Photo via Toronto Star

Pennsylvania man who killed family had controlled their movements and finances: police

Read the original at Toronto Star ↗
Cite

Raby, J. (2026, October 15). Pennsylvania man who killed family had controlled their movements and finances: police. Toronto Star. https://www.thestar.com/news/world/united-states/pennsylvania-man-who-killed-family-had-controlled-their-movements-and-finances-police/article_edd13035-e980-5fea-9cb3-b2ad00544af2.html

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

Toronto Star · collected 2026-10-16 · by John Raby
Content note This article describes sexual violence.

Quick Summary

Erie Police Chief Rick Lorah revealed that Matthew Stone Sr., 45, who fatally shot eight family members and two others before taking his own life on October 9, had previously exercised strict control over their lives. This included limiting their movements and managing the family’s finances. The victims were primarily Stone's wife Michelle, three children, two grandchildren, and two female relatives. Conditions at the home were described as filthy with non-functional plumbing and large unpaid bills, suggesting long-term neglect and isolation of the family members.
Written by AI on 2026-10-16, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

On October 9, Matthew Stone Sr., a 45-year-old man in Erie, Pennsylvania, killed eight people before taking his own life. The victims included his wife and five children, along with two other women who had come to assist them. Police described the scene as one of the worst they have ever encountered, noting that the house was extremely filthy and filled with bottles of urine.

The shooting occurred after 9 pm when residents called 911 due to hearing gunfire; upon arrival, officers found two women dead outside the home. Stone barricaded himself inside and engaged in a standoff with police before dying from a self-inflicted gunshot wound. Inside the house, investigators discovered additional victims, including children.

Police revealed that Stone had exercised strict control over his family for years, managing their finances and restricting their movements. The home's conditions were described as deplorable, further highlighting the isolation and distress experienced by the victims.

Written for “Pennsylvania Shooting Leaves Nine Dead” on 2026-11-21, grounded in this article and the 30 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

16 outlets covered “Pennsylvania Shooting Leaves Nine Dead”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

Toronto StarThis outlet16 Oct

Erie Police Chief Rick Lorah revealed that Matthew Stone Sr., 45, who fatally shot eight family members and two others before taking his own life on October 9, had previously exercised strict control over their lives. This included limiting their movements and managing the family’s finances. The victims were primarily Stone's wife Michelle, three children, two grandchildren, and two female relatives. Conditions at…

Pennsylvania man who killed family had controlled their movements and finances: police (this article)3 articles from Toronto Star on this story
New York Post13 Oct

A chilling doorbell camera video from an Erie, Pennsylvania home shows people running and screaming as gunshots are fired on Friday evening. The footage captures moments leading to a massacre where Matthew Stone Sr., 45, killed eight members of his family and two friends before taking his own life. Among the victims were three generations including his wife Michelle, their children, and Angelina Stone’s unborn child…

Chilling video shows people running, screaming as grandpa massacres 8 in Erie home: ‘Oh my God!’ →5 articles from New York Post on this story
Daily Mail13 Oct

A grandpa killed nine members of his family in a murder-suicide in Erie, Pennsylvania. Matthew Stone Sr., 45, opened fire at his home on Perry Street, killing six adults, two children, and an unborn baby. The victims included Stone Sr.’s wife Michelle (44) and their four children: Jonathan (19), Matthew Jr. (21), Angelina (24), and her young children Isaiah (5) and Amari'anna (2). Also killed were Michelle’s sister…

Screaming children and women run for their lives as grandpa kills 9 loved ones in Erie murder suicide →4 articles from Daily Mail on this story
CBS News15 Oct

Erie Police Chief Rick Lorah described Matthew Stone Sr., 45, as a "controlling" patriarch who killed eight family members and two visitors at his home in Erie last week. The victims included Stone’s wife Michelle (44), their four children ranging from 1 to 24 years old, and two guests. Authorities found the house in poor condition with non-functioning plumbing and bottles containing urine scattered throughout…

