Photo via The Sydney Morning Herald

How One Nation’s negative migration plans would drive up debt by $275b

Read the original at The Sydney Morning Herald ↗
Cite

Wright, S., & Chrysanthos, N. (2026, October 17). How One Nation’s negative migration plans would drive up debt by $275b. The Sydney Morning Herald. https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/how-one-nation-s-negative-migration-plans-would-drive-up-debt-by-275b-20261018-p61575.html?ref=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_source=rss_feed

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

The Sydney Morning Herald · collected 2026-10-17 · by Shane Wright, Natassia Chrysanthos

Quick Summary

The article reports that under One Nation's proposed lower migration policies in Australia, the national debt would increase by $275 billion over ten years and economic output would decrease by $212 billion due to 820,000 fewer taxpayering workers. Former finance minister Mathias Cormann warns against arbitrary migration caps without considering their impact on businesses, hospitals, and universities, noting that an ageing population shrinking its workforce while increasing spending could be contradictory. The article highlights concerns from industry sectors like hospitality and accommodation about the economic risks of sharply reducing migrant labor.
Written by AI on 2026-10-17, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).

AI analysis

Story summary

One Nation’s plans for reducing immigration over 10 years would drive up Australia's national debt by an additional $275 billion, according to a Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO) analysis. The report predicts that such measures would keep the budget in deficit, reduce economic output by $212 billion, and result in 820,000 fewer taxpaying workers by the middle of the next decade. Former Coalition finance minister Mathias Cormann, now head of the OECD, criticized arbitrary migration caps without considering their impact on businesses, hospitals, and universities, warning that an aging country choosing to shrink its working-age population while promising more spending is contradictory.

Written for “One Nation's Negative Migration Plans Debt Impact” on 2026-11-21, grounded in this article and the 0 other(s) covering the same event.

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans strongly left and hedges 7% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
Daily Mail
Leans strongly right further right than this Hedges 0 of 27 claims Outlet record 69/100
“The articles discuss different government actions regarding migration in two distinct countries and do not refer to the same specific incident.”

Story

One Nation's Negative Migration Plans Debt Impact
Economy/Business · 1 article(s) covering the same event.
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
46
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
7%
3 of 46 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans strongly left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
61/100
The Sydney Morning Herald's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
1
Economy/Business
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-10-17 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

The Sydney Morning Herald · 7770 article(s) · 16 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 16 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Shane Wright
30 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
Treasurer Jim Chalmers is promising a “Goldilocks” mid-year budget update that will be focused on savings large enough ease inflation pressures but which will not hurt the overall economy.
The Greens could get in the way of Treasurer Jim Chalmers’ plans to overhaul capital gains tax by the end of the year, backing an inquiry into a separate proposal from independent MP Allegra Spender.
The CEOs of two of the nation’s largest banks have backed cuts in government spending to bring down inflation and make housing more affordable amid warnings the AI building boom could push up the cost of suburban homes as they compete for electricians and plumbers.
The federal government’s budget overhaul of negative gearing and capital gains tax has been blamed for the biggest fall in home loans taken out by investors on record, with warnings the property market will struggle well into next year.
The AI building boom that is powering the global economy could force interest rates to remain higher, the Reserve Bank’s chief economist has warned, while revealing there are few signs the new technology will eat into the job prospects of young Australians.
But it wasn’t accompanied by a surge in unemployment which would peak at 7.4 per cent.
It may not be an official recession, but the Reserve Bank knows it may feel like one for plenty of Australians after it delivered another dose of monetary policy punishment to the country.
The last time the RBA board split was in May when 8 voted in favour of a rate hike with one holding out.
The Reserve Bank is being warned it could drive Australia into a recession and leave tens of thousands of people out of work with a Melbourne Cup Day interest rate rise that will lift pressure on Treasurer Jim Chalmers to cut deeper into government spending.
The nationwide slump in house values has spread to Brisbane and Perth with no signs the property downturn is close to ending, amid fears it could get worse if the Reserve Bank pushes ahead with another interest rate hike this week.
Also by Shane Wright
Chalmers reveals plan for ‘Goldilocks’ budget update
2026-11-16 · The Sydney Morning Herald
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 30 articles by Shane Wright →
Natassia Chrysanthos
31 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
The prime minister will soon finish his 11-day international tour with a final stop in Beijing to meet Chinese Premier Li Qiang and hold a roundtable with Australian business executives.
The meeting will mark the first time in history the leaders of the US, China and Russia sit down for face-to-face talks.
The world’s eyes are on Trump this week as he blitzes through Asia, where he will hold a historic meeting with China and Russia in his first international tour since the bruising midterm elections.
United States President Donald Trump has landed in the Philippines and will meet Prime Minister Anthony Albanese for his first stop in a diplomatic blitz through Asia following the bruising midterm elections.
Regional employers crying out for backpackers to fill pubs and cafes are set to win a reprieve on Tuesday, when Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke is expected to wind back a proposed crackdown on working holidaymakers.
“How can it possibly be acceptable for Anthony Albanese, the leader of a democratic country which has stood alongside Ukraine for nearly five years, to willingly take part in a photograph with the man responsible for this war?
Under the deal, 35 restaurants are set to come to Australia in the next five years, a $60 million investment that should create about 900 jobs.
Australia will ramp up its investment in drones and other defence measures in a pact with the Philippines to protect important trade routes and increase maritime surveillance as Beijing extends its reach over the South China Sea.
He apologised in July this year after he was asked whether he would “marry, shag or date” pop star Kylie Minogue, and he said “all of the above.”
He left Turkey shortly after Friday’s business roundtable, and will head straight to the Philippines for the ASEAN summit.
2026-11-13 · assertive framing · Albanese and Bowen caught in hot mic gaffe
Also by Natassia Chrysanthos
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 31 articles by Natassia Chrysanthos →

