ripping off the United States," no matter what the Trump administration claims. uncertain
administration → see → what
Instead, Canada has hampered its own economic prospects with a growing government sector that drains wealth from the productive private sector. asserted
that → hamper → sector
Yes, Canada has some foolish protectionist trade policies—including barriers between provinces—but so does the United States, especially under the Trump administration. asserted
States → have → administration
Both are now doubling down on self-harming tariffs. asserted
Both → double → tariffs
…and 3 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support