Pennsylvania man who killed 8 people was "controlling" patriarch, police say →2 articles from CBS News on this story
Fox News12 Oct

A pregnant woman named Angelina Stone, who was eight months into her pregnancy and just four days from giving birth, along with her two young children and five other relatives, were killed in a mass shooting at an Erie home on Friday evening. The suspected shooter, identified as the family’s 45-year-old patriarch, died by what police believe to be a self-inflicted gunshot wound. Authorities are investigating…

Pregnant mom just 4 days from giving birth among 8 killed in Pennsylvania massacre: reports →2 articles from Fox News on this story
The Hindu11 Oct

On October 10, 2026, in Erie, Pennsylvania, a 45-year-old man killed eight people at his home before taking his own life. The victims included relatives and a friend of the pregnant woman who was also shot; one of the women died outside along with a second victim. Police used technology like drones and robots to enter the house where they found multiple bodies, including children and young adults. Erie’s mayor…

Shooting leaves 9 dead including suspect in Erie, Pennsylvania, police say →2 articles from The Hindu on this story
Show 10 more outlets
Sydney Morning Herald10 Oct

Eight members of the same family were killed in a shooting incident in Erie, Pennsylvania. The victims included a five-year-old boy, a one-year-old girl, and a woman who was eight months pregnant. No additional details or context about the shooter or circumstances are provided in the article.

Eight people from the same family killed in Pennsylvania shooting →2 articles from Sydney Morning Herald on this story
ABC News (AU)12 Oct

A grandfather in Pennsylvania shot and killed eight people, including children and a pregnant woman. Among the victims is a one-year-old toddler whose father is struggling with the loss. Law enforcement plans to interview family members and review mobile phone data from two deceased women to gather more information about the shooting.

Father mourns toddler killed in Pennsylvania shooting →2 articles from ABC News (AU) on this story
NBC News15 Oct

Matthew Stone, 45, carried out a mass shooting at his northwest Pennsylvania home in Erie on Friday, killing eight people including family members before taking his own life. The house was described by police as extremely filthy with non-functional plumbing and bottles of urine scattered throughout. Stone had previously been arrested for threatening a family member with a .40-caliber handgun in 2019 but the case was…

Pennsylvania house that was scene of mass shooting was ‘filthy,’ filled with bottles of urine →2 articles from NBC News on this story
Times of India10 Oct

A gunman killed at least nine people, including two children and a pregnant woman, in a shooting incident in Erie, Pennsylvania, on Friday evening. The shooter died by suicide after a standoff with SWAT teams. Emergency calls were received around 5 pm local time reporting the shootings; upon arrival, police found two women dead outside and multiple victims inside the home on Perry Street. Police Chief Rick Lorah…

Pregnant woman & 2 children among 9 killed in Pennsylvania shooting; gunman dies by suicide →
The Straits Times10 Oct

On October 9, a man killed eight people, including two children, at a home in Erie, Pennsylvania, before apparent suicide. Local media reported that initial calls around 5pm led police to find two women dead outside the residence; additional victims were found inside after a standoff where further shots were heard. Police are offering counseling to officers who responded due to the traumatic nature of the event. The…

Eight killed in shooting at Pennsylvania home: US media →
The Independent10 Oct

Eight people were killed in a shooting incident on Friday in Erie, Pennsylvania, with the shooter also dead. Police confirmed there was no ongoing threat to public safety and provided limited details about the event. Erie's police chief described it as unprecedented in terms of its impact and scale. Governor Josh Shapiro offered support to the mayor following the tragedy.

Eight people killed in ‘devastating’ shooting in Pennsylvania →
South China Morning Post10 Oct

A shooting in Erie, Pennsylvania, resulted in nine deaths, including a pregnant woman and two children. The suspect, a 45-year-old male relative of most victims, was found dead at the scene. Police Chief Rick Lorah reported that video evidence indicated two distressed women approached the home just before 5pm, only to be shot by the gunman after knocking on the door.