Topics

Australia Coalition Labor One Nation’s Parliamentary Budget Office

Subjects

Coalition ORG · 4× Australia GPE · 3× Labor NORP · 2× One Nation ORG · 2× One Nation’s ORG · 2× Mathias Cormann PERSON · 1× OECD ORG · 1× Parliamentary Budget Office ORG · 1× Pauline Hanson’s PERSON · 1× The Australian Hotels Association ORG · 1×

Narrative

As political parties of all stripes come under pressure to appease public anxiety about immigration, a 10-year analysis of lower migration scenarios using Parliamentary Budget Office tools exposes the economic and fiscal consequences of blunt measures to bring fewer people to the country.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-10-17
Australia’s budget would remain mired in deficit for more than 10 years under One Nation’s plans for lower migration, delivering an economic blow that would drive up national debt by an extra $275 billion.
2026-10-17 · The Sydney Morning Herald
How One Nation’s negative migration plans would drive up debt by $275b · assertive framing

Claims (46 extracted, 3 hedged)

Australia’s budget would remain mired in deficit for more than 10 years under One Nation’s plans for lower migration, delivering an economic blow that would drive up national debt by an extra $275 billion. asserted
that → remain → billion
As political parties of all stripes come under pressure to appease public anxiety about immigration, a 10-year analysis of lower migration scenarios using Parliamentary Budget Office tools exposes the economic and fiscal consequences of blunt measures to bring fewer people to the country. asserted
analysis → come → country
According to the analysis, Pauline Hanson’s three-year negative migration scenario would also reduce Australia’s economic output by $212 billion by the middle of next decade, when there would be 820,000 fewer taxpaying workers in the economy. Former Coalition finance minister Mathias Cormann, now head of the OECD, on Saturday warned against setting “arbitrary migration caps” without thought to their impact on businesses, hospitals or universities. uncertain
Cormann → accord → businesses
“An ageing country that chooses to shrink its working-age population while promising to spend more on health, care and defence has not developed a plan. asserted
that → age → plan
It has put forward a contradiction,” he said in a speech. asserted
he → put → speech
The analysis shows cutting migration to the Coalition’s desired levels would mean $150 billion more debt in a decade under current migration settings, demonstrating the opposition has a high-wire task in executing precise changes to the visa system that avoid a compounding fiscal fallout. asserted
that → show → fallout
The Labor government is already wearing backlash from the hospitality and accommodation sector, which relies on migrant labour, for its decision to limit working holidaymaker visas as a key measure to quickly bring down the net overseas migration intake. asserted
which → wear → intake
Public anxiety about immigration has grown alongside the number of temporary visa holders in Australia, but industry and business groups are becoming increasingly concerned that a political contest to drive numbers down quickly risks jeopardising the economy. asserted
contest → grow → economy
The Australian Hotels Association made its own intervention into public debate this week with an AI-generated advertisement that showed services falling apart as migrant workers disappeared from cafes, aged care homes, supermarkets and hotels across the country. asserted
workers → make → country
“The hotel industry understands the need for migration changes, but it’s unfair our sector is copping the brunt of the planned cuts,” Accommodation Australia chief executive James Goodwin said. asserted
Goodwin → understand → cuts
Labor will cut second- and third-year working holidaymaker visas and student family visas in its plans to get net overseas migration numbers down to 225,000. asserted
numbers → cut → 225,000
The Coalition will target graduates and refugees to hit a 100,000 target, before lifting it to 160,000 with more skilled entrants. asserted
Coalition → target → entrants
One Nation has not specified its plans but wants three years of negative migration, before a maximum net intake of 130,000 people a year, which would retain regional workers. asserted
which → specify → workers
Deciphering the economic impacts of lower migration asserted
Deciphering → decipher → migration
Economist Chris Richardson said higher migration levels generally gave the federal government a higher tax intake, although they saddled state governments with more spending. asserted
