Photo via The Guardian

New York City’s Marble Hill residents furious after ICE shooting: ‘Why do this?’

Read the original at The Guardian ↗
Cite

York, A. B. i. N. (2026, October 9). New York City’s Marble Hill residents furious after ICE shooting: ‘Why do this?’. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/oct/09/marble-hill-new-york-city-ice-shooting-reaction

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

The Guardian · collected 2026-10-09 · by Auzzy Byrdsell in New York
Content note This article describes violence described in detail.

Quick Summary

Residents of Marble Hill, New York City, were outraged and scared after an ICE officer shot Oscar Belgal, 28, who had a child in his car. The shooting occurred on Thursday night when ICE agents arrested Belgal without wearing uniforms or clear identification, leading neighbors to question the legitimacy of the operation. Local politicians and officials have condemned the incident and called for an investigation into the use of force by federal immigration enforcement.
Written by AI on 2026-10-09, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

On October 8, 2026, Oscar Belgal, a 28-year-old Dominican national with criminal history, was shot by ICE agents in New York City's Marble Hill neighborhood while his five-year-old son was present. The shooting occurred around 4 p.m. when ICE officers approached Belgal’s SUV and drew their weapons; Belgal then attempted to drive away, leading to the confrontation and subsequent shooting. Belgal remains hospitalized with a bullet lodged in his neck and is being held at the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn. His attorneys claim he has been denied necessary medical care, including surgery for the embedded bullet. The incident sparked outrage among New Yorkers and calls from Mayor Zohran Mamdani to reassess ICE's presence in the city.

Written for “ICE Agents Shoot Man In NYC” on 2026-11-21, grounded in this article and the 75 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

22 outlets covered “ICE Agents Shoot Man In NYC”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

The GuardianThis outlet9 Oct

Residents of Marble Hill, New York City, were outraged and scared after an ICE officer shot Oscar Belgal, 28, who had a child in his car. The shooting occurred on Thursday night when ICE agents arrested Belgal without wearing uniforms or clear identification, leading neighbors to question the legitimacy of the operation. Local politicians and officials have condemned the incident and called for an investigation into…

New York City’s Marble Hill residents furious after ICE shooting: ‘Why do this?’ (this article)4 articles from The Guardian on this story
New York Post12 Oct

Oscar Belgal, a 28-year-old Dominican immigrant convicted of armed robbery, remains in critical condition at the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn after being shot by ICE agents. Lawyers for Belgal claim he has a bullet lodged in his neck and cannot eat due to nerve damage. Held in solitary confinement, Belgal reportedly suffers from severe medical neglect, including lack of food and clean drinking water…

NYC illegal migrant thug shot by ICE still has bullet lodged in neck, can’t eat, lawyers say: ‘Unimaginable nightmare’ →17 articles from New York Post on this story
CBS News10 Oct

In New York City, a man from the Bronx was shot by an ICE agent as his young child was present in the vehicle's back seat. DHS stated that the individual refused to obey lawful commands given by the officer. Journalist Camilo Montoya-Galvez provides this report.

What we know about the man shot by ICE in New York City →10 articles from CBS News on this story
Washington Examiner11 Oct

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani likened a plainclothes Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officer to a "mass shooter" after an ICE operation shooting in New York City last week. During an interview, Mamdani criticized the incident for highlighting why law enforcement should wear identifiable uniforms, arguing that bystanders were confused by the appearance of the officer involved. In response, Department…

Mamdani likens plainclothes ICE officer to ‘mass shooter’ after NYC shooting →6 articles from Washington Examiner on this story
Fox News13 Oct

On October 8, ICE officers attempted to arrest Oscar Belgal, 28, in Manhattan after school dismissal when he was with his five-year-old son. A confrontation ensued as Belgal tried to drive away; one officer fired seven shots, hitting Belgal in the neck while his child remained unharmed. The article argues that liberal figures quickly dismissed Belgal’s criminal history and immigration status, focusing instead on…

ELI STEELE: NYC ICE shooting exposes how White guilt erases personal responsibility →5 articles from Fox News on this story
NBC News9 Oct

DHS officials defended the actions of ICE officers who shot Oscar Bergal, a Dominican immigrant in New York City on Thursday, arguing that Bergal endangered his own 5-year-old son by refusing to exit his car and intentionally ramming into ICE vehicles. DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin said during a press briefing that Bergal knew about his child’s presence but did not inform the officers, while Executive Associate…

DHS officials defend their actions in shooting of NYC immigrant amid outcry →5 articles from NBC News on this story
Show 16 more outlets
Al Jazeera11 Oct

Protesters in New York City are demonstrating against Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) following the shooting of Oscar Belgal by officers while he was driving with his five-year-old son in the car in the Bronx. The incident has escalated demands to halt federal immigration enforcement activities within the city. Al Jazeera is reporting on these developments.