9 dead, including children and pregnant woman, in shooting in Erie, Pennsylvania →
CBC10 Oct

A shooting in Erie, Pennsylvania, resulted in nine deaths including two children and a pregnant woman. The suspected shooter was among the victims. Police arrived quickly after being alerted by ShotSpotter but found that all fatalities had occurred before their arrival. City officials clarified that sounds heard during the police response were flash bangs used in law enforcement operations. Erie’s mayor and…

Children, pregnant woman among 9 dead in Pennsylvania shooting →
Global News11 Oct

In Erie, Pennsylvania, a 45-year-old man killed eight people including his relatives and a friend before taking his own life on Friday evening. The victims included two women outside the home and six others inside, including a toddler and an unborn child. Julius Windham, whose daughter was among the victims, described the shooter as someone who appeared normal despite any underlying issues. Police Chief Rick Lorah…

Pennsylvania shooter who killed 8 was family’s patriarch, slain toddler’s dad says →
The Guardian12 Oct

A man in Erie, Pennsylvania, killed eight people, including his own family members, before taking his life on Friday evening. The shooter, a 45-year-old grandfather, had not shown signs of distress or violent tendencies, according to those who knew him. Among the victims were Julius Windham’s one-year-old daughter and her pregnant mother, along with other relatives and friends. Authorities have identified the…

Pennsylvania shooter who killed eight was a grandfather, says slain child’s dad →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

AI · cited, from two or more outlets

  • Emergency responders conducted a tactical response at the scene, using flash bang devices.13
  • The shooter was also dead and there was no threat to the public remaining after the incident.14
Quoted from the coverage (4)

Governor Josh Shapiro said Saturday he offered his administration’s “full support” to Erie Mayor Daria Devlin.

5 outlets

After deploying a drone and robot, they went inside and found the bodies of a 5-year-old boy; a 1-year-old girl on the first floor; two more women and two young men in a stairwell; and the shooter on the second floor.

5 outlets

Lorah believes “mental health is at play here,” but did not provide a motive behind the killings.

4 outlets

The man who killed eight people, before turning the gun on himself, in a mass shooting in a home in Erie, Pennsylvania, on Friday was a grandfather who had not shown signs that he was capable of such violence, according to people who knew the shooter.

4 outlets

Disputed

Picked by our model, which is sometimes wrong

  • The number of victims differs between sources, with some reporting eight deaths and others nine including the shooter.34
  • Details about the sequence of events vary; one source mentions a standoff while another does not.14

Framing

How the first headlines put it

  • Headlines emphasize different aspects, such as the number of victims and the involvement of children or pregnant women.14
  • Some headlines focus on the shooter's identity and relationship to the victims, while others highlight specific details like the use of a gunshot detection system.56
Attributed to a source3
Stated as fact9
The headlines (12)

Nine people, including children, killed in Pennsylvania shooting that left bodies lying in the street, report says Daily Mail · attributed to a source

Multiple people killed in Pennsylvania shooting; suspected gunman found dead: report Fox News · attributed to a source

Police in Erie, Pennsylvania, say 9 people died in connection with a shooting, including the suspect Toronto Star · attributed to a source

Multiple people, including 2 children, dead in suspected murder-suicide at Pennsylvania home New York Post · stated as fact

Multiple people, including 2 children, killed in reported mass shooting in Erie CBS News · stated as fact

Pregnant woman & 2 children among 9 killed in Pennsylvania shooting; gunman dies by suicide Times of India · stated as fact

Eight killed in shooting at Pennsylvania home: US media The Straits Times · stated as fact

Eight killed in shooting at Pennsylvania home: local media The Hindu · stated as fact

Nine dead after mass shooting in Pennsylvania Sydney Morning Herald · stated as fact

Eight people killed in ‘devastating’ shooting in Pennsylvania The Independent · stated as fact