they → say → spending
He said there were not examples of economic models that effectively combined the impact of migration on federal budgets, state budgets and the complex issue of housing. asserted
that → say → housing
The budget office’s “build your own budget” calculator is one tool that enables users to compare policy initiatives, including cuts to net overseas migration, and their impact on the federal budget and population growth over time. asserted
that → build → time
It is limited and assumes current policy settings, so the Coalition’s plans to reconfigure the migration program cannot be factored into the forecasts. asserted
plans → limit → forecasts
But without published budget analysis from the opposition or One Nation, it is one measure to gauge the fiscal impact of cuts if current migration settings were maintained but scaled down to include fewer people. asserted
settings → publish → people
Based on One Nation’s desired immigration levels, by the middle of next decade the country would have 820,000 fewer people in paid employment. asserted
country → base → employment
That has a flow-on impact on personal income tax, company tax and GST collections. asserted
That → have → tax
Under the government’s policies, the budget is expected to show cumulative deficits of $108 billion over the next decade, returning to the black in 2034-35. asserted
budget → expect → 2034
But One Nation would run cumulative deficits of $391 billion, and the budget would not return to surplus over the next 10 years. asserted
budget → run → years
The larger deficits mean more gross debt, which is currently $995 billion. asserted
which → mean → debt
By the middle of next decade, current government policy would take debt to almost $1.4 trillion. asserted
policy → take → trillion
But with deep cuts in net overseas migration, One Nation would have debt at $1.67 trillion. asserted
Nation → have → trillion
The Coalition’s numbers, under today’s migration settings, would lead to debt at $1.54 trillion. asserted
numbers → lead → trillion
It would get back to surplus in 2036-37. asserted
It → get → 2036
The opposition’s own analysis deviates significantly from these estimates because the Coalition plans on changing the mix of migrants, whereas the PBO budget tool assumes the make-up of the migration program remains the same as today but in smaller numbers. asserted
up → deviate → numbers
The Coalition forecasts losing $6.1 billion over the four-year forward estimates because of lower migration. asserted
Coalition → forecast → migration
However, halving the refugee intake from 20,000 to 10,000 people would deliver $2.7 billion in budget savings, while a new skilled project visa scheme is forecast to deliver $3.9 billion. asserted
scheme → halve → billion
The Coalition says its policy would improve the budget bottom line by $260 million in four years and $2.5 billion over the decade, although it has not published the analysis, which was also completed by the PBO, so it is unclear what other caveats or conditions are factored into that scenario. uncertain
it → say → scenario
Richardson said high-skilled young adult migrants delivered the most positive budget and economic impact, but changing migration policy was complex. asserted
changing → say → policy
“As the government has tried to wind back migration in recent years, it’s increasingly clear that it’s hard,” he said. asserted
he → try → years
“Regardless of what any political party wants to do, we’ve built a system that’s a supertanker – it doesn’t change direction fast. asserted
it → want → direction
The politics have changed, but the poles and wires of the system haven’t. asserted
poles → change → system
The Coalition is mounting its case for lower migration levels as it competes in the polls with One Nation, which has not outlined any policy details or addressed economic impacts. asserted
which → mount → impacts
A spokesperson for leader Angus Taylor said One Nation’s policy was a mess while the government had been relying on migration to pump up their budget, claiming the Coalition could both deliver a historic cut to migration and fully protect the economy. uncertain
Coalition → say → economy
Cormann, in his speech to the right-leaning Centre for Independent Studies in Brisbane on Saturday, doused that argument. asserted
Cormann → lean → argument
He acknowledged public concern about immigration had grown, particularly because of housing shortfalls, but rejected cutting immigration as the answer. asserted
concern → acknowledge → answer
…and 6 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support