Anti-ICE protests in New York after man shot in car with child →5 articles from Al Jazeera on this story
The Straits Times10 Oct

Protesters gathered in New York on October 10 to protest against an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) shooting that occurred two days prior in the Bronx. The incident involved the wounding of a Dominican man named Oscar Bergal in his car while his five-year-old child was present but unharmed. Mayor Zohran Mamdani criticized the ICE operation, advocating for its abolition, which prompted a response from US…

Protests in New York as Trump admin defends ICE shooting →3 articles from The Straits Times on this story
BBC10 Oct

The article discusses a video analysis by BBC journalist Nada Tawfik of body cam footage from the New York Police Department, which shows the aftermath of an incident where US Immigration and Customs Enforcement shot and wounded a man in his car, with his five-year-old son present in the back seat. The video depicts NYPD officers assisting the injured man following the shooting.

BBC breaks down video of the aftermath of New York City ICE shooting →3 articles from BBC on this story
Daily Mail9 Oct

Judge J. Paul Oetken, appointed by former President Barack Obama, has blocked the immediate deportation of Oscar Bergal, a 28-year-old illegal immigrant with a criminal history, who was shot by an ICE agent in New York City. The judge's ruling came after Bergal survived being shot in the neck during an enforcement operation targeting him and his alleged gang affiliations. Bergal had been arrested on charges related…

Obama-appointed judge blocks deportation of illegal immigrant dramatically shot by ICE in New York City →2 articles from Daily Mail on this story
The Intercept9 Oct

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is under pressure after an ICE officer shot Oscar Belgal in Manhattan, sparking protests and clashes between protesters and the NYPD. The incident has reignited debates about Mamdani’s approach to policing and immigration enforcement. Critics argue that while Mamdani condemns ICE actions, he needs to propose actionable plans beyond rhetoric to address federal raids effectively.

ICE Shooting in NYC Inflames Mamdani’s Policing Problem →2 articles from The Intercept on this story
The Independent9 Oct

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani strongly criticized Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) as "rotten to its core" after ICE agents shot at least seven rounds into a car containing a 5-year-old child, injuring the driver, Oscar Belgal, who was identified by police commissioner Jessica Tisch as a man with prior criminal convictions. The incident occurred Thursday evening in Marble Hill and was discussed during…

NYC mayor Mamdani calls ICE ‘rotten to its core’ after agents shoot at car with 5-year-old inside →2 articles from The Independent on this story
CBC9 Oct

A U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent shot a 28-year-old Dominican man in New York City while he was with a five-year-old child in the car. ICE claims they fired because their lives were at risk, stating that the man refused to exit his vehicle and used it as a weapon by accelerating towards officers. This incident has sparked outrage among New Yorkers, including Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who called for…

ICE says officer shot New York man because they believe their lives were in danger →2 articles from CBC on this story
Time9 Oct

The NYPD released bodycam footage from one of their officers who responded to a shooting incident involving an ICE agent in New York City. The video shows two NYPD officers arriving at the scene where a man was seated on the ground, with an ICE officer present but unresponsive to questions about medical care for the injured individual. ICE has not yet released its own bodycam footage from the incident, citing…

NYPD Releases ICE Shooting Bodycam Footage →2 articles from Time on this story
Mother Jones9 Oct

On Thursday afternoon in the Bronx, a federal immigration agent shot a man who had a five-year-old child in his car. The victim is conscious and receiving treatment at a local hospital. New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani criticized ICE for terrorizing communities and called for the agency to leave the city. Since President Trump's return to office, ICE agents have been involved in more than 21 shootings, resulting in six…

ICE Shoots New York Man With Five-Year-Old in Car →
The Hindu9 Oct

On Thursday, October 8, 2026, federal immigration agents shot a Dominican man during his arrest in New York City's Marble Hill neighborhood. The Department of Homeland Security described it as part of a "targeted enforcement operation," while protesters called it an example of dangerous immigration policies. The injured man was previously convicted of grand larceny and had other arrests; he survived and is receiving…

Immigration agents shoot a man during arrest in New York City →
Times of India9 Oct