9 dead, including children and pregnant woman, in shooting in Erie, Pennsylvania South China Morning Post · stated as fact

Children, pregnant woman among 9 dead in Pennsylvania shooting CBC · stated as fact

Words to watch (2)

Eight people killed in ‘devastating’ shooting in Pennsylvania The Independent

Grandpa ID’d as crazed killer who shot 9 of his kids, grandkids in shocking Pa. murder-suicide: relatives New York Post

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 31 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 12% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
ABC News (AU)
Hedges 0 of 3 claims Outlet record 67/100
The Hindu
Hedges 2 of 22 claims Outlet record 78/100
Global News
Hedges 1 of 33 claims Outlet record 63/100
Fox News
Hedges 5 of 15 claims Outlet record 66/100
The Guardian
Hedges 2 of 38 claims Outlet record 64/100
ABC News (AU)
Hedges 0 of 4 claims Outlet record 67/100
NBC News
Hedges 3 of 11 claims Outlet record 78/100

Story

Pennsylvania Shooting Leaves Nine Dead
Crime & Law · 31 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
32
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
12%
4 of 32 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
64/100
Toronto Star's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
31
Crime & Law
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-10-16 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Toronto Star · 16334 article(s) · 31 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 31 correction(s)
2026-11-17
Correction
2026-10-26
Correction
2026-10-24
Correction
2026-10-07
Correction
2026-09-24
Correction

Who wrote this

John Raby
13 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
Heavy rains that left large swaths of Florida’s Atlantic coast under water and led to dozens of rescues moved further north on Friday as forecasters warned flooding threats could stretch into next week when a major river is expected to crest well above record levels.
"I could not imagine a more rewarding career," Rockefeller said upon his retirement in 2015.
A university spokesperson said they would provide updates on the investigation online as they become available.
Family members told detectives that the elder Stone “restricted when family members could leave the residence or spend time with relatives,” Lorah said.
Cook couldn’t handle an option pitch that went behind him and Molette scooped up the fumble and went 32 yards to put Arizona ahead 14-3.
“We’ll continue to search and saturate the area until we’re at the point where we are confident that if there were any survivors remaining on the surface of the water, we would have found them,” McTamney said.
McNoldy anticipates the current pattern will peak this coming winter and persist through 2027.
McNoldy predicted that the current El Nino will peak during the coming winter but linger into 2027.
Cook and Hawkins looked as good as advertised but the team’s struggles in the second half will need fixing.
Nelson said that "without Red Auerbach teaching me the mechanics of running the fast break, none of it would have been possible.
Also by John Raby
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 13 articles by John Raby →

Topics

Erie Pennsylvania

Subjects

Lorah PERSON · 8× Stone PERSON · 6× Michelle Stone PERSON · 3× Angelina Stone PERSON · 2× Angelina Stone’s PERSON · 2× Roberts PERSON · 2× Tanner PERSON · 2× Erie GPE · 1× Matthew Stone Sr PERSON · 1× Pennsylvania GPE · 1×

Narrative

The adult victims of the Oct. 9 shooting previously were identified as Stone’s wife, Michelle Stone, 44; their daughter, Angelina Stone, 24, who was due to give birth Monday, three days after the shooting; sons Jonathan Stone, 19, and Matthew Stone Jr., 21; and two women who lived at other addresses: Lora Roberts, 37, and Twila Tanner, 51.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-10-16
Family members told detectives that the elder Stone “restricted when family members could leave the residence or spend time with relatives,” Lorah said.

Claims (32 extracted, 4 hedged)

A Pennsylvania man who fatally shot eight others, including seven family members, before killing himself had exercised strict control over his relatives, including their finances and interactions with others, police said Thursday. asserted
police → shoot → others
Investigators still don’t know why family patriarch Matthew Stone Sr. gunned down his wife, their three children, two grandchildren and two women who had rushed to the home and were shot outside, Erie Police Chief Rick Lorah said at a news conference. asserted
Lorah → know → conference
Lorah painted a picture of a family living in a home in isolated, filthy conditions. asserted
Lorah → paint → conditions
He said the authoritarian behavior of Stone, 45, started after his wife became pregnant with their first child more than two decades ago. asserted
wife → say → child
The adult victims of the Oct. 9 shooting previously were identified as Stone’s wife, Michelle Stone, 44; their daughter, Angelina Stone, 24, who was due to give birth Monday, three days after the shooting; sons Jonathan Stone, 19, and Matthew Stone Jr., 21; and two women who lived at other addresses: Lora Roberts, 37, and Twila Tanner, 51. asserted
who → identify → addresses
A 5-year-old boy and a 22-month-old girl who were identified by relatives as Angelina Stone’s children also were killed. asserted
who → identify → children
State law prevented authorities from releasing their names. asserted
law → prevent → names
Family members told detectives that the elder Stone “restricted when family members could leave the residence or spend time with relatives,” Lorah said. uncertain
Lorah → tell → relatives
In addition, Michelle Stone “stopped maintaining contact with friends.” asserted
Stone → stop → friends
The elder Stone also kept a tight grip over the family’s money, including supplemental government income received for one of the grandchildren, Lorah said. asserted
Lorah → keep → grandchildren
In 2019, Stone was arrested and charged with threatening his wife with the same .40-caliber handgun that he used in the Oct. 9 shootings. asserted
he → arrest → shootings
However, at a preliminary hearing, Michelle Stone “changed her original statement and those charges were withdrawn,” Lorah said. asserted
Lorah → change → statement
A year ago, daughter Angelina filed a petition to change her last name, citing concerns about the elder Stone’s “declining mental health,” according to Lorah. uncertain
Angelina → file → Lorah
She had planned to pursue a career in medicine and didn’t want her last name associated with her father. asserted
name → plan → father
But that application was closed in April 2026. asserted
application → close → April
Angelina Stone posted ultrasound photos of her unborn child on social media on Sept. 25. asserted
Stone → post → Sept.
Lorah said she had been sending messages to others indicating she was going to leave the home after giving birth. asserted
she → say → birth
She also said her father had been physically abusive toward her brothers. asserted
father → say → brothers
After the shootings, detectives found bags and boxes that were packed in Angelina Stone’s bedroom. asserted
that → find → bedroom
Detectives described conditions in the home as “extremely filthy.” asserted
Detectives → describe → home
A shower, toilet and kitchen sink didn’t appear to be working, and there were numerous soda bottles filled with urine throughout the house. asserted
shower → appear → house
Water service remained active but had an outstanding balance of $1,900, the chief said. asserted
chief → remain → 1,900
During their search, detectives also found drug paraphernalia, “but we cannot establish what role, if any, mental health or substance use played in the shooting,” Lorah said. asserted
Lorah → find → shooting
Video and audio evidence recovered by investigators included muffled gunshot sounds coming from inside the home just before Roberts and Tanner arrived and began pounding on the door. asserted
Roberts → recover → door
The gunman then came out and shot them as they ran toward him, before returning inside. asserted
they → come → him
Tanner was the only nonrelative killed, Lorah said. asserted
Lorah → kill → ?
As circumstances of the family’s living conditions and history came to light, Mayor Daria Devlin said some difficult questions, too, have surfaced. asserted
questions → come → light
“Were there opportunities to recognize that this family was struggling?” Devlin said. asserted
Devlin → recognize → ?
“Were there places where our systems could have responded differently? uncertain
systems → respond → ?
And how do we make sure that families in this community who are suffering and struggling like this don’t fall through the cracks? asserted
who → make → cracks
“We cannot assume that any one intervention could have prevented what happened on Friday. uncertain
what → assume → Friday
But that can’t stop us from examining where each one of us can do better.” asserted
one → stop → us
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support