On Thursday in New York City's Marble Hill neighborhood, an ICE agent shot and wounded a Dominican man during what DHS called a targeted enforcement operation. The man had a prior conviction for grand larceny and was reportedly arrested by local police earlier but released due to sanctuary city policies. Mayor Zohran Mamdani criticized the shooting as "unconscionable" and demanded an end to ICE operations in New…

'ICE out of our neighbourhoods’: Shooting of man sparks protests in New York →
South China Morning Post9 Oct

New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani has called on President Donald Trump to remove ICE from the city following a recent incident in which an individual driving with a five-year-old child was shot by federal agents during an operation in the Bronx neighborhood of Marble Hill. The mayor made this statement after it became clear that the shooting involved ICE, prompting heightened tensions over immigration enforcement…

New York mayor urges Trump to remove ICE after driver with child in car is shot →
Euronews9 Oct

Masked ICE officers shot a Dominican man while making an arrest in Marble Hill, Manhattan on Thursday evening. Eyewitnesses reported hearing three or four gunshots as officers surrounded and arrested the injured man, who is currently hospitalized but stable. Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Governor Kathy Hochul criticized the incident, calling it an example of the dangers posed by strict immigration enforcement policies…

Masked ICE officers shoot a man while making an arrest in New York, officials say →
The Bulwark9 Oct

William Kristol criticizes Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth for advocating that the execution of Fort Hood mass murderer Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan be a public spectacle, calling it neo-fascist rhetoric. Hegseth suggested people should watch the execution live-streamed online, claiming this would help convey serious consequences for such crimes. Kristol argues that exposing citizens to violent spectacles is…

Hegseth Wants You to Watch a Snuff Film →
Global News9 Oct

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani criticized the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) after an officer shot a Dominican man in the neck while he was driving with his 5-year-old son on Thursday afternoon. ICE officials claim they opened fire because the man had rammed into their vehicles, posing an immediate threat to their safety. The incident has reignited debates over sanctuary city policies and the conduct…

After ICE shot man with kid in car, Mamdani urges halt to operations in NYC →
ABC News (US)15 Oct

Oscar Belgal remains hospitalized at a detention center with a bullet still lodged in his neck nearly a week after being shot during an ICE encounter in Manhattan. His attorneys claim the officers did not identify themselves before opening fire while Belgal's 5-year-old son was present in the car. The petition alleges that Belgal is only receiving ibuprofen for pain management despite the severity of his injury. A…

Man shot during ICE encounter in NYC still has bullet lodged in neck, attorneys say →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

AI · cited, from two or more outlets

  • A child was present in the car and is reported to be okay.13
Quoted from the coverage (4)

The NYPD said its officers were not involved in the incident and were not at the scene when the shooting occurred.

6 outlets

The person who was shot was conscious and being treated at a hospital, the New York Police Department said in a post on X, noting that its officers didn't witness the shooting and weren't involved.

6 outlets

New York Gov. Kathy Hochul, a Democrat, said in a post on social media that she had been briefed on the shooting.

6 outlets

Mamdani said he had called President Donald Trump and would demand that he end all ICE enforcement actions in the city.

6 outlets

Disputed

Picked by our model, which is sometimes wrong

  • The Hindu describes the man as a 'criminal illegal alien' with a prior criminal conviction, while The Intercept does not provide such details about the victim's background.31

Were victims terrorists?

undocumented migrants: Two Americans – Renee Good and Alex Pretti – were shot and killed by federal immigration agents in separate incidents in Minnesota during a crackdown on undocumented migrants in the northern state earlier in 2026. The Straits Times

domestic terrorist: After Good’s killing, Trump officials labelled her a “domestic terrorist” even as video of the shooting cast doubt on claims she had tried to run over an agent. Al Jazeera

Framing

How the first headlines put it

  • The Intercept frames the event by focusing on the identity of the ICE agent as a construction worker, while The Independent highlights the broader context of the shooting and its political implications.12
Attributed to a source7
Stated as fact14
The headlines (21)

Federal agents involved in NYC shooting that leaves one person wounded, NYPD says Fox News · attributed to a source

Federal agents shoot person in New York, police say The Guardian · attributed to a source

Person shot by ICE agent in New York City, law enforcement sources say CBS News · attributed to a source

ICE Agent on Scene of NYC Shooting Was Posing as Construction Worker, Eyewitness Says The Intercept · attributed to a source

New York City man shot in car with child present by ICE agents, mayor says The Straits Times · attributed to a source

ICE agent shoots man in car with five-year-old child in New York: Mayor Al Jazeera · attributed to a source

Masked ICE officers shoot a man while making an arrest in New York, officials say Euronews · attributed to a source

ICE agents shoot person in NYC as victim is conscious and rushed to hospital Daily Mail · stated as fact

One hospitalized after shooting involving federal agents in New York City Washington Examiner · stated as fact

Person shot by ICE officers in New York City NBC News · stated as fact

Man shot during apparent ICE operation in NYC, Gov. Hochul demands explanation The Independent · stated as fact

ICE Shoots New York Man With Five-Year-Old in Car Mother Jones · stated as fact

U.S. ICE agents shoot and wound man during arrest in New York City CBC · stated as fact

Immigration agents shoot a man during arrest in New York City The Hindu · stated as fact

Anti-ICE protesters, cops clash outside NYC hospital where wounded ‘criminal migrant’ recovering after an agent shot him New York Post · stated as fact

ICE agent shoots man in New York City BBC · stated as fact

'ICE out of our neighbourhoods’: Shooting of man sparks protests in New York Times of India · stated as fact

New York mayor urges Trump to remove ICE after driver with child in car is shot South China Morning Post · stated as fact

Mamdani Demands Trump End ICE Operations in New York After Shooting Time · stated as fact

Hegseth Wants You to Watch a Snuff Film The Bulwark · stated as fact

After ICE shot man with kid in car, Mamdani urges halt to operations in NYC Global News · stated as fact

Words to watch (3)

New York City’s Marble Hill residents furious after ICE shooting: ‘Why do this?’ The Guardian

Mamdani says he tried to negotiate release of wounded ‘criminal migrant’ shot by federal agent as he slams ICE as ‘rotten to the core’ New York Post

Mullin rips Mamdani’s ‘dangerous’ tone over New York ICE shooting Washington Examiner

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 76 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans left and hedges 7% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
The Straits Times
Hedges 1 of 16 claims Outlet record 64/100
Al Jazeera
Leans left Hedges 3 of 15 claims Outlet record 60/100
The Guardian
Leans strongly left further left than this Hedges 3 of 51 claims Outlet record 64/100
The Guardian
Hedges 0 of 4 claims Outlet record 64/100
CBS News
Leans left Hedges 0 of 2 claims Outlet record 66/100
Times of India
Leans strongly left further left than this Hedges 2 of 31 claims Outlet record 59/100
Daily Mail
Leans left Hedges 2 of 9 claims Outlet record 69/100
CBS News
Hedges 4 of 18 claims Outlet record 66/100
Washington Examiner
Leans left Hedges 1 of 16 claims Outlet record 67/100

Story

ICE Agents Shoot Man In NYC
Crime & Law · 76 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
29
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
7%
2 of 29 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
64/100
The Guardian's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
76
Crime & Law
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-10-09 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

The Guardian · 2645 article(s) · 9 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 9 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Auzzy Byrdsell in New York
5 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
“If we did not have the profit motive, we wouldn’t be having these issues,” he said.
He was the first named by police and had one child and his wife is pregnant, according to the Ecuadorian consulate, which will help with the transfer of his body to Ecuador, the network reported.
Zohran Mamdani, New York City’s mayor, addressed some of Foster’s, and other’s, concerns in a press conference Thursday.
At a news conference, the Westchester county executive, Kenneth Jenkins, stressed that people were still able to vote, and would be directed to use emergency ballots, which would be placed in sealed orange bags and counted later.
He said he wished that New York’s progressive Democratic mayor, Zohran Mamdani, would be more outspoken about ICE tensions in New York.
Also by Auzzy Byrdsell in New York
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.

Topics

Belgal Bronx ICE Immigration and Customs Enforcement Manhattan

Subjects

ICE ORG · 8× Belgal PERSON · 6× Perez PERSON · 3× Bronx GPE · 2× Manhattan GPE · 2× Miller PERSON · 2× New York GPE · 2× Immigration and Customs Enforcement ORG · 1× Orlando Perez PERSON · 1× Oscar Belgal PERSON · 1×

Narrative

Leading New York City and state politicians and officials have condemned ICE’s action, called for an investigation and demanded violent federal immigration enforcement cease. Zachary Miller said he heard six gun shots from his apartment on Thursday afternoon, when the shooting occurred around 4pm, just when children were streaming home from school.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-10-09
He said he wished that New York’s progressive Democratic mayor, Zohran Mamdani, would be more outspoken about ICE tensions in New York.

Claims (29 extracted, 2 hedged)

Residents of Manhattan’s Marble Hill neighborhood were furious at federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) on Friday but also scared after an officer shot their neighbor who had his child in the back of his car. asserted
who → shoot → car
Orlando Perez had parked his car on the corner of 225th St and Marble Hill Avenue on Thursday night and witnessed ICE arresting Oscar Belgal, 28, after he had been shot in the neck, apparently with an assault-style rifle. asserted
he → park → rifle
“I thought I was going to get shot,” he said on Friday The streets, now calm after protests had broken out the night before, were noticeably quieter than normal despite golden early October sunshine under blue skies. asserted
protests → think → skies
Perez said he did not see that the agents targeting Belgal were not wearing uniforms and he did not see them wearing identification badges or any gear showing that they belonged to ICE. asserted
they → say → ICE
However, footage of the aftermath of the shooting shows a man in a high visibility construction-type vest, possibly with a badge on a lanyard, and carrying an assault-style rifle. uncertain
footage → show → rifle
Bystanders can be heard on video asking each other “Is it ICE or not?” asserted
it → hear → other
The car that Belgal had driven appeared to have bullet holes in it, according to Perez. uncertain
Belgal → drive → Perez
The homeland security secretary, Markwayne Mullin, said in a press conference in Washington DC on Friday morning that federal officers did not know there was a child in the target’s car. But Perez added that the car had only light tints on the windows and that ICE “had to see that the kid was inside”. asserted
kid → say → windows
Leading New York City and state politicians and officials have condemned ICE’s action, called for an investigation and demanded violent federal immigration enforcement cease. Zachary Miller said he heard six gun shots from his apartment on Thursday afternoon, when the shooting occurred around 4pm, just when children were streaming home from school. asserted
children → lead → school
Federal and city law enforcement have listed prior convictions for Belgal and said he was on probation for felony offenses, with the Trump administration accusing him of having gang affiliations. asserted
administration → list → affiliations
Miller said he knew Belgal from being around the neighborhood and said: “He’s a nice kid. “I don’t see him doing something like this,” he said, referring to the accusations of gang ties and drugs and weapons crimes. asserted
he → say → ties
Miller has lived in the Marble Hill neighborhood – which is geographically in the Bronx, but considered part of Manhattan – where the shooting occurred for 20 years and said he had never seen such a violent encounter with law enforcement. asserted
he → live → enforcement
“I’m a little upset,” he said. asserted
he → ’m → ?
Carlos Martinez, 18, said that he had heard five or six gunshots while he was eating in P & P Gourmet Deli, which sits on the corner directly across from where the shooting and arrest took place. asserted
shooting → say → place
“I thought the shots came from inside the store, so I was nervous,” he said. asserted
he → think → store
Coming from a Dominican family, like Belgal, and growing up in the Bronx, he said he longer feels safe at home, despite he and all his family members being US citizens. asserted
he → come → home
“Over here we are all community, but personally I am uncomfortable,” he said. asserted
he → say → ?
“They want to target the most innocent people.” asserted
They → want → people
The small three-way intersection where Belgal was shot is home to about five apartment complexes and some businesses. asserted
Belgal → shoot → complexes
New York police on Friday afternoon took away street barricades but yellow crime scene tape was still visible around the scene. asserted
tape → take → scene
Another longtime resident, Carlos Rodriguez, said he felt “soiled” by ICE’s presence in his neighborhood. asserted
he → say → neighborhood
“I need to take a shower and clean off the filth that comes into my ambit of being,” he said. asserted
he → need → being
He said he wished that New York’s progressive Democratic mayor, Zohran Mamdani, would be more outspoken about ICE tensions in New York. asserted
mayor → say → York
“From my point of view, he can come out stronger and more often about this,” he said, adding that he wanted lawmakers to be more proactive against enforcement agents, especially where they are going to residents’ homes and demanding access to make checks or an arrest. asserted
they → come → checks
Mamdani strongly condemned ICE at a hastily arranged press conference on Thursday night, as protesters can be heard chanting in the background, and called for the agency to be abolished. asserted
agency → condemn → background
Meanwhile, several local residents said they had seen ICE officers and vehicles “camped out” in a parking lot nearby that serves a store belonging to the giant retail chain Target. asserted
that → say → chain
Rodriguez said he suspected the agents were looking for Belgal. asserted
agents → say → Belgal
Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez late on Thursday criticized Target for accommodating ICE. asserted
Cortez → criticize → ICE
A hearing was expected in New York federal court on Friday afternoon in relation to a petition of habeas corpus requesting Belgal’s release from custody, after public defender lawyers representing him were unable to trace his whereabouts, Courthouse News reported. asserted
News → expect → whereabouts
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support